This study addressed the issues of how men experienced their emotional adjustment to the death of a child from cancer, as well as how they dealt with the normative imperatives of the bereaved father role. Taking a men's studies perspective, the analysis started from the assumption that our present understanding of the parental mourning process may be shaped by a tendency to apply and operationalize concepts formulated through the study of grieving mothers rather than fathers. Interviews and questionnaires were used to gather qualitative data from 55 men whose children had died 10 months to 5 years previously. Results indicated that fathers' approaches to grief were often cognitive and solitary; the men defined both the experience and expression of negative affect as dangerous for themselves and those around them. Related to this was the presence of two double binds that arose from the fathers' reluctance to divulge their feelings: The first bind stemmed from the societal expectation that men should comfort their wives and the second from the cultural ideal that healthy grieving cannot be accomplished without the sharing of feelings. The manner in which men and their families resolved these binds offers us some insight into the unique aspects of men's mourning.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BALSWICK, J.
(1970) “The effect of spouse support on employment success.”J. of Marriage and the Family32: 212-215.
2.
BALSWICK, J.
(1979) “The inexpressive male: functional-conflict and role theory as contrasting explanations.”Family Coordinator28: 331-336.
3.
BALSWICK, J.
and C. PEEK (1970) “The inexpressive male and family relationships during childhood.”Soc. Symposium4: 1-12.
4.
BALSWICK, J.
and C. PEEK (1971) “The inexpressive male: a tragedy of American society.”Family Coordinator20: 363-368.
5.
BELL, R.
(1981) Worlds of Friendship.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
6.
BOXER, A,.J. COOK
, and B. COHLER (1986) “Grandfathers, fathers, and sons: intergenerational relations among men,” pp. 93-121 in K. Pillemer and R. Wolf (eds.) Elder Abuse: Conflict in the Family.Dover, MA: Auburn.
7.
BROD, H.
(1987) “The case for men's studies,” pp. 39-62 in H. Brod (ed.) The Making of Masculinities: The New Men's Studies.Boston: Allen & Unwin.
8.
CALDWELL, M.
and L. PEPLAU (1982) “Sex differences in same-sex friendship.”Sex Roles8: 721-731.
9.
CHARMAZ, K.
(1980) The Social Reality of Death.Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
10.
CHODOROW, N.
(1978) The Reproduction of Mothering.Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.
11.
COOK, J.
(1983) “A death in the family: parental bereavement in the first year.”Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior13: 42-61
12.
COOK, J
(1984) “Influence of gender on the problems of parents of fatally ill children.”J. of Psychosocial Oncology2: 71-91.
13.
COOK, J.
(1985) “Emotional factors in the experiences of men following their children's deaths.” Presented at the American Sociological Association Annual Meetings, Washington, DC.
14.
COOK, J.
and B. COHLER (1986) “Reciprocal socialization and the care of offspring with cancer and with schizophrenia,” pp. 223-243 in N. Datan, A. Greene, and H. Reese (eds.) Life-Span Developmental Psychology: Intergenerational Relations.Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
15.
COOK, J.
and M. FONOW (1985) “Am I my sister's gatekeeper?: cautionary tales from the academic hierarchy.”Humanity and Society8: 442-452.
16.
COOK, J.
and M. FONOW (1986) “Knowledge and women's interests: issues of epistemology and methodology in feminist sociological research.”Soc. Inquiry56: 2-29.
17.
COOK, J.
and D. WIMBERLEY (1983) “If I should die before I wake: religious commitment and adjustment to the death of a child.”J. for the Scientific Study of Religion22: 222-238.
18.
DAVID, D.
and R. BRANNON (1976) “The male sex role: our culture's blueprint of manhood and what it's done for us lately,” pp. 1-45 in D. David and R. Brannon (eds.) The Forty-Nine Percent Majority: The Male Sex Role.Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
19.
DAVIDSON, L.
and L. DUBERMAN (1982) “Friendship: communication and interactional patterns in same-sex dyads.”Sex Roles8: 809-822.
20.
EVERSOLL, D.
(1979) “A two-generational view of fathering.”Family Coordinator28: 503-508.
21.
FRIEDMAN, S.
, P. CHODOFF, J. MASON, and D. HAMBURG (1963) “Behavioral observations on parents anticipating the death of a child.”Pediatrics32: 610-625.
22.
GILLIGAN, C.
(1982) In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.
23.
GLICK, I.
, R. WEISS, and C. PARKES (1974) The First Year of Bereavement.New York: John Wiley.
24.
GOLDBERG, P.
(1976) The Hazards of Being Male.New York: Signet.
25.
GOODE, W.
(1969) “A theory of role strain.”Amer. Soc. Rev.11: 483-496.
26.
GOODE, W.
(1982) “Why men resist,” pp. 131-150 in B. Thorne and N. Yalom (eds.) Rethinking the Family.New York: Longman.
27.
JOURARD, S.
(1964) “Some lethal aspects of the male sex role,” in S. Jourard (ed.) The Transparent Self.New York: Van Nostrand.
28.
KOMAROVSKY, M.
(1964) Blue-Collar Marriage.New York: Random House.
29.
KOMAROVSKY, M.
(1976) Dilemmas of Masculinity.New York: Norton.
30.
KÜBLER-ROSS, E.
(1981) Living with Death and Dying.New York: Macmillan.
31.
LEIN, L.
(1979) “Male participation in home life: impact of social supports and breadwinner responsibility on the allocation of tasks.”Family Coordinator28: 489-495.
32.
LINDEMANN, E.
(1944) “Symptomology and management of acute grief.”Amer. J. of Psychiatry101: 141-148.
33.
McCOLLUM, A.
and A. SCHWARTZ (1972) “Social work and the mourning parent.”Social Work17: 25-36.
34.
MICHAELIS, D.
(1983) The Best of Friends.New York: Morrow.
35.
MORGAN, B.
(1976) “Intimacy of disclosure topics and sex differences in self-disclosure.”Sex Roles2: 161-166.
36.
NOLFI, M.
(1967) “Families in grief: the question of casework intervention.”Social Work21: 40-46.
37.
OCHBERG, R. L.
(1987) “The male career code and the ideology of role,” pp. 173-191 in H. Brod. (ed.) The Making of Masculinities: The New Men's Studies.Boston: Allen & Unwin.
38.
PARKES, C.
(1972) Bereavement: Studies of Grief in Adult Life.New York: Penguin.
39.
PAYNE, J.
, J. GOFF, and M. PAULSON (1980) “Psychosocial adjustment of families with childhood leukemia,” pp. 183-193 in J. Schulman and M. Kupst (eds.) The Child with Cancer.Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
40.
PEPPERS, L.
and R. KNAPP (1980) Motherhood and Mourning: Perinatal Death.New York: Praeger.
41.
RICHARDS, M.
(1981) “How should we approach the study of fathers?” in L. McKee and M. O'Brien (eds.) The Father Figure.London: Tavistock.
42.
RUDDICK, S.
(1982) “Maternal thinking,” pp. 76-94 in B. Thorne and M. Yalom (eds.) Rethinking the Family.New York: Longman.
43.
RUBIN, L.
(1976) Worlds of Pain: Life in the Working-Class Family.New York: Basic Books.
44.
RUBIN, L.
(1983) Intimate Strangers: Men and Women Together.New York: Harper Colophon.
45.
SCHIFF, H.
(1977) The Bereaved Parent.New York: Crown.
46.
SHERROD, D.
(1987) “The bonds of men: problems and possibilities in close male relationships,” pp. 213-139 in H. Brod (ed.) The Making of Masculinities: The New Men's Studies.Boston: Allen & Unwin.
47.
SINGH, B.
and B. RAPHAEL (1981) “Postdisaster morbidity of the bereaved: a possible role for preventative psychiatry?”J. of Nervous and Mental Disease169: 203-212.
48.
SOLNIT, A.
and M. GREEN (1959) “Psychologic considerations in management of deaths on pediatric hospital services.”Pediatrics24: 106-112.
49.
TOWNES, B.
, WOLD, H., and T. HOLMES (1974) “Parental adjustment to childhood leukemia.”J. of Psychosomatic Research18: 9-14.
50.
VIDEKA-SHERMAN, L.
(1982) “Coping with the death of a child: a study over time.”Amer. J. of Orthopsychiatry52: 688-698.
