Although policies regarding the enlistment of homosexuals in Western armies have become the subject of a heated debate, their own experiences in the military have received little systematic analysis. The authors examine the experience of gay men in combat units of the Israeli army, as derived from retrospective life stories. The authors found no common adjustment problems related to these men's sexual orientation. At the same time, variable identification strategies with hegemonic masculine military culture emerged. One is engagement and includes identification with soldiery as a test for masculinity, taking part in heterosexual discourse, and an active attempt to develop social ties. The second strategy is compartmentalization, which involves focusing on professional aspects of the military job and building walls in the interpersonal sphere. Consequently, the authors propose that the ties between behavioral adaptation to military service, processes of identification with organizational values, and the acquisition of a particular identity are loosely coupled.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson, C. W.
, and H. R. Smith. 1993. Stigma and honor: Gay, lesbian and bisexual people in the U.S. military. In Homosexual issues in the workplace, edited by L. Diamant, 65-89. Washington, DC: Taylor and Francis.
2.
Anderson-Boers, M.
, and J. Van Der Meulen. 1994. Homosexuality in the armed forces in the Netherlands. In Gays and lesbian in the military: Issues, concerns and contrasts, edited by J. Scott and S. C. Stanley, 205-216. New York: Aldine.
3.
Arkin, W.
, and L. R. Dobrofsky. 1978. Military socialization and masculinity.Journal of Social Issues34 (1): 151-168.
4.
Bacevich, A. J.1993. Military culture and effectiveness.Society31 (1): 43-47.
5.
Badinter, E.
1995. On masculine identity.New York: Columbia University Press.
6.
Barrett, F. J.1996. The organizational construction of hegemonic masculinity: The case of the U.S. Navy.Gender, Work, and Organization3:129-142.
7.
Ben-Ari, E.
1998. Mastering soldiers: Conflict, emotions and the enemy in an Israeli military unit.Oxford, UK: Berghahn.
8.
Ben-Ari, E.
with the assistance of G. Dardashti. Forthcoming. Tests of soldierhood, trials of manhood: Military service and male ideals in Israel. In The military, the state, and society in Israel: Theoretical and comparative perspectives, edited by D. Maman, Z. Rosenhek, and E. Ben-Ari.New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
9.
Bérubé, A.
1993. Foreword. In Barrack buddies and soldier lovers: Dialogues with gay young men in the US military, by S. Zeeland. New York: Haworth.
10.
Bourne, P. G.1967. Some observations on the psychological phenomena seen in basic training.Psychiatry30:187-196.
11.
Britton, D. M.
, and C. L. Williams. 1995. Don't ask, don't tell, don't pursue: Military policy and the construction of heterosexual masculinity.Journal of Homosexuality30 (1): 1-21.
12.
Bruner, J.
1986. Actual minds, possible worlds.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
13.
Buskirk, W. V.
, F. Barrett, D. McGrath, and S. Schor. 1995. Coping with hypermasculine tradition in organizational cultures. Paper submitted at the annual meeting of the Academy of Management.
14.
Cameron, P.
, K. Cameron, and K. Proctor. 1984. Homosexuals in the armed forces.Psychological Reports62 (1): 211-219.
15.
Cass, V.1979. Homosexual identity formation: A theoretical model.Journal of Homosexuality4:219-235.
16.
Cass, V.1984. Homosexual identity formation: Testing a theoretical model.Journal of Sex Research20 (2): 143-167.
17.
Chapkis, W.
1988. Sexuality and militarism. In Women and the military system, edited by E. Isaksson, 106-113. Hemel Hempstead, UK: Harvester-Wheatsheaf.
18.
Connell, R. W.1992. A very straight gay: Masculinity, homosexual experience, and the dynamics of gender.American Sociological Review57 (6): 735-751.
19.
Connell, R. W.1993. A bastard of a life: Homosexual desire and practice among men in working-class milieux.Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology29 (1): 112-135.
20.
Connell, R. W.
1995. Masculinities.Berkeley: University of California Press.
21.
Devilbiss, M. C.
1994. Best-kept secrets. In Gays and lesbian in the military: Issues, concerns and contrasts, edited by J. Scott and S. C. Stanley, 135-148. New York: Aldine.
22.
Flickstein, B.
1993. Homosexuality and military service in Germany. SOWI Arbeitspapier Nr. 84. Munich: German Armed Forces Institute for Social Research.
23.
Forrest, D.
1994. “We're here, we're queer, and we're not going shopping”: Changing gay male identities in contemporary Britain. In Dislocating masculinity: Comparative ethnographies, edited by A. Cornwall and N. Lindisfarne, 97-110. London: Routledge.
24.
Gal, R.
1986. A portrait of the Israeli soldier.New York: Greenwood.
25.
Gal, R.
1994. Gays in the military: Policy and practice in the Israeli defence forces. In Gays and lesbian in the military: Issues, concerns and contrasts, edited by J. Scott and S. C. Stanley, 181-189. New York: Aldine.
26.
General Accounting Office (GAO).
1993. Homosexuals in the military: Policies and practices of foreign countries. NSIAD-93-215. Washington, DC: Author.
27.
Gilmore, D. D.
1990. Manhood in the making: Cultural concepts of masculinity.New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
28.
Harries-Jenkins, G.
1986. Role images, military attitudes, and the enlisted culture in Great Britain. In Life in the rank and file, edited by D. R. Segal and H. W. Sinaiko, 254-271. Washington, DC: Pergamon-Brassey's.
29.
Harry, J.1995. Book review on “gays and lesbians in the military: Issues, concerns and contrasts.”Journal of Political and Military Sociology23:297-298.
30.
Heinecken, L.
Forthcoming. Social equality versus combat effectiveness: An institutional challenge for the military.African Security Review.
31.
Helman, S.1997. Militarism and the construction of community.Journal of Political and Military Sociology25:305-332.
32.
Henderson, D.
1985. Cohesion: The human element in battle.Washington, DC: National Defense University Press.
33.
Herek, G. M.1993. Sexual orientation and military service.American Psychologist48:538-549.
34.
HPAT, British Military
. 1993. Integration of homosexuals to the military. Unpublished manuscript.
35.
Jones, F. D.
, and R. J. Koshes. 1995. Homosexuality and the military.American Journal of Psychiatry152 (1): 16-21.
36.
Kaplan, D.
1999. David, Jonathan and other soldiers: Masculinity, identity and sexuality in combat units in the Israeli army (in Hebrew). Tel-Aviv: Ha-Kibbutz Ha-Meuchad Press.
37.
Kaplan, D.
Forthcoming. The military as a second Bar Mitzvah: Combat service as an initiation rite to Zionist masculinity. In Imagined masculinities: Male identity and culture in the modern Middle East, edited by E. Sinclair-Webb and M. Ghoussoub.London: Al-Saqi Books.
38.
Kellet, A.
1982. Combat motivation: The behavior of soldiers in battle.Boston: Kluwer.
39.
Kimmel, S. M.
1994. Masculinity as homophobia: Fear, shame and silence in the construction of gender identity. In Theorizing masculinities, edited by H. Brod and M. Kaufman, 119-141. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
40.
Kimmerling, B.1993. Patterns of militarism in Israel.European Journal of Sociology34:196-223.
41.
Korb, L.
1994. Evolving perspectives on the military's policy on homosexuals: A personal note. In Gays and lesbian in the military: Issues, concerns and contrasts, edited by J. Scott and S. C. Stanley, 219-229. New York: Aldine.
42.
Koriat, A.
1990. Adjustment to the IDF—A review. Unpublished manuscript, Department of behavioral science, IDF.
43.
Levy-Schreiber, E.
, and E. Ben-Ari. Forthcoming. Body-building, character-building and nation-building: Gender and military service in Israel.Studies in Contemporary Judaism.
44.
Lieblich, A.
1989. Transition to adulthood during military service: The Israeli case.Albany: State University of New York Press.
45.
Lieblich, A.
, R. Tuval-Mashiach, and T. Zilber. 1998. Narrative research: Reading, analysis and interpretation.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
46.
Loizos, P.
1994. A broken mirror: Masculine sexuality in Greek ethnography. In Dislocating masculinity: Comparative ethnographies, edited by A. Cornwall and N. Lindisfarne, 66-81. London: Routledge.
47.
Martin, J.
1992. Cultures in organizations: Three perspectives.New York: Oxford University Press.
48.
Messner, M. A.
1992. Like family: Power, intimacy, and sexuality in male athletes friendships. In Men's friendships, edited by P. M. Nardi, 215-238. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
49.
Miller, L. L.
1994. Fighting for a just cause: Soldiers' views on gays in the military. In Gays and lesbian in the military: Issues, concerns and contrasts, edited by J. Scott and S. C. Stanley, 69-85. New York: Aldine.
50.
Morgan, D.H.J.
1994. Theater of war: Combat, the military and masculinities. In Theorizing masculinities, edited by H. Brod and M. Kaufman, 165-182. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
51.
Moskos, C. C.
1994. From citizens' army to social laboratory. In Gays and lesbian in the military: Issues, concerns and contrasts, edited by J. Scott and S. C. Stanley, 53-65. New York: Aldine.
52.
Orr, E.
, E. Liran, and J. Meyer. 1986. Compulsory military service as a challenge and a threat: Attitudes of Israeli twelfth graders towards conscription.Israel Social Science Research4 (2): 5-20.
53.
Roper, M.
, and J. Tosh. 1991. Introduction: Historians and the politics of masculinity. In Manful assertions, edited by M. Roper and J. Tosh, 1-24. London: Routledge.
54.
Salas, R. G.
1968. The assimilation of male volunteer recruits to the Australian regular army. A study of the process of militarization.Psychological research unit—Australian military forces. Report no. 10/68.
55.
Sedgewick, E.
1993. Epistemology of the closet. In The lesbian and gay reader, edited by H. Abelove, M. A. Barale, and D. Halperine, 45-61. New York: Routledge.
56.
Segal, D. R.
, P. A. Gade, and E. M. Johnson. 1993. Homosexuals in Western armed forces.Society31 (1): 37-42.
57.
Sion, L.
1997. Images of manhood among combat soldiers: Military service in the Israeli infantry as a rite of initiation from youth to adulthood (in Hebrew).Shaine Working Papers, 3. Jerusalem: Hebrew University.
58.
Sion, L.
, and E. Ben-Ari. 2000. Hungry, weary and horny: Humor and laughter in Israel's military reserves.
59.
Spence, D. P.
1982. Narrative truth and historical truth: Meaning and interpretation in psychoanalysis.New York: Norton.
60.
Strauss, A.
, and J. Corbin. 1990. Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques.Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
61.
Weeks, J.
1985. Sexuality and its discontents.London: Routledge.
62.
Weinstein, R. 1999. Homosexual men in the Israeli military: “Passing” and the reinforcement and legitimization of the military norms. Master's thesis, The Rothberg school of overseas students, Hebrew University, Jerusalem.
63.
Williams, W.
1977. Marxism and literature.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
64.
Zeeland, S.
1995. Sailors and sexual identity: Crossing the line between “straight” and “gay” in the U.S. navy.New York: Haworth.
