Characterize factors associated with smoking-cessation counseling in clinical encounters.
Design
Cross-sectional analysis of Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) 2000 data.
Setting
U.S. households.
Subjects
10,582 smokers (aged ≥ 18 years) reporting one or more clinical encounters during the prior year.
Measures
Multivariate-adjusted odds ratios (OR) and 95 % confidence intervals (CI) for quit advice associated with respondent and encounter variables.
Results
Almost 55 % of respondents were advised to quit smoking. Young men were advised to quit least often. Increasing age (18–24, 25–39, 40–64, ≥65 years) was associated with increasing odds of receiving quit advice (OR = 1.33, CI 1.10–1.61) for men. Other positive associations with quit advice included patient education, BMI, diagnosis of asthma, and private health insurance. Patients seeing physicians had greater odds of being advised to quit smoking (OR = 3.29, CI 2.13–5.06) than those seeing dentists. There was a 4% to 23% chance of receiving quit advice at any given nondental clinical encounter; the odds of such counseling did not rise significantly with the number of visits.
Conclusion
Smoking cessation counseling may be provided preferentially on the basis of patient demographics, and often is not provided at all. In a given year, just over half of smoking patients are advised to quit, and such counseling is provided at less than a quarter of clinical encounters.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).Annual smoking-attributable mortality, years of potential life lost, and economic costs—United States, 1995–1999.MMWR2002; 51: 300–303.
2.
Anonymous.Stat bite: leading causes of death in the United States, 1980 vs. 2001.J Natl Cancer Inst.2003; 95: 1819.
3.
LawM., TangJ.L.. An analysis of the effectiveness of interventions intended to help people stop smoking.Arch Intern Med.1995; 155: 1933–1941.
4.
SilagyC., SteadL.F.. Physician advice for smoking cessation.Cochrane Database Syst Rev.2000; update of Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2001; (2)CD000165.
5.
GoldsteinM.G., DePueJ.D., MonroeA.D.. A population-based survey of physician smoking cessation counseling practices.Prev Med.1998; 27: 720–729.
6.
GottliebN.H., GuoJ.L., BlozisS.A., HuangP.P.. Individual and contextual factors related to family practice residents’ assessment and counseling for tobacco cessation.J Am Board Fam Pract.2001; 14: 343–351.
7.
BockB.C., BeckerB., MonteiroR.. Physician intervention and patient risk perception among smokers with acute respiratory illness in the emergency department.Prev Med.2001; 32: 175–181.
8.
BockB.C., BeckerB., NiauraR., PartridgeR.. Smoking among emergency chest pain patients: motivation to quit, risk perception and physician intervention.Nicotine Tob Res.2000; 2: 93–96.
9.
DoescherM.P., SaverB.G.. Physicians’ advice to quit smoking. The glass remains half empty.J Fam Pract.2000; 49: 543–547.
10.
LinM., WardJ.E.. Smoking among ethnic Chinese patients and their recall of quit advice by Chinese-speaking general practitioners in Sydney.Aust N Z J Public Health.2000; 24: 437–440.
11.
ThorndikeA.N., FerrisT.G., StaffordR.S., RigottiN.A.. Rates of U.S. physicians counseling adolescents about smoking.J Natl Cancer Inst.1999; 91: 1857–1862.
12.
ThorndikeA.N., RigottiN.A., StaffordR.S., SingerD.E.. National patterns in the treatment of smokers by physicians.JAMA.1998; 279: 604–608.
13.
ChambersA.K., CorbinD.E.. Tobacco control activities of Iowa dental hygienists.J Community Health.1996; 21: 375–387.
AndaR.F., RemingtonP.L., SienkoD.G., DavisR.M.. Are physicians advising smokers to quit? The patient's perspective.JAMA.1987; 257: 1916–1919.
16.
GilpinE.A., PierceJ.P., JohnsonM., BalD.. Physician advice to quit smoking: results from the 1990 California Tobacco Survey.J Gen Intern Med.1993; 8: 549–553.
17.
AlfanoC.M., ZbikowskiS.M., RobinsonL.A.. Adolescent reports of physician counseling for smoking.Pediatrics.2002; 109: E47.
18.
LandoH.A., HatsukamiD.K.. Low rates of physicians counseling adolescents about smoking: a critical wake-up call.J Natl Cancer Inst.1999; 91: 1795–1796.
19.
GregorioD.I.. Counseling adolescents for smoking prevention: a survey of primary care physicians and dentists.Am J Public Health.1994; 84: 1151–1153.
20.
GerbertB., CoatesT., ZahndE.. Dentists as smoking cessation counselors.J Am Dent Assoc.1989; 118: 29–32.
21.
BlockD.E., BlockL.E., HuttonS.J., JohnsonK.M.. Tobacco counseling practices of dentists compared to other health care providers in a Midwestern region.J Dent Educ.1999; 63: 821–827.
22.
HillH.A., BraithwaiteR.L.. Attitudes, beliefs, and practices regarding smoking and smoking cessation among African-American physicians and dentists.J Natl Med Assoc.1997; 89: 745–751.
23.
PollakK.I., McBrideC.M., ScholesD.. Women's reports of smoking cessation advice during reproductive health visits and subsequent smoking cessation.Am J Manag Care.2002; 8: 837–844.
24.
ThorndikeA.N., StaffordR.S., RigottiN.A.. US physicians’ treatment of smoking in outpatients with psychiatric diagnoses.Nicotine Tob Res.2001; 3: 85–91.
25.
KleinJ.D., LevineL.J., AllanM.J.. Delivery of smoking prevention and cessation services to adolescents.Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.2001; 155: 597–602.
26.
JaenC.R., StangeK.C., TumielL.M., NuttingP.. Missed opportunities for prevention: smoking cessation counseling and the competing demands of practice.J Fam Pract1997; 45: 348–354.
27.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System Survey (BRFSS) Overview.U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/brfss/technical_infodata/surveydata/2000/Overview_00.rtf. Accessed June 12, 2005.
28.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) User's Guide.U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/brfss/pdf/userguide.pdf. Accessed June 12, 2005.
29.
PollakK.I., YarnallK.S., RimerB.K.. Factors associated with patient-recalled smoking cessation advice in a low-income clinic.J Natl Med Assoc.2002; 94: 354–363.
30.
HymowitzN., JacksonJ., CarterR., EckholdtH.. Past quit smoking assistance and doctors’ advice for white and African-American smokers.J Natl Med Assoc.1996; 88: 249–252.
31.
ParnesB., MainD.S., HolcombS., PaceW.. Tobacco cessation counseling among underserved patients: a report from CaReNet.J Fam Pract.2002; 51: 65–69.
32.
SaywellR.M., JayS.J., LukasP.J.. Indiana family physician attitudes and practices concerning smoking cessation.Indiana Med.1996; 89: 149–156.
33.
MalarcherA.M., FordE.S., NelsonD.E.. Trends in cigarette smoking and physicians’ advice to quit smoking among people with diabetes in the U.S.Diabetes Care.1995; 18: 694–697.
34.
Ossip-KIeinD.J., McintoshS., UtmanC.. Smokers ages 50+: who gets physician advice to quit?Prev Med2000; 31: 364–369.
35.
HelgasonA.R., LundK.E.. General practitioners’ perceived barriers to smoking cessation—results from four Nordic countries.Scand J Public Health.2002; 30: 141–147.
36.
ColemanT., MurphyE., CheaterF.. Factors influencing discussion of smoking between general practitioners and patients who smoke: a qualitative study.Br J Gen Pract.2000; 50: 207–210.
37.
JaenC.R., CrabtreeB.F., ZyzanskiS.J.. Making time for tobacco cessation counseling.J Fam Pract.1998; 46: 425–428.
38.
HayesC., KressinN., GarciaR.. Tobacco control practices: how do Massachusetts dentists compare with dentists nationwide?J Mass Dent Soc.1997; 46: 9–12, 14.
39.
SimoyanO.M., BadnerV.M., FreemanK.D.. Tobacco cessation services in dental offices. Are we doing all we can?N Y State Dent J.2002; 68: 34–40.
40.
FranklinJ.L., WilliamsA.F., KreschG.M.. Smoking cessation interventions by family physicians in Texas.Tex Med1992; 88: 60–64.
41.
PollakK.I., ArredondoE.M., YarnallK.S.. How do residents prioritize smoking cessation for young “high-risk” women? Factors associated with addressing smoking cessation.Prev Med.2001; 33: 292–299.
42.
Anonymous.From the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Trends in cigarette smoking among high school students-United States, 1991–2001.JAMA.2002; 288: 308–309.
43.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).Preventing Tobacco Use Among Young People-A Report of the Surgeon General.MMWR1994; 43.
44.
DolanT.A., McGorrayS.P., Grinstead-SkigenC.L., MecklenburgR.. Tobacco control activities in U.S. dental practices.J Am Dent Assoc.1997; 128: 1669–1679.
45.
KvizF.J., ClarkM.A., HopeH., DavisA.M.. Patients’ perceptions of their physician's role in smoking cessation by age and readiness to stop smoking.Prev Med.1997; 26: 340–349.
