Across Australia, patron banning measures address alcohol-related behavioral issues in entertainment districts. This article compares the legislative framing of Victoria’s licensee barring order policy with the experiences of recipients. The rationale and operational expectations for licensee barring are examined in relation to key themes which emerged during parliamentary debates of the legislation, and contrasted with the reported experiences of recipients. The findings point to a disconnect between the expected and actual operation of licensee barring, an absence of oversight, and a tangible risk of misuse. Barring orders extend to ordinary citizens a unique police-enforceable power to punish, yet licensees currently act without scrutiny or accountability. A review of barring policy is recommended to ensure a robust process for effective monitoring, meaningful consequences for the misuse of barring powers, and deeper consideration of the attendant risks to due process and procedural justice of the civilianisation of punishment.
AshworthA. (2004). Social control and anti-social behaviour: The subversion of human rights?Law Quarterly Review, 120, 263–291.
2.
BeckettK.HerbertS. (2010). Banished: The new social control in urban America. Oxford University Press.
3.
BradfordB.JacksonJ. (2016). Cooperating with the police as an act of social control: Trust and neighbourhood concerns as predictors of public assistance. Nordic Journal of Studies in Policing, 3(2), 111–131.
4.
BurneyE. (2002). Talking tough, acting coy: What happened to the anti-social behaviour order?The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice, 41, 469–484.
5.
BurneyE. (2006). “No spitting”: Regulation of offensive behaviour in England and Wales. In Von HirschA.SimesterA. P. (Eds.), Incivilities: Regulating offensive behaviour (pp. 195–218). Hart Publishing.
6.
BurneyE. (2009). Making people behave: Anti-social behaviour, politics and policy. Willan Publishing.
7.
CrawfordA. (2009). Governing through anti-social behaviour: Regulatory challenges to criminal justice. The British Journal of Criminology, 49(6), 810–831.
8.
Department of Justice. (2008). Victoria’s alcohol action plan 2008-2013. State Government of Victoria.
9.
FarmerC. (2017a). The disparity between human rights policy and parliamentary practice in Australia: A Victorian case study. The International Journal of Human Rights, 27(2), 167–188.
10.
FarmerC. (2017b). Upholding whose right? Discretionary police powers to punish, collective “pre-victimisation” and the dilution of individual rights. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 50(4), 493–509.
11.
FarmerC. (2018). Discretionary police powers to punish: A case study of Victoria’s banning notice provisions. Springer.
12.
FarmerC. (2019). Invisible powers to punish: Licensee-barring order provisions in Victoria and South Australia. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 8(1), 70–84.
13.
FarmerC.CurtisA.MillerP. (2018). The steady proliferation of Australia’s discretionary police-imposed patron banning powers: An unsubstantiated cycle of assertion and presumption. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 18(4), 431–449.
14.
HadfieldP.ListerS.TraynorP. (2009). “This town’s a different town today”: Policing and regulating the night-time economy. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 9(4), 465–485.
15.
HeapV.DickinsonJ. (2018). Public spaces protection orders: A critical policy analysis. Safer Communities, 17(3), 182–192.
16.
HuqA. Z.JacksonJ.TrinknerR. (2017). Legitimating practices: Revisiting the predicates of police legitimacy. The British Journal of Criminology, 57(5), 1101–1122.
17.
Legislative Assembly. (2011a, March3). State of Victoria parliamentary debates, pp. 586–587.
18.
Legislative Assembly. (2011b, March23). State of Victoria parliamentary debates, pp. 733–742.
19.
Legislative Assembly. (2011c, March24). State of Victoria parliamentary debates, pp. 789.
20.
Legislative Council. (2011a, April7). State of Victoria parliamentary debates, pp. 974–977.
21.
Legislative Council. (2011b, May3). State of Victoria parliamentary debates, pp. 1056–1070.
22.
MazerolleL.AntrobusE.BennettS.TylerT. R. (2013). Shaping citizen perceptions of police legitimacy: A randomized field trial of procedural justice. Criminology, 51(1), 33–64.
23.
McNamaraL.QuilterJ. (2014). Turning the spotlight on “offensiveness” as a basis for criminal liability. Alternative Law Journal, 39(1), 36–39.
24.
McNamaraL.QuilterJ. (2015). Public intoxication in NSW: The contours of criminalisation. The Sydney Law Review, 37(1), 1–35.
25.
MillerP.CoomberK.FerrisJ.BurnM.VakidisV.LivingstonM.. . . NajmanJ. (2019, April). Queensland Alcohol-Related Violence and Night Time Economy Monitoring (QUANTEM): Final report [Prepared for the Queensland Government Department of Premier and Cabinet]. Deakin University.
26.
MillerP.CurtisA.PalmerD.WarrenI.McFarlaneE. (2016). Patron banning in the nightlife entertainment districts: A key informant perspective. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 77(4), 606–611.
27.
NieuwenhuysenJ. (1986). Review of the Liquor Control Reform Act 1968. Victorian Government.
28.
PalmerD.WarrenI. (2014). The pursuit of exclusion through zonal banning. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 47(3), 429–446.
Scrutiny of Acts and Regulations Committee. (2011). SARC alert digest no. 2 of 2011. State Government of Victoria.
31.
TankebeJ.LieblingA. (2014). Legitimacy and criminal justice: An international exploration. Oxford University Press.
32.
TylerT. R. (2006). Why people obey the law. Princeton University Press.
33.
TylerT. R.JacksonJ. (2014). Popular legitimacy and the exercise of legal authority: Motivating compliance, cooperation, and engagement. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 20(1), 78–95.
34.
TylerT. R.WakslakC. J. (2004). Profiling and police legitimacy: Procedural justice, attributions of motive, and acceptance of police authority. Criminology, 42(2), 253–282.
WhelanJ. (Contributor). (2019). Gertie’s law podcast [Audio podcast] (Episode 1, March 25, transcript p. 23). The Supreme Court of Victoria. https://www.supremecourt.vic.gov.au/podcast
37.
YoungR. (2010). Ethnic profiling and summary justice—An ominous silence. In SvenssonK. (Ed.), Ethnic profiling: The use of “race” in UK law enforcement (pp. 43–49). Runnymede Trust.
