Ethical Concerns About Private (and Public) Corrections: Extending the Focus Beyond Profit- Making and the Delegation of Punishment

Abstract

Common criticisms of privatized corrections are that tying punishment to profits is unethical and that the administration of punishment should not be delegated to private entities. Such criticisms are important to consider but other ethical concerns also arise when privatizing corrections. For example, do private correctional entities protect individuals’ rights? The focus on profit-making also overlooks ethical considerations that arise with public corrections. Indeed, focusing only on the ethics of financially incentivizing punishment or the delegation of punishment obscures important nuances about the ethics of privatization and corrections generally. To these ends, a framework is presented that highlights that a range of ethical considerations attend to private corrections as well as to public corrections. It also reveals that a focus on ethics, while a good unto itself, could improve the effectiveness and efficiency of private and public corrections.

Keywords

privatized corrections ethics public corrections private prisons

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albin-Lackey

(2014). Profiting from probation: America’s “offender-funded” probation industry. Washington, DC: Human Rights Watch.

Allen

(2012, October 15). Florida’s Dozier school for boys: A true horror story. National Public Radio. Retrieved from www.npr.org/2012/10/15/162941770/floridas-dozier-school-for-boys-a-true-horror-story

American Civil Liberties Union. (2011). Banking on bondage: Private prisons and mass incarceration. New York, NY: Author.

Armstrong

G. S.

Griffin

M. L.

(2004). Does the job matter? Comparing correlates of stress among treatment and correctional staff in prisons. Journal of Criminal Justice, 32, 577-592.

Armstrong

G. S.

MacKenzie

D. L.

(2000). Private versus public sector operation: A comparison of the environmental quality in juvenile correctional facilities. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.

Armstrong

G. S.

MacKenzie

D. L.

(2003). Private versus public juvenile correctional facilities: Do differences in environmental quality exist? Crime & Delinquency, 49, 542-563.

Austin

Coventry

(2001). Emerging issues on privatized prisons. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Assistance.

Bales

W. D.

Bedard

L. E.

Quinn

S. T.

Ensley

D. T.

Holley

G. P.

(2005). Recidivism of public and private state prison inmates in Florida. Criminology & Public Policy, 4, 57-82.

Banks

(2016). Criminal justice ethics: Theory and practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

10.

Bannon

Nagrecha

Diller

(2010). Criminal justice debt: A barrier to reentry. New York, NY: Brennan Center for Justice.

11.

Baumgartner

F. R.

De Boef

Boydstun

A. E.

(2008). The decline of the death penalty and the discovery of innocence. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

12.

Blomberg

T. G.

Mestre

(2014). Net-widening. In Miller

J. M.

(Ed.), The encyclopedia of theoretical criminology (pp. 1-3). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.

13.

Bobrow

D. B.

Dryzek

J. S.

(1987). Policy analysis by design. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

14.

Bonta

Gendreau

(1990). Reexamining the cruel and unusual punishment of prison life. Law and Human Behavior, 14, 347-372.

15.

Bowditch

Everett

R. S.

(1987). Private prisons: Problems within the solution. Justice Quarterly, 4, 441-453.

16.

Brodsky

S. L.

(1974). A bill of rights for the correctional officer. Federal Probation, 38, 38-40.

17.

Brown

J. K.

(2017, January 12). Violence spiked in Florida’s prisons last year. Here are 2 reasons why. Miami Herald. Retrieved from http://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/miami-dade/article126239339.html

18.

Buchanan

J. M.

(1978). From private preferences to public philosophy: The development of public choice. In Buchanan

J. M.

et al. (Eds.), The economics of politics (pp. 1-21). London, England: Institute of Economic Affairs.

19.

Bureau of Justice Statistics. (1989). Children in custody, 1975-85: Census of public and private juvenile detention, correctional, and shelter facilities, 1975, 1977, 1979, 1983, and 1985. Washington, DC: Author.

20.

Burkhardt

B. C.

(2014). Private prisons in public discourse: Measuring moral legitimacy. Sociological Focus, 47, 279-298.

21.

Burkhardt

B. C.

Jones

(2016). Judicial intervention into prisons: Comparing private and public prisons from 1990 to 2005. Justice System Journal, 37, 39-52.

22.

Butts

J. A.

Pfaff

(2019). It’s about quality: Private confinement facilities in juvenile justice. Criminology & Public Policy, 18, 361-378.

23.

Call

J. E.

(1995). The supreme court and prisoners’ rights. Federal Probation, 59, 36-46.

24.

Carson

E. A.

(2018, February 24). Prisoners in 2016. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.

25.

Cohen

(2015, April 28). How for-profit prisons have become the biggest lobby no one is talking about. The Washington Post. Retrieved from www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/04/28/how-for-profit-prisons-have-become-the-biggest-lobby-no-one-is-talking-about

26.

Crewe

Liebling

Hulley

(2011). Staff culture, use of authority and prisoner quality of life in public and private sector prisons. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 44, 94-115.

27.

Cullen

F. T.

Jonson

C. L.

Mears

D. P.

(2017). Reinventing community corrections. Crime and Justice, 46, 27-93.

28.

DaCosse

(1998). Richardson v. McKnight: Barring qualified immunity from 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for private jailers. Pepperdine Law Review, 26, 149-168.

29.

Davilmar

C. M.

(2014). We tried to make them offer rehab, but they said, “no, no, no!”: Incentivizing private prison reform through the private prisoner rehabilitation credit. New York University Law Review, 89, 267-292.

30.

Davis

(2000). From the convict lease system to the super-max prison. In James

(Ed.), States of confinement: Policing, detention, and prisons (pp. 60-74). New York, NY: St. Martin’s Press.

31.

DiIulio

J. J.

(1990). The duty to govern: A critical perspective on the private management of prisons and jails. In McDonald

D. C.

(Ed.), Private prisons and the public interest (pp. 154-178). New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

32.

Dolovich

(2009). Cruelty, prison conditions, and the eighth amendment. New York University Law Review, 84, 881-979.

33.

Ducharme

(2018, February 3). A controversial bill would allow chemical castration of sex offenders in Oklahoma. Time. Retrieved from http://time.com/5132314/chemical-castration-sex-offenders/

34.

Duwe

Clark

(2013). The effects of private prison confinement on offender recidivism: Evidence from Minnesota. Criminal Justice Review, 38, 375-394.

35.

Eisen

L. B.

(2017a). Inside private prisons: An American dilemma in the age of mass incarceration. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

36.

Eisen

L. B.

(2017b). Private prisons lock up thousands of Americans with almost no oversight. New York, NY: Brennan Center for Justice. Retrieved from https://www.brennancenter.org/analysis/private-prisons-lock-thousands-americans-almost-no-oversight

37.

Eisen

L. B.

(2018, November 14). Down under, more humane private prisons. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/14/opinion/private-prisons-australia-new-zealand.html

38.

Eisen

L. B.

(2019). Privatized corrections: Questions of legality. Criminology & Public Policy, 18, 419-446.

39.

Ericson

R. V.

McMahon

M. W.

Evans

D. G.

(1987). Punishing for profit: Reflections on the revival of privatization in corrections. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 29, 355-387.

40.

Farabee

Knight

(2002). A comparison of public and private prisons in Florida: During- and post-prison performance indicators. Los Angeles, CA: Query Research.

41.

Feeley

M. M.

(1991). The privatization of punishment in historical perspective. In Gormley

W. T.

(Ed.), Privatization and its alternatives (pp. 199-225). Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press.

42.

Feeley

M. M.

(2002). Entrepreneurs of punishment: The legacy of privatization. Punishment & Society, 4, 321-344.

43.

Feeley

M. M.

(2014). The unconvincing case against private prisons. Indiana Law Journal, 89, 1401-1436.

44.

Flexner

Baldwin

R. N.

(1914). Juvenile courts and probation. New York, NY: Century.

45.

Forst

(2004). Errors of justice: Nature, sources, and remedies. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

46.

Gaes

G. G.

(2019). Current status of prison privatization research on American prisons and jails. Criminology & Public Policy, 18, 269-293.

47.

Gaes

G. G.

Camp

S. D.

Nelson

J. B.

Saylor

W. G.

(2004). Measuring prison performance: Government privatization and accountability. Walnut Creek, CA: Rowman & Littlefield.

48.

Geraghty

Velez

(2011). Bringing transparency and accountability to criminal justice institutions in the South. Stanford Law & Policy Review, 22, 455-488.

49.

Getlen

(2014, February 23). Corrupt “kids for cash” judge ruined more than 2,000 lives. New York Post. Retrieved from https://nypost.com/2014/02/23/film-details-teens-struggles-in-state-detention-in-payoff-scandal/

50.

Hackett

J. C.

Hatry

H. P.

Levinson

R. B.

Allen

Chi

Feigenbaum

E. D.

(1987). Contracting for the operation of prisons and jails. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.

51.

Harding

R. W.

(1997). Private prisons and public accountability. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.

52.

Harding

R. W.

(2000). Private prisons. In Tonry

(Ed.), The handbook of crime and punishment (pp. 626-655). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

53.

Harding

R. W.

(2001). Private prisons. Crime and Justice, 28, 265-346.

54.

Harris

Smith

Obara

(2019). Justice “cost points”: Examination of privatization within public systems of justice. Criminology & Public Policy, 18, 343-359.

55.

Hogan

N. L.

Lambert

E. G.

Jenkins

Hall

D. E.

(2009). The impact of job characteristics on private prison staff: Why management should care. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 34, 151-165.

56.

Johnson

(2012, March 8). Prison buyers lock in occupancy: Private purchases bring in cash, but could mean harsh sentences. USA Today, p. A1.

57.

Johnson

(2019, July 16). Federal prison officials get bonuses as staffing shortages, management problems persist. USA Today. Retrieved from https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2019/07/16/us-bureau-prisons-officials-got-thousands-bonuses-despite-staff-shortages/1708217001/

58.

Kantorowicz-Reznichenko

(2015). Can imprisonment be cheaper? The case for private prisons. European Journal of Law Reform, 17, 502-527.

59.

Lanza-Kaduce

Parker

K. F.

Thomas

C. W.

(1999). A comparative recidivism analysis of releasees from private and public prisons. Crime & Delinquency, 45, 28-47.

60.

Latessa

E. J.

Cullen

F. T.

Gendreau

(2002). Beyond correctional quackery—Professionalism and the possibility of effective treatment. Federal Probation, 66, 43-49.

61.

Lemkemeier

(1998). Withholding qualified immunity from private prison guards: A costly mistake. Journal of Urban and Contemporary Law, 54, 345-360.

62.

Levinson

R. B.

(1985). Okeechobee: An evaluation of privatization in corrections. The Prison Journal, 65, 75-94.

63.

Lindsey

A. M.

Mears

D. P.

(2018). The impacts of privatization in corrections: The state of evidence and recommendations for moving forward. In Huebner

B. M.

Frost

N. A.

(Eds.), Handbook on the consequences of sentencing and punishment decisions (pp. 311-330). New York, NY: Routledge.

64.

Lindsey

A. M.

Mears

D. P.

Cochran

J. C.

(2016). The privatization debate: A conceptual framework for improving (public and private) corrections. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 32, 308-327.

65.

Logan

C. H.

(1987). The propriety of proprietary prisons. Federal Probation, 51, 35-40.

66.

Logan

C. H.

(1988). Private prisons: Cons and pros. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.

67.

Logan

C. H.

(1990). Private prisons: Cons and pros. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

68.

Lundahl

B. W.

Kunz

Brownell

Harris

Van Vleet

(2009). Prison privatization: A meta-analysis of cost and quality of confinement indicators. Research on Social Work Practice, 19, 383-394.

69.

MacIntyre

(2005). A short history of ethics: A history of moral philosophy from the Homeric age to the 20th century. London, England: Routledge.

70.

Mahtesian

(1996). The uprising of the prison guards. Governing Magazine, 9, 38-41.

71.

McDonald

Patten

(2003). Governments’ management of private prisons. Cambridge, MA: Abt Associates.

72.

Mears

D. P.

(2008). Accountability, efficiency, and effectiveness in corrections: Shining a light on the black box of prison systems. Criminology & Public Policy, 7, 143-152.

73.

Mears

D. P.

(2010). American criminal justice policy: An evaluation approach to increasing accountability and effectiveness. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

74.

Mears

D. P.

Bacon

(2009). Improving criminal justice through better decision making: Lessons from the medical system. Journal of Criminal Justice, 37, 142-154.

75.

Mei

Cortright

C. E.

Stohr

M. K.

Hemmens

Collins

P. A.

Iannacchione

Hudson

(2018). Confirmatory analysis of an ethics instrument for corrections. The Prison Journal, 98, 229-250.

76.

Miller

C. M.

Burch

A. D. S.

(2017, October 10). Criminal record? Horrible work history? Florida juvenile justice would still hire you. Miami Herald. Retrieved from www.miamiherald.com/news/special-reports/florida-prisons/article177889736.html

77.

Miller

J. R.

(2017, November 28). Corrections officer arrested for sex with inmate. New York Post. Retrieved from https://nypost.com/2017/11/28/corrections-officer-arrested-for-sex-with-inmate/

78.

Minton

T. D.

(2015). Census of jails: Population changes, 1999-2013. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.

79.

Montes

A. M.

Mears

D. P.

(2019). Privatized corrections in the 21st century: Reframing the privatization debate. Criminology & Public Policy, 18, 217-239.

80.

Mukherjee

(2019, January 4). Does prison privatization distort justice? Evidence on time served and recidivism. Presented at the annual meeting of the American Economic Association. Retrieved from https://www.aeaweb.org/conference/2019/preliminary/paper/DittFBZG

81.

Mullen

Chabotar

K. J.

Carrow

D. M.

(1985). The privatization of corrections. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.

82.

The New York Times . (2016, September 27). Transcript of the first debate. The New York Times. Transcript. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/27/us/politics/transcript-debate.html

83.

Niskanen

W. A.

(1968). The peculiar economics of bureaucracy. The American Economic Review, 58, 293-305.

84.

Ovalle

(2018, May 15). Florida Prison colonel charged in pepper-spray attack on inmate caught on video. Miami Herald. Retrieved from https://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/crime/article211154054.html

85.

Perrone

Pratt

T. C.

(2003). Comparing the quality of confinement and cost-effectiveness of public versus private prisons: What we know, why we do not know more, and where to go from here. The Prison Journal, 83, 301-322.

86.

Petersilia

(2003). When prisoners come home: Parole and prisoner reentry. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

87.

Pollock

J. M.

(2013). Ethical dilemmas and decisions in criminal justice. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth, Cengage Learning.

88.

Powers

R. A.

Kaukinen

Jeanis

(2017). An examination of recidivism among inmates released from a private reentry center and public institutions in Colorado. The Prison Journal, 97, 609-627.

89.

Pratt

T. C.

(2019). Cost-benefit analysis and privatized corrections. Criminology & Public Policy, 18, 447-456.

90.

Prentice

(2013, September 16). U.S. judge: CCA violated Idaho contract when it understaffed private prison. Boise Weekly. Retrieved from https://www.boiseweekly.com/CityDesk/archives/2013/09/16/us-judge-cca-violated-idaho-contract-when-it-understaffed-private-prison

91.

Press

Washburn

(2002, December). The at-risk-youth industry. The Atlantic Monthly, pp. 38-40.

92.

Reed

(2016). The life and adventures of a haunted convict. New York, NY: Random House.

93.

Reisig

M. D.

Pratt

T. C.

(2000). The ethics of correctional privatization: A critical examination of the delegation of coercive authority. The Prison Journal, 80, 210-222.

94.

Robbins

I. P.

(1989). The legal dimensions of private incarceration. The American University Law Review, 38, 531-854.

95.

Russell

(1910). Philosophical essays. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

96.

Schultz

J. L.

(1973). The cycle of juvenile court history. Crime & Delinquency, 19, 457-476.

97.

Sessions

J. B.

(2017). Rescission of memorandum on use of private prisons. Washington, DC: Office of the Attorney General.

98.

Shichor

(1993). The corporate context of private prisons. Crime, Law and Social Change, 20, 113-138.

99.

Shichor

(1995). Punishment for profit: Private prisons/public concerns. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

100.

Shichor

(1998). Private prisons in perspective: Some conceptual issues. The Howard Journal, 37, 82-100.

101.

Singer

(1970). Bringing the constitution to prison: Substantive due process and the eighth amendment. Cincinnati Law Review, 39, 650-684.

102.

Sparks

Gacek

(2019). Persistent puzzles: The philosophy and ethics of private corrections in the context of contemporary penality. Criminology & Public Policy, 18, 379-399.

103.

Spivak

A. L.

Sharp

S. F.

(2008). Inmate recidivism as a measure of private prison performance. Crime & Delinquency, 54, 482-508.

104.

Starr

(1988). The meaning of privatization. Yale Law & Policy Review, 6, 6-41.

105.

Stephan

J. J.

(2008). Census of state and federal correctional facilities, 2005. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.

106.

Stillman

(2014, June 23). Get out of jail, Inc.: Does the alternative-to-incarceration industry profit from injustice? The New Yorker, pp. 46-61.

107.

Sullivan

(2014, June 30). Youth care worker accused of sex acts with teen at Tampa facility. Tampa Bay Times. Retrieved from http://www.tampabay.com/news/publicsafety/crime/worker-at-tampa-juvenile-facility-under-investigation-for-sex-with-teen/2186627

108.

Tanner

(2013). The case for private prisons. London, England: Reform.

109.

Tartaglia

(2014). Private prisons, private records. Boston University Law Review, 94, 1689-1744.

110.

Thomas

C. W.

(1991). Prisoners’ rights and correctional privatization: A legal and ethical analysis. Business and Professional Ethics Journal, 10, 3-45.

111.

Tonry

Petersilia

(1999). American prisons at the beginning of the twenty-first century. Crime and Justice, 26, 1-16.

112.

Travis

(2002). Invisible punishment: An instrument of social exclusion. In Mauer

Chesney-Lind

(Eds.), Invisible punishment: The collateral consequences of mass imprisonment (pp. 15-36). New York, NY: The New Press.

113.

Travis

(2005). But they all come back: Facing the challenges of prisoner reentry. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.

114.

Triplett

Mullings

(1996). Work-related stress and coping among correctional officers: Implications from organizational literature. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24, 291-308.

115.

United States Department of Labor. (2014). The GEO group must address workplace violence hazards as a result of corporate-wide settlement with U.S. Department of Labor. Washington, DC: Author.

116.

Volokh

(2013). The modest effect of Minneci v. Pollard on inmate litigants. Akron Law Review, 46, 287-329.

117.

Waks

A. L.

(2013). Federal incarceration by contract in a Post-Minneci world: Legislation to equalize the constitutional rights of prisoners. University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 46, 1065-1096.

118.

Wright

K. A.

(2010). Strange bedfellows? Reaffirming rehabilitation and prison privatization. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 49, 74-90.

119.

Yates

S. Q.

(2016). Reducing our use of private prisons. Washington, DC: Office of the Deputy Attorney General.