It is widely accepted that individuals with major mental disorders are arrested at significantly higher rates when compared with non-disordered individuals. However, theoretical consensus regarding the cause of the arrest disparity still eludes researchers today. Two prevailing perspectives have dominated the debate—criminalization and criminality. Criminalization proponents argue the arrest disparity results from structural forces in society that have increasingly caused persons with mental disorders to come into contact with the justice system. Criminality proponents argue that the source of the disparity is the increased criminal behavior of persons with mental disorders. This study tests competing hypotheses drawn from these two perspectives. We analyze data from a sample of individuals recently released from psychiatric hospitals and a comparison sample of individuals from the same communities. Results of multivariate logistic regression models predicting arrest provide support for both perspectives. Implications of this research and suggestions for future research are discussed.
AbramsonM. (1972). The criminalization of mentally disordered behavior: Possible side effects of new mental health law. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 23, 101-105.
2.
American Psychiatric Association. (1980). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
3.
American Psychiatric Association. (1987). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed., rev.). Washington, DC: Author.
4.
AppelbaumP. S.RobbinsP. C.MonahanJ. (2000). Violence and delusions: Data from the MacArthur Violence Risk Assessment Study. American Journal of Psychiatry, 157, 566-572.
5.
BeckerM. A.RossA.BoazT.ConstantineR. (2011). Gender differences and risk of arrest among offenders with serious mental illness. Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research, 38, 16-27.
6.
BittnerE. (1967). Police discretion in the emergency apprehension of mentally ill persons. Social Problems, 14, 278-292.
7.
BorumR.Williams DeaneM.SteadmanH. J.MorrisseyJ. (1998). Police perspectives on responding to mentally ill people in crisis: Perceptions of program effectiveness. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 16, 393-405.
8.
BrekkeJ. S.PrindleC.BaeS. W.LongJ. D. (2001). Risks for individuals with schizophrenia who are living in the community. Psychiatric Services, 52, 1358-1366.
9.
ClarkR. E.RickettsS. K.McHugoG. J. (1999). Legal system involvement and costs for persons in treatment for severe mental illness and substance use disorders. Psychiatric Services, 50, 641-647.
10.
DeLisiM.VaughnM. G.BeaverK. M.WrightJ. P. (2010). The Hannibal Lecter myth: Psychopathy and verbal intelligence in the MacArthur Violence Risk Assessment Study. Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 32, 169-177.
11.
DeMatteoD.LaDukeC.LocklairB. R.HeilbrunK. (2013). Community-based alternatives for justice-involved individuals with severe mental illness: Diversion, problem-solving courts, and reentry. Journal of Criminal Justice, 41, 64-71.
12.
DittonP. M. (1999, May). Special report: Mental health treatment of inmates and probationers (NVJ 174463). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
13.
ElbogenE. B.MustilloS.van DornR.SwansonJ. W.SwartzM. S. (2007). The impact of perceived need for treatment on risk of arrest and violence among people with severe mental illness. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 34, 197-210.
14.
EngelR. S.SilverE. (2001). Policing mentally disordered suspects: A reexamination of the criminalization hypothesis. Criminology, 39, 225-252.
15.
FirstM. B.SpitzerR. L.GibbonM.WilliamsJ. B. (1995). Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I Disorders, Patient Edition, January 1995 FINAL. SCID-I/P Version 2.0). New York, NY: Biometrics Research Department, New York State Psychiatric Institute.
16.
FisherW. H.BanksS. M.Roy-BujnowskiK.GrudzinskasA. J.Jr.SimonL. J.WolffN. (2010). Categorizing temporal patterns of arrest in a cohort of adults with serious mental illness. Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research, 37, 477-490.
17.
FisherW.H.DrakeR.E. (2007). Forensic mental illness and other policy misadventures. Commentary on “Extending assertive community trteatment to criminal justice settings: Origins, current evidence, and future directions.”Community Mental Health Journal, 43(5), 545-548.
18.
FisherW. H.Roy-BujnowskiK. M.GrudzinskasA. J.Jr.ClayfieldJ. C.BanksS. M.WolffN. (2006). Patterns and prevalence of arrest in a statewide cohort of mental health care consumers. Psychiatric Services, 57, 1623-1628.
19.
FisherW. H.SilverE.WolffN. (2006). Beyond criminalization: Toward a criminologically-informed mental health policy and services research. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 33, 544-557.
20.
FisherW. H.SimonL.Roy-BujnowskiK.GrudzinskasA.WolffN.CrockettE.BanksS. (2011). Risk of arrest among public mental health services recipients and the general public. Psychiatric Services, 62, 67-72.
21.
FrankR.GliedS. (2006). Mental health policy in the United States since 1950: Better but not well. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
22.
GodfredsonJ. W.OgloffJ. R. P.ThomasS. D. M.LuebbersS. (2010). Police discretion and encounters with people experiencing mental illness. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 37, 1392-1405.
23.
GreenT. M. (1997). Police as frontline mental health workers: The decision to arrest or refer to mental health agencies. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 20, 469-486.
24.
GrudzinskasA. J.Jr.ClayfieldJ. C.Roy-BujnowskiK.FisherW. H.RichardsonM. H. (2005). Integrating the criminal justice system into mental health service delivery: The Worcester diversion experience. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 23, 277-293.
25.
HidayV. A.BurnsP. J. (2010). Mental illness and the criminal justice system. In ScheidT. L.BrownT. N. (Eds.), A handbook for the study of mental health: Social contexts, theories, and systems (pp. 478-498). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
26.
HirschfieldP.MaschiT.WhiteH. R.TraubL. G.LoeberR. (2006). Mental health and juvenile arrests: Criminality, criminalization, or compassion?Criminology, 44, 593-630.
27.
HodginsS.AldertonC. J.MakT. (2007). From conduct disorder to severe mental illness: Associations with aggressive behavior, crime, and victimization. Psychological Medicine, 38, 975-987.
28.
JungingerJ.ClaypooleK.LaygoR.CrisantiA. (2006). Effects of serious mental illness and substance abuse on criminal offenses. Psychiatric Services, 57, 879-882.
29.
KondoL. L. (2000). Therapeutic jurisprudence: Issues analysis and applications: Advocacy of the establishment of mental health specialty courts in the provision of therapeutic justice for mentally ill offenders. Seattle University Law Review, 48, 296-313.
30.
LambH. R.WeinbergerL. E. (1998). Persons with severe mental illness in jails and prisons: A review. Psychiatric Services, 49, 483-492.
31.
LambH. R.WeinbergerL. E. (2011). Meeting the needs of those persons with serious mental illness who are most likely to become criminalized. The Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 39, 549-554.
32.
LambH. R.WeinbergerL. E.DeCuirW. J. (2002). The police and mental health. Psychiatric Services, 53, 1266-1271.
33.
LambH. R.WeinbergerL. E.GrossB. H. (2004). Mentally ill persons in the criminal justice system: Some perspectives. Psychiatric Quarterly, 75, 107-126.
34.
LipsonG. S.TurnerJ. T.KasperR. (2010). A strategic approach to police interactions involving persons with mental illness. Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 10, 30-38.
35.
LitschgeC. M.VaughnM. G. (2009). The Mentally Ill Offender Treatment and Crime Reduction Act of 2004: Problem and prospects. The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry, 20, 542-558.
36.
LurigioA. J. (2012). Responding to the needs of people with mental illness in the criminal justice system: An area ripe for research and community partnerships. Journal of Crime and Justice, 35, 1-12.
37.
LurigioA. J.WatsonA. C. (2010). The police and people with mental illness: New approaches to a longstanding problem. Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 10, 3-14.
38.
MarkowitzF. E. (2006). Psychiatric hospital capacity and crime and arrest rates. Criminology, 44, 45-72.
39.
MarkowitzF. E. (2011). Mental illness, crime, and violence: Risk, context, and social control. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 16, 36-44.
40.
MartinezL. E. (2010). Police departments’ response in dealing with persons with mental illness. Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 10, 166-174.
41.
McPhersonW. (2008). Managing the mental health population at the Broward Sheriff’s office. Corrections Today, 70, 62-67.
42.
MenardS. (2004). Six approaches to calculating standardized logistic regression coefficients. The American Statistician, 58, 218-223.
43.
MonahanJ.SteadmanH. J.SilverE.AppelbaumP. S.Clark RobbinsP.MulveyE. P.. . .BanksS. (2001). Rethinking risk assessment: The MacArthur study of mental disorder and violence. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
44.
NovakK. J.EngelR. S. (2005). Disentangling the influence of suspect’s demeanor and mental disorder on arrest. Policing: International Journal of Police Strategy & Management, 28, 493-512.
45.
PandianiJ. A.RosencheckR.BanksS. M. (2003). Elevated risk of arrest for Veteran’s Administration health services recipients in four Florida counties. Law and Human Behavior, 27, 289-298.
46.
PetersonJ. P.SkeemJ. L.HartE.VidalS.KeithF. (2010). Analyzing offense patterns as a function of mental illness to test the criminalization hypothesis. Psychiatric Services, 61, 1217-1222.
47.
RajputS.HassiotisARichardsM.HatchS.L.StewartR. (2011). Associations between IQ and common mental disorders: The 2000 British National Survey of Psychiatric Morbidity. European Psychiatry, 26(6), 390-395.
48.
SilverE. (2000). Extending social disorganization theory: A multilevel approach to the study of violence among persons with mental illnesses. Criminology, 38, 1043-1074.
49.
SilverE.MulveyE. P.MonahanJ. (1999). Assessing violence risk among discharged psychiatric patients: Towards an ecological approach. Law and Human Behavior, 23, 235-253.
50.
SkeemJ. L.ManchakS.PetersonJ. K. (2011). Correctional policy for offenders with mental illness: Creating a new perspective for recidivism reduction. Law and Human Behavior, 35, 110-126.
51.
SolomonP.DraineJ. (1995). Issues in serving the forensic client. Social Work, 40, 25-33.
52.
SteadmanH. J.MulveyE. P.MonahanJ.RobbinsP. C.AppelbaumP. S.GrissoT.. . .SilverE. (1998). Violence by people discharged from acute psychiatric inpatient facilities and by others in the same neighborhoods. Archives of General Psychiatry, 55, 393-401.
53.
SwartzJ. A.LurigioA. J. (2007). Serious mental illness and arrest: The generalized mediating effect of substance use. Crime & Delinquency, 53, 581-604.
54.
TengstromA.HodginsS.GrannM.LangstromN.KullgrenG. (2004). Schizophrenia and criminal offending: The role of psychopathy and substance use disorders. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 31, 367-391.
55.
TeplinL. A. (1984). Criminalizing mental disorder: The comparative arrest rate of the mentally ill. The American Psychologist, 39, 794-803.
56.
TeplinL. A. (1985). The criminality of the mentally ill: A dangerous misconception. American Journal of Psychiatry, 142, 593-599.
57.
TeplinL. A. (1990). The prevalence of severe mental disorder among male urban jail detainees: Comparison with the epidemiologic catchment area program. American Journal of Public Health, 80, 663-669.
58.
TeplinL. A. (2000). Keeping the peace: Police discretion and mentally ill persons. National Institute of Justice Journal, 244, 8-15.
59.
TeplinL. A.AbramK. M.McClellandG. M. (1997). Prevalence of psychiatric disorders among incarcerated women. Archives of General Psychiatry, 53, 505-512.
60.
TeplinL. A.PruettN. S. (1992). Police as street corner psychiatrists: Managing the mentally ill. International Journal of Law Psychiatry, 15, 139-156.
61.
ThomasJ. M.ThomasS. A.BurgasonK. A.WichinskyL. C. (2014). Early contact with the criminal justice system and intellectual functioning as risk factors for violent and chronic adult offending. Western Criminology Review, 15(1), 34-50.
TuckerA. S.VanHasseltV. B.VecchiG. M.BrowningS. L. (2011). Responding to persons with mental illness. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 80(10), 1-6.
64.
WatsonA. C.AngellB. (2013). The role of stigma and uncertainty in moderating the effect of procedural justice on cooperation and resistance in police encounters with persons with mental illness. Psychiatry, Public Policy, and Law, 19, 30-39.
65.
WatsonA. C.CorriganP. W.OttariV. (2004). Police officers’ attitudes toward and decisions about persons with mental illness. Psychiatric Services, 55, 49-53.
66.
WhiteM. C.ChafetzL.Collins-BrideG.NickensJ. (2006). History of arrest, incarceration, and victimization in community-based severely mentally ill. Journal of Community Health, 31, 123-135.
67.
WolffN.DiamondR. J.HelminiakT. W. (1997). A new look at an old issue: People with mental illness and the law enforcement system. The Journal of Mental Health Administration, 24, 152-165.
68.
WolffN.FruahB. C.HueningJ.ShiJ.EppersonM. W. (2013). Practice informs the next generation of behavioral health and criminal justice interventions. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 36, 1-10.
69.
WolffN.MaschiT.BjerklieJ. R. (2004). Profiling mentally disordered prison inmates: A case study in New Jersey. Journal of Correctional Care, 11(5), 5-27.
