Effect of Abrasion on Penetration of Tri-allate Through Selected Disposable Coverall Fabrics

Abstract

Many agricultural workers wear disposable nonwoven coveralls while applying pesticides in the field. The degree of protection these garments offer after abrasive wear has not been studied. The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of abrasion on the penetration of a liquid pesticide, tri-allate, through selected disposable garment fabrics: Kleenguard® EP and Tyvek®. The relationship between the initial thickness and the initial mass of the fabric specimens and pesticide penetration also was examined to determine the effect of initial fabric variability on penetration. Penetration of tri-allate through the two fabrics differed statistically although total penetration was less than 1 % for both fabrics. Abrasion simulating one day's wearing resulted in a statistically significant increase in penetration through Kleenguard® EP but had no effect on penetration through Tyvek®. Initial mean thickness correlated with the penetration of tri-allate for Tyvek® at all three levels of abrasion and for unabraded Kleenguard® EP, but there was no correlation between initial mean thickness and pesticide penetration on abraded Kleenguard® EP specimens. Abrasion was a greater determinant of the rate of pesticide penetration than initial variability in thickness for Kleenguard® EP; initial variability in thickness remained a significant factor in pesticide penetration even after abrasion for Tyvek®. Initial mass did not correlate with pesticide penetration for either fabric.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Branson, D.H. , DeJonge, J.O. , & Munson, D. (1986). Thermal response associated with prototype pesticide protective clothing. Textile Research Journal, 56, 27-34.

Hobbs, N.E. , & Oakland, B.G. (1988). Use of methylene blue dye to predict fabric penetration by malathion. In S. Z. Mansdorf , R. Sager , & A. P. Nielson (Eds.), Performance of protective clothing: Second symposium , ASTM STP 989 (pp. 738-744). Philadelphia : American Society for Testing and Materials.

Laughlin, J.M. , Easley, C.B. , Gold, R.E. , & Hill, R.M. (1986). Fabric parameters and pesticide characteristics that impact on dermal exposure of applicators. In R. L. Barker & G. C. Coletta (Eds.), Performance of protective clothing, ASTM STP 900 (pp. 136-150). Philadelphia: American Society for Testing and Materials .

Leonas, K.K. (1986). Apparel fabrics as barriers to pesticide penetration (Doctoral dissertation, University of Tennessee, 1985). Dissertation Abstracts International, 47, 595B.

Lloyd, G.A. , Bell, G.J. , Howarth, J.A. , & Samuels, S. (1985, May). Evaluation of the Kimberly-Clark boiler suit for the protection of spray operators. (Available from Operator Protection Research Group, Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries & Food, Hatching Green, Harpenden, Hertts, England)

Martin-Scott, S. (1987). The effect of abrasion on pesticide penetration through disposable coverall fabrics. Unpublished master's thesis, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.

Martin-Scott, S. , Kerr, N. , & Rigakis, K. (1987). An analysis of laboratory abrasion on limited-use garment fabrics. Proceeding of the Association of College Professors of Textiles and Clothing, p. 45.

Martin-Scott, S. , & Rigakis, K. (1987). Efficacy of selected laundry practices used by Alberta farm families in removing pesticide residues from clothing. Proceedings of the 22nd Annual Workshop for Pesticide and Trace Organic Residue Analysts (pp. 32-37). Calgary: Pesticide and Trace Organic Residue Analysts.

Moraski, R.V. , & Nielsen, A.P. (1985). Protective clothing and its significance to the pesticide user. American Chemical Society Symposium Series , 273, 395-402.

10.

Orlando, J. , Branson, D. , Ayers, G. , & Leavitt, R. (1981). The penetration of formulated Guthion spray through selected fabrics. Journal of Environmental Science & Health , B16, 617-628.

11.

Perkins, H.M. (1988). Attitude and behavior of farmers toward disposable protective clothing: An experimental field study. Unpublished master's thesis , University of Alberta, Edmonton , Canada.

12.

Rigakis, K.B. , Kerr, N. , & Crown, E.M. (1985, October). Efficacy of selected laundry practices used by Alberta farm families in removing pesticide residues from clothing . Paper presented at the meeting of the Association of College Professors of Textiles and Clothing, Napa, CA .

13.

Staiff, D.C. , Davis, J.E. , & Stevens, E.R. (1982). Evaluation of various clothing materials for protection and worker acceptability during application of pesticides. Archives of Environmental Contamination & Toxicology, 11, 391-398.