Primary Versus Secondary Prevention Effects of a Gender-Transformative Sexual Violence Prevention Program Among Male Youth: A Planned Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Clinical Trial
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online October, 2023
Primary Versus Secondary Prevention Effects of a Gender-Transformative Sexual Violence Prevention Program Among Male Youth: A Planned Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Clinical Trial
Engaging adolescent males is a promising violence prevention strategy. This study explored primary versus secondary prevention effects of a gender-transformative program (i.e., Manhood 2.0) versus job-readiness training on multiple forms of violence perpetration. Adolescent males, ages 13 to 19 years, were recruited through youth-serving organizations in Pittsburgh, PA, between July 27, 2015, and June 5, 2017, to participate in an unblinded community-based cluster-randomized trial in 20 neighborhoods. The intervention curriculum, Manhood 2.0, focused on challenging norms that foster gender-based violence and building bystander skills. The control program was job-readiness training. We completed a planned secondary analysis of surveys from baseline and 9 months post intervention (follow-up), wherein we stratified participants based on any sexual violence/adolescent relationship abuse (SV/ARA) at baseline and examined risk of perpetration of SV/ARA, incapacitated sex, sexual harassment, cyber sexual abuse, peer violence, bullying, and homophobic teasing at follow-up. Among 866 participants, mean age was 15.6 years, 70% identified as Black, 6% as Hispanic, and 6% as multiracial. In both the Manhood 2.0 intervention group and job-readiness control groups, youth who reported SV/ARA at baseline were significantly more likely to report any form of SV/ARA, incapacitated sex, sexual harassment, cyber sexual abuse, bullying, and homophobic teasing at follow-up. Among participants who reported no SV/ARA perpetration at baseline, participating in the Manhood 2.0 intervention program was associated with increased risk of SV/ARA at follow-up compared to participating in the job-readiness control program. Among participants who reported SV/ARA perpetration at baseline, participating in the Manhood 2.0 intervention group was associated with lower risk of peer violence at follow-up. Synergizing gender-transformative approaches with job-readiness training may offer opportunities for crosscutting prevention programming to address multiple forms of violence.
AAUW Educational Foundation Sexual Harassment Task Force. (2004). Harassment-free hallways: How to stop sexual harassment in schools. American Association of University Women Educational Foundation: Washington, DC. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED534504.
2.
AbebeK. Z.JonesK. A.CulybaA. J.FelizN. B.AndersonH.TorresI.ZelaznyS.BamwineP.BoatengA.CirbaB.DetchonA.DevineD.FeinsteinZ.MacakJ.MassofM.Miller-WalfishS.MorrowS. E.MulbahP.MulwaZ.. . .MillerE. (2018). Engendering healthy masculinities to prevent sexual violence: Rationale for and design of the Manhood 2.0 trial. Contemporary Clinical Trials, 71, 18–32.
3.
AminA.Chandra-MouliV. (2014). Empowering adolescent girls: Developing egalitarian gender norms and relations to end violence. Reproductive Health, 11(1), 75.
4.
BarkerG.RicardoC.NascimentoM.OrganizationW. H. (2007). Engaging men and boys in changing gender-based inequity in health: Evidence from programme interventions. World Health Organization.
5.
BasileK. C.DeGueS.JonesK.FreireK.DillsJ.SmithS. G.RaifordJ. L. (2016). STOP SV: A technical package to prevent sexual violence. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control.
6.
BennettD. C.GuranE. L.RamosM. C.MargolinG. (2011). College students’ electronic victimization in friendships and dating relationships: Anticipated distress and associations with risky behaviors. Violence and Victims, 26(4), 410–429.
7.
BreidingM. J.BasileK. C.KlevensJ.SmithS. G. (2017). Economic insecurity and intimate partner and sexual violence victimization. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 53(4), 457–464.
8.
CaseyE.CarlsonJ.Two BullsS.YagerA. (2018). Gender transformative approaches to engaging men in gender-based violence prevention: A review and conceptual model. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 19(2), 231–246.
ConnellR. W. (1987). Gender and power. Stanford University.
11.
CulybaA. J.MillerE.AlbertS. M.AbebeK. Z. (2019). Co-occurrence of violence-related risk and protective behaviors and adult support among male youth in urban neighborhoods. JAMA Network Open, 2(9), e1911375.
12.
DartnallE.JewkesR. (2013). Sexual violence against women: The scope of the problem. Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 27(1), 3–13.
13.
DeGueS.MassettiG. M.HoltM. K.TharpA. T.ValleL. A.MatjaskoJ. L.LippyC. (2013). Identifying links between sexual violence and youth violence perpetration: New opportunities for sexual violence prevention. Psychology of Violence, 3(2), 140.
14.
DeGueS.ValleL. A.HoltM. K.MassettiG. M.MatjaskoJ. L.TharpA. T. (2014). A systematic review of primary prevention strategies for sexual violence perpetration. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 19(4), 346–362.
15.
DickR. N.McCauleyH. L.JonesK. A.TancrediD. J.GoldsteinS.BlackburnS.MonasterioE.JamesL.SilvermanJ. G.MillerE. (2014). Cyber dating abuse among teens using school-based health centers. Pediatrics, 134(6), e1560–e1567.
16.
D’InvernoA. S.BartholowB. N. (2021). Engaging communities in youth violence prevention: Introduction and contents. American Journal of Public Health, 111(S1), S10–S16.
17.
Division of Violence Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2016). Preventing multiple forms of violence: A strategic vision for connecting the dots.
18.
DworkinS. L.Treves-KaganS.LippmanS. A. (2013). Gender-transformative interventions to reduce HIV risks and violence with heterosexually-active men: A review of the global evidence. AIDS and Behavior, 17(9), 2845–2863.
19.
ElgarF. J.CraigW.BoyceW.MorganA.Vella-ZarbR. (2009). Income inequality and school bullying: Multilevel study of adolescents in 37 countries. Journal of Adolescent Health, 45(4), 351–359.
20.
EspelageD.HoltM. K. (2001). Bullying and victimization during early adolescence: Peer influences and psychosocial correlates. Journal of Emotional Abuse, 2, 123–142.
21.
EspelageD.HoltM. (2007). Dating violence & sexual harassment across the bully-victim continuum among middle and high school students. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 36, 799–811.
22.
EspelageD. L.AragonS. R.BirkettM.KoenigB. W. (2008). Homophobic teasing, psychological outcomes, and sexual orientation among high school students: What influence do parents and schools have?School Psychology Review, 37(2), 202–216.
23.
EspelageD. L.BosworthK.SimonT. R. (2000). Examining the social context of bullying behaviors in early adolescence. Journal of Counseling & Development, 78(3), 326–333.
24.
EspelageD. L.BosworthK.SimonT. R. (2001). Short-term stability and prospective correlates of bullying in middle-school students: An examination of potential demographic, psychosocial, and environmental influences. Violence and Victims, 16(4), 411.
25.
EspelageD. L.HongJ. S.MerrinG. J.DavisJ. P.RoseC. A.LittleT. D. (2018). A longitudinal examination of homophobic name-calling in middle school: Bullying, traditional masculinity, and sexual harassment as predictors. Psychology of Violence, 8(1), 57.
26.
Exner-CortensD.EckenrodeJ.RothmanE. (2013). Longitudinal associations between teen dating violence victimization and adverse health outcomes. Pediatrics, 131(1), 71–78.
27.
GibbsA.DunkleK.RamsoomarL.WillanS.Jama ShaiN.ChatterjiS.NavedR.JewkesR. (2020). New learnings on drivers of men’s physical and/or sexual violence against their female partners, and women’s experiences of this, and the implications for prevention interventions. Global Health Action, 13(1), 1739845.
28.
KalichmanS. C.SimbayiL. C.CainD.CherryC.HendaN.CloeteA. (2007). Sexual assault, sexual risks and gender attitudes in a community sample of South African men. AIDS Care, 19(1), 20–27.
29.
KhetarpalS. K.SzokoN.RagavanM. I.CulybaA. J. (2021). Future orientation as a cross-cutting protective factor against multiple forms of violence. The Journal of Pediatrics, 235, 288–291.
30.
KingstonB. E.ZimmermanM. A.WendelM. L.Gorman-SmithD.Wright-KellyE.MattsonS. A.TrudeauA. -R. T. (2021). Developing and implementing community-level strategies for preventing youth violence in the United States. American Journal of Public Health, 111(S1), S20–S24.
31.
KossM. P.GidyczC. A. (1985). Sexual experiences survey: Reliability and validity. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 53(3), 422.
32.
KrugE. G.MercyJ. A.DahlbergL. L.ZwiA. B. (2002). The world report on violence and health. Lancet, 360(9339), 1083–1088.
33.
LundgrenR.AminA. (2015). Addressing intimate partner violence and sexual violence among adolescents: Emerging evidence of effectiveness. Journal of Adolescent Health, 56(1), S42–S50.
34.
McCarthyK. J.MehtaR.HaberlandN. A. (2018). Gender, power, and violence: A systematic review of measures and their association with male perpetration of IPV. PLoS One, 13(11), e0207091.
35.
McCauleyH. L.JaimeM. C. D.TancrediD. J.SilvermanJ. G.DeckerM. R.AustinS. B.JonesE.MillerE. (2014). Differences in adolescent relationship abuse perpetration and gender-inequitable attitudes by sport among male high school athletes. Journal of Adolescent Health, 54(6), 742–744.
36.
McMahonS.PostmusJ. L.KoenickR. A. (2011). Conceptualizing the engaging bystander approach to sexual violence prevention on college campuses. Journal of College Student Development, 52(1), 115–130.
37.
MillerE.BreslauJ.ChungW. J.GreenJ. G.McLaughlinK. A.KesslerR. C. (2011). Adverse childhood experiences and risk of physical violence in adolescent dating relationships. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 65(11), 1006–1013.
38.
MillerE.CulybaA. J.PaglisottiT.MassofM.GaoQ.PortsK. A.Kato-WallaceJ.PulerwitzJ.EspelageD.AbebeK. Z.JonesK. A. (2020). Male adolescents’ gender attitudes and violence: Implications for youth violence prevention. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 58(3), 396–406.
39.
MillerE.JonesK. A.CulybaA. J.PaglisottiT.DwarakanathN.MassofM.FeinsteinZ.PortsK. A.EspelageD.PulerwitzJ.GargA.Kato-WallaceJ.AbebeK. Z. (2020). Effect of a community-based gender norms program on sexual violence perpetration by adolescent boys and young men: a cluster randomized clinical trial. JAMA Network Open, 3(12), e2028499.
40.
MillerE.TancrediD. J.McCauleyH. L.DeckerM. R.VirataM. C.AndersonH. A.StetkevichN.BrownE. W.MoideenF.SilvermanJ. G. (2012). “Coaching boys into men”: A cluster-randomized controlled trial of a dating violence prevention program. The Journal of Adolescent Health, 51(5), 431–438.
41.
MillerL. S.WassermanG. A.NeugebauerR.Gorman-SmithD.KamboukosD. (1999). Witnessed community violence and antisocial behavior in high-risk, urban boys. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 28(1), 2–11.
42.
NiolonP. H.KearnsM.DillsJ.RamboK.IrvingS.ArmsteadT.GilbertL. (2017). Preventing intimate partner violence across the lifespan: A technical package of programs, policies, and practices. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
43.
PinchevskyG. M.WrightE. M. (2012). The impact of neighborhoods on intimate partner violence and victimization. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 13(2), 112–132.
44.
PiolantiA.ForanH. M. (2021). Efficacy of interventions to prevent physical and sexual dating violence among adolescents: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Pediatrics, 176, 142–149.
45.
PoteatV. P.EspelageD. L. (2005). Exploring the relation between bullying and homophobic verbal content: The homophobic content agent target (HCAT) scale. Violence and Victims, 20(5), 513–528.
46.
RagavanM.MillerE. (2021). Prioritizing prevention of teen dating violence. JAMA Pediatrics, 176, 127–128.
47.
ReedE.SilvermanJ. G.RajA.DeckerM. R.MillerE. (2011). Male perpetration of teen dating violence: Associations with neighborhood violence involvement, gender attitudes, and perceived peer and neighborhood norms. Journal of Urban Health, 88(2), 226–239.
48.
ReedE.SilvermanJ. G.RajA.RothmanE. F.DeckerM. R.GottliebB. R.MolnarB. E.MillerE. (2008). Social and environmental contexts of adolescent and young adult male perpetrators of intimate partner violence: A qualitative study. American Journal of Men’s Health, 2(3), 260–271.
49.
RichJ. A.GreyC. M. (2005). Pathways to recurrent trauma among young black men: Traumatic stress, substance use, and the “code of the street”. American Journal of Public Health, 95(5), 816–824.
50.
RinehartS. J.EspelageD. L. (2016). A multilevel analysis of school climate, homophobic name-calling, and sexual harassment victimization/perpetration among middle school youth. Psychology of Violence, 6(2), 213.
51.
RipperL.CiaravinoS.JonesK.JaimeM. C. D.MillerE. (2017). Use of a respondent-generated personal code for matching anonymous adolescent surveys in longitudinal studies. Journal of Adolescent Health, 60(6), 751–753.
52.
SmithS. G.ZhangX.BasileK. C.MerrickM. T.WangJ.KresnowM. -j.ChenJ. (2018). The national intimate partner and sexual violence survey: 2015 data brief–updated release. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
VermaR. K.PulerwitzJ.MahendraV.KhandekarS.BarkerG.FulpagareP.SinghS. (2006). Challenging and changing gender attitudes among young men in Mumbai, India. Reproductive Health Matters, 14(28), 135–143.
56.
WeberA. M.CislaghiB.MeausooneV.AbdallaS.Mejía-GuevaraI.LoftusP.HallgrenE.SeffI.StartL.VictoraC. G.BuffariniR.BarrosA. J. D.DomingueB. W.BhushanD.GuptaR.NagataJ. M.ShakyaH. B.RichterL. M.NorrisS. A.. . . DarmstadtG. L. (2019). Gender norms and health: Insights from global survey data. The Lancet, 393(10189), 2455–2468.
57.
WilkinsN.TsaoB.HertzM.DavisR.KlevensJ. (2014). Connecting the dots: An overview of the links among multiple forms of violence. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Oakland, CA: Prevention Institute.
58.
World Health Organization. (2013). Global and regional estimates of violence against women: Prevalence and health effects of intimate partner violence and non-partner sexual violence.
59.
YbarraM. L.EspelageD. L.MitchellK. J. (2007). The co-occurrence of Internet harassment and unwanted sexual solicitation victimization and perpetration: Associations with psychosocial indicators. The Journal of Adolescent Health, 41(6Suppl 1), S31–S41.
60.
YouthWorks. (2014). JumpStart success: Work readiness and career exploration training. Retrieved December 9, 2021, from https://www.youthworksinc.org
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
