Typologies and Correlates of Police Violence Against Female Sex Workers Who Inject Drugs at the México–United States Border: Limits of De Jure Decriminalization in Advancing Health and Human Rights
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2022
Typologies and Correlates of Police Violence Against Female Sex Workers Who Inject Drugs at the México–United States Border: Limits of De Jure Decriminalization in Advancing Health and Human Rights
Decriminalization of sex work is increasingly promoted as a structural measure to improve the health of vulnerable groups. In México, sex work is not illegal, but knowledge of policies’ street-level impact is limited. This study describes typologies of police violence against female sex workers who inject drugs (FSWID), identifying risk and protective factors for violence exposure to inform policy responses. Survey data were collected during 2008–2010 among HIV-negative FSWID in a behavioral intervention in Tijuana and Ciudad Juarez (N = 584). Latent class analysis identified typologies of police violence in the past 6 months: asked for money, money taken, syringes taken, asked for sex, and sexually assaulted. Structural equation modeling (SEM) predicted latent class membership using sociodemographic, behavioral and risk environment factors, controlling for age, education, marital status, and city. Recent police violence was reported by 68% of FSWID, with three typologies emerging: Low (36.6%); Material (47.8%): having money/syringes taken or being asked for money; and Material/Sexual (15.7%): material violence and being asked for sex or sexually assaulted. In multivariable SEM, Material Violence was associated with: being jailed [adjusted Odds Ratio (aOR) = 4.34], HIV testing (aOR = 2.18), and trading sex indoors (aOR = 1.66). Factors associated with Material/Sexual Violence included: being jailed (aOR = 41.18), injecting with clients (aOR = 3.12), earning more money for sex without a condom (aOR = 2.88), being raped by a client (aOR = 2.13), drinking with clients (aOR = 2.03), receiving substance use treatment (aOR = 1.95), being <18 when first trading sex (aOR = .43), trading sex outdoors (aOR = .53), and poor working conditions (aOR = .56). Despite de jure decriminalization of sex work, police violence against FSWID at the México–United States border is pervasive with implications for sex- and drug-related harms. Closing gaps in policy implementation and mitigating material/sexual violence from police is imperative to decreasing economic vulnerability, risk of overdose and HIV, and improving engagement in HIV and harm reduction services.
AbelG. (2014). A decade of decriminalization: Sex work “down under” but not underground. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 14(5), 580–592.
2.
AinsworthM., BeyrerC., & SoucatA. (2003). AIDS and public policy: The lessons and challenges of “success” in Thailand. Health Policy, 64(1), 13–37.
3.
AndersonS., JiaJ., LiuV., ChattierJ., KrüsiA., AllanS., MaherL., & ShannonK. (2015). Violence prevention and municipal licensing of indoor sex work venues in the Greater Vancouver Area: Narratives of migrant sex workers, managers and business owners. Culture, Health & Sexuality, 17(7), 825–841.
4.
AndradeE., LeyvaR., KwanM.-P., MagisC., Stainez-OrozcoH., & BrouwerK. (2019). Women in sex work and the risk environment: Agency, risk perception, and management in the sex work environments of two Mexico–US border cities. Sexuality Research and Social Policy, 16(3), 317–328.
5.
ArredondoJ., BeletskyL., BakerP., AbramovitzD., ArtamonovaI., ClairgueE., MoralesM., MittalM. L., Rocha-JimenezT., KerrT., & BanuelosA. (2019). Interactive versus video-based training of police to communicate syringe legality to people who inject drugs: The SHIELD Study, Mexico, 2015–2016. American Journal of Public Health, 109(6), 921–926.
6.
ArredondoJ., GainesT., ManianS., VilaltaC., BañuelosA., StrathdeeS., & BeletskyL. (2018). The law on the streets: Evaluating the impact of Mexico’s drug decriminalization reform on drug possession arrests in Tijuana, Mexico. International Journal of Drug Policy, 54, 1–8.
7.
BeletskyL., LozadaR., GainesT., AbramovitzD., StainesH., VeraA., RangelG., ArredondoJ., & StrathdeeS. A. (2013). Syringe confiscation as an HIV risk factor: The public health implications of arbitrary policing in Tijuana and Ciudad Juarez, Mexico. Journal of Urban Health, 90(2), 284–298.
8.
BeletskyL., WagnerK. D., ArredondoJ., PalinkasL., RodriguezMagis, KalicC., BarronN., & StrathdeeN. L. S. A. (2016). Implementing Mexico’s “Narcomenudeo” drug law reform: A mixed methods assessment of early experiences among people who inject drugs. Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 10(4), 384–401.
9.
BiradavoluM. R., BurrisS., GeorgeA., JenaA., & BlankenshipK. M. (2009). Can sex workers regulate police? Learning from an HIV prevention project for sex workers in southern India. Social Science & Medicine, 68(8), 1541–1547.
10.
BlankenshipK. M., & KoesterS. (2002). Criminal law, policing policy, and HIV risk in female street sex workers and injection drug users. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 30(4), 548–559.
11.
BorquezA., BeletskyL., NosykB., StrathdeeS. A., MadrazoA., AbramovitzD., RaffulC., MoralesM., CepedaJ., PanagiotoglouD., & KrebsE. (2018). The effect of public health-oriented drug law reform on HIV incidence in people who inject drugs in Tijuana, Mexico: An epidemic modelling study. The Lancet Public Health, 3(9), e429–e437.
12.
BungayV., & GutaA. (2018). Strategies and challenges in preventing violence against Canadian indoor sex workers. American Journal of Public Health, 108(3), 393–398.
13.
ChoiS. Y. (2011). Heterogeneous and vulnerable: The health risks facing transnational female sex workers. Sociology of Health & Illness, 33(1), 33–49.
14.
CloitreM., GarvertD. W., WeissB., CarlsonE. B., & BryantR. A. (2014). Distinguishing PTSD, complex PTSD, and borderline personality disorder: A latent class analysis. European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 5(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.3402/ejpt.v5.25097
15.
ConnersE. E., SilvermanJ. G., UlibarriM., Magis-RodriguezC., StrathdeeS. A., Staines-OrozcoH., & BrouwerK. C. (2016). Structural determinants of client perpetrated violence among female sex workers in two Mexico–US border cities. AIDS and Behavior, 20(1), 215–224.
16.
CovingtonS. S. (2008). Women and addiction: A trauma-informed approach. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 40(Suppl. 5), 377–385.
DeckerM. R., McCauleyH. L., PhuengsamranD., JanyamS., & SilvermanJ. G. (2011). Sex trafficking, sexual risk, sexually transmitted infection and reproductive health among female sex workers in Thailand. Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, 65(4), 334–339.
19.
DeckerM. R., TomkoC., WingoE., SawyerA., PeitzmeierS., GlassN., & ShermanS. G. (2018). A brief, trauma-informed intervention increases safety behavior and reduces HIV risk for drug-involved women who trade sex. BMC Public Health, 18(1), 75.
20.
DeckerM. R., WirtzA. L., BaralS. D., PeryshkinaA., MogilnyiV., WeberR. A., StachowiakJ., GoV., & BeyrerC. (2012). Injection drug use, sexual risk, violence and STI/HIV among Moscow female sex workers. Sexually Transmitted Infections, 88(4), 278–283.
21.
DeeringK. N., AminA., ShovellerJ., NesbittA., Garcia-MorenoC., DuffP., ArgentoE., & ShannonK. (2014). A Systematic Review of the Correlates of Violence Against Sex Workers. American Journal of Public Health, 104(5), e42–e54. https://doi.org/10.2105/ajph.2014.301909
22.
DeeringK. N., BhattacharjeeP., MohanH., BradleyJ., ShannonK., BoilyM.-C., RameshB. M., IsacS., MosesS., & BlanchardJ. (2013). Violence and HIV risk among female sex workers in Southern India. Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 40(2), 168–174.
23.
DeeringK. N., LyonsT., FengC., NosykB., StrathdeeS., MontanerJ., & ShannonK. (2013). Client demands for unsafe sex: The socio-economic risk environment for HIV among street and off-street sex workers. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 63(4), 522.
24.
DuffP., BirungiJ., DobrerS., AkelloM., MuzaayaG., & ShannonK. (2018). Social and structural factors increase inconsistent condom use by sex workers’ one-time and regular clients in Northern Uganda. Aids Care, 30(6), 751–759.
25.
DuffP., ShovellerJ., DobrerS., OgilvieG., MontanerJ., ChettiarJ., & ShannonK. (2015). The relationship between social, policy and physical venue features and social cohesion on condom use for pregnancy prevention among sex workers: A safer indoor work environment scale. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 69(7), 666–672.
26.
ErausquinJ. T., ReedE., & BlankenshipK. M. (2011). Police-related experiences and HIV risk among female sex workers in Andhra Pradesh, India. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 204(Suppl. 5), S1223–S1228.
27.
FooterK. H., SilberzahnB. E., TormohlenK. N., & ShermanS. G. (2016). Policing practices as a structural determinant for HIV among sex workers: A systematic review of empirical findings. Journal of the International AIDS Society, 19, 20883.
28.
GainesT. L., RuschM. L., BrouwerK. C., GoldenbergS. M., LozadaR., RobertsonA. M., PerkinsE., StrathdeeS. A., & PattersonT. L. (2013). Venue-level correlates of female sex worker registration status: A multilevel analysis of bars in Tijuana, Mexico. Global Public Health, 8(4), 405–416.
GoldenbergS. M., DuffP., & KrusiA. (2015). Work environments and HIV prevention: A qualitative review and meta-synthesis of sex worker narratives. BMC Public Health, 15(1), 1241.
32.
GreenS. T., GoldbergD. J., ChristieP., FrischerM., ThomsonA., CarrS., & TaylorA. (1993). Female streetworker—Prostitutes in Glasgrow: A descriptive study of their lifestyle. Aids Care, 5(3), 321–335.
33.
GreenfieldS. F., & GrellaC. E. (2009). Alcohol & drug abuse: What is “women-focused” treatment for substance use disorders? Psychiatric Services, 60(7), 880–882.
KrüsiA., ChettiarJ., RidgwayA., AbbottJ., StrathdeeS. A., & ShannonK. (2012). Negotiating safety and sexual risk reduction with clients in unsanctioned safer indoor sex work environments: A qualitative study. American Journal of Public Health, 102(6), 1154–1159.
38.
KutsaO., MarcusR., BojkoM. J., ZelenevA., MazhnayaA., DvoriakS., FilippovychS., & AlticeF. L. (2016). Factors associated with physical and sexual violence by police among people who inject drugs in Ukraine: Implications for retention on opioid agonist therapy. Journal of the International AIDS Society, 19(4S3), 20897. https://doi.org/10.7448/ias.19.4.20897
39.
LozaO., StrathdeeS. A., LozadaR., StainesH., OjedaV. D., MartínezG. A., AmaroH., PattersonT. L., & SeguraP. M. (2010). Correlates of early versus later initiation into sex work in two Mexico–US border cities. Journal of Adolescent Health, 46(1), 37–44.
40.
LutnickA., & CohanD. (2009). Criminalization, legalization or decriminalization of sex work: What female sex workers say in San Francisco, USA. Reproductive Health Matters, 17(34), 38–46.
41.
MaherL., Mooney-SomersJ., PhlongP., CoutureM.-C., SteinE., EvansJ., CockroftM., SansothyN., NemotoT., PageK., & Collaborative.Young Women’s Health Study (2011). Selling sex in unsafe spaces: Sex work risk environments in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. Harm Reduction Journal, 8(1), 30.
42.
MillerC. L., FirestoneM., RamosR., BurrisS., RamosM. E., CaseP., BrouwerK. C., FragaM. A., & StrathdeeS. A. (2008). Injecting drug users’ experiences of policing practices in two Mexican–US border cities: Public health perspectives. International Journal of Drug Policy, 19(4), 324–331.
43.
MoralesM., RaffulC., BakerP., ArredondoJ., KangS., MittalM. L., Rocha-JiménezT., StrathdeeS. A., & BeletskyL. (2020). “Pick up anything that moves:” A qualitative analysis of a police crackdown against people who use drugs in Tijuana, Mexico. Health & Justice, 8, 1–13.
44.
MorenoJ. G. B., LiceaJ. A. I., & AjenjoC. R. (2010). Tackling HIV and drug addiction in Mexico. The Lancet, 376(9740), 493–495.
45.
NtumbanzondoM., DubrowR., NiccolaiL. M., MwandagalirwaK., & MersonM. (2006). Unprotected intercourse for extra money among commercial sex workers in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo. Aids Care, 18(7), 777–785.
46.
OdinokovaV., RusakovaM., UradaL. A., SilvermanJ. G., & RajA. (2014). Police sexual coercion and its association with risky sex work and substance use behaviors among female sex workers in St. Petersburg and Orenburg, Russia. International Journal of Drug Policy, 25(1), 96–104. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2013.06.008
PhilbinM., PolliniR. A., RamosR., LozadaR., BrouwerK. C., RamosM. E., Firestone-CruzM., CaseP., & StrathdeeS. A. (2008). Shooting gallery attendance among IDUs in Tijuana and Ciudad Juarez, Mexico: Correlates, prevention opportunities, and the role of the environment. AIDS and Behavior, 12(4), 552–560.
49.
PlattL., GrenfellP., BonellC., CreightonS., WellingsK., ParryJ., & RhodesT. (2011). Risk of sexually transmitted infections and violence among indoor-working female sex workers in London: The effect of migration from Eastern Europe. Sexually Transmitted Infections, 87(5), 377–384.
50.
PlattL., GrenfellP., MeiksinR., ElmesJ., ShermanS. G., SandersT., MwangiP., & CragoA.-L. (2018). Associations between sex work laws and sex workers’ health: A systematic review and meta-analysis of quantitative and qualitative studies. PLoS Medicine, 15(12), e1002680.
51.
PolliniR. A., BrouwerK. C., LozadaR. M., RamosR., CruzM. F., Magis-RodriguezC., CaseP., BurrisS., PuM., FrostS. D., & PalinkasL. A. (2008). Syringe possession arrests are associated with receptive syringe sharing in two Mexico–US border cities. Addiction, 103(1), 101–108.
52.
PolliniR. A., GallardoM., HasanS., MinutoJ., LozadaR., VeraA., ZúñigaM. L., & StrathdeeS. A. (2010). High prevalence of abscesses and self-treatment among injection drug users in Tijuana, Mexico. International Journal of Infectious Diseases, 14, e117–e122.
53.
PopoolaB. I. (2013). Occupational hazards and coping strategies of sex workers in southwestern Nigeria. Health Care for Women International, 34(2), 139–149.
54.
PuriN., ShannonK., NguyenP., & GoldenbergS. (2017). Burden and correlates of mental health diagnoses among sex workers in an urban setting. BMC Women’s Health, 17(1), 133.
55.
RamosR., Ferreira-PintoJ. B., BrouwerK. C., RamosM. E., LozadaR. M., Firestone-CruzM., & StrathdeeS. A. (2009). A tale of two cities: Social and environmental influences shaping risk factors and protective behaviors in two Mexico–US border cities. Health & Place, 15(4), 999–1005.
56.
ReedE., GuptaJ., BiradavoluM., DevireddyV., & BlankenshipK. M. (2010). The context of economic insecurity and its relation to violence and risk factors for HIV among female sex workers in Andhra Pradesh, India. Public Health Reports, 125(Suppl. 4), 81–89.
57.
ReevesE. (2015). A synthesis of the literature on trauma-informed care. Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 36(9), 698–709.
58.
RekartM. L. (2005). Sex-work harm reduction. The Lancet, 366(9503), 2123–2134.
59.
RhodesT. (2002). The “risk environment:” A framework for understanding and reducing drug-related harm. International Journal of Drug Policy, 13(2), 85–94.
60.
RhodesT., PlattL., SarangA., VlasovA., MikhailovaL., & MonaghanG. (2006). Street policing, injecting drug use and harm reduction in a Russian city: A qualitative study of police perspectives. Journal of Urban Health, 83(5), 911–925.
61.
RhodesT., SimićM., BarošS., PlattL., & ŽikićB. (2008). Police violence and sexual risk among female and transvestite sex workers in Serbia: Qualitative study. BMJ, 337, a811.
62.
RobertsonA. M., GarfeinR. S., WagnerK. D., MehtaS. R., Magis-RodriguezC., Cuevas-MotaJ., Moreno-ZunigaP. G., & StrathdeeS. A. (2014). Evaluating the impact of Mexico’s drug policy reforms on people who inject drugs in Tijuana, BC, Mexico, and San Diego, CA, United States: A binational mixed methods research agenda. Harm Reduction Journal, 11(1), 1–14.
63.
RossM. W., CrispB. R., MånssonS.-A., & HawkesS. (2012). Occupational health and safety among commercial sex workers. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 105–119.
64.
SalesJ. M., SwartzendruberA., & PhillipsA. L. (2016). Trauma-informed HIV prevention and treatment. Current HIV/AIDS Reports, 13(6), 374–382.
65.
ShannonK. (2010). The hypocrisy of Canada’s prostitution legislation. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 182(12), 1388–1388.
66.
ShannonK., & CseteJ. (2010). Violence, condom negotiation, and HIV/STI risk among sex workers. Jama, 304(5), 573–574.
67.
ShannonK., KerrT., AllinottS., ChettiarJ., ShovellerJ., & TyndallM. W. (2008). Social and structural violence and power relations in mitigating HIV risk of drug-using women in survival sex work. Social Science and Medicine, 66, 911–921.
68.
ShannonK., KerrT., StrathdeeS. A., ShovellerJ., MontanerJ. S., & TyndallM. W. (2009). Prevalence and structural correlates of gender based violence among a prospective cohort of female sex workers. BMJ, 339, b2939.
69.
ShannonK., StrathdeeS. A., ShovellerJ., RuschM., KerrT., & TyndallM. W. (2009). Structural and environmental barriers to condom use negotiation with clients among female sex workers: Implications for HIV-prevention strategies and policy. American Journal of Public Health, 99(4), 659–665.
70.
SimićM., & RhodesT. (2009). Violence, dignity and HIV vulnerability: Street sex work in Serbia. Sociology of Health & Illness, 31(1), 1–16.
71.
SirotinN., StrathdeeS. A., LozadaR., AbramovitzD., SempleS. J., BucardoJ., & PattersonT. L. (2010). Effects of government registration on unprotected sex amongst female sex workers in Tijuana; Mexico. International Journal of Drug Policy, 21(6), 466–470.
72.
SirotinN., StrathdeeS. A., LozadaR., NguyenL., GallardoM., VeraA., & PattersonT. L. (2010). A comparison of registered and unregistered female sex workers in Tijuana, Mexico. Public Health Reports, 125(Suppl. 4), 101–109.
73.
SlossC. M., & HarperG. W. (2010). Legal service needs and utilization of women who trade sex. Sexuality Research and Social Policy, 7(3), 229–241.
74.
StataCorp. (2013). Stata Structural Equation Modeling Reference Manual, Release 13. Stata Press.
75.
StataCorp. (2019). Stata Statistical Software: Release 16. StataCorp LLC.
76.
StrathdeeS. A., HallettT. B., BobrovaN., RhodesT., BoothR., AbdoolR., & HankinsC. A. (2010). HIV and risk environment for injecting drug users: The past, present, and future. The Lancet, 376(9737), 268–284.
77.
StrathdeeS. A., LozadaR., MartinezG., VeraA., RuschM., NguyenL., PolliniR. A., Uribe-SalasF., BeletskyL., & PattersonT. L. (2011). Social and structural factors associated with HIV infection among female sex workers who inject drugs in the Mexico–US border region. PloS One, 6(4), e19048.
78.
StrathdeeS. A., LozadaR., PolliniR. A., BrouwerK. C., MantsiosA., AbramovitzD. A., RhodesT., LatkinC. A., LozaO., AlvelaisJ., & Magis-RodriguezC. (2008). Individual, social, and environmental influences associated with HIV infection among injection drug users in Tijuana, Mexico. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes (1999), 47(3), 369.
79.
StrathdeeS. A., WestB. S., ReedE., MoazenB., AzimT., & DolanK. (2015). Substance use and HIV among female sex workers and female prisoners: Risk environments and implications for prevention, treatment, and policies. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes (1999), 69(Suppl. 2), S110–S117. https://doi.org/10.1097/QAI.0000000000000624
80.
United Nations. (2000). Protocol to prevent, suppress and punish trafficking in persons, especially women and children, supplementing the United Nations convention against transnational organized crime[Paper presentation]. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime and the Protocols Thereto.
81.
VeraA., AbramovitzD., LozadaR., MartinezG., RangelM. G., StainesH., PattersonT. L., & StrathdeeS. A. (2012). Mujer Mas Segura (safer women): A combination prevention intervention to reduce sexual and injection risks among female sex workers who inject drugs. BMC Public Health, 12(1), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-12-653
82.
WerbD., WoodE., SmallW., StrathdeeS. A., LiK., MontanerJ., & KerrT. (2008). Effects of police confiscation of illicit drugs and syringes among injection drug users in Vancouver. International Journal of Drug Policy, 19(4), 332–338.
83.
WestB. S., AbramovitzD. A., Gonzalez-ZunigaP., RangelG., WerbD., CepedaJ., BeletskyL., & StrathdeeS. A. (2020). Drugs, discipline and death: Causes and predictors of mortality among people who inject drugs in Tijuana, 2011–2018. International Journal of Drug Policy, 75, 102601.
ZimmermanC., HossainM., YunK., GajdadzievV., GuzunN., TchomarovaM., CiarrocchiR. A., JohanssonA., KefurtovaA., ScodanibbioS., & MotusM. N. (2008). The health of trafficked women: A survey of women entering posttrafficking services in Europe. American Journal of Public Health, 98(1), 55–59.
