Domestic Violence Protective Orders: A Qualitative Examination of Judges’ Decision-Making Processes

Abstract

Approximately one in three women in the United States experience intimate partner violence (IPV). IPV is associated with long-term negative health consequences; therefore, there is a need to examine potential prevention strategies. Evidence suggests that domestic violence protective orders (DVPOs), a legal intervention that prevents contact between two parties for up to 12 months, are an effective secondary prevention tool. However, because judges have relative autonomy in granting or denying DVPOs, research is needed to examine the processes they use to guide their decisions. The aim of the study was to investigate how District Court judges decide whether to issue a DVPO. Using in-depth interviews with 20 North Carolina District Court judges, the present study addressed three research questions: (a) what factors influence judges’ decisions to grant or deny a DVPO, (b) what heuristics or cognitive shortcuts potentially guide their decisions, and (c) what judges worry about when making decisions. Three themes emerged from the data analyses: (a) violent incidents must reach a certain threshold, (b) the presence of children creates competing concerns, and (c) judges worry about the negative impact their decisions may have on the lives of those involved. Recommendations for improving the DVPO issuance process are also discussed.

Keywords

legal intervention domestic violence perceptions of domestic violence intervention/treatment assessment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbott

Johnson

Koziol-McLain

Lowenstein

S. R.

(1995). Domestic violence against women: Incidence and prevalence in an emergency department population. Journal of the American Medical Association, 273, 1763-1767.

American Bar Association Commission on Domestic and Sexual Violence. (2009). Domestic violence civil protection orders (CPOs) by state. Washington, DC: American Bar Association.

Bainbridge

S. M.

Gulati

G. M.

(2002). How do judges maximize-the same way everybody else does-boundedly: Rules of thumb in securities fraud opinions. Emory Law Journal, 51, 83-154.

Ballou

Tabol

Liriano

Vazquez-Nuttall

Butler

Boorstein

B. W.

McGovern

(2007). Initial development of a psychological model for judicial decision making in continuing restraining orders. Family Court Review, 45, 274-286.

Black

M. C.

(2011). Intimate partner violence and adverse health consequences: Implications for clinicians. American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine, 5, 428-439.

Braun

Clarke

(2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3, 77-101.

Casey

Burke

Leben

(2013). Minding the court: Enhancing the decision-making process. International Journal for Court Administration, 5(1), 45-54.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2010). The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey (NISVS). Atlanta, GA: National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Charmaz

(2006). Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. London, England: Sage.

10.

Coker

A. L.

Smith

P. H.

Bethea

King

M. R.

McKeown

R. E.

(2000). Physical health consequences of physical and psychological intimate partner violence. Archives of Family Medicine, 9, 451-457.

11.

Czapanskiy

(1993). Domestic violence, the family, and the lawyering process: Lessons from studies on gender bias in the courts. Family Law Quarterly, 27, 247-277.

12.

DeJong

Burgess-Proctor

(2006). A summary of personal protection order statutes in the United States. Violence Against Women, 12, 68-88.

13.

Dickinson

L. M.

deGruy

F. V.

Dickinson

W. P.

Candib

L. M.

(1999). Health-related quality of life and symptom profiles of female survivors of sexual abuse. Archives of Family Medicine, 8, 35-43.

14.

Drossman

D. A.

Talley

N. J.

Leserman

Olden

K. W.

Barreiro

M. A.

(1995). Sexual and physical abuse and gastrointestinal illness: Review and recommendations. Annals of Internal Medicine, 123, 782-794.

15.

Dugan

(2003). Domestic violence legislation: Exploring its impact on the likelihood of domestic violence, police involvement, and arrest. Criminology & Public Policy, 2, 283-312.

16.

Dutton

M. A.

(2009). Pathways linking intimate partner violence and posttraumatic disorder. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 10, 211-224.

17.

Feldman

H.L.

(1994). Objectivity in legal judgement. Michigan Law Review, 92(5) 1187-1255.

18.

Garner

(2009). Black’s law dictionary: 9th edition, 9. St. Paul, MN: Thomson Reuters West.

19.

Gist

J. H.

McFarlane

Malecha

Fredland

Schultz

Willson

(2001). Women in danger: Intimate partner violence experienced by women who qualify and do not qualify for a protective order. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 19, 637-647.

20.

Glaser

B. G.

(1965). The constant comparative method of qualitative analysis. Social Problems, 12, 436-445.

21.

Golding

J. M.

(1999). Intimate partner violence as a risk factor for mental disorders: A meta-analysis. Journal of Family Violence, 14, 99-132.

22.

Graneheim

U. H.

Lundman

(2004). Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: Concepts, procedures and measures to achieve trustworthiness. Nurse Education Today, 24, 105-112.

23.

Guest

Bunce

Johnson

(2006). How many interviews are enough? An experiment with data saturation and variability. Field Methods, 18, 59-82.

24.

Guthrie

Rachlinski

J. J.

Wistrich

A. J.

(2000). Inside the judicial mind. Cornell Law Review, 86, 777-810.

25.

Guthrie

Rachlinski

J. J.

Wistrich

A. J.

(2007). Blinking on the bench: How judges decide cases. Cornell Law Review, 93(1), 1-40.

26.

Harrell

Smith

Newmark

(1993). Court processing the effects of restraining orders for victims of domestic violence. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.

27.

Hathaway

J. E.

Mucci

L. A.

Silverman

J. G.

Brooks

D. R.

Mathews

Pavlos

C. A.

(2000). Health status and health care use of Massachusetts women reporting partner abuse. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 19, 302-307.

28.

Heath

Larrick

R. P.

Klayman

(1998). Cognitive repairs: How organizational practices can compensate for individual shortcomings. Research in Organizational Behavior, 20,1-37.

29.

Holt

V. L.

Kernic

M. A.

Lumley

Wolf

M. E.

Rivara

F. P.

(2002). Civil protection orders and risk of subsequent police-reported violence. Journal of the American Medical Association, 288, 589-594.

30.

Holt

V. L.

Kernic

M. A.

Wolf

M. E.

Rivara

F. P.

(2003). Do protection orders affect the likelihood of future partner violence and injury? American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 24, 16-21.

31.

Hsieh

H.-F.

Shannon

S. E.

(2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 15, 1277-1288.

32.

Janis

I. L.

Mann

(1977). Decision making: A psychological analysis of conflict, choice, and commitment. New York, NY: Free Press.

33.

Jordan

C. E.

(2004). Intimate partner violence and the justice system: An examination of the interface. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 19, 1412-1434.

34.

Jordan

C. E.

Pritchard

A. J.

Wilcox

Duckett-Pritchard

(2008). The denial of emergency protection: Factors associated with court decision making. Violence and Victims, 23, 603-616.

35.

Lindhorst

Oxford

Gillmore

M. R.

(2007). Longitudinal effects of domestic violence on employment and welfare outcomes. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 22, 812-828.

36.

Logan

Shannon

Walker

(2005). Protective orders in rural and urban areas a Multiple Perspective Study. Violence Against Women, 11, 876-911.

37.

Marshall

Rossman

G. B.

(2010). Designing qualitative research. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

38.

McFarlane

Malecha

Gist

Watson

Batten

Hall

Smith

(2004). Protection orders and intimate partner violence: An 18-month study of 150 Black, Hispanic, and White women. American Journal of Public Health, 94, 613-618.

39.

Moracco

K.E.

Bowling

J.M.

Person

C.J.

(2015). Is intimate partner violence severity associated with obtaining a domestic violence protective order? Manuscript submitted for publication.

40.

Muhr

(2004). ATLAS.ti 5.0 [computer software]. Berlin, Germany: ATLAS.ti Scientific Software Development GmbH.

41.

Neilson

L. C.

(2013). Enhancing safety: When domestic violence cases are in multiple legal systems (criminal, family, child protection) a family law, domestic violence perspective, 2nd edition, 2013. Retrieved from http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/fl-lf/famil/enhan-renfo/neilson_web.pdf

42.

North Carolina General Assembly Statutes—Chapter 7A Article 16, 7A–176 C.F.R. (2008).

43.

North Carolina General Assembly Statutes-Chapter 50B Domestic Violence. (2005).

44.

Ostrom

B. J.

(2003). Domestic violence courts. Criminology & Public Policy, 3, 105-108.

45.

Rachlinski

J. J.

(2000). Heuristics and biases in the courts: Ignorance or adaptation. Cornell Law Faculty Publications, 79, 61-102.

46.

Rachlinski

J. J.

Guthrie

Wistrich

A. J.

(2007). Heuristics and biases in bankruptcy judges. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 163, 167-186.

47.

Sabina

Tindale

R. S.

(2008). Abuse characteristics and coping resources as predictors of problem-focused coping strategies among battered women. Violence Against Women, 14(4), 437-456.

48.

Saks

M. J.

Kidd

R. F.

(1980). Human information processing and adjudication: Trial by heuristics. Law & Society Review, 15, 123-160.

49.

Sandelowski

(1995). Sample size in qualitative research. Research in Nursing & Health, 18, 179-183.

50.

Schafran

L. H.

(1994). Gender bias in family courts: Why prejudice permeates the process. Family Advocate, 17, 22-28.

51.

Sorenson

S. B.

Shen

(2005). Restraining orders in California: A look at statewide data. Violence Against Women, 11, 912-933.

52.

Truman

J. L.

(2011). Criminal victimization, 2010. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics.

53.

Tversky

Kahneman

(1974). Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science, 185, 1124-1131.

54.

Walters

M. L.

Chen

Breiding

M. J.

(2013). The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey (NISVS): 2010 findings on victimization by sexual orientation. Atlanta, GA: National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

55.

Wyshak

(2000). Violence, mental health, substance abuse-problems for women worldwide. Health Care for Women International, 21, 631-639.

56.

Zink

Jacobson

C. J.

Pabst

Regan

Fisher

B. S.

(2006). A lifetime of intimate partner violence coping strategies of older women. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 21, 634-651.

57.

Zoellner

L. A.

Feeny

N. C.

Alvarez

Watlington

O’Neill

M. L.

Zager

Foa

E. B.

(2000). Factors associated with completion of the restraining order process in female victims of partner violence. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 15, 1081-1099.