Billing records from the outpatient clinics of a uni versity medical center were used to identify report able communicable diseases. Patient charts were re viewed to check the accuracy of all cases of commu nicable diseases not reported to the local health department. Thirty-three percent of the cases iden tified as one of 20 communicable diseases, using the ICD-9-CM system, were found to be incorrectly coded. This study documents a lack of specificity (nu merous false positives) when using encounter form data and ICD-9-CM codes to identify communicable diseases in an outpatient setting.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Kimball AM, Thacker SB, Levy MEShigella surveillance in a large metropolitan area: Asessment of a passive reporting system. AJPH1980;70:164-166.
2.
Curtis ACNational survey of venereal disease treatments. JAMA1963;186:46.
3.
Vogt RL, LaRue D., Klaucke DN, Jillson DAComparison of an active and passive surveillance system of primary care providers for hepatitis, measles, rubella and salmonellosis in Vermont. AJPH1983;73:795-797.
4.
Fleming WL, Brown WJ, Donohue JF, et al. National survey of venereal disease treated by physicians in 1968. JAMA1970;211:1827-1830.
5.
Harkess JR, Gildon BA, Archer Pin, Istre GRIs passive surveillance always sensitive? An evaluation of shigellosis surveillance in Oklahoma. Am J Epidemiol1988;128:878-881.
6.
Marier R.The reporting of communicable diseases. Am J Epidemiol1977;105:587-590.
Weiss BP, Strassburg MA, Fannin SLImproving disease reporting in Los Angeles county: Trial and results. Public Health Rep1988;103:415-421.
9.
Bouvier B., Octavio J.A model system for reporting communicable diseases to local agencies. Am J Infect Control1988;16:35A-36A.
10.
Spencer L., Wren GRNew reporting system aids epidmiologists. Hospitals1979 (October 16):105-106.
11.
Schaffner W. , Scott HD, Rosenstein BJ, et al. Innovative communicable disease reporting . HSMHA Reports1971;86:431-436.
12.
Rothenberg R., Bross DC, Vernon TMReporting of gonorrhea by private physicians: a behavioral study. AJPH1988;70:983-986.
13.
George AM, Maddocks GBAccuracy of diagnostic content of hospital activity analysis in infectious diseases. Br Med J1979 (1):1332-1334.
14.
Saitz EWPneumococcal pneumonia: A misleading diagnosis for audit studies. JAMA1979;239:2372.
15.
Marrie TJ, Durant H., Sealy E.Pneumonia: The quality of medical records data. Med Care1987;25:20-24.
16.
Kennedy CT, Stern MP, Crawford MHMiscoding of hospital discharges as acute myocardial infarction: Implications for survelliance programs aimed at elucidating trends in coronary artery disease . Am J Cardiol1984;53:1000-1002.
17.
Demlo LK, Campbell PM, Brown SSReliability of information abstracted from patients' medical records. Med Care1978;16:995-1005.
18.
Doremus HD, Michenzi EMDATA quality: An illustration of its potential impact upon a diagnosis-related group's case Mix Index and reimbursement. Med Care1983;21:1001-1011.
19.
Lloyd SS, Rissing JPPhysician and coding errors in patient records. JAMA1985;254:1330-1336.
20.
McMahon LF, Smits HLCan medicare prospective payment survive the ICD-9-CM disease classification system? Ann Intern Med1986;104:562-566.
21.
Wood M.The international classification of primary care: An update. J Fam Pract1989;28:147-149.
22.
Bridges-Webb C.Classifying and coding morbidity in general practice: Validity and reliability in an international trail. J Fam Pract1986;23:147-150.
23.
Boyle RM, Schneeweiss R.Accuracy and reliability of ICH PPC-2 recording. J Fam Pract1983;17:922-928.