Visioning: Did Anybody See Where It Came from?

Abstract

Vision and several related terms are now common in planning discourse. This article surveys a wide range of planning-related periodical literature and analyzes the history, rise, and geographic distribution of the use of the terms vision and visioning. Vision has evolved from a product, a pronouncement about the ftiture made by special people, into a visioning process in which whole communities participate. Vision has also come to have a metaphorical as well as a literal meaning. Pitfalls and cautionary points for planners are discussed because little critical thought has accompanied the profession's adoption cf vision and visioning.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbott, John . 1995. SEQ 2001: Quality strategic planning for South East Queensland. Australian Planner 32, 3: 135-138.

Allinson, John . 1995. Forward visions. Planning Week 3,16: 11-11.

Barnett, Jonathan , and Nory Miller . 1983. Edmund Bacon. Planning 49, 11: 4-11.

Belliveau, GCrard . 1997. Shaking the foundations. Plan Canada (September)37, 5: 16-25.

Brehny, Michael , and Peter Hall . 1984. The strange death of strategic planning and the victory of the know-nothing school. Built Environment 10, 2: 95-99.

Bruning, John . 1992. Perth city planning scheme review. Australian Planner 30, 3: 142-144.

Bryson, John , and Robert Einsweiler . 1988. Strategic planning: Threats and opportunities for planners. Chicago: Planners Press.

Burrows, Tracy . 1989. Honorary mentions. Planning 55, 3 (March): 14-15.

Castle, Deborah Jane. 1993. The visioning process as it is known and utilized by human resources development consultants. Ph.D. diss., Department of Education, University of Toronto.

10.

Challis, James . 1990. Clarifying our visions of a better world. Town and Country Planning 59, 5: 139-141.

11.

Chandler, Michael . 1994. Putting "vision" in your community. Virginia Town and City (May): 19-19.

12.

Codd, Richard . 1996. Vision for the future. Planning 62, 1 (February): 31-31.

13.

Cohn, Roger . 1988. Philadelphia keeps the faith. Planning 54, 9 (September): 22-28.

14.

Cooper, Barbara . 1986. Here comes the future, and it's small. Town and Country Planning 55, 11: 298-299.

15.

Cullick, Robert . 1988. San Antonio hangs tight to its dream. Planning 54,3 (March): 4-14.

16.

Dawkins, Jeremy . 1996. In praise of regulations. Australian Planner 33, 1: 10-15.

17.

Dercle, Julie . 1995. Spin doctors. Planning 61, 12 (December): 18-24.

18.

Dewar, David . 1995. The urban question in South Africa: Need for a planning paradigm shift. Third World Planning 17, 4: 407-419.

19.

Downs, Anthony . 1994. New visions for metropolitan America. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

20.

Duany, Andres , and Elizabeth Playter-Zyberk . 1992. The second coming of the American small town. Plan Canada 32, 3 (May): 6-13.

21.

El-Namaki, M.S.S. 1992. Creating a corporate vision. Long Range Planning 25, 6: 25-29.

22.

Filion, Pierre . 1995. Planning proposals and urban development trends: Can the gap be bridged? Plan Canada 35, 5 (September): 17-19.

23.

Finucan, Karen . 1996. Daniel Varin. Planning 62,4 (April): 16-17.

24.

Franklin, Rod . 1991. Planning news: Northwest vision. Planning 57,3 (March): 25-25.

25.

Fryson, Anthony . 1995. Astrategic vision for the countryside. Planning Week 3, 4: 10-10.

26.

Forester, John . 1984. Lest planners be seen as tools. Built Environment 10, 2: 124-130.

27.

Forester, John 1982. Planning in the face of power. Journal of the American Planning Association 48, 1: 67-80.

28.

Gallagher, Mary Lou . 1995. Santa Clara County strategic vision program. Planning 61,4 (April): 6-6.

29.

Gallagher, Mary Lou 1992. Cleveland city wide and downtown plan. Planning 58, 3 (March): 8-10.

30.

Gallagher, Mary Lou 1991. Des Moines and the vision thing. Planning 57, 12 (December): 12-15.

31.

Gosling, David . 1992. Public realm design: Urban issues for US midwestern cities. Cities 9, 1: 34-42.

32.

Grant, Jill . 1994. Visions of the future. Plan Canada 34,4 (July): 99-103.

33.

Greater Vancouver Regional District . 1993. Creating ourfuture: Steps to a more livable region. Burnaby, British Columbia: Greater Vancouver Regional District.

34.

Greene, Robert . 1990. Creative visioning in government: Anew vision for Greene, NEW York. Journalfor Quality and Participation 13, 5: 82-85.

35.

Hall, David . 1995. A forward look for planning. Town and Country Planning 64, 5-6: 144-147.

36.

Hall, David 1990. A planning agenda for the 1990s. Town and Country Planning 59, 1: 7-9.

37.

Henderson, Harold . 1987. Top of the Line. Planning 53, 4 (April): 7-9.

38.

Hirst, Clayton . 1996. Waterways Council calls for dedicated canals PPG. Planning Wleek 4, 15: 1-1.

39.

Hsing, You-Tien . 1991. The making of the future: Limits and alternatives to forecasting in the planning process. Berkeley Planning Journal 6:176-191.

40.

Hutton, Thomas . 1994. City profile: Vancouver. Cities 11, 4: 219-239.

41.

Jamieson, Walter . 1995. Commentary. Plan Canada 35,5 (September): 25-25.

42.

Kemp, Roger . 1992. Strategic planning in local government: A casebook. Chicago: Planners Press.

43.

Kiechel III, Walter : 1989. A hard look at executive vision. Fortune 120, 9: 207-210.

44.

Klein, William , Virginia Lee Benson , John Andersen , Philip Herr , Pamela Plumb , and Nancy Davis . 1993. Vision of things to come. Planning 59, 5 (May): 10-15.

45.

Knack, Ruth . 1995. A dose of inspiration. Planning 61, 4 (April): 18-19.

46.

Knack, Ruth 1993. After the fair: National planning landmarks and pioneers. Planning 59, 3 (March): 22-23.

47.

Krumholz, Norman . 1995. Dilemmas of equity planning: A personal memoir. Planning Theory Newsletter 10-11: 45-56.

48.

Leigh, Anton , Pat Holm , Stephen Brown , Joy Grant , and Paul Kennedy . 1996. North American study tour. Planning Quarterly 120: 20-23.

49.

Levy, Richard . 1995. Computer modeling: An image of the future. Plan Canada 35, 5 (September): 24-25.

50.

Lucy, William . 1994. If planning includes too much, maybe it should include more. Journal of the American Planning Association 60, 3: 305-318.

51.

Martinson, Tom . 1990. The persistence of vision: A century of civic progress in St. Louis. Places 6, 4: 22-33.

52.

McAfee, Ann , Michael Seelig , and Julie Seelig . 1997. Point counterpoint. Plan Canada 37, 3: 18-22.

53.

McClendon, Bruce . 1993. The paradigm of empowerment. Journal of the American Planning Association 59, 2: 145-147.

54.

McDowell, Lynn . 1988. Street smarts. Canadian Heritage 14, 1: 20-23.

55.

McGee, Terry . 1994. The future of urbanization in developing countries: The case of Indonesia. Third World Planning Review 16, 1: iv-xii.

56.

Micak, James , and Gail Roberts . 1994. Vision circles: An innovative approach to community consultation. Ontario Planning Journal 9, 1: 3-5.

57.

Nanus, Burt . 1990. Futures-creative leadership. Futurist 24, 3: 13-17.

58.

National Trust for Historic Preservation . 1988. Revitalizing downtown: A retrospective analysis of Main Street programs 1976-1986. Washington, DC: National Trust for Historic Preservation.

59.

Naylor, Amy . 1992. Democracy confirmed. Small Town 23, 2: 4-13.

60.

Nelessen, Anton . 1994. Visions for a new American dream. Chicago: American Planning Association.

61.

Nelessen, Anton , and Linda Howe . 1995. Flexible friendly neighborhood transit: A solution for the suburban transportation dilemma. Plan Canada 35, 5 (September): 14-16.

62.

Newman, John . 1993. Sydney's future. Australian Planner 31, 2: 86-91.

63.

Newman, Peter . 1996. Greening the city. Alternatives 22, 2: 10-16.

64.

Norton, Seamus P. 1994. Clearcutting a culture: Visions and sociocultural implications for economic development and industrialization in Brazil. Environments 22, 3: 59-75.

65.

Nutt, Paul , and Robert Backoff . 1992. Strategic management of public and third sector organizations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

66.

Oliver, Gordon . 1990. Portland's central city plan. Planning 55, 3 (March): 8-9.

67.

Ontario Niagara Parks Commission . 1998. Niagara Parks: Planning the second century. Toronto: Moriyama and Teshima Planners.

68.

Oregon Chapter of the American Planning Association . 1993. A guide to community visioning. Chicago: Planners Press.

69.

Pearce, Bill . 1995. Hamilton Wentworth Region's sustainable community initiative. Plan Canada 35, 5 (September): 26-27.

70.

Peets, Elbert . 1933. L'Enfant's Washington. Town Planning Review 15, 3: 155-164.

71.

Percy, Margaret . 1996. The best laid plans. Town and Country Planning 65,3: 75-82.

72.

Rademan, Myles . 1995. If it's broke... fix it. Planning 61, 12 (December): 4-8.

73.

Rifkin, Anthony . 1995. Vision on. Planning Week 3, 14:13-13.

74.

Roberts, Peter . 1996. Regional planning guidance in England and Wales: Back to the future. Town Planning Review 67, 1: 97-109.

75.

Rothschild, Jan . 1995. Specific project: Oregon. Planning 61, 4 (April): 17-17.

76.

Schwab, Jim . 1986. Small town, big dreams. Planning 52, 11 (November): 4-9.

77.

Segal, H. 1986. The technological utopians. In Imagining tomorrow, Joseph Corn , ed. Cambridge: MIT Press.

78.

Senge, Peter . 1990. Thefifth discipline. New York: Doubleday

79.

Simonton, C. , S. Matthews-Simonton , and E. Creighton . 1978. Getting well again. Los Angeles: J. P. Tarcher.

80.

Simpson, Judith . 1990. Visioning: More than meets the eye. Training and Development Journal 44, 9: 70-72.

81.

Skelton, Bradley . 1990. Main street mid-America: An historical overview. Small Town 21, 1: 4-13.

82.

Smith, D. 1990. Imagery in sport: An historical and current overview. In Mental imagery: Proceedings of the 11th and 12th annual conferences of the American Associationfor the Study of Mental Imagery, Robert G. Kunsendorf , ed., New York: Plenum.

83.

Southwest Center for Advanced Studies . 1969. Goals for Dallas: Summaries of the proposals for achieving the goals for Dallas. Dallas, TX: Southwest Center for Advanced Studies.

84.

Southworth, Michael . 1985. Shaping the city image. Journal of Planning Education and Research 5, 1: 52-59.

85.

Spain, Daphne . 1995. Sustainability, feminist visions, and the utopian tradition. Journal of Planning Literature 9, 4: 362-369.

86.

Steiner, William . 1994. Assessing the shape of tomorrow's communities: Putting it all together. Small Town 24, 6: 6-23.

87.

Stewart, J. 1993. Future state visioning-A powerful leadership process. Long Range Planning 26, 6: 89-98.

88.

Thomas, K. , and S. Kimberly . 1995. Rediscovering regional planning? Progress on regional planning guidance in England. Regional Studies 29, 4: 414-421.

89.

Turok, Ivan . 1995. Regional planning and reconstruction in southern Africa. Regional Studies 29, 2: 181-191.

90.

Verma, Niraj . 1993. Metaphor and analogy as elements of a theory of similarity for planning. Journal of Planning Education and Research 13, 1: 13-25.

91.

Warren Evans, Roger . 1996. Reform from above and below. Town and Country Planning 65, 3: 69-70.

92.

Wheeland, Craig . 1993. Citywide strategic planning: An evaluation of Rock Hill's empowering vision. Public Administration Review 53, 1: 65-72.

93.

Wilson, Ian . 1992. Realizing the power of strategic vision. Long Range Planning 25, 5: 18-28.

94.

Young, Stephen . 1995. Participation: Out with the old, in with the new. Town and Country Planning 64,4: 110-112.

95.

Ziegler, Warren . 1991. Envisioning the future. Futures 23, 5: 516-527.

96.

Zotti , Ed. 1991. New angles on citizen participation. Planning 57, 1 (January): 19-21.

97.

Zotti . 1986a. Dreaming of density. Planning 52, 1 (January): 4-9.

98.

Zotti . 1986b. Jane Jacobs. Planning 59, 9 (September): 24-30.