The present study is a comparative analysis of various theoretical approaches to the question of divergence versus convergence in regional development. The article examines a number of studies presented in this field. The first section deals with the economic aspect of this subject, while the second discusses population dispersal and polarization in the context of regional development. The third section analyzes the empirical findings on developed and developing countries, as well as Eastern European (formerly Communist bloc) countries. An integrative approach to this field is also proposed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abe, H.
, and J. D. Alden. 1988. Regional development planning in Japan. Regional Studies22: 429-438.
2.
Alden, J. D.
, and A. H. Awang. 1985. Regional development planning in Malaysia. Regional Studies19:495-508.
3.
Amin, A.
, and K Robins. 1990. The re-emergence of regional economies? The mythical geography of flexible accumulation. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space8: 7-34.
4.
Aryeetey-Attoh, S.
, and L. Chatterjee. 1988. Regional inequalities in Ghana: Assessment and policy issues. TESG (Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie)79: 31-38.
5.
Baer, W.1964. Regional inequality and economic growth in Brazil. Economic Development and Cultural Change1, 2: 268-285.
6.
Ball, B.
, and G. J. Demko. 1978. Internal migration in the Soviet Union. Economic Geography54: 95-114.
7.
Baran, P. A.1962. The political economy of growth. New York: Monthly Review Press.
8.
Berry, B.J.L.1988. Migration reversals in perspective: The long wave evidence. International Regional Science Review11: 245-251.
9.
Black, B.1985. Regional earning convergence: The case of Northern Ireland. Regional Studies19: 1-8.
10.
Borts, G. H.
, and J. L. Stein. 1964. Economic growth in afree market. New York: Columbia University Press.
11.
Brown, L. A.
, K V. L. England, and A. R. Goetz. 1989. Location, social categories, and individual labor market experiences in developing economies: The Venezuelan case. International Regional Science Review12: 1-28.
12.
Brown, L. A.
, and A. R. Goetz. 1987. Development-related contextual effects and individual attributes in Third World migration processes: A Venezuelan example. Demography24:497-516.
13.
Brown, L. A.
, and V. A. Lawson. 1989. Polarization reversal, migration related shifts in human resource profiles, and spatial growth policies: A Venezuelan study. International Regional Science Review12: 185-188.
14.
Brown, L. A.
, and F. C. Stetzer. 1984. Development aspects of migration in Third World settings: A simulation with implications for urbanization. Environment and Planning A16: 1583-1603.
15.
Burns, L. S.1987. Regional economic integration and national economic growth. Regional Studies21: 327-339.
16.
Champion, A. G.1988. The reversal of migration turnaround: Resumption of traditional trends?International Regional Science Review11: 253-260.
17.
Cochrane, S. G.
, and D. R. Vining, Jr.1988. Recent trends in migration between core and peripheral regions in developed and advanced developing countries. International Regional Science Review11: 215-243.
18.
De Janvry, A.1981. The agrarian question. Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press.
19.
Easterlin, R. D.1958. Long term regional income changes: Some suggested factors. Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Science Association4: 313-325.
20.
Endres, W. T.1980. Regional disparities in industrial growth in Brazil. Economic Geography56: 300-310.
21.
Enyedi, G.1990. Specific urbanization in east-central Europe. Geoforum21: 163-172.
22.
Estall, R. C.1977. Economic geography and regional geography. Geography62: 297-310.
23.
Evans, P.1979. Dependent development. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
24.
Fielding, A.1982. Counterurbanization in Western Europe. Progress in Planning17, Part 1: 1-52.
25.
Fisch, O.1984. Regional income inequality and economic development. Regional Science and Urban Economics14: 89-111.
26.
Frank, A. G.1979. The development of underdevelopment. In The political economy of development and underdevelopment. 2d ed., C. K. Wilber, ed. London: Random House.
27.
Frey, W. H.1988. The re-emergence of core regions growth: A return to metropolis?International Regional Science Review11: 261-267.
28.
Friedmann, J.1973. Urbanization, planning and national development. Beverly Hills, Ca.: Sage.
29.
Friedmann, J.
, and C. Weaver. 1979. Territory and function. Berkeley: University of California Press.
30.
Friedmann, J.
, and U. Douglass. 1978. Agropolitan development Toward a new strategy for regional planning in Asia. In Growth poles and regional development policy: Asian experiences and alternative strategies, F. Lo and K. Salih, eds. London: Pergamon.
31.
Gilbert, A.
, and D. F. Goodman. 1976. Regionalincome disparities and economic development: A critique. In Development planning and spatial structure, A. Gilbert, ed. London: Wiley.
32.
Gilbert, A.
, and J. Gugler. 1982. Cities, povertyand development. London: Oxford University Press.
33.
Ginneken, W. V.1976. Rural and urban income inequalities in Indonesia, Mexico, Pakistan, Tanzania and Tunisia. Geneva: ILO.
34.
Gleave, D.
, and M. Cordoey-Hayes. 1977. Migration dynamics and labour market turnover. Progress in Planning8:1-95.
35.
Gordon, P.1979. Deconcentration without a dean break. Environment and Planning A11: 281-290.
36.
Gradus, Y.1984. The eergenceof regionalismin a centralized system The case of IsraeLEnvironment and Planning D: Sciety and Space287-100.
37.
Gradus, Y.1983. The role of politics in regional inequality: The Israeli case. Annals of the Association of American Geographers73: 388-403.
38.
Griffin, K.1979. Underdevelopment in history. In The political economy of development and underdevelopment, C. K. Wilber, ed. London: Random House.
39.
Gurely, J. W.1979. Maoist economic development: The new man in the new China. In The political economy of development and underdevelopment, C. K. Wilber, ed. London: Random House.
40.
Harris, S. E.1957. International and interregional economics. New York: McGraw-Hill.
41.
Henriot, P. J.1979. Development alternatives: Problems, strategies, values. In The political economy of development and underdevelopment, C. K. Wilber, ed. London: Random House.
42.
Hirschman, A. O.1958. The strategy of economic development. New Haven, Ct.: Yale University Press.
43.
Keeble, D.1977. Spatial policy in Britain: Regional or urban. Area9: 3-9.
44.
Keeble, D.1968. Models of economic development. In Socio-economic models in geography, R. J. Chorley and P. Haggett, eds. London: Penguin.
45.
Kipnis, B. A.1984. Role and timing of complimentary objectives of a regional policy, the case of Northern Israel. Geoforum15: 191-200.
46.
Kiassen, L. H.
, and J. H. Paelinck. 1979. The future of large towns. Environment and Planning A11: 1091-1104.
47.
Korcelli, P.1990. Recent urban and population settlement systems: Polarization processes in Czech lands. Geoforum21: 173-184.
48.
Koropeckyi, I. S.1972. Equalization of regional development in socialist countries: An empirical study. Economic Development and Cultural Change21: 68-86.
49.
Lipshitz, Gabriel
. 1991a. Differences in migratory patterns in Israel's national periphery-Theoretical ramifications. Geography Research Forum11: 66-77.
50.
Lipshitz, Gabriel1991b. Immigration and internal migration as a mechanism of dispersion and polarization of population and development. Economic Development and Cultural Change39: 391-408.
51.
Lipshitz, Gabriel
. 1987. Migration within metropolitan areas of Israel: Comparative periodic analysis. Papers of the Regional Science Association61: 161-174.
52.
Lipshitz, Gabriel
. 1986. The stability of the spatial pattern of welfare: The Israeli case. Geoforum17: 353-366.
53.
Logan, N. I.1970. The spatial dimension of economic development The case of the upper-midwest. Regional Studies4: 117-125.
54.
Mera, K.1988. The emergence of migration cycles?International Regional Science Review11: 269-275.
55.
Mera, K.1979. Basic human needs versus economic growth approach for coping with urban-rural imbalances: An evaluation based on relative welfare. Environment and Planning A11: 1129-1145.
56.
Mera, K.1978. Population concentration and regional income disparities: A comparative analysis of Japan and Korea. In Human settlement systems, M. Hansen, ed. Cambridge, Ma.: Ballinger.
57.
Miyao, T.
, and P. Shapiro. 1979. Dynamic of rural-urban migration in a developing economy. Environment and Planning A11: 1157-1163.
58.
Molle, W.
, and L. Beumer. 1984. Regional income disparity in the Netherlands 1950-1975. TESG (Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie)75: 82-98.
59.
Morrison, P. A.
, and J. P. Wheeler. 1976. Rural renaissance in America. Population Bulletin31: 1-27.
60.
Murdoch, W. W.1980. The poverty of nations: The political economyofhunger and population. Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press.
61.
Musil, J.1990. Stability and change in settlement systems: Polarization processes in Czech lands. Geoforum21: 135-191.
62.
Myrdal, G.1957. Economic theory and underdeveloped regions. London: Duckworth.
63.
Nijkamp, P.1986. Technological change, employment and spatial dynamics. Berlin: Springer.
64.
Peet, R.1975. Inequality and poverty: A Marxist geographic theory. Annals of the Association of American Geographers65: 564-571.
65.
Piore, M.
, and C. F. Sabel. 1984. The second industrial divide: Possibilities for prosperity. New York: Basic Books.
66.
Pred, A.1977. City systems in advanced economics: Past growth, present processes, and future development options. New York: Wiley.
67.
Pred, A.1976. The interurban transmission of growth in advanced economies: Empirical findings versus regional planning assumption. Regional Studies10: 151-171.
68.
Richardson, H. W.1980. Polarization reversal in developing countries. Papers of the Regional Science Association25: 67-86.
69.
Richardson, H. W.1978. Growth centers, rural development and national urban policy: A defense. International Regional Science Review3: 133-152.
70.
Richardson, H. W.1976. Growth pole spillover: The dynamics of backwash and spread. Regional Studies10: 1-10.
71.
Richardson, H. W.1973. Regional growth theory. London: Macmillan.
72.
Sabel, C. F.1989. Flexible specialization and the re-emergence of regional economies. In Reversing industrial decline? Industrial structure and policy in Britain and her competitors, P. Hirst and J. Zeitlin, eds. Leamington, England: Berg.
73.
Saha, S. K.1990. Industrialization and interregional disparities in postcolonial India: Toward a new regional policy. TESG (Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie)81: 93-109.
74.
Scott, A. J.1988. Flexible production systems and regional development: The rise of new industrial spaces in North American and Western Europe. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research12: 171-186.
75.
Scott, A. J.1986. Industrial organization and location: Division of labour, the firm and spatial process. Economic Geography62: 215-231.
76.
Scott, A. J.
, and M. Storper. 1987. High technology industry and regional development: A theoretical critique and reconstruction. International Social Science Journal39: 215-232.
77.
Semple, R. K
, and H. L. Gauthier. 1972. Spatial-temporal trends in income inequalities in Brazil. Geographical Analysis4: 169-180.
78.
Shachar, A.
, and G. Lipshitz. 1981. Regional inequalities in IsraeLEnvironment and Planning A13: 436-473.
79.
Shachar, A.
, and G. Lipshitz. 1980. Inter-regional migration in Israel. Studies in the Geography of Israel11: 153-178 (in Hebrew).
80.
Shachar, A.
, and S. Oberg. 1990. The world economy and the spatial organization of power. Aldershot, England: Avebury.
81.
Shefer, Daniel
. 1990. Innovation, technical change and metropolitan development: An Israeli example. In Sustainability of urban systems, P. Nijkamp, ed. Aldershot, England: Avebury.
82.
Shefer, Daniel
.1974. Has the inter-regional gap in Israel increased or decreased?Centerfor Urban and Regional Studies. Haifa, Israel: Technion.
83.
Simon, D.1986. Regional inequality, migration and development: The case of Zimbabwe. TESG (Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie)77: 7-17.
84.
Slater, D.1975. Underdevelopment and spatial inequality. Progress in Planning4: 101-165.
85.
Smith, W. R.
, W. Hugh, and G. J. Demko. 1983. Population concentration in an urban system: Korea 1949-1980. Urban Geography4: 63-79.
86.
Soja, E. W.1980. The social-spatial dialectic. Annals of the Association of American Geographers70: 207-335.
87.
Storper, M.
, and A. J. Scott. 1989. The geographical foundations and social regulation of flexible production complexes. In The power of geography: How territory shapes social life, J. Wolch and M. Dear, eds. Winchester, Ma.: Unwin Hyman.
88.
Tabuchi, T.1988. Interregional income differentials and migration: Their interrelationships. Regional Studies22: 1-10.
89.
Todaro, M. P.1981. Economic development in the third world. New York: Longman.
90.
Townroe, P. M.
, and D. Keen. 1984. Polarization dispersal in the state of Sao Paulo, Brazil. Regional Studies18: 45-54.
91.
Vining, D. R., Jr.
, and T. P. Kontuly. 1978. Population dispersion from major metropolitan regions: An international comparison. International Regional Science Review2: 49-73.
92.
Vining, D. R., Jr.
, and R. Palone. 1982. Migration between core and periphery regions: A description and tentative explanation of the patterns of 22 countries. Geoforum13: 339-410.
93.
Vining, D. R., Jr.
, and A. Strauss. 1977. A demonstration that the current deconcentration of population in the United States is a clean break with the past. Environment and Planning A9: 751-758.
94.
Weisskopf, T. E.1979. Imperialism and the economic development of the third world. In The political economy of development and underdevelopment, C. K. Wilber, ed. London: Random House.
95.
Whitbread, M.1981. Growth determinants in the regions of the EECAn empirical study. Annals of Regional Science15: 13-26.
96.
Wilber, C. K
, and J. H. Weaver. 1979. Patterns of dependency: Income distribution and the history of underdevelopment. In The political economy of development and underdevelopment, C. K. Wilber, ed. New York: Random House.
97.
Williamson, J. C.1965. Regional inequality and the process of national development: A description of the patterns. Economic Development and Cultural Change13: 3-45.
98.
Zimon, H. A.1979. Regional inequalities in Poland 1960-1975. Economic Geography55: 242-252.
