This review evaluates the perception that subsidized housing results in negative neighborhood impacts by considering four commonly studied putative impacts of subsidized housing location: property values, racial transition, poverty concentration, and crime. The authors assess theoretical and methodological bases for discerning impacts and determine which study results inspire confidence. Research reveals a relationship between the presence of subsidized housing and both property values and crime in certain circumstances, with both positive and negative impacts, and suggests that the presence of subsidized housing does not lead to racial transition. Research on the impact of subsidized housing on poverty concentration is too flawed methodologically to permit conclusions. Future research must, among other steps, control for variability of impacts across types of neighborhoods, use data that distinguish between residents of subsidized and nonsubsidized housing, and take into account changing attitudes as well as the context in which housing is proposed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Babb, Carol E.
, Louis G. Pol, and Rebecca F. Guy. 1984. The impact of federally assisted housing on single-family housing sales: 1970-1980. Mid-South Business Journal4 (July): 13-17.
2.
Brewster, Karin L.
, John O. G. Billy, and William R. Grady. 1993. Social context and adolescent behavior: The impact of community on the transition to sexual activity. Social Forces71: 713-740.
3.
Briggs, Xavier de Souza
, Joe Darden, and Angela Aidala. 1999. In the wake of desegregation: Early impacts of scattered site public housing on neighborhoods in Yonkers, NewYork. Journal of the American Planning Association65: 27-49.
4.
Brooks-Gunn, Jeanne
, Greg J. Duncan, Pamela Kato Klebanov, and Naomi Sealand. 1993. Do neighborhoods influence child and adolescent development?American Journal of Sociology99: 353-395.
5.
Carson, Larry
. 1995. Baltimore County wants more say in Section 8. Baltimore Sun(Local) (March 6): 3B-3B.
6.
Carter, William H.
, Michael H. Schill, and Susan M. Wachter. 1998. Polarisation, public housing and racial minorities in U.S. cities. Urban Studies35: 1889-1911.
7.
Casey, Connie H.1992. Characteristics of HUD-assisted renters and their units in 1989. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Policy Research and Development.
8.
Chandler, Mitte O.
, Virginia O. Benson, and Richard Klein. 1993. The impact of public housing: A new perspective. Real Estate Issues18: 29-32.
9.
Crane, Jonathan
. 1991. The epidemic theory of ghettos and neighborhood effects on dropping out and teenage childbearing. American Journal of Sociology96: 1226-1259.
10.
Cummings, Paul
, and John Landis. 1993. Relationships between affordable housing developments and neighboring property values. Working paper No. 599, University of California, Institute of Urban and Regional Development, Berkeley.
11.
Cuomo, Mario
. 1974. Forest Hills diary: The crisis of low-income housing. New York: Vintage.
12.
DeSalvo, Joseph
. 1974. Neighborhood upgrading effects of middle income housing projects inNewYork City. Journal of Urban Economics1: 269-277.
13.
Duncan, Otis D.
, and Beverly Duncan. 1957. The Negro population of Chicago: A study of residential succession. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
14.
Ellen, Ingrid Gould
. 1998. Stable, racial integration in the contemporary United States: An empirical overview. Journal of Urban Affairs20, 1: 24-42.
15.
Ellen, Ingrid Gould
, and Margery Austin Turner. 1997. Does neighborhood matter? Assessing recent evidence. Housing Policy Debate8, 4: 833-866.
16.
Farley, John E.1982. Has public housing gotten a bum rap? The incidence of crime in St. Louis public housing developments. Environment & Behavior14: 443-477.
17.
Freeman, Lance
. 2001. The impact of assisted housing on concentrated poverty. Washington, DC: Fannie Mae Foundation.
18.
Freeman, Lance
, and William Rohe. 2000. The impact of assisted housing on neighborhood racial transition: An empirical investigation. Housing Policy Debate11, 1: 67-89.
19.
Galster, George
. 1995. A response to Schill and Wachter’s the spatial bias of federal housing law and policy: Concentrated poverty in urban America. University of Pennsylvania Law Review143: 1343-1347.
20.
Galster, George
, and Heather Keeney. 1993. Subsidized housing and racial change inYonkers, NewYork. Journal of the American Planning Association59: 172-181.
21.
Galster, George
, and Sean P. Killen. 1995. The geography of metropolitan opportunity: A reconnaissance and conceptual framework. Housing Policy Debate6, 1: 7-44.
22.
Galster, George
, Peter Tatian, and Robin Smith. 1999. The impact of neighbors who use Section 8 certificates on property values. Housing Policy Debate10, 4: 879-918.
23.
Glover, Chad G.1998. Philadelphia Housing Authority changes Section 8 policies. Philadelphia Tribune(December 18): 3A-3A.
24.
Goering, John
. 1994. The location and racial composition of public housing in the United States. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Policy Development and Research.
25.
Goering, John
, Ali Kamely, and Todd Richardson. 1997. Recent research on racial segregation and poverty concentration in public housing in the United States. Urban Affairs Review32, 5: 723-745.
26.
Goetz, Edward
, Hin Kin Lam, and Anne Heitlinger. 1996. There goes the neighborhood? The impact of subsidized multi-family housing on urban neighborhoods. Minneapolis, MN: Center for Urban and Regional Affairs.
27.
Goldstein, Ira
, and William L. Yancey. 1986. Public housing projects, blacks, and public policy: The historical ecology of public housing in Philadelphia. In Housing desegregation and federal policy, John M. Goering, ed. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
28.
Guy, Donald C.
, John L. Husom, and Stephen R. Roth. 1985. The effect of subsidized housing on values of adjacent housing. AREVEA Journal13: 378-387.
29.
Holloway, Steven R.
, Deborah Bryan, Robert Chabot, Donna M. Rogers, and James Rulli. 1998. Exploring the effects of public housing on the concentration of poverty in Columbus, Ohio. Urban Affairs Review33: 767-789.
30.
Husock, Howard
. 2000. Let’s end housing vouchers. City Journal10, 4: 84-91.
31.
Katz, Michael B.1993. The urban underclass as a metaphor of social transformation. In The underclass debate: Views from history, Michael B. Katz, ed. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
32.
Katz, Michael B.1986. In the shadow of the poorhouse: A social history of welfare in America. New York: Basic Books.
33.
Lee, Barrett A.
, and PeterWood. 1991. Is neighborhood racial succession place-specific?Demography28: 21-40.
34.
Lee, Chang-Moo
, Dennis P. Culhane, and Susan M. Wachter. 1999. The differential impacts of federally assisted housing programs on nearby property values: A Philadelphia case study. Housing Policy Debate10, 1: 75-93.
35.
Logan, John R.1978. Growth, politics, and the stratification of places. American Journal of Sociology84: 404-416.
36.
Lueck, Thomas J.1991. Prices decline as gentrification ebbs: The future is uncertain in areas that bloomed too late in the 1980s. New York Times(September 29): sec. 10, p. 1-1.
37.
Lyons, Robert F.
, and Scott Loveridge. 1993. Ahedonic estimation of the effect of federally subsidized housing on nearby residential property values. Staff Paper P93-6, University of Minnesota, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, St. Paul.
38.
MaRous, Michael S.1996. Low-income housing in our backyards: What happens to residential property values?The Appraisal Journal64 (January): 27-33.
39.
Massey, D. S.
, and B. Bitterman. 1985. Explaining the paradox of Puerto Rican segregation. Social Forces64: 306-331.
40.
Massey, Douglas S.
, and Shawn M. Kanaiaupuni. 1993. Public housing and the concentration of poverty. Social Science Quarterly74: 107-121.
41.
Massey, Douglas S.
, and Brendan P. Mullan. 1984. Processes of Hispanic and Black assimilation. American Journal of Sociology91: 396-400.
42.
McNulty, Thomas L.
, and Steven R. Holloway. 2000. Race, crime and public housing in Atlanta: Testing a conditional effect hypothesis. Social Forces79, 2: 707-729.
43.
Messner, Steven F.
, and Reid M. Golden. 1992. Racial inequality and racially disaggregated homicide rates: An assessment of alternative theoretical explanations. Criminology30: 421-447.
44.
Myerson, Martin
, and Edward Banfield. 1955. Politics, planning, and the public interest. New York: Free Press.
45.
Newman, Oscar
. 1973. Defensible space: Crime prevention through urban design. New York: Collier Books.
46.
Nourse, Hugh O.1963. The effect of public housing on property values in St. Louis. Land Economics39: 433-441.
47.
Park, Robert E.1936. Succession, an ecological concept. American Sociological Review1: 171-179.
48.
Puryear, Vivian. 1989. The effects of scattered-site public housing on residential property values. Master’s thesis, University of North Carolina at Charlotte.
49.
Quadagno, Jill S.1994. The color of welfare: How racism undermined the War on Poverty. New York: Oxford University Press.
50.
Rabiega, William A.
, Ta-Win Lin, and Linda Robinson. 1984. The property value impacts of public housing projects in low and moderate density residential neighborhoods. Land Economics6: 174-179.
51.
Rohe, William
, and Lance Freeman. 2001. Assisted housing and residential segregation. Journal of the American Planning Association67: 279-292.
52.
Roncek, Dennis W.
, Ralph Bell, and Jeffrey M. A. Francik. 1981. Housing projects and crime: Testing a proximity hypothesis. Social Problems29, 2: 151-166.
53.
Rothenberg, Jerome
, and George Galster. 1991. The maze of urban housing markets: Theory, evidence, and policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
54.
Saltman, Juliet
. 1990. A fragile movement: The struggle for neighborhood stabilization. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
55.
Sampson, Robert J.
, and William J. Wilson. 1995. Toward a theory of race, crime, and urban inequality. In Crime and inequality, John Hagan and Ruth D. Peterson, eds. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.
56.
Santiago, Anna M.
, George C. Galster, and Peter Tatian. 2001. Assessing the property value impacts of the dispersed housing subsidy program in Denver. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management20: 65-88.
57.
Schafer, Robert
. 1972. The effect of BMIR housing on property values. Land Economics48: 262-286.
58.
Schill, Michael H.
, and Susan M. Wachter. 1995. The spatial bias of federal housing law and policy: Concentrated poverty in urban America. University of Pennsylvania Law Review143: 1285-1342.
59.
Schuman, Howard
. 1985. Racial attitudes in America: Trends and interpretations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
60.
Spain, Daphne
. 1995. Direct and default policies in the transformation of public housing. Journal of Urban Affairs17: 357-376.
61.
Taeuber, Karl E.
, and Alma F. Taeuber. 1965. Negroes in the cities. Chicago: Aldine.
62.
Warren, Elizabeth
, Robert M. Aduddell, and Raymond Tatalovich. 1983. The impact of subsidized housing on property values: A twopronged analysis of Chicago and Cook County suburbs. Urban Insight Series, no. 13. Chicago: Loyola University, Center for Urban Policy.
63.
Williamson, John B.1974. The stigma of public dependency: A comparison of alternative forms of public aid to the poor. Social Problems22, 2: 213-228.
64.
Wilson, William J.1987. The truly disadvantaged. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
