The Use of Biomaterials in the Repair of Abdominal Wall Defects: A Comparative Study between Polypropylene Meshes (Marlex) and a New Polytetrafluoroethylene Prosthesis (Dual Mesh)

Abstract

In this study we compared the behaviour of the non-porous on one side ePTFE Dual Mesh® prosthesis and the macroporous polypropylene mesh Marlex® in the repair of abdominal wall defects in rabbits. We evaluated the degree of integration with recipient tissue, biological tolerance, adhesion formation with viscera and the biomechanical resistance of the repair zone. Our results showed good biological tolerance of both prostheses and a high degree of adhesion formation in Marlex implants. In animals with Dual Mesh(r) implants, only loose adhesions were seen. Marlex implants induced the presence of disorganized scar tissue, while the Dual Mesh prostheses were encapsulated by organized tissue. The macrophage response was similar in both decreasing with time. The resistance to traction was higher when the reparation was done with polypropylene. We concluded that the structure of the prosthesis determines its degree of integration and the resistance to traction of the repaired zone.

Keywords

ePTFE polypropylene Marlex Dual Mesh abdominal wall defects macrophages

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Bellón, J. M. , J. Buján , L. A. Contreras , A, Hernando and F. Jurado . 1994. "Macrophage Response to Experimental Implantation of Polypropylene Prosthesis," Eur. Surg. Res., 26, 46-53.

2. Bellon, J. M. , J. Bujan , L. A. Contreras and A. Hernando . 1995

"Integration of Biomaterials Implanted into Abdominal Wall: Process of Scar Formation and Macrophage Response,"

Biomaterials, 16, 381-387.

3. Law, N. W. and H. Ellis . 1988. "Adhesion Formation and Peritoneal Healing on Prosthetic Materials," Clinical Materials, 3, 95-101.

4. Bellón, J. M. , L. A. Contreras , J. Buján , A. Carrera-San Martin , E. Jorge-Herrero , C. Campo and A. Hernando . 1996. "A New Type of Polytetrafluoroethylene Mycro Mesh Prosthesis (Mycro Mesh): An Experimental Study," J. Mater. Sci.: Mat. Med., 7, 475-478.

5. Murphy, J. L. , J. B. Freeman and P. G. Dionne . 1989. "Comparison of Marlex and Gore-Tex to Repair Abdominal Wall Defects in the Rat," Can. J. Surg., 32, 244-247.

6. Bellón, J. M. , J. Buján , L. A. Contreras , A. Carrera-San Martin and F. Jurado . 1996. "Comparison of a New Type of Polytetrafluoroethylene Patch (Mycro Mesh) and Polypropylene Prosthesis (Marlex) for Repair of Abdominal Wall Defects," J. Am. Coll. Surg., 183, 11-18.

7. Lamb, J. P. , T. Vitale and D. L. Kaminsky . 1983. "Comparative Evaluation of Synthetic Meshes used for Abdominal Wall Replacement," Surgery, 93, 643-648.

8. Pans, A. and G. E. Pierard . 1992. "A Comparison of Intraperitoneal Prostheses for the Repair of Abdominal Muscular Wall Defects in Rats," Eur. Surg. Res., 24, 54-60.

9. Dabrowiecki, S. , K. Svanes , J. Lekven and K. Grong . 1991."Tissue Reaction to Polypropylene Mesh: A Study of Oedema, Blood Flow, and Inflammation in the Abdominal Wall," Eur. Surg. Res., 23, 240-249.

10.

10. Walker, A. P. , J. Henderson and R. E. Condon . 1993. "Double-Layer Prostheses for Repair of Abdominal Wall Defects in a Rabbit Model," J. Surg. Res., 55, 32-37.

11.

11. Bellon, J. M. , L. A. Contreras , J. Bujan and F. Jurado . 1996. "Effect of Phosphatidylcholine on the Process of Peritoneal Adhesions Following Implantation of a Polypropylene Mesh Prosthesis," Biomaterials, 17, 1369-1372.

12.

12. Bellon, J. M. , J. Bujan , L. A. Contreras and A. Hernando . 1996. "Interface Formed between Visceral Peritoneum and Experimental Polypropylene or Polytetrafluoroethylene Abdominal Wall Implants," J. Mater. Sci.: Mater. Med., 7, 331-336.

13.

13. Bellón, J. M. , J. Bujin , L. A. Contreras , A. Carrera-San Martin , A. Hernando and E. Jurado . 1996. "Improvement of the Tissue Integration of a New Modified Polytetrafluoroethylene Prosthesis: Mycro Mesh," Biomaterials, 17, 1265-1271.

14.

14. Bellon, J. M. , J. Bujain , L. A. Contreras , C. Campo and A. Hernando . 1994. Interactions and Integration of Prosthetic Material in Tissue Repair. Societa Italiana Di Fisiopatologia Chirurgica. VIII Congresso Nazionale. PA: G. Cassini Editore s.r.l, pp: 85-90.

15.

15. Bellon, J. M. , J. Bujain , L. A. Contreras , A. Hernando and F. Jurado . 1996. "Similarity in Behavior of Polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) Prostheses Implanted into Different Interfaces," J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 31, 1-9.

16.

16. Buckman, R. F. , M. Woods , L. Sargent and A. S. Gervin . 1976. "A Unifying Pathogenetic Mechanism in the Etiology of Intraperitoneal Adhesions," J. Surg. Res., 20:1-5.

17.

17. Buckman, R. F. , D. Buckman , H. V. Hufnagel and A. S. Gervin . 1976. "A Physiologic Basis for the Adhesion-Free Healing of Deperitonealized Surfaces," J. Surg. Res., 21:67-76.

18.

18. Ar'Rajab, A. , B. Ahren , J. Rozga and S. Bengmark . 1991. "Phosphatidyl Choline Prevents Postoperative Peritoneal Adhesions: An Experimental Study in Rat," J. Surg. Res., 50, 212-215.