An Open,Nonrandomized Clinical Comparative Study Evaluating the Effect of Epilepsy on Learning

Abstract

Children with epilepsy, as a group, have a greater risk for developing learning problems as comorbid disorders. It is unknown which factors contribute to the development of such learning problems; therefore, our current knowledge does not allow the prediction of educational delay in an individual child with epilepsy. This study aimed at excluding as many factors as possible that could interfere with the analysis of the impact of epilepsy on learning. From patients referred to us in 1997 (N = 123), children were included with mild global learning impairment, defined as educational delay between 6 months and 1 year and no other apparent reason for learning impairment except for epilepsy (ie, excluding children with dyslexia, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, or mental handicap). A total of 44 patients fulfilled this criterion: 31 also had epilepsy (experimental group); the remaining 13 patients with similar mild learning impairment but without epilepsy were used as controls. In the experimental group two subgroups were distinguished on the basis of onset of learning impairment: in group A (n = 17) the learning problems are not unexpected as they were preceded by mild developmental delay; in group B (n = 14) the problems are unexpected and had a sudden onset. The two experimental groups differed from the control group on a number of variables, such as gender and the incidence of perinatal complications. More differences have been found between the two experimental groups: group B is selected from a larger group: all children with mild global learning impairment with sudden onset. In this group considerably more children with epilepsy have been found compared to the children with developmental delay; moreover the epilepsy is more often characterized in these children as "unexpected," that is, there was no previous established diagnosis of epilepsy, the symptoms were mostly unclear and behavioral in make-up (attentional lapses, etc); the electroencephalogram plays a much greater role in the diagnosis in this group, especially in demonstrating seizures; finally, the children in this group more frequently have neuropsychologic impairment. Children with epilepsy can have mild global learning difficulties, especially in the period after the onset of seizures. This group can be divided in a group with "trait-dependent learning difficulties," that is learning difficulties based on developmental delay, and a group with "state-dependent learning difficulties." The focus in our study was on this latter group, consisting of children with sudden and unexpected decline of results in school. The crucial finding in this group is the relatively frequent demonstration of difficult-to-detect seizures, demonstrating that an uncontrolled epilepsy can cause a decline in school results even when the seizures are of short duration and have subtle symptoms. (J Child Neurol 1999;14:795-800).

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

stores G. : Scnool children with epilepsy at risk for learning and behavior problems . Dev Med Child Neurol 1978;20:502-508.

Seidenberg M. , Beck N. , Geisser M. , et al: Academic achievement of children with epilepsy. Epilepsia 1986;29:753-759.

Thompson PJ : Educational attainment in children and young people with epilepsy , in Oxley J , Stores G (eds): Epilepsy and Education. London , Medical Tribune Group, 1987, pp 15-24.

Aldenkamp AP : Learning disabilities in epilepsy, in Aldenkamp AP , Alpherts WCJ , Meinardi H , Stores G (eds): Education and Epilepsy. Berwyn, IL, Swets & Zeitlinger, 1987, pp 21-38.

Aldenkamp AP : The impact of epilepsy on cognitive development and learning behavior, in Aldenkamp AP , Dreifuss FE , Renier WO (eds): Epilepsy in Children and Adolescents. New York, CRC Press, 1995, pp 225-239.

Aldenkamp AP , Alpherts Wcj , Dekker Mca : Neuropsychological aspects of learning disabilities in epilepsy. Epilepsia 1990;31 (Suppl 4):9-20.

Rutter M. , Graham P. , Yule WA : A Neuropsychiatric Study in Childhood; Clinics in Developmental Medicine . London, Heinemann, 1970.

Green JB , Hartlage LC : Comparative performance of epileptic and non-epileptic children and adolescents . Dis Nerve Syst 1971;32:418-421.

Holdsworth L. , Whitmore K. : A study of children with epilepsy attending ordinary schools. Dev Med Child Neurol 1974 ;16:746-758.

10.

Ross EM , Tookey P. : Educational needs and epilepsy in childhood, in Trimble MR , Reynolds EH (eds): Epilepsy, Behaviour and Cognitive Function. Chichester , John Wiley & Sons, 1988, pp 87-97.

11.

Rourke BP : Neuropsychology of Learning Disabilities—Essentials of Subtype Analysis . New York, Guilford, 1985.

12.

Strang J. , Rourke BP : Adaptive behavior of children who exhibit specific arithmetic disabilities and associated neuropsychological abilities and deficits, in Rourke BP (ed): Neuropsychology of Learning Disabilities—Essentials of Subtype Analysis. New York, Guilford, 1985, pp 302-331.

13.

Strang J. : Educational and related treatment considerations concerning the child with epilepsy: A developmental neuropsychological approach, in Aldenkamp AP , Alpherts WCJ , Meinardi H , Stores G (eds): Education and Epilepsy. Berwyn, IL, Swets & Zeitlinger, 1987, pp 118-135.

14.

Vermeulen J. , Kortstee SWAT, Alpherts WCJ, Aldenkamp AP: Cognitive performance in learning disabled children with and without epilepsy . Seizure 1994;3:13-21.

15.

Kema GN , Kema-van Leggelo MKG: Handleiding G.S.O. [Manual Groninger school onderzoek] . Lisse, Swets & Zeitlinger , 1987.

16.

Siegel S. : Nonparcemetric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1956.

17.

Henderson S. , Sugden D. : Movement Assessment Battery for Children . London, Psychological Corp, 1992.

18.

Wechsler D. : Manual for the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, revised. New York, Psychological Corp, 1974 .

19.

Aldenkamp AP , Alpherts Wcj , Blennow G. , et al: Computerized assessment of cognitive function and quality of life, in Dodson WE , Trimble MR (eds): Epilepsy and Quality of Life in Epilepsy . New York, Raven Press, 1994, pp 199-215.

20.

Hynd GW , Willis WG : Pediatric Neuropsychology. New York, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1988.

21.

Mandelbaum DE , Burack GD : The effect of seizure type and medication on cognitive and behavioral functioning in children with idiopathic epilepsy . Dev Med Child Neur 1997;39:731-735.