We propose a simple pathogenetic mechanism that reduces a bewildering variety of central nervous system malformations to a manageable group sharing defects of midline prosencephalic growth. It is neither new nor innovative, but attempts to summarize many pathologic entities within a concept that accounts for known embryologic events and the sequence and timing of those events. We propose midline prosencephalic dysgenesis as a category of malformations including aprosencephaly, holoprosencephaly, septo-optic dysplasia, and agenesis of the corpus callosum. (J Child Neurol 1986; 1:3-18)
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Byrd SE, Harwood-Nash DC, Fitz CR, Rogovitz DM: Computed tomography evaluation in holoprosencephaly in infants and children . J Comput Assist Tomogr1977;1:456-463.
2.
Cohen MM: An update on the holoprosencephalic disorders. J Pediatr1982; 101:865-869.
3.
Gorlin RJ, Yunis J., Anderson VE: Short arm deletion of chromosome 18 in cebocephaly. Am J Dis Child1968;115:473-476.
4.
Nitowsky HM, Sindhvananda N., Konigsberg VR, et al: Partial 18 monosomy in the cyclops malformation. Pediatrics1966;37:260-269.
5.
Matsunaga E. , Shiota K.: Holoprosencephaly in human embryos: epidemiologic studies of 150 cases. Teratology1977 ;16:261-272.
6.
Sulik KK, Johnston, MC: Embryonic origin of holoprosencephaly: interrelationship of the developing brain and face. Scan Electron Microsc1982 ;1:309-322.
7.
Saunders ES, Shortland D., Dunn PM: What is the incidence of holoprosencephaly? J Med Genet1984;21:21-26.
8.
Schwartz S., Meekins J., Panny SR, et al: Cebocephaly-holoprosencephaly in a newborn girl with a terminal 7q deletion [46,XX,del(7)(pter→q32:)]. Am J Med Genet1983;15:141-144.
9.
Roach E., DeMyer W., Conneally PM, et al: Holoprosencephaly: birth data, genetic and demographic analyses of 30 families. Birth Defects1975;11:294-313.
10.
Colacino SC , Pettersen JC: Analysis of the gross anatomical variations found in four cases of trisomy 13. Am J Med Genet1978;2:31-50.
11.
Gullotta F. , Rehder H., Gropp A.: Descriptive neuropathology of chromosomal disorders in man. Hum Genet1981;57:337-344.
12.
Hamerton JL : Abnormalities of the autosomes—group D (13-15 group—Denver Conference) , in Human Cytogenetics . New York, Academic Press Inc , 1971, pp 310-344.
13.
Hori A., Peiffer J., Pfeiffer RA, et al: Cerebello-cortical heterotopia in dentate nucleus and other microdysgeneses in Trisomy D1 (Patau) syndrome. Brain Dev1980;2:345-352.
14.
Agbata IA, Kovi J., Parshad R., et al: Holoprosencephaly and trisomy 13 in a cyclops. JAMA1979;241:1109.
15.
Lorch V., Fojaco R., Bauer CR: Cebocephalus associated with Trisomy 13-15 mosaicism. Arch Neurol1978;35:163-165.
16.
Gaba AR, Anderson GJ, Van Dyke DL, et al: Alobar holoprosencephaly and otocephaly in a female infant with a normal karyotype and placental villitis. JMed Genet1982;19:78.
17.
Rowlatt U., Pruzansky S.: Premaxillary agenesis, ocular hypotelorism, holoprosencephaly, and extracranial anomalies in an infant with a normal karyogram. Cleft Palate J1980 ;17:197-204.
18.
Bishop K., Connolly JM, Carter CH, et al: Holoprosencephaly. J Pediatr1964;65:406-414.
19.
Pi SY, Fineman RM, Wing SD, et al: Holoprosencephaly in a Down syndrome child. Am J Med Genet1980;5:201-206.
20.
Martin NJ, Steinberg BG: The dup(3)(p25→pter) syndrome: a case with holoprosencephaly . Am J Med Genet1983; 14:767-772.
21.
Faint S., Lewis FJW: Presumptive deletion of the short arm of chromosome 18 in a cyclops . Human Chromosome Newsletter1964;14:5-6.
22.
Lambert JC, Philip P., Charpentier G., et al: Triploidy with cyclopia and identical HLA alleles in the parents . J Med Genet1984;21:63-66.
23.
Schnabel R. , Hansen S.: Karyotype 47,XXY,18p- in a newborn child with holoprosencephaly. Clin Genet1983 ;23:186-190.
24.
Opitz JM, Howe JJ: The Meckel syndrome (Dysencephalia splanchnocystica, the Gruber syndrome) . Birth Defects1969;5:167-179.
25.
Hsia YE, Bratu M., Herbordt A.: Genetics of the Meckel syndrome (dysencephalia splanchnocystica). Pediatrics1971; 47:237-247.
26.
Flori A., Orthner H., Kohlschutter A., et al: CNS dysplasia in dysencephalia splanchnocystica (Gruber's syndrome) . Acta Neuropathol1980 ;51:93-97.
27.
Benke PJ, Cohen MM Jr: Recurrence of holoprosencephaly in families with a positive history . Clin Genet1983;24:324-328.
Berry SA, Pierpont ME, Gorlin RJ: Single antral incisor in familial holoprosencephaly. J Pediatr1984;104:877-880.
30.
Hintz RL, Menking M., Sotos JF: Familial holoprosencephaly with endocrine dysplasia. J Pediatr1968;72:81-87.
31.
Cantu JM, Gragoso R., Garcia-Cruz D., et al: Dominant inheritance of holoprosencephaly. Birth Defects1978;14:215-220.
32.
Grote W., Rehder H., Weisner D., et al: Prenatal diagnosis of a probable hereditary syndrome with holoprosencephaly, hydrocephaly, octodactyly, and cardiac malformations. Eur J Pediatr1984;143:155-157.
33.
Pauli RM, Pettersen JC, Arya S., et al: Familial agnathia-holoprosencephaly. Am J Med Genet1983;14:677-698.
34.
Romshe CA: Hypothalamic-pituitary dysfunction in siblings of patients with holoprosencephaly . J Pediatr1973;83:1088-1089.
35.
Begleiter ML , Harris DJ: Holoprosencephaly and endocrine dysgenesis in brothers. Am Med Genet1980;7:315-318.
36.
Merriam GR, Beitins IZ, Bode HH: Father-to-son transmission of hypogonadism with anosmia. Am J Dis Child1977 ;131:1216-1219.
37.
Conly ME, Beckwith JB, Mancer JFK, et al.: The spectrum of the DiGeorge syndrome. J Pediatr1979;94:883-890.
38.
Aleksic S., Budzilovich G., Reuben R., et al: Unilateral arhinencephaly in Goldenhar-Gorlin syndrome. Dev Med Child Neurol1975;17:498-504.
39.
Wilson GN: Cranial defects in the Goldenhar-syndrome. Am J Med Genet1983;14:435-443.
40.
Nakamura Y. , Nakashima T., Nakashima H., et al: Bilateral cystic nephroblastomas and botryoid sarcoma involving vagina and urinary bladder in a child with microcephaly, arhinencephaly, and bilateral cataracts. Cancer1981;48:1012-1015.
41.
Fitch N., Srolovitz H., Robitaille Y., et al: Absent left diaphragm, arhinencephaly, and cardiac malformations . J Med Genet1978;15:399-401.
42.
Gitlin G., Behar AJ: Meningeal angiomatosis, arhinencephaly, agenesis of the corpus callosum and large hamartoma of the brain, with neoplasia, in an infant having bilateral nasal proboscis. Acta Anat1960;41:56-79.
43.
Dekaban A.: Arhinencephaly in an infant born to a diabetic mother. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol1959;18:620-626.
44.
Bain AD, Gauld IK: Multiple congenital abnormalities associated with ring chromosome . Lancet1963;2:304-305.
45.
Stewart RM, Arhinencephaly. J Neurol Psychiatr1939;2:303-312.
46.
Issajew PO: Ein fall der abwesenheit des N. olfactorius. Anat Anx1932;74:398-400.
47.
Lemire RJ, Loeser JD, Leech RW, et al: Normal and Abnormal Development of the Human NervousSystem. Hagerstown, 1975, pp 206-230.
48.
Jellinger K. , Gross H., Kaltenback E., et al: Holoprosencephaly and agenesis of the corpus callosum: frequency of associated malformations . Acta Neuropathol1981;55:1-10.
49.
Fitz CR: Holoprosencephaly and related entities. Neuroradiology1983;25:225-238.
50.
Warkany J.: Congenital Malformations. Chicago, Year Book Medical Publishers Inc, 1971, pp 201-210.
51.
Burck V.: Genetic counselling in holoprosencephaly. Helv Paediatr Acta1982;37:231-237.
52.
DeMyer W.: Median facial malformations and their implications for brain malformations. Birth Defects1975 ;11:155-181.
53.
DeMyer W., Zeman W., Palmer CG: The face predicts the brain: diagnostic significance of median facial anomalies for holoprosencephaly (arhinencephaly). Pediatrics1964;34:256-263.
54.
DeMyer W.: Classification of cerebral malformations . Birth Defects1971;7:78-93.
55.
Cohen MM, Jirasek JE, Guzman RT, et al: Holoprosencephaly and facial dysmorphia: nosology, etiology and pathogenesis. Birth Defects1971;7:125-135.
56.
Lemire RJ, Cohen MM, Beckwith JB, et al: The facial features of holoprosencephaly in anencephalic human specimens. I. Historical review and associated malformations. Teratology1981;23:297-303.
57.
Siebert Jr, Kokich VG, Beckwith JB, et al: The facial features of holoprosencephaly in anencephalic human specimens. II. Craniofacial anatomy. Teratology1981;23:305-315.
58.
DeMyer W., Zeman W.: Alobar holoprosencephaly (arhinencephaly) with median cleft lip and palate: clinical, electroencephalographic and nosologic considerations. Confin Neurol1963;23:1-6.
59.
Altman NR, Altman DH, Sheldon JJ, et al: Holoprosencephaly classified by computed tomography. AJNR1984;5:433-437.
60.
Arakaki DT, Wasman SH: Trisomy D in a cyclops. J Pediatr1969;74:620-622.
61.
Barber AN, Muelling RJ: Cyclopia with complete separation of the neural and mesodermal elements of the eye. Arch Ophthalmol1950;43:989-1007.
62.
Burck U., Held KR, Kitschke HJ: Occurrence of cyclopia, myelomeningocele, deafness, and abducens paralysis in siblings. Am J Genet1982;11:443-448.
63.
Currarino G. , Silverman FN: Orbital hypotelorism, arhinencephaly, and trigonocephaly. Radiology1960;74:206-217.
64.
De Lange C.: Two cases of congenital anomalies of the brain . Am J Dis Child1937;53:429-444.
65.
De Lange C.: Cebocephalia minor. Acta Psychiatr Scand1940; 15:299-336.
66.
Derakhshan I., Sabouri-Deylami M., Lotfi J.: Holoprosencephaly . Arch Neurol1980;37:55-57.
67.
Fatt CY: Cebocephaly: a report of five post-mortem cases and review of literature . Aust Paediatr J1972;8:52-56.
68.
Hayashi T., Kuramoto S., Takagi S., et al: CT findings in an alobar holoprosencephaly associated with Dandy-Walker's cyst. Kurume Med J1980;27:139-142.
69.
Hayashi T., Takagi S., Kuramoto S.: A case of holoprosencephaly: with possible association of Dandy-Walker cyst . Brain Dev1981;3:97-101.
70.
Hutchinson JW, Stovring J., Turner PT: Occipital encephalocele with holoprosencephaly and aqueduct stenosis. Surg Neurol1979;12:331-335.
71.
lannetti P. , Chessa L., Brattoli L., et al: Holoprosencephalic disorders. Clin Pediatr1984;23:294-296.
72.
Lang AP, Schlager FM, Gardner HA: Trisomy 18 and cyclopia. Teratology1976;14:195-204.
73.
Landau JW, Berry JM, Koch R.: Arhinencephaly. J Pediatr1963;62:895-900.
74.
Marburg O., Warner FJ: The brain in a case of human cyclopia. J Nerv Ment Dis1946;103:319-336.
75.
Mieden GD: An anatomical study of three cases of alobar holoprosencephaly. Teratology1982;26:123-133.
76.
Miyasaki K. , Murao S., Nakamura K., et al: Arhinencephaly (holoprosencephaly) associated with external hydrocephaly. Acta Pathol Jpn1977;27:893-905.
Osaka K., Matsumoto S.: Holoprosencephaly in neurosurgical practice. J Neurosurg1978;48:787-803.
79.
Roubicek M. , Spranger J., Wende S.: Frontonasal dysplasia as an expression of holoprosencephaly. Eur J Pediatr1981 ;137:229-231.
80.
Sedano HO, Gorlin RJ: The oral manifestations of cyclopia. Oral Surg1963;16:823-838.
81.
Yakovlev PI : Pathoarchitectonic studies of cerebral malformations. III. Arrhinencephalies (holotelencephalies). J Neuropathol Exp Neurol1959;18:22-55.
82.
Gilles FH: Telencephalon medium and the olfacto-cerebral outpouching, in Gilles FH, Leviton A , Dooling EC (eds): The Developing Human Brain. Littleton, Mass, John Wright PSG Inc, 1983, pp 59-86.
83.
Loeser JD, Alvord EC Jr: Agenesis of the corpus callosum. Brain1968 ;91:553-570.
84.
Rakic P., Yakovlev PI: Development of the corpus callosum and cavum septi in man. J Comp Neurol1968;132:45-72.
85.
Biemond A.: Ueber einen fall von kernaplasie (Moebius), kombiniert mit arhinencephalie . Acta Psychiatr Scand1936 ;11:48-62.
86.
Taylor AI: Patau's, Edward's and Cri Du Chat syndromes: a tabulated summary of current findings. Dev Med Child Neurol1967 ;9:78-86.
87.
Taylor AI: Autosomal trisomy syndromes: a detailed study of 27 cases of Edward's syndrome and 27 cases of Patau's syndrome. J Med Genet1968;5:227-252.
88.
Warkany J., Passarge E., Smith LB: Congenital malformations in autosomal trisomy syndromes. Am J Dis Child1966;112:502-517.
89.
Sumi SM: Brain malformations in the trisomy 18 syndrome. Brain1970;93:821-830.
90.
Smith DW, Patau K., Therman E., et al: The D1 trisomy syndrome. J Pediatr1963;62:326-341.
91.
Miller JQ, Selden RF: Arhinencephaly, encephalocele, and 1315 trisomy syndrome with normal chromosomes . Neurology1967;17:1087-1091.
92.
Michaelson PS , Gilles FH: Central nervous system abnormalities in trisomy E (17-18) syndrome. J Neurol Sci1972 ;15:193-208.
93.
Conen PE, Phillips KG, Mauntner LS: Multiple developmental anomalies and trisomy of a 13-15 group chromosome ('D' syndrome). Can Med J1962;87:709-712.
94.
Dziekanowska D., Dziuba P., Sobanski T.: The trisomy 18 syndrome with E/G translocation . Hum Genet1976;31:347-349.
95.
Hamerton JL: Abnormalities of the autosomes—group E (16-18 group—Denver Conference) , in Human Cytogenetics. New York, Academic Press, 1971, pp 276-309.
96.
DeMorsier G. : Etudes sur les dysraphies cranio-encephaliques: III. Agenesis du septum lucidum avec malformation du tractu optique. La dysplasie septo-optique. Schweiz Arch NeurochirPsychiatr1956;77:267-292.
97.
DeMorsier G. : Median cranioencephalic dysraphias and olfactogenital dysplasia. World Neurol1962;3:485-504.
98.
Acers TE: Optic nerve hypoplasia: septo-optic-pituitary dysplasia syndrome. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc1981;79:425-457.
99.
Hoyt WF, Kaplan SL, Grumbach MM, et al: Septo-optic dysplasia and pituitary dwarfism. Lancet1970;1:893-894.
Billson F. , Hopkins IJ: Optic hypoplasia and hypopituitarism . Lancet1972;1:905.
102.
Patel H., Tze WJ, Crichton JU, et al: Optic nerve hypoplasia with hypopituitarism. Am J Dis Child1975;129:175-180.
103.
Hall DMB , Bartlett M., Faerber EN, et al: Septo-optic dysplasia. S Afr Med J1977;52:367-369.
104.
Wilson RW, Easley RB, Bolander FF, et al: Evidence for a hypothalamic defect in septo-optic dysplasia . Arch Intern Med1978;138:1276-1277.
105.
Wilson DM, Enzmann DR, Hintz RL, et al: Computed tomographic findings in septo-optic dysplasia: discordance between clinical and radiological findings. Neuroradiology1984 ;26:279-283.
106.
Huseman CA , Kelch RP, Hopwood NJ, et al: Sexual precosity in association with septo-optic dysplasia and hypothalamic hypopituitarism . J Pediatr1978;92:748-753.
107.
Rush JA, Bajandas FJ: Septo-optic dysplasia (De Morsier syndrome). Am J Ophthalmol1978;86:202-205.
108.
Manelfe C. , Rochiccioli P.: CT of septo-optic dysplasia. AJR1979;133:1157-1160.
109.
Krause-Brucker W., Gardner DW: Optic nerve hypoplasia associated with absent septum pellucidum and hypopituitarism. Am J Ophthalmol1980;89:113-120.
110.
Donat JFG : Septo-optic dysplasia in an infant of a diabetic mother. Arch Neurol1981;38:590-591.
111.
Stewart C. , Castro-Magana M., Sherman J., et al: Septo-optic dysplasia and median cleft face syndrome in a patient with isolated growth hormone deficiency and hyperprolactinemia . Am J Dis Child1983;137:484-487.
112.
Izenberg N. , Rosenblum M., Parts JS: The endocrine spectrum of septo-optic dysplasia . Clin Pediatr1984 ;23:632-636.
113.
Pagon RA, Stephan MJ: Septo-optic dysplasia with digital anomalies. J Pediatr1984;105:966-968.
114.
Hale BR, Rice P.: Septo-optic dysplasia: clinical and embryological aspects. Dev Med Child Neurol1974;16:812-820.
115.
Thomsett MJ : Septo-optic dysplasia presenting in early infancy . Aust Paediatr J1977;13:305-308.
116.
Lovrencic MK, Oberiter V., Banovac ZR, et al: Pituitary function in a patient with septo-optic dysplasia and pituitary dwarfism (Kaplan-Grumbach-Hoyt syndrome) . Eur Pediatr1978; 129:47-53.
117.
Ellenberger C., Runyan TE: Holoprosencephaly with hypoplasia of the optic nerves, dwarfism, and agenesis of the septum pellucidum. Am J Ophthalmol1970;70:960-967.
118.
Arslanian SA, Rothfus WE, Foley TPJr, et al: Hormonal, metabolic, and neuroradiologic abnormalities associated with septo-optic dysplasiaActa Endocrinol1984;107:282-288.
119.
Griffiths P., Hunt S.: Specific spatial defect in a child with septo-optic dysplasia. Dev Med Child Neurol1984;26:295-400.
120.
Lichtenstein BW, Maloney JE: Malformation of the forebrain with comments on the so-called dorsal cyst, the corpus callosum and the hippocampal structures . J Neuropathol Exp Neurol1954 ;13:117-128.
121.
Aicardi J. , Goutieres F.: The syndrome of absence of the septum pellucidum with porencephalies and other development defects. Neuropediatrics1981;12:319-329.
122.
Gastaut H. , De Wulf : Etude de deux cas d'une dysgenesie cerebrale exceptionnelle: la synraphie des fissures cerebrales et des anomalies anatomiques et cliniques qu'elle entraine. Rev Neurol1947;79:591-601.
123.
Yokota A., Oota T., Matsukado Y.: Dorsal cyst malformations. Part 1. Clinical study and critical review on the definition of holoprosencephaly. Childs Brain1984;11:320-341.
124.
Adkins WN, Kaveggia EG: Sporadic case of apparent aprosencephaly. Am J Med Genet1979;3:311-314.
125.
Garcia CA, Duncan C.: Atelencephalic microcephaly. Dev Med Child Neurol1977;19:227-232.
126.
Lurie IW, Nedzved MK, Lazjuk GI, et al: Aprosencephalyatelencephaly and the aprosencephaly (XK) syndrome . Am J Med Genet1979;3:303-309.
127.
Parrish ML , Roessmann U., Levinsohn MW: Agenesis of the corpus callosum: a study of the frequency of associated malformations. Ann Neurol1979;6:349-354.
128.
Ropers HH, Zuffardi O., Bianchi E., et al: Agenesis of corpus callosum, ocular skeletal anomalies (X-linked dominant Aicardi's syndrome) in a girl with balanced X/3 translocation. Hum Genet1982;61:364-368.
129.
Pollack MA , Kolbert GS: Congenital cataracts associated with agenesis of the corpus callosum and cerebral dysgenesis: a case report . J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus1981;18:6-8.
130.
Ozdirim E. , Renda Y.: Familial corpus callosum agenesis . Turk J Pediatr1978;20:76-84.
131.
Larbrisseau A., Vanasse M., Brochu P., et al: The Andermann Syndrome: agenesis of the corpus callosum associated with mental retardation and progressive sensorimotor neuronopathy. Can J Neurol Sci1984;11:257-261.
132.
Dinani S., Jancar J.: Aicardi's syndrome: (agenesis of the corpus callosum, infantile spasms, and ocular anomalies). J Ment Defic Rec1984 ;28:143-149.
133.
Denslow GT , Robb RM, Aicardi's syndrome: a report of four cases and review of the literature. Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus1979;16:10-15.
134.
Cao A. , Ciancheiti C., Signorini E., et al: Agenesis of the corpus callosum, infantile spasms, spastic quadriplegia, microcephaly and severe mental retardation in three siblings. Clin Genet1977;12:290-296.
135.
Bertoni JM , von Loh S., Allen RJ: The Aicardi syndrome: Report of 4 cases and review of the literature. Ann Neurol1979 ;5:475-482.
136.
Bale PM, Reye RDK: Epignathus, double pituitary and agenesis of the corpus callosum. J Pathol1976;120:161-164.
137.
Jellinger K., Gross H.: Congenital telencephalic midline defects . Neuropadiatrie1973;4:446-452.
