Educational Underachievement in Children With Epilepsy: A Model to Predict the Effects of Epilepsy on Educational Achievement

Abstract

In this study, we evaluated the impact on educational achievement of four characteristics of epilepsy individually and combined: epilepsy syndrome (type of epilepsy), seizure type, the frequency of epileptiform electroencephalographic (EEG) discharges, and the effect of antiepileptic treatment. Simultaneously, the effect on cognitive function and the relationship between educational underachievement and cognitive impairment were evaluated, focusing on memory, attention, speed of information processing, and intelligence level. This study was an open, controlled, parallel-group, nonrandomized clinical investigation. Eligible patients were selected when referred to our center for assessment of relationships between epilepsy and learning impairment in the years 1997 to 2001. Separately, children without neurologic deficit and without educational delay were assessed with the same tests as the children with epilepsy. This latter group is used in this study as a control group. One hundred seventy-six children with epilepsy and 113 controls were included. Gender distribution and age were comparable for the two groups. All children were in regular primary education. The children were assessed with a test battery consisting of tests for educational achievement, cognitive tests and tests for reaction time, and tests for memory and intelligence. Multivariate analysis of variance for tests of educational achievement showed a statistically significant effect for type of epilepsy (F = 4.386; P = .04), caused by the statistically lower scores for patients with localized epilepsy and symptomatic generalized epilepsy. For the reaction-time tests, a statistically significant effect for epileptiform EEG discharges (F = 3.165; P = .01) and treatment (F = 4.472; P = .001) on both vigilance tests was found, caused by patients with frequent epileptiform EEG discharges and polytherapy. Two-way interactions showed an interaction with type of epilepsy, with more patients with symptomatic generalized epilepsy having frequent epileptiform EEG discharges and polytherapy. For memory, none of the analyses showed statistically significant effects. For intelligence only for type of epilepsy, a statistically significant effect was found (F = 10.174; P = < .001). We propose a model with the type of epilepsy (epilepsy syndrome) as the dominant factor explaining educational underachievement in children with epilepsy. Such educational underachievement is most prominent for the localized and symptomatic generalized epilepsies, which suggests a dominant impact of underlying etiology (brain dysfunction or damage). These epilepsies are characterized specifically by a lower intelligence; hence, this could be the primary cognitive factor mediating between the type of epilepsy and educational underachievement. From the other factors, treatment (the use of polytherapy) and frequent epileptiform EEG discharges are associated with impaired vigilance, which could have an additional influence on educational achievement. These factors are, however, not independent of the type of epilepsy. (J Child Neurol 2005;20:175—180).

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Stores G. : School children with epilepsy at risk for learning and behaviour problems . Dev Med Child Neurol 1978;20:502—508.

Seidenberg M. , Beck N. , Geisser M. , et al: Academic achievement of children with epilepsy. Epilepsia 1986;29:753—759.

Aldenkamp AP : Epilepsy and learning behavior, in Parsonage M , Grant RHE , Graig AG , et al, (eds): Advances in Epileptology. New York, Raven Press, 1983, 221—229.

Aldenkamp AP : Learning disabilities in epilepsy, in Aldenkamp AP , Alpherts WCJ , Meinardi H , Stores G (eds): Education and Epilepsy. Berwyn, PA, Swets & Zeitlinger, 1987, 21—38.

Aldenkamp AP : The impact of epilepsy on cognitive development and learning behaviour, in Aldenkamp AP , Dreifuss FE , Renier WO (eds): Epilepsy in Children and Adolescents. New York, CRC Press Publishers, 1995, 225—239.

Thompson PJ : Educational attainment in children and young people with epilepsy, in Oxley J , Stores G (eds): Epilepsy and Education. London , The Medical Tribune Group, 1987 , 15—24.

Aldenkamp AP , Overweg-Plandsoen Wcg , Diepman Lam : Factors involved in learning problems and educational delay in children with epilepsy. Child Neuropsychol 1999;5:130—138.

Rutter M. , Graham P. , Yule WA : A neuropsychiatric study in childhood, in Clinics in Developmental Medicine. London, Heinemann, 1970.

Aldenkamp AP , Alpherts Wcj , Dekker Mca : Neuropsychological aspects of learning disabilities in epilepsy. Epilepsia 1990;31(Suppl 4):9—20.

10.

Vermeulen J. , Kortstee SWAT, Alpherts WCJ, Aldenkamp AP: Cognitive performance in learning disabled children with and without epilepsy . Seizure 1994;3:1321.

11.

Green JB , Hartlage LC : Comparative performance of epileptic and non-epileptic children and adolescents . Dis Nerv Syst 1971;32:418—421.

12.

Holdsworth L. , Whitmore K. : A study of children with epilepsy attending ordinary schools. Dev Med Child Neurol 1974 ; 16:746-758.

13.

Ross EM , Tookey P. : Educational needs and epilepsy in childhood, in Trimble MR , Reynolds EH (eds): Epilepsy, Behaviour and Cognitive Function. Chichester, UK, John Wiley & Sons, 1988, 87—97.

14.

Aldenkamp AP , Overweg-Plandsoen Wcg , Arends J. : An open nonrandomized clinical comparative study evaluating the effect of epilepsy on learning. J Child Neurol 1999;14:795—801.

15.

Baird HW , John ER , Ahn H. : Neurometric evaluation of epileptic children who do well and poorly in school . Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1980 ;48:683—693.

16.

Bourgeois Bfd , Presky AL , Palkes HS : Intelligence in epilepsy: A prospective study in children. Ann Neurol 1983;14:438—444.

17.

Mandelbaum DE , Burack GD : The effect of seizure type and medication on cognitive and behavioral functioning in children with idiopathic epilepsy . Dev Med Child Neurol 1997;39:731—735.

18.

Aldenkamp AP , Arends J. , Overweg-Plandsoen TC , et al: Acute cognitive effects of nonconvulsive difficult-to-detect epileptic seizures and epileptiform electroencephalographic discharges. J Child Neurol 2001;16:119—123.

19.

Aldenkamp AP , Van Bronswijk K , Braken M. , et al: A clinical comparative study evaluating the effect of epilepsy versus ADHD on timedcognitivetasksinchildren . Child Neuropsychol 2001;6:209—219.

20.

Aarts Jhp , Binnie CD , Smit AM , Wilkins AJ : Selective cognitive impairment during focal and generalised epileptiform EEG activity. Brain 1984;107:293—308.

21.

Aldenkamp AP , Overweg J. , Gutter TH , et al: Effect of epilepsy, seizures and epileptiform EEG-discharges on cognitive function. Acta Neurol Scand 1996;93:253—259.

22.

Aldenkamp AP , Alpherts Wcj , Blennow G. , et al: Withdrawal of antiepileptic medication effects on cognitive function in children—The results of the multicentre `Holmfrid' study. Neurology 1993;43:41—51.

23.

Vermeulen J. , Aldenkamp AP : Cognitive side-effects of chronic antiepileptic drug treatment: A review of 25 years of research. Epilepsy Res 1995;22:65—95.

24.

Wechsler D. : Manual for the Wechsler Intelligence Scale Revised. New York, The Psychological Corporation, 1974.

25.

De Vos T. : Handleiding Tempotest Lezen (Zinnen) (Manual Speedtest Reading— Sentences) . Nijmegen, Berkhout, 1992.

26.

De Vos T. : Handleiding Tempotest Rekenen (Manual Speedtest Arithmetic). Nijmegen, Berkhout, 1994.

27.

Aldenkamp AP , Vermeulen J. , Alpherts Wcj , et al: Validity of computerized testing: Patient dysfunction and complaints versus measured changes, in Dodson WE , Kinsbourne M (eds): Assessment of Cognitive Function. New York, Demos, 1992, 51—68.

28.

Alpherts Wcj , Aldenkamp AP : Computerized neuropsychological assessment in children with epilepsy. Epilepsia 1990;31(Suppl 4):35—40.

29.

Cohen J. : Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. New York, Academic Press, 1977.

30.

Cook D. , Campbell DT : Quasi-Experimentation; Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings. Boston, Houghton Mifflin Company, 1979.