The Effects of Prior Special Education Placement and Current Test Data on School Psychologists' Decisions

Abstract

This study investigated the possible biasing effects of prior special education involvement (and associated diagnostic label) and current psychoeducational test data on 82 school psychologists' prognostic, diagnostic, and placement decisions for a case study child. The findings indicated that the school psychologists' decisions were not influenced by the child's prior special education placement but were influenced by current psychological test results. School psychologists who reevaluated a child who had been previously placed in a resource program for learning disabled students, but who currently demonstrated normal academic functioning, were likely to re-classify the child as non-handicapped and recommend return to regular class programs. The findings suggested that school psychologists are not biased by knowledge of previous special program involvement and diagnostic label and that individual psychological test data may act to minimize potential bias effects.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Algozzine, B.

, &

Sutherland, J.

(1977). Non-psychoeducational foundations of learning disabilities. Journal of Special Education , 11, 91-98.

Amira, S.

Abramowitz, S.

, &

Gomes-Schwartz, B.

, (1977). Socially charged pupil and psychologist effects on psychoeducational decisions. Journal of Special Education, 11, 433-440.

Bailey, D.B.

, &

Harbin, G.L.

(1980). Nondiscriminatory evaluation. Exceptional Children, 46, 590-596.

Boucher, C.R.

, &

Deno, S.L.

(1979). Learning disabled and emotionally disturbed: Will the labels affect teacher planning?Psychology in the Schools , 16, 395-402.

Galvin, G.A.

, &

Elliott, S.N.

(1985). Psychological reevaluations of handicapped children: A survey of practitioners and policymakers. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 16(1), 64-75.

Gilliam, J.E.

(1979). Contributions and status rankings of educational planning committee participants. Exceptional Children, 45, 466-468.

Gillung, T.B.

, &

Rucker, C.N.

(1977). Labels and teachers expectations. Exceptional Children, 43, 464-465.

Greenbaum, R.M.

(1977). Generalizability of labeling effects over two facets of children's behavior. Dissertation Abstracts International , 38, 704-A ( University Microfilms No. 77-16, 672).

Gresham, F.

(1983). Multitrait-multimethod approach to multifactored assessment: Theoretical rationale and practical application. School Psychology Review, 12, 26-34.

10.

Guskin, S.L.

(1978). Theoretical and empirical strategies for the study of the labelling of mentally retarded persons. In

N.R. Ellis

(Ed.), International Review of Research in Mental Retardation (pp. 127-157). New York: Academic Press.

11.

Huebner, E.S.

, &

Cummings, J.A.

(1985). The impact of sociocultural background and assessment data upon school psychologists' decisions. Journal of School Psychology, 23, 157-166.

12.

Hull, C.H.

, &

Nie, N.H.

(1981). SPSS Update 7-9, New York: McGraw-Hill.

13.

Javel, M.E.

, &

Greenspan, S.

(1983). Influence of personal competence profiles on mainstreaming recommendations of school psychologists. Psychology in the Schools, 20, 459-465.

14.

McDermott, P.A.

(1981). Sources of error in the psychoeducational diagnosis of children. Journal of School Psychology, 19(1), 31-44.

15.

Matuszek, P.

, &

Oakland, T.

(1979). Factors influencing teachers' and psychologists' recommendations regarding special class placement. Journal of School Psychology, 17, 116-125.

16.

Nathan, P.E.

(1967). Cues, decisions, and diagnoses: A systems analytic approach to the diagnosis of psychopathology. New York : Academic Press.

17.

Pfeiffer, S.I.

(1980). The influence of diagnostic labeling on special education placement decisions. Psychology in the Schools, 17, 346-350.

18.

Reynolds, C.R.

(1981). The fallacy of "two years below grade level for age" as a diagnostic criterion for reading disorders. Journal of School Psychology, 19, 350-358.

19.

Smith, C.R.

, &

Knoff, H.M.

(1981). School psychology and special education students' placement decisions: IQ still tips the scale. The Journal of Special Education, 15, 55-64.

20.

Wilson, C.R.

, &

Cone, T.

(1984). The regression equation method of determining academic discrepancy. Journal of School Psychology, 22, 95-110.

21.

Ysseldyke, J.

, &

Algozzine, B.

(1979). Perspectives on assessment of learning disabled students. Learning Disabilities Quarterly, 2, 3-12.

22.

Ysseldyke, J.

, &

Foster, G.E.

(1978). Bias in teachers' observations of emotionally disturbed and learning disabled children. Exceptional Children , 44, 613-615.