A controlled comparison of symptoms and chemical intolerances reported by Gulf War veterans,implant recipients and persons with multiple chemical sensitivity

Abstract

Using the Environmental Exposure and Sensitivity Inventory (EESI), a standardized instrument for measuring chemical sensitivity, weobtained and compared ratings of symptoms, chemical (inhalant) intolerances, other intolerances (e.g., drugs, caffeine, alcohol, skin contactants), lifeimpact, and masking (ongoing exposures) in five populations: multiple chemical sensitivity (MCS) patients who did (n=96) or did not (n=90) attribute onset of their illness to a specific exposure event, patients with implanted devices (n=87), Gulf War veterans (n=72), and controls (n=76). For each patient group, mean scores on the first four scales were significantly greater than for controls. MCS patients reported avoiding more chemical exposures (were less masked) than the other groups. Across groups, for a given level of symptoms, as masking increased, mean scores on the Chemical Intolerance Scale decreased. In contrast, mean scores on the Other Intolerance Scale appeared to be less affected by masking. These findings suggest that some patients with antecedent chemical exposures, whether exogenous (chemical spill, pesticide application, indoor air contaminants) or endogenous (implant), develop new chemical, food, and drug intolerances. Reports of new caffeine, alcohol, medication, food, or other intolerances by patients may signal exposure-related illness. Masking may reduce individuals' awareness of chemical intolerances, and, to a lesser degree, other intolerances.

Keywords

chemical sensitivity environmental exposures environmental illness Gulf War veterans implant multiple chemical sensitivity pesticide

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ashford N. , and Miller C. Chemical Exposures: Low Levels and High Stakes. Wiley and Sons, New York, 1998.

Ashford N. , Heinzow B. , Lütjen K. , Marouli C. , Mølhave L. , Mönch B. , Papadopoulos S. , Rest K. , Rosdahl D. , Siskos P. , and Velonakis, E. Chemical sensitivity in selected European countries: an exploratory study. A report to the European Commission, 1995.

Bell I. , Miller C. , Schwartz G. , Peterson J. , and Amend D. Neuropsychiatric and somatic characteristics of young adults with and without self-reported chemical odor intolerance and chemical sensitivity. Arch. Environ. Health 1996: 51 (1): 9-21.

Brautbar N. , Vojdani A. , and Campbell A.

Multiple chemical sensitivity—fact or myth?

Toxicol. Ind. Health 1992: 8 (6): v-xiii.

Buchwald D. , and Garrity D. Comparison of patients with chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, and multiple chemical sensitivities. Arch. Int. Med. 1994: 154: 2049-2053.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) . Unexplained illness among Persian Gulf War veterans in an Air National Guard unit: preliminary report. MMWR 1995: 44 (23): 443-447.

Cullen M. , Pace P. , and Redlich C. The experience of the Yale Occupational and Environmental Medicine Clinics with multiple chemical sensitivities, 1986-1991. Toxicol. Ind. Health 1992: 8: 15-19.

Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) . Report to Congress on Indoor Air Quality, Volume II, Assessment and Control of Indoor Air Pollution, 1989.

Fiedler N. , Kipen H. , Deluca J. , Kelly-McNeil K. , and Natelson B. Neuropsychology and psychology of MCS. Toxicol. Ind. Health 1994: 10 (4/5): 545-554.

10.

Fukuda K. , Nisenbaum R. , Stewart G. , Thompson W. , Robin L. , Washko R. , Noah D. , Barrett D. , Randall B. , Herwaldt B. , Mawle A. , and Reeves W. Chronic multi-system illness affecting Air Force veterans of the Gulf War. JAMA 1998: 280(11): 981-988.

11.

Hoffman D. , Stockdale S. , Hicks L. , and Schwaninger J. Neurocognitive symptoms and quantitative EEG results in women presenting with silicone-induced autoimmune disease. Int. J. Occup. Med. Toxicol. 1995: 4 (1): 91-98.

12.

Kang H. , and Bullman T. Mortality among U.S. veterans of the Persian Gulf War. New Engl. J. Med. 1996: 335 (2a): 1498-1504.

13.

Kipen H. , Hallman W. , Kelly-Mcneil K. , and Fiedler N. Measuring chemical sensitivity prevalence: a questionnaire for population studies. Am. J. Public Health 1995: 85 (4): 574-577.

14.

Kruetzer R. , and Neutra R. Evaluating individuals reporting sensitivities to multiple chemicals. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA. Publication #P896-187646, 1996.

15.

Lax M. ,and Henneberger P. Patients with multiple chemical sensitivities in an occupational health clinic: presentation and follow-up. Arch. Environ. Health 1995: 50 (6): 425-431.

16.

Meggs W. , Dunn K. , Bloch R. , Goodman P. , and Davidoff L. Prevalence and nature of allergy and chemical sensitivity in a general population. Arch. Environ. Health 1996: 51 (4): 275-282.

17.

Miller C. White paper: chemical sensitivity: history and phenomenology. Toxicol. Ind. Health 1994: 10 (4): 253-276.

18.

Miller C.

Toxicant-induced loss of tolerance—an emerging theory of disease?

Environ. Health Perspect. 1997: 105 (suppl 2): 445-453.

19.

Miller C. Are we on the threshold of a new theory of disease? Toxicantinduced loss of tolerance and its relationship to addiction and abdiction. Toxicol. Ind. Health 1999: 284-294.

20.

Miller C. , and Mitzel H. Chemical sensitivity attributed to pesticide exposure versus remodeling. Arch. Environ. Health 1995: 50 (2): 119-129.

21.

Miller C. , and Prihoda T. The Environmental Exposure and Sensitivity Inventory (EESI): a standardized approach for measuring chemical intolerances for research and clinical applications. Toxicol. Ind. Health 1999: 370-385.

22.

Miller C. , Ashford N. , Doty R. , Lamielle M. , Otto D. , Rahill A. , and Wallace L. Empirical approaches for the investigation of toxicant-induced loss of tolerance. Environ. Health Perspect. 1997: 105 (suppl 2): 515-519.

23.

National Institute of Health (NIH) . Technology assessment workshop panel. The Persian Gulf experience and health. JAMA 1994: 272: 391-395.

24.

Overstreet D. , Miller C. , Janowsky D. , and Russell R. Potential animal model of multiple chemical sensitivity with cholinergic supersensitivity. Toxicology 1996: 111: 119-134.

25.

Randolph T. Environmental Medicine: Beginnings and Bibliographies of Clinical Ecology (1987). Clinical Ecology Publications, Fort Collins, CO, 1987.

26.

Randolph T. , and Moss R. An Alternative Approach to Allergies. Lippincott and Crowell, New York, 1980.

27.

Rogers W. , Miller, C. , and Bunegin L. A rat model of neurobehavioral sensitization to toluene. Toxicol. Ind. Health 1999: 295-304.

28.

Simon G. , Katon W. , and Sparks P. Allergic to life: psychological factors in environmental illness. Am. J. Psychiatry 1990: 147: 901-906.

29.

Simon G. , Daniell W. , Stockbridge H. , Claypoole K. , and Rosenstock L. Immunological, psychological, and neuropsychological factors in multiple chemical sensitivity: a controlled study. Ann. Int. Med. 1993: 19 (2): 97-103.

30.

Sorg B. Proposed animal model for multiple chemical sensitivity in studies with formalin. Toxicology 1996: 111: 135-145.