Neurological symptoms are frequently reported by patients with multiple chemical
sensitivities (MCS). Methods to compare the psychiatric, personality, and
neuropsychological function of patients with MCS, chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), and
normal controls are described. Increased rates of Axis I psychiatric diagnoses are
observed in the literature for MCS and CFS subjects relative to controls. Findings on the
MMPI-2 and the Toronto Alexithymia Scale reveal prof iles consistent with the tendency to
report somatic rather than emotional symptoms in response to stress. However, many of the
reported somatic symptoms also coincide with those found in neurologic disorders. The
overall neuropsychological prof ile for MCS subjects does not reflect cognitive
impairment. Relative to normal controls, the only difference in neuropsychological
performance observed is reduced recognition of nontarget designs on a visual memory task.
More fruitful areas for future psychological research will include measurement of the
interaction between behavioral response styles and attentional processes in cognition, as
well as observations under controlled challenge conditions.
ALFANO, D., FINLAYSON, M.,
STEARNS,
G., and NEILSON, P. (1990).
The MMPI and neurologic dysfunction: prof ile configuration and
analysis. Clin. Neuropsych.4:
6979.
2.
ANGER, W.K. and JOHNSON, B.L.
(1992). Human behavioral neurotoxicology: workplace and
community assessments. In: Environmental and Occupational
Medicine (W.N.
Rom, ed.). Little Brown,
Boston, pp.
573592.
3.
BAKER, E., LETZ, R., and
FIDLER,
A. (1985). A
computer-administered neurobehavioral evaluation system for occupational and
environmental epidemiology. J. Occup.
Med.27: 206212.
4.
BLACK, E.W., RATHE, A., and
GOLDSTEIN,
R.B. (1990). Environmental
illness: a controlled study of 26 subjects with 20th century disease.
J. Am. Med. Assoc.264:
31663170.
5.
BLACK, D.W., RATHE, A., and
GOLDSTEIN
R.B. (1993). Measures of
distress in 26 environmentally ill subjects.
Psychosom.34:
131138.
6.
BOLLA-WILSON, K., WILSON, R.J., and
BLEECKER,
M.L. (1988). Conditioning of
physical symptoms after neurotoxic exposure. J. Occup.
Med.30: 684686.
7.
BRODSKY, C.M. (1983).
Psychological factors contributing to somatof orm diseases attributed to
the workplace. J. Occup. Med.25:
459464.
8.
CULLEN, M.R. (1987).
Workers with Multiple Chemical Sensitivities. Hanley
and Belfus, Philadelphia, pp.
655662.
9.
DELIS, D.C., KRAMER, J.H.,
KAPLAN,
E., and OBER, B.A. (1987).
California Verbal Learning Test Manual. The
Psychological Corporation, San Antonio,
Texas.
10.
DeLUCA, J., JOHNSON, S., and
NATELSON,
B. (1993). Information
processing efficiency in chronic fatigue syndrome and multiple
sclerosis. Arch. Neurol.50:
301304.
11.
FIEDLER, N., MACCIA, C., and
KIPEN,
H. (1992a). Evaluation of
chemically sensitive patients. J. Occup.
Med.34: 529538.
12.
FIEDLER, N., KIPEN, H., and
KELLY-McNEIL,
K. (1992b). Neuropsychological
and psychiatric prof ile of patients with multiple chemical
sensitivities. Clin. Neuropsych, 6:
347.
13.
GASS, C.S. (1991).
MMPI-2 interpretation and closed head injury: a correction
factor. Psychol. Assess.: J. Consult. Clin.
Psychol.3:
2731.
14.
HARTMAN, D.E. (1988).
Neuropsychological Toxicology: Identification and Assessment of Human Neurotoxic
Syndromes. Cook County Hospital, University of Illinois Medical Center.
Pergamon Press,
Chicago.
15.
HATHAWAY, S.R. and MCKINLEY, J.C.
(1989). MMPI-2. University of Minnesota
Press, Minneapolis, MN.
16.
HOLMES, G.P., KAPLAN, J.E.,
NELSON,
M., GANTZ, N.M., KOMAROF F, A.L.,
SCHONBERGER,
L.B., STRAUSS, S.E., JONES, J.F.,
BUBOIS,
R.E., CUNNINGHAMRUNDLES, C., PAHWA, S.,
TOSATO,
G., ZEGANS, L.S., PURTILO, D.T.,
BROWN,
N., SCHOOLEY, R.T., and BRUX, I.
(1988). Chronic fatigue syndrome: a working case
definition. Ann. Int. Med.106:
387389.
17.
JAMES, L., SINGER, A.,
ZURYNSKI,
Y., GORDON, E., KRAIUHIN, C.,
HARRIS,
A., HOWSON, A., and MEARES, R.
(1987). Evoked response potentials and regional cerebral blood flow
in somatization disorder.47:
190196.
18.
KATON, W. and RUSSO, J.
(1992). Chronic fatigue syndrome criteria. A critique of the
requirement for multiple physical complaints. Arch. Int.
Med.152:
16041609.
19.
LEZAK, M.D. (1983).
Neuropsychological Assessment. Oxford University
Press, New York.
20.
MATEER, C.A., SOHLBERG, M.M., and
CRINEAN,
J. (1987). Focus on clinical
research: perceptions of memory function in individuals with closed-head
injury. J. Head Trauma Rehab.2:
7484.
21.
MEYERINK, L.H., REITAN, R.M., and
SELZ,
M. (1988). The validity of the
MMPI with multiple sclerosis patients. J. Clin.
Psychol.44:
764769.
22.
National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health (NIOSH) (1987). Current Intelligence Bulletin 48: Organic solvent neurotoxicity.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease
Control.
23.
REA, W.J. (1992).
Chemical Sensitivity. Lewis
Publishers, Boca Raton,
Florida.
24.
ROBINS, L.N. and HELZER, J.E.
(1985). Diagnostic Interview Schedule (DIS) Version
III-A.Washington University School of
Medicine.St. Louis, MO.
25.
RYAN, C.M., MORROW, L.A., and
HODGSON,
M. (1988). Cacosmia and
neurobehavioral dysfunction associated with occupational exposure to mixtures of organic
solvents. Am. J. Psychiat.145:
14421445.
26.
SCHLUEDERBERG, A., STRAUS, S.,
PETERSON,
P., BLUMENTHAL, S., KOMAROF F, A.L.,
SPRING,
S.B., LANDAY, A., and BUCKWALD, D.
(1992). Chronic fatigue syndrome research: definition and
medical outcome assessment. Ann. Int.
Med.117:
325331.
27.
SCHOTTENFELD, R.S. and CULLEN, M.R.
(1986). Recognition of occupationinduced posttraumatic
stress disorders. J. Occup. Med.28:
365369.
28.
SIMON, G.E., KATON, W., and
SPARKS,
P.J. (1990). Allergic to life:
psychological factors in environmental illness. Am. J.
Psychiat.147:
901906.
29.
SIMON, G.E., DANIELL, W.,
STOCKBRIDGE,
H., CLAYPOOLE, K., and ROSENSTOCK, L.
(1993). Immunologic, psychological, and neuropsychological
factors in multiple chemical sensitivity: A controlled study.
Ann. Int. Med.19:
97103.
30.
SPITZER, R.L., WILLIAMS, J.B.W.,
GIBBON,
M., and FIRST, M.B. (1990).
User's Guide for the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R.
American Psychiatric Press, Washington,
D.C.
31.
STEWART, D.E. and RASKIN, J
(1985). Psychiatric assessment of patients with 20th century
disease (Total Allergy Syndrome). Can. Med. Assoc.
J.133:
10011006.
32.
TAYLOR, G.J., BAGBY, R.M.,
RYAN,
D.P., PARKER, J.D.A., DOODY, K.F., and
KEEFE,
P. (1988). Criterion validity
of the Toronto alexithymia scale. Psychosom.
Med.50: 500509.
