Permissible Concentrations of Chemicals in Air and Water Derived From Rtecs Entries: a "Rash" Chemical Scoring System

Abstract

Many chemicals are of concern to human health, but only a few have epidemiologically derived risk estimates. About 45,000 chemicals are listed in RTECS, most of which have had some testing in subhuman models. RTECS entries range from cellular effects through organoleptic damage to lethality, with many pathological endpoints listed, including mutagenic changes, irritation, teratogenesis, cancer, mortality, etc. However, it is difficult to extend any biological test results to human risk assessments. If the results are extended, the degree of validity is highly uncertain.

This paper describes a logical basis for using the entire complex spectrum of test results to evaluate the overall toxicological potency of a chemical to be assayed (i.e., an interviewing chemical) and describes how to derive tentative, permissible concentrations in air and water for any particular chemical for which no regulatory guidance exists. This approach has been tested for 16 reference chemicals discussed in NIOSH Criteria Documents, EPA-CAG reports, etc. The evaluations are uncomplicated, but occasionally it is difficult to match RTECS entries for two different chemicals. Difficult comparisons may require some familiarity with experimental design and the toxicological literature.

One important product of this novel approach is that a distribution or array of potency values is obtained for any chemical evaluated. This distribution reflects many uncertainties stemming from low statistical power, experimental design, pharmacological processes, interspecies variability, dose rate, biological effect monitored, route of treatment, etc. The array of relative values for a particular chemical reflects many different biological and physical conditions. The distribution of the array helps to index a composite toxicological profile for many different biological effects resulting from numerous treatment protocols.

To minimize the effect of extreme sensitivity of certain (perhaps novel) biological test models, possible errors in the RTECS database, and possible human pharmacological insensitivity to a particular chemical and/or a particular route of administration, we consider the interquartile range (i.e., the central 50%) of the array of relative potency values between two chemicals being compared as a practical measure of uncertainty. Thus, the range in response derived from variability in relative potency should be useful in addressing the range of response in man as estimated from extrapolations of test data.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acgih. (1980). Documentation of the Threshold Limit Values, 4th Edition. P.O. Box 1937, Cincinnati, Ohio.

Acgih. (1980). Threshold Limit Values for Chemical Substances and Physical Agents in the Workroom Environment with Intended Changesfor 1980. P.O. Box 1937, Cincinnati, Ohio.

Albert, R.E. , Lewtas, J. , Nesnow, S. , Thorslund, T.W. , and Anderson, E. (1983). Comparative potency method for cancer risk assessment: Application to diesel particulate emissions. Risk Analysis 3:101-117.

Albert, R.E. , Train, R.E. , and Anderson, E. (1977). Rationale developed by the Environmental Protection Agency for the assessment of carcinogenic risks. J. Natl. Cancer Inst. 58:1537-1541.

Ames, B.N. (1979). Identifying environmental chemicals causing mutations and cancer. Science 204:587-593.

Amlocher, E. , Danz, M. , Stiller, K.J. , and Rudolph, C.L. (1977). Persistent action of low dose of carcinogens on DNA-synthesis in comparison with protein synthesis in the regenerating rat liver. Experimental Pathology Board 14:227-231.

Anderson, E.L. and Cpa-Cag ( 1983). Quantitative approaches in use to assess cancer risk . Risk Analysis 3:277-295.

Argyris, T.S. , and Slaga, T.J. (1981). Promotion of carcinomas by repeated abrasion in initiated skin of mice. Cancer Research 41:5193-5195.

Ashurst, S.W. , Cohen, G.M. , Nesnow, S. , D, J. , and Slaga, T.J. (1983). Formation of benzo(a)pyrene/ DNA adducts and their relationship to tumor initiation in mouse epidermis. Cancer Research 43:1024-1029.

10.

Bender, M.A. (1980). Cytogenetic bases for risk inference. In: Measurement of Risks ( G.G. Berg and H.D. Maillie , Eds.). Plenum Press, New York.

11.

Bridges, B.A. (1980). An approach to the assessment of the risk to man from DNA damaging agents. In: Quantitative Aspect of Risk Assessment in Chemical Carcinogenesis, Arch. Toxicol. Suppli. 3:271-281.

12.

Brooks, P. , and Lawley, P.D. (1964). Evidence for the binding of polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons to the nucleic acids of mouse skin: Relation between carcinogenic power of hydrocarbons and their binding to deoxyribonucleic acid. Nature 4934:781-784.

13.

Carver, J.H. , Hatch, F.T. , and Branscomb, E.W. (1979). Estimating maximum limits to mutagenic potency from cytotoxic potency. Nature 279:154-156.

14.

Clayton, G.D. , and Clayton, F.E. , Editors. (1981). Patty's Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology, Third Revised Edition. John Wiley & Sons, New York.

15.

Cohen, S.M. , Murasaki, G. , Fukushima, S. , and Greenfield, R.E. (1982). Effect of regenerative hyperplasia on the urinary bladder. Cancer Research 42:65-71.

16.

Dudney, C.S. , Walsh, P.J. , Jones, T.D. , Calle, E.E. , and Griffin, G.D. (1983). On the use of relative toxicity for risk estimation . In: Proceedings of Conference on Short-term Biossays in the Analysis of Complex Environmental Mixtures III ( Waters, Sandhu, Lewtas, Claxton , Chernoff, and Nesnow, Eds.) pp. 499-513. Plenum Publishing Corp., New York.

17.

Evans, M.J. , Dekker, N.P. , Cabral-Anderson, L.J. , and Freeman, G. (1978). Quantification of damage to the alveolar epithelium by means of type 2 cell proliferation. Am. Rev. of Respir. Disease 118:787-790.

18.

Farber, E. (1973). Hyperplastic liver nodule. Methods in Cancer Research 7:345-375.

19.

Gori, G.B. (1980). The regulation of carcinogenic hazards. Science 208:256-261.

20.

Greenfield, R.W. , Ellwein, L.B. , and Cohen, S.M. (1984). A general probabilistic model of carcinogenesis: Analysis of experimental urinary bladder cancer. Carcinogenesis 5:437-445.

21.

Heddle, J.A. , and Athanasiou, K. (1975). Mutation rate, genome size, and their relation to the rec concept. Nature 258:358-361.

22.

Interdisciplinary Panel On Carcinogenicity. ( 1984). Criteria for evidence of chemical carcinogenicity. Science 225:683-687.

23.

Iarc. (1979-1983). IARC Monographs on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risk of Chemicals to Man . World Health Organization Publication, Geneva, Switzerland.

24.

Jones, T.D. (1984). A unifying concept for carcinogenic risk assessments: Comparison with radiation-induced leukemia in mice and men. Health Physics 47:533-558.

25.

Jones, T.D. , Dudney, C.S. , and Walsh, P.J. (1984b). A unifying concept for carcinogenic risk assessments: Comparison with tumors in the ED01 study of 2-acetylaminofluorene, in review for journal publication.

26.

Jones, T.D. , Griffin, G.D. , and Walsh, P.J. (1983). A unifying concept for carcinogenic risk assessments . J. Theor. Biol. 105:35-61.

27.

Jones, T.D. , and Walsh, P.J. (1985). Animal studies and prediction of human tumors can be aided by graphical sorting of animal data: Neoplastic risk from B(a)P, benzene, benzidine, and chromium. Am. J. of Industrial Medicine 7:185-217.

28.

Kingsbury, G.L. and Chessin, R.L. (1983). Monitoring Trigger Levels for Process Characterization Studies. U.S. EPA, Research Triangle Park, work in progress.

29.

Kingsbury, G.L. , Sims, R.C. , and White, J.B. (1979). Multimedia Environmental Goals for Environmental Assessment, Vols. 3,4, MEG Charts and Background Information Summaries (Categories 1-26), EPA-600/7-79-176a,b. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.

30.

Lewis, R.J., SR. , and Tatken, R.L. (1980). Registry of Toxic Effects of Chemical Substances . U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, February 1982.

31.

McMillin, C.R. , Mote, L.B. and DeAngelis, D.G. (1980). Potential Atmospheric Carcinogens, Phase I. Identification and Classification. EPA-600/2-80-015, U.S. EPA, Washington, D.C.

32.

Meselson, M. , and Russell, K. (1977). Comparisons of carcinogenic and mutagenic potency . In: Origins of Human Cancer, pp. 1473-1481, Cold Spring Harbor.

33.

Nci. (1961-1973). Survey of Compounds which Have Been Tested for Carcinogenic Activity, prepared by Tracor Jitco, Inc., for NCI, Public Health Service Publication No. 149, U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, 7 volumes.

34.

Nrc. (1984). Toxicity Testing: Strategies to Determine Needs and Priorities. Steering Committee on Identification of Toxic and Potentially Toxic Chemicals for Consideration by the National Toxicology Program, National Academy Press , Washington, D.C.

35.

Oecd. (1980). Chairman's Report on the First Working Party Meeting. F. Schmidt-Bleek, Chemical Group and Step Systems Group Working Party on Exposure Analysis. October 13-15, 1980, Expo.-80.121D (working draft).

36.

Office Of Science And Technology Policy. ( 1984). Chemical Carcinogens; Review of the Science and Its Associated Principles. Federal Register 49:21594-21661.

37.

Rajewsky, M.F. (1972). Proliferative parameters of mammalian cell systems and their role in tumor growth and carcinogenesis. Zekrebsforsch 78:12-30.

38.

Saffiotti, U. (1980). Identification, classification and regulation of potential occupational carcinogens. Occupational Safety and Health Administration , Federal Register 45(15).

39.

Sax, N.I. (1979). Dangerous Properties of Industrial Materials, 5th Edition. Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York.

40.

Shami, S.G. , Thibodeau, L.A. , Kennedy, A.R. , and Little, J.B. (1982). Proliferative and morphological changes in the pulmonary epithelium of the syrian golden hamster during carcinogenesis initiated by 210Po γ-radiation. Cancer Research 42:1405-1411.

41.

Sittig, M. , Editor. (1980). Priority Toxic Pollutants: Health Impacts and Allowable Limits. Noyes Data Corp., Park Ridge, New Jersey.

42.

Synthetic Fuels Corporation. (1983). Final environmental monitoring plan guidelines. Federal Register 49:46676-46685.

43.

U.S. Department Of Health And Human Services. ( 1981). National Toxicology Program Chemical Registry Handbook . Produced by the Specialized Services Division of the National Library of Medicine, PB82-142977.

44.

Walsh, P.J. , Jones, T.D. , Griffin, G.D. , Dudney, C.S. , Calle, E.E. , and Easterly, C.E. (1982). Risk assessment approaches: General definitions, limitations, and research needs. J. Environ. Sci. Health A17:541-552.

45.

Ying, T.J. , Sarms, D.S.R. , and Farber, E. (1981). Role of acute hepatic necrosis in the induction of early steps in liver carcinogenesis by diethyl-nitrosamine. Cancer Research 41:2096-2102.