This paper briefly discusses criteria for evaluating epidemiologic studies for risk assessment purposes, using asbestos as an example. Asbestos is one of the few carcinogens for which substantial data exist on exposures to humans. However, there are major difficulties in using these data for conducting risk assessments. In particular, exposure data are often incomplete, and risk assessments usually involve extrapolating from the higher exposures of the occupational environments to the lower levels typically encountered in the nonoccupational environment. The term "asbestos" refers to the fibrous form of several minerals, and levels of exposures to these fibers are not easily assessed. Criteria for evaluating epidemiologic studies used in an Ontario Royal Commission report on asbestos are discussed. The importance of considering the statistical power of studies to detect an excess risk is examined using as examples major cohort studies of asbestos-exposed workers, as summarized in a report by the U. S. National Research Council.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Acheson, E.D., Gardner, M.J., Pippard, E.C., and Grime, L.P. (1982). Mortality of two groups of women who manufactured gas masks from chrysotile and crocidolite asbestos: A 40-year followup. Br. J. Ind. Med.39:344-348.
2.
Beaumont, J., and Breslow, N. (1981). Power considerations in epidemiologic studies of vinyl chloride workers. Am. J. of Epidemiol.5:725-734.
3.
Berry, G., and Newhouse, M.L. (1983). Mortality of workers manufacturing friction materials using asbestos. Brit. J. Ind. Med.40:1-7.
4.
Clemmesen, J., and Hjalgrim-Jensen, S. (1981). Cancer incidence among 5686 asbestos-cement workers followed from 1943 through 1976. Ecotox. Environ. Safety5:15-23.
5.
Cpsc. (1983). Report by the Chronic Hazard Advisory Panel on Asbestos. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Washington, D.C.
6.
Dement, J.M., Harris, R.L., Symons, M.J., and Shy, C.M. (1983). Exposures and mortality among chrysotile asbestos workers: Part II. Mortality. Am. J. Ind. Med.4:421-434.
7.
Dement, J.M., Harris, R.L., Symons, M.J., and Shy, C.M. (1982). Estimates of dose-response for respiratory cancer among chrysotile asbestos textile workers. Annals Occup. Hyg.26:869-887.
8.
Elmes, P.C., and Simpson, M. (1977). Insulation workers in Belfast. A further study of mortality due to asbestos exposure (1940-75). Br. J. Ind. Med.34:174-180.
9.
Enterline, P.E., Decoufle, P., and Henderson, V.L. (1973). Respiratory cancer in relation to occupational exposures among retired asbestos workers. Brit. J. Ind. Med.30:162-166.
10.
Finkelstein, M.M. (1983). Mortality among employees of an Ontario asbestos-cement factory. Brit. J. Ind. Med.40:138-144.
11.
Henderson, V., and Enterline, P.E. (1979). Asbestos exposure: Factors associated with excess cancer and respiratory mortality. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.330:117-126.
12.
Hobbs, M.S.T., Woodward, S.D., Murphy, B., Musk, A.W., and Elder, J.E. (1980). The incidence of pneumoconiosis, mesothelioma and other respiratory cancer in men engaged in mining and milling crocidolite in Western Australia. In: Biological Effects of Mineral Fibres (J.C. Wagner, Ed.) pp. 615-625, IARC Scientific Pub. No. 30, Lyon, France.
13.
Hughes, J., and Weill, H. (1980). Lung cancer risk associated with manufacture of asbestos-cement product. In: Biological Effects of Mineral Fibres (J.C. Wagner, Ed.) Vol. 2, pp. 627-635, IARC Scientific Pub. No. 30, Lyon, France.
14.
Jones, J.S.P., Pooley, F.D., Sawle, G.W., Madeley, R.J., Smith, P.G., Berry, G., Wignall, B.K., and Aggarwal, A. (1980). The consequences of exposure to asbestos dust in a wartime gas-mask factory. In: Biological Effects of Mineral Fibres (J.C. Wagner, Ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 637-653, IARC Scientific Pub. No. 30, Lyon, France.
15.
Karstadt, M., Bobal, R., and Selikoff, I.J. (1981). A survey of availability of epidemiologic data on humans exposed to animal carcinogens. In: Quantification of Occupational Cancer (R. Peto and M. Schneiderman, Eds), pp. 223-246, Banbury Report 9, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, New York.
16.
McDonald, J.C., Liddel, F.D.K., Gibbs, G.W., Eyssen, G.E., and McDonald, A.D. (1980). Dust exposure and mortality in chrysotile mining, 1910-1975. Brit. J. Ind. Med.37:11-24.
17.
McDonald, J.C., and McDonald, A.D. (1981). Mesothelioma as an index of asbestos impact. In: Quantification of Occupational Cancer ( R. Peto and M. Schneiderman, Eds.), pp. 73-85, Banbury Report 9, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, New York.
18.
McDonald, J.C., McDonald, A.D., Graham, M.D., Gibbs, W., Siemiatycki, J., and Rossiter, C.F. (1971). Respiratory cancer in relation to occupational exposures among retired asbestos workers. Arch. of Environ. Health22:677-686.
19.
Marsh, G.M. (1983). Review of epidemiologic studies related to ingested asbestos. Environ. Health Perspect.53:49-56.
20.
Meurman, L.O., Kiviluoto, R., and Hakaman, M. (1979). Combined effects of asbestos exposure and tobacco smoking on Finnish anthophyllite miners and millers. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.330:491-495.
21.
Nrc Committee On Nonoccupational Health Risks Of Asbestiform Fibers. (1984). Asbestiform Fibers: Nonoccupational Health Risks. National Academy Press, Washington, D.C.
22.
Newhouse, M.L., Berry, G., and Skidmore, J.W. (1982). A mortality study of workers manufacturing friction materials with chrysotile asbestos. Ann. Occup. Hyg.26:899-909.
23.
Newhouse, M.L., and Berry, G. (1979). Patterns of mortality in asbestos factory workers in London. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.330:53-60.
24.
Nicholson, W.J., Selikoff, I.J., Seidman, H., Lilis, R., and Formby, P. (1979). Long-term mortality experience of chrysotile miners and millers in Thetford mines, Quebec. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.330:11-21.
25.
Peto, J. (1980). Lung cancer mortality in relation to measured dust levels in an asbestos textile factory. In: Biological Effects of Mineral Fibres (J.C. Wagner, Ed.) Vol. 2, pp. 829-836. IARC Scientific Publications, No. 30, Lyon, France.
26.
Peto, J., Doll, R., Howard, S.V., Kinlen, L.J., and Lewinsohn, H.C. (1977). A mortality study among workers in an English asbestos factory. Brit. J. Indus. Med.34:169-173.
27.
Puntoni, R., Vercelli, M., Merlo, F., Valerio, F., and Santi, L. (1979). Mortality among shipyard workers in Genoa, Italy . Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.330:353-377.
28.
Rossiter, C.G., and Coles, R.M. (1980). H.M. Dockyard, Devonport: 1947 mortality study . In: Biological Effects of Mineral Fibres (J.C. Wagner, Ed.), pp. 713-721, IARC Scientific Pub. No. 30, Lyon, France.
29.
Royal Commission On Matters Of Health And Safety Arising From The Use Of Asbestos In Ontario. (1984). Report to the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General. Three volumes. J. Stephan Dupre, Chairman, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
30.
Rubino, G.F., Piolatto, G., Newhouse, M.L., Scansetti, G., Aresini, G.A., and Murray, R. (1979). Mortality of chrysotile asbestos workers at the Balanero mine, northern Italy. Br. J. Ind. Med.36:187-194.
31.
Schlesselman, J.J. (1982). Case-control Studies: Design, Conduct, Analysis . Oxford University Press, New York .
32.
Schneiderman, M.A., Nisbet, I.C., and Brett, S.M. (1981). Assessment of Risks Posed by Exposure to Low Levels of Asbestos in the General Environment. Prepared for Institut fur Wasser-, Boden-, und Lufthygiene des Bundesgesundheitsamtes, No. 4, DietrickReimer Verlag, Berlin.
33.
Seidman, H., Selikoff, I.J., and Hammond, E.C., (1979). Short-term asbestos work exposure and long-term observation. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.330:61-89.
34.
Selikoff, I.J., Hammond, E.C., and Seidman, H. (1979). Mortality experience of insulation workers in the U.S. and Canada, 1943-1976. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.330:91-116.
