In this article, the authors consider the economic consequences of State Oil v. Khan (1997) for franchising. After discussing the evolution of antitrust policy regarding maximum resale prices, they examine the economics behind franchisors’ desire to impose price ceilings on franchisees. The authors show that the most likely explanations for this practice imply that maximum resale prices enhance consumer welfare.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Acquaire v. Canada Dry Bottling Company of New-York (1994), 24 F.3d 401 (2d Cir.).
2.
Albrecht v. Herald Company (1968), 390 U.S. 145.
3.
AreedaP., and HovenkampH. (1993), Antitrust Law(Supp.). Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
4.
Atlantic Richfield Co. v. USA Petroleum Co. (1990), 495 U.S. 328.
5.
BarronJohn M., and UmbeckJohn R., (1984), “The Effects of Different Contractual Arrangements: The Case of Retail Gasoline,”Journal of Law and Economics, 27 (2), 313–28.
6.
BlairRoger D., and EsquibelAmanda K. (1996), “Maximum Resale Price Restraints in Franchising,”Antitrust Law Journal, 65 (Fall), 157–80.
7.
BlairRoger D., and FesmireJ.M. (1986), “Maximum Price Fixing and the Goals of Antitrust,”Syracuse Law Review, 37, 43–77.
8.
BlairRoger D., and KasermanDavid L. (1981), “The Albrecht Rule and Consumer Welfare: An Economic Analysis,”University of Florida Law Review, 33 (Summer), 461–84.
9.
BlairRoger D., and KasermanDavid L. (1983), Law and Economics of Vertical Integration and Control.Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
10.
BlairRoger D., and KasermanDavid L. (1985), Antitrust Economics.Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
11.
BlairRoger D., and KasermanDavid L. (1994), “A Note on Incentive Incompatibility under Franchising,”Review of Industrial Organization, 9 (3), 323–30.
12.
Business Electronics Corp. v. Sharp Electronics Corp. (1988), 485 U.S. 717.
13.
Caribe BMW Inc. v. Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft (1994), 19F.3d 745 (1st Cir.).
14.
CoughlanAnne (1985), “Competition and Cooperation in Marketing Channel Choice: Theory and Application,”Marketing Science, 4 (2), 110–29.
Dr. Miles Medical Co. v. John D. Park & Sons Co. (1911), 220 U.S. 373.
17.
EasterbrookFrank H. (1981), “Maximum Price Fixing,”University of Chicago Law Review, 48 (Fall), 886–910.
18.
GraddyKathryn (1997), “Do Fast-Food Chains Price Discriminate on the Race and Income Characteristics of an Area?”Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 15 (4), 391–401.
19.
GreenhutMel vin L., and OhtaHiroshi (1979), “Vertical Integration of Successive Oligopolies,”American Economic Review, 69 (1), 137–41.
20.
GrewalDhruv, and CompeauLarry D. (1992), “Comparative Price Advertising: Informative or Deceptive?”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 11 (Spring), 52–62.
21.
HadfieldGillian K. (1990), “Problematic Relations: Franchising and the Law of Incomplete Contracts,”Stanford Law Review, 42 (April), 927–92.
22.
HuntShelby D., and NevinJohn R. (1975), “Tying Agreements in Franchising,”Journal of Marketing, 39 (July), 20–26.
23.
Jack Walters & Sons Corp. v. Morton Building Inc. (1984), 737 F.2d 698, 706–07, (7th Cir.).
24.
JeulandAbel P., and ShuganSteven M. (1983), “Managing Channel Profits,”Marketing Science, 2 (3), 239–72.
25.
Kiefer-Stewart Co. v. Joseph E. Seagram & Sons (1951), 340 U.S. 211.
KleinBenjamin, and SaftLester F. (1985), “The Law and Economics of Franchise Tying Contracts,”Journal of Law and Economics, 28 (2), 345–61.
28.
LafontaineFrancine (1993), “Contractual Arrangements as Signaling Devices: Evidence from Franchising,”Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization, 9 (2), 256–89.
29.
LafontaineFrancine (1995), “Pricing Decisions in Franchised Chains: A Look at the Fast-Food Industry,”Working Paper #5247, National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER).
30.
LafontaineFrancine (1999), “Franchising vs. Corporate Ownership: the Effect on Price Dispersion,”The Journal of Business Venturing, 14 (1), 17–34.
31.
LafontaineFrancine, and SladeMargaret E. (1997), “Retail Contracting: Theory and Practice,”Journal of Industrial Economics, 45 (1), 1–25.
32.
MachlupFritz, and TaberM. (1960), “Bilateral Monopoly, Successive Monopoly, and Vertical Integration,”Economica, 27 (May), 101.
33.
McGuireTimothy W., and StaelinRichard (1983), “An Industry Equilibrium Analysis of Downstream Vertical Integration,”Marketing Science, 2 (Spring), 161–92.
34.
Monsanto Co. v. Spray-Rite Service Corp. (1984), 465 U.S. 752.
35.
MurisThomas J., ScheffmanDavid T., and SpilllerPablo T. (1992), “Strategy and Transaction Costs: The Organization of Distribution in the Carbonated Soft Drink Industry,”Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 1 (1), 83–128.
36.
NagleThomas T., and HoldenReed K. (1995), The Strategy and Tactics of Pricing, 2d ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
37.
OzanneUrban B., and HuntShelby D. (1971), The Economic Effect of Franchising.Washington, DC: U.S. Senate Select Committee on Small Business, Government Printing Office.
38.
SchmidtTorsten (1994), “An Analysis of Intrabrand Competition in the Franchise Industry,”Review of Industrial Organization, 9 (3), 293–310.
39.
SheffetMary J., and ScammonDebra L. (1985), “Resale Price Maintenance: Is It Safe to Suggest Retail Prices?”Journal of Marketing, 49 (Fall), 82–91.
40.
ShepardAndrea (1993), “Contractual Form, Retail Price, and Asset Characteristics,”RAND Journal of Economics, 24 (1), 58–77.
41.
SladeMargaret E. (1998), “Beer and the Tie: Did Divestiture of Brewer-Owned Public Houses Lead to Higher Beer Prices?”Economic Journal, 108 (May), 1–38.
42.
Slowiak v. Land O'Lakes Inc. (1993), 987 F.2d 1293 (7th Cir.).
43.
SpenglerJoseph J. (1950), “Vertical Integration and Antitrust Policy,”Journal of Political Economy, 58 (July/August), 347–52.
44.
StassenRobert, and MittelstaedtRobert A. (1991), “A Successive Monopolies Examination of Conflict in Franchise Channels,” in 5th Annual Proceedings of the Society of Franchising, NevinJohn, ed. St. Paul, MN: University of St. Thomas.
45.
State Oil Co. v. Khan (1997), 118 S. Ct. 275.
46.
SternLouis W., and EovaldiT.L. (1984), Legal Aspects of Marketing Strategy: Antitrust and Consumer Protection Issues.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
47.
U.S. Department of Commerce (1988), Franchising in the Economy, 1986–88.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
48.
United States v. Colgate & Co. (1919), 250 U.S. 300.
49.
United States v. Socony-Vacuum Oil Co. (1940), 310 U.S. 150.
50.
USA Petroleum Co. v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (1994), 13 F.3d 1276 (9th Cir.).
51.
Warren-BoultonFrederick R. (1978), Vertical Control of Markets: Business and Labor Practices.Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Co.
