In a meta-analysis of warnings literature, the authors examine empirical studies containing no-warning control groups to address the question of whether the presence of on-product warnings increases the safe behavior of product users. The major findings of the study are that (1) warnings increase safe behavior and (2) this increase is found for both nonstudent and student subjects.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alcohol Beverage Labeling Act of 1988 (1988), Public Law 100,690, 27 U.S.C. §201–211 (November 18).
2.
AyresT. J., GrossM. M., HorstD. P., and RobinsonJ. N. (1992), “A Methodological Taxonomy for Warning Research,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 36th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 499–503.
3.
BarnettR. L., and SwitalskiW. G. (1988), “Principles of Safety Behavior,”Safety Brief, 5 (February), 1–15.
4.
CookT. D., and CampbellD. T. (1979), Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings.Chicago: Rand McNally.
5.
CoxE. P., HoyerW. D.III, and KrshnaK. (1995), “The Behavioral Effectiveness of On-Product Warnings in Low Hazard Conditions,” in Marketing and Public Policy Conference Proceedings, EllenPam Scholder, and KaufmanPatrick J., eds. Atlanta: Georgia State University, 1–10.
6.
DeJoyD. (1989), “Consumer Product Warnings: Review and Analysis of Effectiveness Research,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 31st Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 936–40.
7.
DingusT. A., HunnB. P., and WreggitS. S. (1991), “Two Reasons for Providing Protective Equipment as Part of Hazardous Consumer Product Packaging,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 35th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 1039–42.
8.
DingusT. A., WregittS. S., and HathawayJ. A. (1993), “Warning Variables Affecting Personal Protective Equipment Use,”Safety Science, 16, 655–73.
9.
DorrisA. L., and PurswellJ. L. (1977), “Warnings and Human Behavior: Implications for the Design of Product Warnings,”Journal of Products Liability, 1, 255–64.
10.
DuffyR. R. (1993), “The Effectiveness of an Interactive Warning Label: An Examination of Warning Effectiveness, Task Load and Hazard Perception,” unpublished master's thesis, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute.
11.
DuffyR. R., KalsherM. J., and WogalterM. S. (1993), “The Effectiveness of an Interactive Warning in a Realistic Product-Use Situation,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 37th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 935–39.
12.
EdworthyJ., StantonN., and HellierE. (1995), “Editorial: Warnings in Research and Practice,”Ergonomics, 38 (November), 2145–54.
13.
FarleyJ. U., and LehmannD. R. (1986), Meta-Analysis in Marketing: Generalization of Response Models.Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
14.
FrantzJ. P., and RhoadesT. P. (1993), “A Task-Analytic Approach to the Temporal and Spatial Placement of Product Warnings,”Human Factors, 35 (4), 719–30.
15.
FriedmannK. (1988), “The Effects of Adding Symbols to Written Labels on User Behavior and Recall,”Human Factors, 30 (August), 507–15.
16.
GomerF. E. (1986), “Evaluating the Effectiveness of Warnings Under Prevailing Working Conditions,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 30th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica CA: The Human Factors Society, 712–15.
17.
HaddonS. G. (1986), Read the Label: Reducing the Risk by Providing Information.Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
18.
HardieW. H. (1994), “Critical Analysis of On-Product Warning Theory,”Product Safety & Liability Reporter, 22 (February 2), 145–63.
19.
HatemA. T. (1993), “The Effect of Performance Level on Warning Compliance,” unpublished master's thesis, Purdue University.
20.
HatemA. T., and LehtoL. (1995), “Effectiveness of Glue Odour as a Warning Signal,”Ergonomics, 38 (November), 2250–61.
21.
HedgesL. V., and OlkinI. (1985), Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis.New York: Academic Press.
22.
HendersonJ. A.Jr., and TwerskyA. D. (1990), “Doctrinal Collapse in Products Liability: The Empty Shell of Failure to Warn,”New York University Law Review, 6 (May), 265–327.
23.
HorstD. P., McCarthyG. E., RobinsonJ. N., McCarthyR. L., and Krumm-ScottS. (1986), “Safety Information Presentation: Factors Influencing the Potential for Changing Behavior,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 30th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica CA: The Human Factors Society, 111–15.
24.
HunnB. P., and DingusT. A. (1992), “Interactivity, Information, and Compliance Cost in a Consumer Product Warning Scenario,”Accident Analysis and Prevention, 24 (5), 497–505.
25.
HunterJ. E., and SchmidtF. L. (1990), Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings.Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
26.
LehtoM. R., and FoleyJ. P. (1989), “The Influence of Regulation, Training and Product Information on Use of Helmets by ATV Operators: A Field Study,” in Proceedings of INTERFACE ‘89—The Sixth Symposium on Human Factors and Industrial Design in Consumer Products.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 107–13.
27.
LehtoM. R., and FoleyJ. P. (1991), “Risk-Taking, Warning Labels, Training, and Regulation: Are They Associated with the Use of Helmets by All-Terrain Vehicle Riders?”Journal of Safety Research, 22 (Winter), 191–200.
28.
LehtoM. R., and MillerJ. M. (1988), “The Effectiveness of Warning Labels,”Journal of Products Liability, 11 (3), 225–65.
29.
McCarthyG. E., HorstD. B., BeyerR. R., RobinsonJ. N., and McCarthyR. L. (1987), “Measured Impact of a Mandated Warning on User Behavior,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 31st Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 479–83.
30.
McCarthyR. L., AyresT. J., and WoodC. T. (1995), “Risk and Effectiveness Criteria for Using On-Product Warnings,”Ergonomics, 38 (November), 2164–75.
31.
McCarthyR. L., FinneganJ. P., Scott-CrumS., and McCarthyG. E. (1984), “Product Information Presentation, User Behavior and Safety,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 28th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 81–85.
32.
MillerJ. M., LehtoM. H., and FrantzJ. P. (1994), Instructions and Warnings: The Annotated Bibliography.Ann Arbor, MI: Fuller Technical Publications.
33.
OtsuboS. M. (1988a), “Effectiveness of Warning Signs on Consumer Products,” unpublished master's thesis, California State University, Northridge.
34.
OtsuboS. M. (1988b), “A Behavioral Study of Warning Labels for Consumer Products: Perceived Danger and Use of Pictographs,” in Proceedings of the Human Factor Society 32nd Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 536–40.
35.
SchneiderK. C. (1977a), “An Experimental Evaluation of Relationships Between Product Package and Label Characteristics and Preschool Childrens’ Awareness of and Behavior Toward Package Contents: A Study in Prevention of Childhood Poisoning,” unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Minnesota.
36.
SchneiderK. C. (1977b), “Prevention of Accidental Poisoning Through Package and Label Design,”Journal of Consumer Research, 4 (September), 67–74.
37.
StrawbridgeJ. A. (1986a), “The Influence of Position, Highlighting and Imbedding on Warning Effectiveness,” unpublished master's thesis, California State University, Northridge.
38.
StrawbridgeJ. A. (1986b), “The Influence of Position, Highlighting, and Imbedding on Warning Effectiveness,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 30th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: The Human Factors Society, 716–20.
39.
StewartD. W., and MartinI. M. (1994), “Intended and Unintended Consequences of Warning Messages: A Review and Synthesis of Empirical Research,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 13 (Spring), 1–19.
40.
ThyerB. A., and GellerE. S. (1987), “The ‘Buckle-Up’ Dashboard Sticker: An Effective Environmental Intervention for Safety Belt Promotion,”Environment and Behavior, 19 (July), 484–94.
41.
VenemaA. (1989), “Product Information for the Prevention of Accidents in the Home and During Leisure Activities,” Research Report No. 69, Institute for Consumer Research, SWOKA, The Netherlands.
42.
WilkieW. L. (1982), “Affirmative Disclosure: Perspectives on FTC Orders,”Journal of Marketing and Public Policy, 1, 95–110.
43.
WilkieW. L. (1983), “Affirmative Disclosure at the FTC: Theoretical Framework and Typology of Case Selection,”Journal of Marketing and Public Policy, 2, 3–15.
44.
WogalterM. S., BarlowT., and MurphyS. A. (1994), “Compliance to Owner's Manual Warnings: The Influence of Familiarity and Placement of a Supplemental Directive,”Ergonomics, 38 (June), 1081–91.
45.
WogalterM. S., and KalsherM. J. (1994), “Increasing the Correct Connection of Car Battery Jumper Cables with an Enhanced Tag Warning,” in Proceedings of Public Graphics.Lunteren, The Netherlands, (September 26–30).
46.
WolfF. M. (1986), Meta-Analysis: Quantitative Methods for Research Synthesis.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
47.
WreggitS. S. (1991), “The Effects of Cost of Compliance, Information, and Physical Activity on Consumer Product Warning Compliance,” unpublished master's thesis, University of Idaho.
