Geopolitical events have forced many countries in Southeast Asia to transform from centrally planned to market-oriented economies. The authors review the literature and introduce a model to help explain the forces and factors that seem to affect the success of Southeast Asian transition policies. The authors submit that though Southeast Asian gradualism or constrained capitalism continues to produce positive macroeconomic results and consumption opportunities, more expansive reform policies eventually could be required if these transition economies are to continue to prosper and enhance the welfare of their people. They conclude by discussing marketing implications and directions for further research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbelDavid (1996), [Brigadier-General and Minister, Ministry of National Planning and Economic Development] “Keynote Address: An Overview of Myanmar's Economy,” Myanmar Business Roundtable, March 14, Yangon.
2.
KittikhounAlounkeo (1995), [Ambassador to the Permanent Mission of the Lao Peoples Democratic Republic] interview with author, December 3, New York.
ArdreyWilliam J., and ShultzClifford J.II (1996), “Laos: Marketing and Consumer Behavior in the Heart of the Golden Quadrangle,” working paper, Arizona State University West.
5.
Asia 1996 (1995), Hong Kong: Far Eastern Economic Review Publishing Company.
6.
Asian Business (1995), “The Challenge of Change,” January, 20–24.
7.
Asian Development Bank (1993), Lao People's Democratic Republic: Economic Update.Manila: ADB Press.
8.
Asian Development Bank (1994), Cambodia Economic Update.Manila: ADB Press.
9.
Asian Survey (1996), “A Survey of Asia in 1995: Part I,” Vol. 36. Berkeley: University of California Press.
10.
BagozziRichard (1975), “Marketing as Exchange,”Journal of Marketing, 39 (4), 32–39.
11.
BelkRussell W. (1988), “Third World Consumer Culture,” in Marketing and Development: Toward Broader Dimensions, KumcuE., and FiratA.F., eds. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, 103–27.
12.
BelkRussell W., and ZhouNan (1986), “Emerging Consumer Culture in the People's Republic of China,” in The Role of Marketing in Development: Global Consumer and Managerial Issues, KumcuErdogan, FiratA. F., KarafakiogluMehmet, KarabulutMuhittin, and OlucMehment, eds. Muncie, IN: Ball State University Press, 137–45.
13.
BelkRussell W., and ZhouNan (1987), “Learning to Want Things,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 14, WallendorfMelanie, and AndersonPaul, eds. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 478–81.
14.
BergerPeter, and Hsin-HuangMichael Hsiao (1988), In Search of an East Asian Developmental Model.New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.
15.
BlackburnKevin (1994), “Does the West Need to Learn ‘Asian Values'?”IP A Review, 47 (2), 35–36.
16.
BlahoAndras (1994), Russian Transition—Chinese Reforms: A Comparative View, United Nations University. New York: Wider.
17.
BourdetYves (1994), “Laos: The Economic Mechanisms and After?” Mimeograph 52/94, Department of Economics, University of Lund.
18.
BrimblePeter (1994), “From Thailand to the Greater Mekong Subregion: The Challenges for Private Business,” Brooker Group Limited paper presented May 1, Bangkok.
19.
Central Intelligence Agency (1994), The World Fact Book.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
20.
ChandlerDavid P. (1992), A History of Cambodia.Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
21.
ChangMaria Hsia (1995), “Greater China and the Chinese ‘Global Tribe,'”Asian Survey, 35 (October), 955–67.
22.
ChiaHock Hwa, and PecotichA. (1988), “Multinational Management and ASEAN Regional Development,”Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 6 (1), 161–74.
23.
DapiceDavid, and VallelyThomas (1996), “Vietnam's Economy: Will It Get and Stay on the Dragon's Trail?” unpublished research report. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Institute for International Development.
24.
DholakiaNikhilesh, and Fuat FiratA. (1988), “Development in an Era of Globalizing Markets and Cosnsumption Patterns,” in Marketing and Development: Toward Broader Dimensions, KumcuE., and FiratA.F., eds. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, 79–101.
25.
DinhDo Due (1993), “Vietnam's Economic Renovation to the Market Mechanism,”Journal of Asian Business, 9 (Summer), 17–33.
26.
DonerRichard F. (1991), “Approaches to the Politics of Economic Growth in Southeast Asia,”The Journal of Asian Studies, 50 (November), 818–49.
27.
The Economist (1995a), “Cambodia on the Slide,” (December 16), 32.
28.
The Economist (1995b), “The New Light of Myanmar,” (July 15), 23.
29.
The Economist (1995c), “Myanmar's Perilous Future,” (July 22), 33–34.
30.
The Economist (1996), “Myanmar's Mysterious Boom,” (April 6), 35–36.
31.
Economist Intelligence Unit (1994a), Country Profiles: Thailand and Myanmar.London: EIU Ltd.
32.
Economist Intelligence Unit (1994b), Indochina Profiles: Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia.London: EIU Ltd.
33.
Economist Intelligence Unit (1995), Country Report: Laos.London: EIU Ltd.
34.
FfordeAdam (1993), “Vietnamese Commerce: The ‘Tiger on a Bicycle’ Syndrome,”Columbia Journal of World Business, 28 (Winter), 48–55.
35.
ForbesDean (1995), “Towards the ‘Pacific Century’: Integration and Disintegration in the Pacific Basin,” in The Far East and Australasia.London: Europa Publications Ltd, 24–38.
36.
FukushimaGlen S. (1995), “Cold War Contradictions,”Tokyo Business Today, 63, 12, 48.
37.
General Statistics Office (1995), unpublished raw data, Hanoi.
38.
General Statistics Office (1996), Vietnam: The Blazing Flame of Reforms.Hanoi: Statistical Publishing House.
39.
GlassmanR.M. (1991), China in Transition: Communism, Capitalism and Democracy.New York: Praeger.
40.
SweeGoh Keng (1995), Wealth of East Asian Nations.Singapore: Federated Publications.
41.
GoldThomas (1986), State and Society in the Taiwan Miracle.New York: M.E. Sharpe.
42.
GoldmanMarshall (1991), What Went Wrong with Perestroika.New York: W.W. Norton.
43.
GoodenoughWard (1971), Culture, Language and Society.Reading, MA: Addison Wesley.
44.
GoodmanAllan E. (1996), “The Political Consequences of Normalization of U.S.-Vietnam Relations,”Contemporary Southeast Asia, 17 (March), 420–29.
45.
HaggardStephan, and ChengTun-jen (1987), “State and Foreign Capital in the East Asian NICs,” in The Political Economy of the New Asian Industrialism, DeyoFrederic, ed. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
46.
HewisonKevin, RobisonRichard, and RodanGarry (1993), Southeast Asia in the 1990s: Authoritarianism, Capitalism and Democracy.Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
47.
HofstedeGeert (1980), Culture's Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
48.
International Monetary Fund (1994), Economic Reviews, No. 8: Cambodia.Washington, DC: IMF.
49.
JohnsonChalmers (1987), “Political Institutions and Economic Performance: The Government-Business Relationship in Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan,” in The Political Economy of the New Asian Industrialism, DeyoFrederic, ed. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
50.
KammHenry (1995), “In Prosperous Singapore, Even the Elite Are Nervous about Speaking Out,”The New York Times, (August 13), 1, 6.
51.
KapsteinEthan (1996), “Workers and the World Economy,”Foreign Affairs, 74 (May/June), 16–37.
52.
KarnowStanley (1991), Vietnam: A History.New York: Penguin.
KraarLouis (1993), “Importance of Chinese in Asian Business,”Journal of Asian Business, 9 (Winter), 87–94.
59.
KaungKyi May (1995), “Theories, Paradigms, or Models in Burma Studies,”Asian Survey, 35 (November), 1030–41.
60.
Lao Peoples Democratic Republic (1995), “Basic Data and Economic Indicators,” New York, Permanent Mission of LPDR to the United Nations and Vientiane, the Statistical Center of the LPDR.
61.
LasserrePhilippe, and SchütteHellmut (1995), Strategies for Asia Pacific.London: Macmillan.
62.
HungLe Ngoc, and RondinelliDennis (1993), “Small Business Development in Vietnam,”Journal of Asian Business, 9 (Fall), 1–23.
63.
BangLe Van (1995), [Vietnam's ambassador to the US] speech given at Columbia University, April 29, New York.
64.
LegerJohn M. (1995), “Rags to Riches,”Far Eastern Economic Review, (October 5), 46–52.
65.
LizéePierre P. (1996), “Cambodia in 1995,”Asian Survey, 36 (January), 83–88.
66.
LjunggrenBörje (1992), Market Economies Under Communist Regimes: Reform in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia, doctoral dissertation, Southern Illinois University.
67.
LjunggrenBörje (1993), The Challenge of Reform in Indochina.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Institute for International Development.
68.
MacIntyreAndrew (1994), Business and Government in Industrialising Asia.St. Leonards, Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
69.
MarerPaul, and ZecchiniSalvatore (1991), The Transition to a Market Economy, 1.Paris: OECD.
70.
McVeyRuth (1992), “The Materialization of the Southeast Asian Entrepreneur,” in Southeast Asian Capitalists, McVeyRuth, ed. Ithaca, NY: Cornell Southeast Asia Program, 7–33.
71.
MeadeWilliam K., and NasonRobert (1991), “Toward a Unified Theory of Macromarketing: A Systems Theoretic Approach,”Journal of Macromarketing, 11 (Fall), 72–82.
72.
MydansSeth (1996), “Side by Side Now in Cambodia: Skulls, Victims and Victimizers,”The New York Times, (May 27), Al.
73.
NayaSeiji Finch, and TanJoseph L.H. (1995), Asian Transitional Economies.Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
74.
KnienNguyen Duy (1996), [Deputy General Secretary, VCCI] Panel discussion comments, Markets and Marketing Opportunities in Vietnam Conference, Phoenix, AZ (April 19).
75.
OverholtWilliam (1993), The Rise of China.New York: W.W. Norton.
76.
ParrinderGeoffrey (1995), “The Religions of Asia,” in The Far East and Australasia.London: Europa Publications Ltd., 15–24.
77.
PecotichAnthony, and ChiaHock Hwa (1992), “The Role of Multinational Corporation Characteristics and Strategic Actions in the Development of ASEAN Regionalism,”Journal of Global Marketing, 5 (3), 63–87.
78.
PecotichAnthony, RenkoNatasa, and ShultzClifford J.II (1994), “Yugoslav Disintegration, War and Consumption in Croatia,” in Research in Consumer Behavior: Consumption in Marketizing Economies, Vol. 7, ShultzC., BelkR., and GerG., eds. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, 1–27.
79.
PetriPeter (1993), The Lessons of East Asia: Common Foundations of East Asian Success.Washington, DC: World Bank.
80.
PetriPeter (1995), “The Lessons of East Asian Success: A Primer for Transitional Economies,” in Asian Transitional Economies, NayaS.F., and TanJ.L.H., eds. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 26–55.
81.
PikeDouglas (1992), “Vietnam in 1991: The Turning Point,”Asian Survey, 31 (January), 74–81.
82.
PollayRichard, TseDavid, and WangZ. W. (1990), “Advertising, Propaganda and Value Change in Economic Development,”Journal of Business Research,”20 (2), 83–95.
83.
PrassoSheri (1994), “Cambodia: A Heritage of Violence,”World Policy Journal, 11 (Fall), 71–77.
84.
RiggJonathan (1995), “Managing Dependency in a Reforming Economy: The Lao PDR,”Contemporary Southeast Asia, 17 (September), 147–72.
85.
RobisonRichard, and GoodmanDavid S. G. (1996), The New Rich in Asia.London: Routledge.
86.
RondinelliDennis, NellisJohn, and Shabbir CheemaG. (1983), “Decentralization in Developing Countries: A Review of Recent Experience,”World Bank Staff Working Paper No. 581.Washington, DC: World Bank.
87.
RossJames (1994), [Resident Representative, Cambodia International Human Rights Group], speech at the Columbia University School of International and Public Affairs, September 29, New York.
88.
RudermanPeter (1996), “Legal Issues in Vietnam,” Markets and Marketing Opportunities in Vietnam Conference, Phoenix, AZ (April 19).
89.
SakakibaraEisuke (1995), “The End of Progressivism,”Foreign Affairs, 74 (5), 8–14.
90.
SchultzTheodore (1960), “Capital Formation by Education,”Journal of Political Economy, 68 (December), 571–83.
91.
SchwabKlaus, and SmadjaClaude (1994), “Power and Policy: The New Economic World Order,”Harvard Business Review, 72 (November/December), 40–50.
92.
SchwarzAdam (1995), “Let That Be a Warning,”Far Eastern Economic Review, 158 (47), 23.
93.
SemenikRichard, ZhouN., and MooreWilliam (1986), “Chinese Managers’ Attitudes Toward Advertising in China,”Journal of Advertising, 15 (4), 56–62.
94.
ShenonPhilip (1995), “Cambodia Can't Shake The Legacy of Madness,”The New York Times, (March 12), Section 4, 3.
95.
ShultzClifford J.II (1994), “Balancing Policy, Consumer Desire and Corporate Interests: Considerations for Market Entry in Vietnam,”Columbia Journal of World Business, 29 (Winter), 43–52.
96.
ShultzClifford J.II, and ArdreyWilliam (1997), “Asia's Next Tiger? Vietnam is Fraught With Promise and Peril for Marketers,”Marketing Management, 5 (4), 27–37.
97.
ShultzClifford J.II, ArdreyWilliam, and PecotichAnthony (1995), “American Involvement in Vietnam, Part II: Prospects for U.S. Business in a New Era,”Business Horizons, 38 (March/April), 21–28.
98.
ShultzClifford J.II, BelkRussell W., and GerGüliz (1994), Research in Consumer Behavior: Consumption in Marketizing Economies, Vol. 7. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
99.
ShultzClifford J.II, and LeKhai (1993), “Vietnam's Inconsistencies Between Political Structure and Socioeconomic Practice: Implications for the Nation's Future,”Contemporary Southeast Asia, 15 (September), 179–94.
100.
ShultzClifford J.II, LowMurray, and ArdreyWilliam (in press), Enterprise Management in Transition Economies.New York: United Nations.
101.
ShultzClifford J.II, PecotichAnthony, and LeKhai (1994), “Changes in Marketing Activity and Consumption in the Socialist Republic of Vietnam,” in Research in Consumer Behavior: Consumption in Marketizing Economies, Vol. 7, ShultzC., BelkR., and GerG., eds. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, 225–57.
102.
SimonDenis F. (1988), “Technology Transfer and National Autonomy,” in Contending Approaches to the Political Economy of Taiwan, WinklerEdwin, and GreenlaghSusan, eds. New York: M.E. Sharpe.
103.
SimonsR. (1994), “Striving for Quality Control in China,”Asian Advertising and Marketing, (November 4), 10–11.
104.
SolomonRichard H. (1994), “Asian Architecture—The US in the Asia-Pacific Community,”Harvard International Review, 16 (Spring), 26–29.
105.
St. JohnRonald B. (1995), “The Political Economy of the Royal Government of Cambodia,”Contemporary Southeast Asia, 17 (December), 265–81.
106.
SteinbergDavid I. (1993), “Liberalization in Myanmar: How Real are the Changes?”Contemporary Southeast Asia, 15 (September), 161–78.
107.
SundhausenUlf (1995), “Indonesia's New Order: A Model for Myanmar?”Asian Survey, 35 (August), 769–80.
108.
SwansonLauren (1990), “Advertising in China: Viability and Structure,”European Journal of Marketing, 14, 277–94.
109.
SwansonLauren (1996), “China: The Changing Consumer,” working paper, Chinese University of Hong Kong.
SavuthTan (1994), [First Secretary of the Permanent Mission to the United Nations of the Kingdom of Cambodia] Interview with author, December 5, New York.
112.
TheinMyat, and ThanMya (1995), “Transitional Economy of Myanmar: Performance, Issues and Problems,” in Asian Transitional Economies, NayaS.F., and TanJ.L.H., eds. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 210–61.
113.
TithNarankhiri, and ShultzClifford J.II (1995), “Cambodia: The Killing Fields, Transition and the Implications for Marketing and Consumer Behavior,” working paper, Arizona State University West.
114.
NghiemTran Quang (1996), [Chairman of the Vietnamese Government Price Committee] interview with author, January 7, Ho Chi Minh City.
115.
TseDavid, BelkRussell W., and ZhouN. (1989), “Becoming a Consumer Society: A Longitudinal and Cross-Cultural Content Analysis of Print Ads from Hong Kong, the People's Republic of China and Taiwan,”Journal of Consumer Research, 15 (4), 457–72.
116.
United Nations (1992), Conditions for Economic Recovery, 2 (2), doc. GVE92.0.24. New York: United Nations Publications.
117.
United Nations (1993a), Development and International Cooperation: Entrepreneurship, doc. A.48.472. New York: United Nations Publications.
118.
United Nations (1993b), Economic and Social Survey of Asia and the Pacific, Part 2.New York: United Nations Publications.
119.
Vietnam Business Journal (1996), “Axe Falls on Social Evils!”4 (April), 18.
120.
KietVo Van (1994), “Keynote Address,” Twelfth Williamsburg Conference, New York: The Asia Society.
The Wall Street Journal (1996), “Economic Freedom Around the World” (May 6), A12.
123.
WanandiJusef (1994), “The Future of ASEAN,”Harvard International Review, 16 (Spring), 30–31.
124.
WeidenbaumMurray (1995), “Isolationism In A Global Economy,”Management Review, 84 (12), 43–45.
125.
WilliamsMichael (1992), Vietnam at the Crossroads.London: Pinter Publishers.
126.
WilliamsMichael (1995), “Population in Asia and the Pacific,” in The Far East and Australasia.London: Europa Publications Ltd, 3–14.
127.
World Bank (1993), The East Asian Miracle: Economic Growth and Public Policy.Washington, DC: World Bank.
128.
ZakariaFareed (1994), “Asia Won't Be a Repeat of Europe's Wartorn Past,”Singapore Straits Times, (March 12), 34.
129.
ZhouNan, and BelkRussell W. (1993), “China's Advertising and the Export Marketing Learning Curve: The First Decade,”Journal of Advertising Research, 33 (6), 50–66.
