An issue currently generating considerable debate is the increasing use of the comparative price format in advertising. In this paper, reviews of comparative price advertising literature and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) guidelines are integrated to discuss whether comparative price advertisements are informative or deceptive. Recent court cases relevant to comparative price advertising are also discussed. The central focus of the paper is to articulate the state of knowledge regarding comparative price advertising and to assess its potential for being informative or deceptive using an examination of relevant literature and public policy. Recommendations regarding comparative price advertising for public policy makers, managers, and researchers are developed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AginsTeri (1990), “Low Prices or Low Practices? Regulators Cast Wary Eye on Retailers’ Many Sales,”Wall Street Journal, (February 13), B1, B7.
2.
AhmedSadrudin A., and GulasGary M. (1982), “Consumers’ Perception of Manufacturers’ Suggested List Price,”Psychological Reports, 50(April), 507–518.
3.
ArmstrongGary M., GurolMetin N., and RussFrederick A. (1979), “Detecting and Correcting Deceptive Advertising,”Journal of Consumer Research, 6(December), 237–246.
4.
BaerWilliam J. (1988), “At the Turning Point: The Commission in 1978,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 7, 11–20.
5.
BarnesJames G. (1975), “Factors Influencing Consumer Reaction to Retail Newspaper ‘Sale’ Advertising,” in Proceedings, MazzeEdward M., ed. Fall Educators’ Conference, Chicago, Ill.: American Marketing Association, 37, 471–477.
6.
BeardenWilliam O., LichtensteinDonald R., and TeelJesse E. (1984), “Comparison Price, Coupon, and Brand Effects on Consumer Reactions to Retail Newspaper Advertisements,”Journal of Retailing, 60(Summer), 11–36.
7.
BerkowitzEric N., and WaltonJohn R. (1980), “Contextual Influences on Consumer Price Responses: An Experimental Analysis,”Journal of Marketing Research, 17(August), 349–358.
8.
BlairEdward A., and Laird LandonE.Jr. (1981), “The Effects of Reference Prices in Retail Advertisements,”Journal of Marketing, 45(Spring), 61–69.
9.
BrandtMichael T., and PrestonIvan L. (1977), “The Federal Trade Commission's Use of Evidence to Determine Deception,”Journal of Marketing, 41(January), 54–62.
10.
BurtonScot, and LichtensteinDonald R. (1988), “The Effect of Ad Claims and Ad Context on Attitude Toward the Advertisement,”Journal of Advertising, 17(1), 3–11.
11.
ChapmanJoseph D. (1987), “The Impact of Discounts on Subjective Product Evaluations,” Ph.D. diss., Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Va.
12.
Committee on Consumer Policy (1979), Bargain Price Offers and Similar Practices, Paris, France: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
13.
CompeauLarry D., and GrewalDhruv (1990), “Comparative Price Advertising: A Methodological Review and Critique,” in AMA Educators’ Proceedings, Chicago, Ill.: American Marketing Association, 56.
14.
CooperHarris M. (1984), The Integrative Research Review: A Systematic Approach, Beverly Hills, Calif: Sage Publications.
15.
BittaDelia, AlbertJ., MonroeKent B., and McGinnisJohn M. (1981), “Consumer Perceptions of Comparative Price Advertisements,”Journal of Marketing Research, 18(November), 416–427.
16.
DiamondWilliam D., and SanyalAbhijit (1990), “The Effect of Framing on the Choice of Supermarket Coupons,” in Advances in Consumer Research, GoldbergMarvin, GornGerald, and PollayRichard W., eds. Provo, Utah: Association for Consumer Research, 17, 488–493.
17.
DoddsWilliam B., MonroeKent B., and GrewalDhruv (1991), “The Effects of Price, Brand, and Store Information on Buyers’ Product Evaluations,”Journal of Marketing Research, 28(August), 307–319.
18.
FordGary T., and CalfeeJohn E. (1983), “Consumer Psychology Research Needs at the Federal Trade Commission,” in Proceedings of the Division of Consumer Psychology, AndersonJames C., ed. Anaheim, Calif.: Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, 118–120.
19.
FordGary T., and CalfeeJohn E. (1986), “Recent Developments in FTC Policy on Deception,”Journal of Marketing, 50(July), 82–102.
20.
FordGary T., SmithDarlene B., and SwasyJohn L. (1990), “Consumer Skepticism of Advertising Claims: Testing Hypotheses from Economics of Information,”Journal of Consumer Research, 16(March), 433–441.
21.
FriedmanHershey H., WeingatenPhilip E., FriedmanLinda W., and GallayRalph (1982), “The Effects of Various Price Mark-downs on Consumers’ Ratings of a New Product,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 10(Fall), 432–437.
22.
FryJoseph N., and McDougallGordon H. (1974), “Consumer Appraisal of Retail Price Advertisements,”Journal of Marketing, 38(July), 64–74.
23.
GardnerDavid M. (1975), “Deception in Advertising: A Conceptual Approach,”Journal of Marketing, 39(January), 40–46.
24.
GotliebJerry B. (1990) “Communicating Price-Perceived Quality Relationship,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 20(March), 404–423.
25.
GotliebJerry B., and FitzgeraldCyndy T. (1990), “An Investigation Into the Effects of Advertised Reference Prices on the Price Consumers Are Willing to Pay for the Product,”Journal of Applied Business Research, 6(1), 59–69.
26.
GotliebJerry B., and SarelDan (1991), “Effect of Price Advertisement on Perceived Quality and Purchase Intentions,”Journal of Business Research, Forthcoming.
27.
GotliebJerry B., and SwanJohn E. (1990), “An Application of the Elaboration Likelihood Model,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 18(Summer), 221–228.
28.
GrewalDhruv, and GrewalDiana S. (1991), “Pricing Responsibility: The Retailer or the State?,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 19(Summer), 276–277.
29.
GrewalDhruv, and MonroeKent B. (1991), “Information Cues, Internal Reference Prices and Product Evaluations: A Conceptual Framework and Synthesis of Past Research,”Coral Gables, Fla.: University of Miami, Working paper.
30.
HisrichRobert D. (1983), “Executive Advertisers’ Views of Comparison Advertising,”Sloan Management Review, 25(Fall), 39–50.
31.
HonigwachsJoshua (1987), “Is It Safe to Call Something Safe? The Law of Puffing in Advertising,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 6, 157–170.
32.
InmanJ. Jeffrey, McAlisterLeigh, and HoyerWayne (1990), “Promotion Signal: Proxy for a Price Cut?”Journal of Consumer Research, 17(June), 74–81.
33.
JonesMary Gardner (1988), “The Federal Trade Commission in 1968: Times of Turmoil and Response,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 7, 1–10.
34.
KamenJoseph, and TomanRobert (1970), “Psychophysics of Prices,”Journal of Marketing Research, 7(February), 27–35.
35.
KeiserStephen K., and KrumJames R. (1976), “Consumer Perceptions of Retail Advertising With Overstated Price Savings,”Journal of Retailing, 52(Fall), 27–36.
36.
KinnearThomas C., and RootAnn R. (1988), “The FTC and Deceptive Advertising in the 1980s: Are Consumers Being Adequately Protected?”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 7, 40–48.
37.
KleinNoreen M., and OglethorpeJanet E. (1987), “Reference Points in Consumer Decision Making,” in Advances in Consumer Research, WallendorfMelanie, and AndersonPaul, eds. Provo, Utah: Association for Consumer Research, 14, 183–187.
38.
LaczniakRussell N., and GrossbartSanford (1990), “An Assessment of Assumptions Underlying the Reasonable Consumer Element in Deceptive Advertising Policy,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 9, 85–99.
39.
LichtensteinDonald R., and BeardenWilliam O. (1986), “Measurement and Structure of Kelley's Covariance Theory,”Journal of Consumer Research, 13(September), 290–296.
40.
LichtensteinDonald R., and BeardenWilliam O. (1988), “An Investigation of Consumer Evaluations of Reference Price Discount Claims,”Journal of Business Research, 17(September), 189–200.
41.
LichtensteinDonald R., and BeardenWilliam O. (1989), “Contextual Influences on Perceptions of Merchant-Supplied Reference Prices,”Journal of Consumer Research, 16(June), 55–66.
42.
LichtensteinDonald R., BurtonScot, and O'HaraBradley S. (1989), “Marketplace Attributions on Consumer Evaluations of Discount Claims,”Psychology and Marketing, 6(Fall), 163–180.
43.
LiefeldJohn, and HeslopLouise A. (1985), “Reference Prices and Deception in Newspaper Advertising,”Journal of Consumer Research, 11(March), 868–876.
44.
MobleyMary F., BeardenWilliam O., and TeelJesse E. (1988), “An Investigation of Individual Responses to Tensile Price Claims,”Journal of Consumer Research, 15(September), 273–279.
45.
MonroeKent B. (1971), “Measuring Price Thresholds by Psychophysics and Latitudes of Acceptance,”Journal of Marketing Research, 18(November), 460–464.
46.
MonroeKent B. (1990), Pricing: Making Profitable Decisions, 2d ed., New York, N.Y.: McGraw Hill Book Co.
47.
MonroeKent B., and ChapmanJoseph D. (1987), “Framing Effects on Buyers Subjective Product Evaluations,” in Advances in Consumer Research, WallendorfMelanie, and AndersonPaul, eds. Provo, Utah: Association for Consumer Research, 14, 193–197.
48.
MonroeKent B., and KrishnanR. (1985), “The Effect of Price On Subjective Product Evaluations,” in Perceived Quality: How Consumers View Stores and Merchandise, JacobyJacob, and OlsonJerry C., eds. Lexington, Mass.: Lexington Books, 209–232.
49.
MooreDavid J., and OlshavskyRichard W. (1989), “Brand Choice and Deep Price Discounts,”Psychology and Marketing, 6(Fall), 181–196.
50.
MuehlingGarrel D., and KangunNorman (1985), “The Multi-Dimensionality of Comparative Advertising: Implications for the Federal Trade Commission,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 4, 112–128.
51.
OglesbyBobbie D. (1984), “Price and Semantic Cues’ Effect on Perceived Quality and Attitude,”Marketing Comes of Age, KleinDavid M., and SmithAllen E., eds. Boca Raton, Fla.: Southern Marketing Association, 308–312.
52.
PrestonIvan L. (1976), “A Comment on “Defining Misleading Advertising” and “Deception in Advertising,”Journal of Marketing, 40(July), 54–60.
53.
RajuP.S., and HastakManoj (1983), “Pre-Trial Cognitive Effects of Cents-Off Coupons,”Journal of Advertising, 12(2), 24–33.
54.
RichardsJef I. (1990a), Deceptive Advertising: Behavioral Study of a Legal Concept, Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
55.
RichardsJef I. (1990b), “A ‘New and Improved’ View of Puffery,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 9, 73–84.
56.
RussoJ. Edward, MetcalfBarbara L., and StephensDebra (1981), “Identifying Misleading Advertising,”Journal of Consumer Research, 8(September), 119–131.
57.
SawyerAlan G., and DicksonPeter R. (1984), “Psychological perspectives on Consumer Response to Sales Promotions,” in Research on Sales Promotions: Collected Papers, JoczKatherine E., ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Marketing Science Institute, Report No. 84–104, 1–21.
58.
SewallMurphy A., and GoldsteinMichael H. (1979), “The Comparative Price Advertising Controversy: Consumer Perceptions of Catalog Showroom Reference Prices,”Journal of Marketing, 43(Summer), 85–92.
59.
StiglerGeorge J. (1961), “The Economics of Information,”Journal of Political Economy, 69(June), 213–25.
60.
StrenioAndrew J.Jr. (1988), “The FTC in 1988: Phoenix of Finis?”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 7, 21–39.
61.
ThalerRichard (1985), “Mental Accounting and Consumer Choice,”Marketing Science, 4(Summer) 199–214.
62.
TurgeonNormand, and BarnabyDavid J. (1988), “Comparative Advertising: Two Decades of Practice and Research,” in Current Issues and Research in Advertising, LeighJames H., and MartinClaude R.Jr., eds. Ann Arbor, Mich.: The University of Michigan, 11 (1–2), 41–65.
63.
UrbanyJoel E., BeardenWilliam O., and WeilbakerDan C. (1988), “The Effect of Plausible and Exaggerated Reference Prices on Consumer Perceptions and Price Search,”Journal of Consumer Research, 15(June), 95–110.
64.
VaradarajanP. Rajan (1986), “Consumers’ Behavioral Responses to Coupon Price Promotions: An Empirical Inquiry,” in AMA Educators’ Proceedings, ShimpTerence A., eds. Chicago, Ill.: American Marketing Association, 52, 211.
65.
WilkieWilliam L., and FarrisPaul W. (1975), “Comparison Advertising: Problems and Potential,”Journal of Marketing, 39(October), 7–15.
66.
WilsonR. Dale (1978), “Comparative Advertising: Some Current Considerations for Managerial Planning and Strategy,” in Current Issues and Research in Advertising, LeighJames, and MartinClaude R.Jr., eds. Ann Arbor, Mich.: The University of Michigan, 5–22.
67.
ZeithamlValarie A. (1988), “Consumer Perceptions of Price, Quality, and Value: A Means-End Model and Synthesis of Evidence,”Journal of Marketing, 52(July), 2–22.
