Advertising regulators should recognize that advertising enhances competition, that regulation cannot prevent every possible misinterpretation, and that advertising cannot provide complete information. At the Federal Trade Commission, a consensus has long existed on these issues. Many state enforcement actions against national advertising have not followed these principles.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Advertising Age (1989), “Programming and Business Side Developments in Broadcasting,” (Aug. 7), 46.
2.
AlexanderGeorge (1967), Honesty and Competition.Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press.
3.
Allen B. Wrisley Co. v. FTC (1940), 113 F.2d. 437 (7th Cir.).
4.
American Bar Association (1989), Report of the American Bar Association Section of Antitrust Law Special Committee to Study the Role of the Federal Trade Commission.
5.
American Dental Association (1979), 94 FTC 403.
6.
American Home Products (1981), 98 FTC 136.
7.
American Medical Association (1979), 94 FTC 701.
8.
American Motors Corp. et al. (1982), 100 FTC 229.
9.
American Suzuki Motor Corporation (1989), Agreement of Voluntary Compliance, Attorneys General of California, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, Texas, and Washington (March 21).
10.
Antitrust & Trade Regulation Report (1990), “J.C. Penney Agrees to Document Sales of Jewelry as Deception Suit Continues,”Antitrust & Trade Regulation Report, 58(January 4), 16–17.
11.
Attorneys General (1990), Comments of the Attorneys General, Food Labeling Rulemaking (January 2).
12.
BaileyJeff (1989), “Quaker Oats Co. Is Sued by Texas Over Health Claims in Cereal Ads,”Wall Street Journal, (September 8), B4.
13.
BaileyPatricia P., and PertschukMichael (1984a), “Analysis of the Law of Deception,” in Deception: FTC Oversight, Hearing before the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations of the Committee on Energy and Commerce, House of Representatives, March 26.
14.
BaileyPatricia P. (1984b), “The Law of Deception: The Past as Prologue,”American University Law Review, 33, 849–897.
15.
BealesHoward, CraswellRichard, and SalopSteven (1981), “The Efficient Regulation of Consumer Information,”Journal of Law and Economics, 24(December), 491–540.
16.
BenhamLee (1972), “The Effect of Advertising on the Price of Eyeglasses,”Journal of Law and Economics, 15(October), 337–352.
17.
BenhamLee, and BenhamAlexandra (1975), “Regulating Through the Professions: A Perspective on Information Control,”Journal of Law and Economics, 18(October), 421–477.
18.
BondRonald S., KwokaJohn E., PhelanJohn J., and WhittenIra T. (1980), Effects of Restrictions on Advertising and Commercial Practice in the Professions: The Case of Optometry, Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Economics Staff Report.
19.
CadyJ. (1976), Restricted Advertising and Competition: The Case of Retail Drugs.Washington: American Enterprise Institute.
20.
California State Board of Optometry v. FTC (1990), No. 89- 1190, D.C. Cir. (August 28).
21.
CalvaniTerry (1989), “Advertising Regulation: The States v. FTC,”Antitrust Law Journal, 58(Spring), 253–268.
22.
Campbell Soup Company (1989), Assurance of Discontinuance, Attorneys General of California, Illinois, Iowa, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, Texas, Wisconsin (May 8).
23.
Clairol, Inc. (1941), 33 FTC 1450.
24.
Colorado v. The May Department Stores d/b/a May D&F (1989), District Court, City and County of Denver, Case No. 89 CV 9274 (filed June 21), Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction.
25.
Colorado v. The May Department Stores d/b/a May D&F (1990), Case No. 89 CV 9274, Slip Opinion, (June 27).
26.
Consumer Reports (1989), “How to Shop Smart for a New Car,”Consumer Reports, 54(April), 203.
27.
CoxEdward F., FellmethRobert C., and SchulzJohn E. (1969), Nader's Raiders Report on the Federal Trade Commission.New York: Grove Press, Inc.
28.
CraswellRichard (1985), “Interpreting Deceptive Advertising,”Boston University Law Review, 65(July), 657–732.
29.
Dannon Milk Products, Inc. (1962), 61 FTC 840.
30.
Encyclopaedia Britannica (1981), Supplemental Submission of Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc. in Support of Request to Reopen Proceedings and Set Aside or Modify Order, Docket No. 8908 (October 9).
31.
Encyclopaedia Britannica (1982), 100 FTC 500 (modifying order).
32.
Federal Trade Commission (1967), “Guides Against Deceptive Pricing,”Federal Register, 32(Nov. 8), 15534 (16 C.F.R. 233).
Federal Trade Commission (1978), “Advertising of Ophthalmic Goods and Services,”Federal Register, 43(June 2), 23992; suspended in part and remanded, American Optometric Ass'n v. FTC, 626 F.2d 896 (D.C. Cir. 1980).
35.
Federal Trade Commission (1979), Consumer Information Remedies, Policy Review Session (June 1).
36.
Federal Trade Commission (1980), “Food Advertising; Request for Comments and Proposals for Voluntary or Regulatory Action,”Federal Register, 45(April 8), 23705.
37.
Federal Trade Commission (1983), FTC Policy Statement on Deception, reprinted in Antitrust & Trade Regulation Reporter (CCH), 4, 13,205.
38.
Federal Trade Commission (1985), “Guides Against Deceptive Advertising of Guarantees,”Federal Register, 50(May 1), 18462.
39.
Federal Trade Commission (1988), Comments of the Bureaus of Competition, Consumer Protection and Economics of the Federal Trade Commission, on Health Messages on Food Labels and Labeling.
40.
Federal Trade Commission (1989a), Complaint, Campbell Soup Company, Docket No. 9223 (Issued January 25).
41.
Federal Trade Commission (1989b), Ophthalmic Practices Rules, Federal Register, 54, 10285.
42.
FordGary T., and CalfeeJohn E. (1986), “Recent Developments in FTC Policy on Deception,”Journal of Marketing, 50(July), 82–103.
43.
FordGary T., and YalchRichard (1982), “Viewer Miscomprehension of Televised Communication—A Comment,”Journal of Marketing, 46(Fall), 27–31.
44.
GibsonRichard (1989), “Kellogg Tries to Blunt the Attacks On Cereal Makers’ Health Claims,”Wall Street Journal, (August 31), B4.
45.
Grolier, Inc. (1978), 91 FTC 315.
46.
HeinzW. Kirchner (1963), 63 FTC 1282.
47.
HilkeJohn C. (1989), “One Step Forward and Two Steps Backward at the SEC?”Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, 3(Spring), 253–268.
48.
In the Matter of Kraft, Inc. (1986), Consent Agreement, Texas Attorney General (February 14).
49.
IppolitoPauline M., and MathiosAlan D. (1989), Health Claims in Advertising and Labeling: A Study of the Cereal Market, Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Economics Staff Report.
50.
ITT Continental Baking Co. (1973), 83 FTC 865.
51.
JacobsWilliam W., DoubravaBrenda W., WeaverRobert P., StewartDouglas O., and PrahlEric L. (1984), Improving Consumer Access to Legal Services: The Case for Removing Restrictions on Truthful Advertising, Federal Trade Commission Staff Report.
52.
JacobyJacob, and HoyerWayne D. (1989), “The Comprehension/Miscomprehension of Print Communication: Selected Findings,”Journal of Consumer Research, 15(March), 434–443.
53.
JacobyJacob, HoyerWayne D., and ShelugaDavid A. (1980), Miscomprehension of Televised Communications, New York: Educational Foundation of the American Association of Advertising Agencies.
54.
KellerKevin Lane, and StaelinRichard (1987), “Effects of Quality and Quantity of Information on Decision Effectiveness,”Journal of Consumer Research, 14(September), 200–213.
55.
LawrenceJennifer (1987), “Airlines Lash Out at Guidelines,”Advertising Age, (September 28), 28.
LawrenceJennifer, and MeyersJanet (1990), “States Urge FDA Crackdown,”Advertising Age, 61(January 8), 1.
58.
Lever Brothers Co. v. Maurer (1988), CA C–2–88–955 (S.D. Ohio filed September 9).
59.
Lever Brothers Co. v. Richards (1989), CA 89–0067-S (W.D. Wisc. filed June 22).
60.
MacLeodWilliam C. (1989), Director, Bureau of Consumer Protection, Federal Trade Commission, Letter to Bruce Silverglade (June 16).
61.
MauriziAlex, and KelleyThom (1978), Prices and Consumer Information: The Benefits From Posting Retail Gasoline Prices, Washington: American Enterprise Institute.
62.
McAuliffeRobert (1988), “The FTC and the Effectiveness of Cigarette Advertising Regulations,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 7, 49–64.
63.
MizerskiRichard W. (1982), “Viewer Miscomprehension Findings Are Measurement Bound,”Journal of Marketing, 46(Fall), 32–34.
64.
MurphyJohn H., and RichardsJef I. (1989), “An Investigation of the Effects of Disclosure Statements in Rental Car Commercials,”Department of Advertising, University of Texas, (June).
65.
National Association of Attorneys General (1987), Report and Recommendations of the NAAG Task Force on the Air Travel Industry, Reprinted in Antitrust & Trade Regulation Report, 53, Special Supplement (December 17).
66.
National Association of Attorneys General (1988a), “Staff Analysis of Implementation of NAAG Airline Guidelines,” Reprinted inAntitrust & Trade Regulation Report, 54(March 17), 471–475.
67.
National Association of Attorneys General (1988b), Resolution, Health Claims in Food Labelling (June/July).
68.
National Association of Attorneys General (1989), Car Rental Practices Guidelines, Reprinted in Antitrust & Trade Regulation Reporter (BNA), 56, 1407 (Special Supplement, March 16).
69.
National Dynamics Corp. (1973), 82 FTC 488.
70.
PertschukMichael (1983), Testimony Before the Subcommittee for Consumers, Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation, U.S. Senate (July 22).
71.
PertschukMichael (1984), FTC Review (1977–84), A Report Prepared by a Member of the Federal Trade Commission Together With Comments From Other Members of the Commission, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, House Committee on Energy and Commerce.
72.
PitofskyRobert (1977), “Beyond Nader: Consumer Protection and the Regulation of Advertising, Harvard Law Review, 90(February), 661–701.
73.
Planters LifeSavers Company (1989), Assurance of Discontinuance, Attorneys General of California, Illinois, Iowa, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, Texas, and Wisconsin (October 27).
74.
PorterRobert H. (1986), “The Impact of Government Policy on the U.S. Cigarette Industry”, in Empirical Approaches to Consumer Protection, IppolitoPauline, and ScheffmanDavid, eds., Federal Trade Commission, 447–481.
75.
RiceDavid A. (1982), “Statement,”Reauthorization of the FTC, Hearings before the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, U. S. Senate, 97th Congress, 2nd Session (March 18-19), 249–259.
76.
SchroeterJ.R., SmithS.L., and CoxS.R. (1987), “Advertising and Competition in Routine Legal Service Markets: An Empirical Investigation,”Journal of Industrial Economics, 35(September), 49–60.
77.
Southwest Sunsites, Inc. (1985), 105 FTC 7, aff'd 785 F.2d 1431 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 479 U.S. 828 (1986).
78.
SteinerRobert L. (1973), “Does Advertising Lower Consumer Prices?”Journal of Marketing, 37(October), 19–26.
79.
SteinerRobert L. (1978), “Learning from the Past—Brand Advertising and the Great Bicycle Craze of the 1890s,” in Advances in Advertising Research and Management, Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the American Academy of Advertising, PermutSteven E., ed., 35–40.
80.
StiglerGeorge (1961), “The Economics of Information,”Journal of Political Economy, 69(June), 213–225.
81.
StreitfeldDavid (1987), “Golden Arches Under Fire,”Washington Post, (June 1), B5.
82.
Texas v. Quaker Oats (1989), State of Texas and Robert Bernstein, Texas Commissioner of Health, v. The Quaker Oats Company, Cause No. 89–10762, District Court of Dallas County, 298th Judicial District, Plaintiff's Original Petition (Filed September 7).
83.
Thompson Medical Co. (1984), 104 FTC 648, aff'd, 791 F.2d 189 (D.C. Cir. 1986), cert. denied, 479 U.S. 1086 (1987).
84.
Warner-Lambert Co. (1975), 86 FTC 1398.
85.
WilkieWilliam L. (1982), “Affirmative Disclosure: Perspective on FTC Orders,”Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, 1, 95–110.
