A Comment on “Public Policy Issues in Health Claims for Foods

Abstract

The regulation of nutrition information on food labels and in food advertising is one of the most important public health issues now pending before the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). Widely disparate recommendations have been made concerning how these two agencies should regulate the provision of such information. This comment responds to the views presented by Calfee and Pappalardo [1991], which rely on free market principles to provide such information. The views expressed by the authors represent a refinement of similar views expressed by the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) Bureau of Economics and the Commission's Bureau of Consumer Protection since 1984. Thus, this comment is not only a response to the preceding paper, but also represents a critique of FTC policy in this area.

Public health concerns underlying the need for better nutrition information in food labeling and advertising will be reviewed. Differing regulatory approaches to providing nutrition information through the inclusion of health claims on food labels will be analyzed by contrasting the requirements of the new Nutrition Labeling and Education Act (NLEA) [1990] with the regulatory approach recommended by the authors. Several marketing campaigns for foods instituted prior to the enactment of the NLEA, and regulated in accordance with the recommendations of the authors will be reviewed. Reasons why the FTC should modify its current regulatory and enforcement policies regarding health claims and make them uniform with those followed by the FDA in accordance with the requirements of the NLEA will be given.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Association of Retired Persons, American Heart Association, American Cancer Society, American Dietetic Association, Public Voice, American College of Physicians, American College of Preventive Medicine, American Diabetes Association, American Institute for Cancer Research, American Nurses’ Association, Americans for Democratic Action, National PTA, Association of Schools of Public Health, Association of State and Territorial Health Officials, Association of State and Territorial Public Health Nutrition Directors, Center for Science in the Public Interest, Citizens for Public Action on Cholesterol, Consumer Affairs Committee, Consumer Federation of America, Johns Hopkins Preventive Cardiology Programs, National Council on Aging, Society for Nutrition Education (1990), Letter to the Honorable Janet Steiger, Chairman, Federal Trade Commission, (March 15, 1990).

Business Week (1989), (October 9), p. 114.

Calfee

John E.

, and Pappalardo

Janis K.

(1991), “Public Policy in Health Claims Issues for Foods,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10, 1.

Committee on Government Operations (1988), “Disease Specific Health Claims on Food Labels: An Unhealthy Idea,” 100th Congress, House Report 100-561, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C.

Committee on Government Operations (1990), “FDA's Continuing Failure to Prevent Deceptive Health Claims for Food,” 101st Congress, House Report 101–928, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., (November 14).

Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Economics Staff Report (1989), Health Claims in Advertising and Labeling: A Study of the Cereal Market, U.S. Government Printing Office.

Food and Drug Administration (1987), Comments on Public Record No. 85N–0061, Dockets Management Branch, Rockville, Maryland.

Food and Drug Administration (1987), “Food Labeling: Public Health Messages on Food Labeling,” Federal Register, 52, 28843–28849. (August 4).

Food and Drug Administration (1990), “Food Labeling: Health Messages and Labels Statements; Re-proposed Rule,” Federal Register, 55, 5176–5192.

10.

Food and Drug Administration (1990), (Notice on Psyllium, GRAS status), Federal Register, 55, 4481 (February 8).

11.

Government Accounting Office (1988), Report of the Chairman, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, Committee on Energy and Commerce, House of Representatives, Food Marketing: Frozen Pizza Cheese—Representative of Broader Food Labeling Issues, GAO/RCED–88–70 (March) 28.

12.

In Re: Kellogg Co. , (1988), Assurance of Discontinuance Between the State of New York Attorney General and the Kellogg Company, (August 4).

13.

Lake

Robert

(1991), Office of Compliance, Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition, Food and Drug Administration, Statement at the Food and Drug Law Institute Conference on Food Labeling, Washington, D.C. (January 15); See also Federal Register, 56, 10906 (March 14, 1991).

14.

Levy

Ostrove

, Guthrie , and Heimbach (1988), Division of Consumer Studies, Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition, Food and Drug Administration, “Recent Trends in Beliefs About Diet/Disease Relationships: Results of the 1979–1988 FDA Health and Diet Surveys,” presented at the FDA/USDA Food Editor Conference (December 1–2).

15.

Larson

Gloria

(1990), Address to the Council of Better Business Bureaus, National Advertising Division Conference on “Substantiating Food Health Claims in Advertising,” Washington D.C., (November 16).

16.

Nutrition Labeling and Education Act of 1990, Public Law No. 101–535, Report No. 101–538, U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Energy and Commerce, Subcommittee on Health and the Environment, (October).

17.

Roper Organization (1984), Roper Report: 84–89.

18.

Silverglade

Bruce

(1990), “Regulatory Policies for Communicating Health Information,” Mass Communication and Public Health, Sage Publications, p. 88.

19.

State of Texas v. The Quaker Oats Company (1989), U.S. CA-3-89-2350-R.

20.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service (1988), The Surgeon General's Report on Nutrition and Health, U.S. Government Printing Office.

21.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and U.S. Department of Agriculture (1990), (Home and Garden Bulletin No. 232, “U.S. Dietary Guidelines for Americans,” 2nd ed., 1985, 3rd ed., 1990.

22.

Wall Street Journal (1988), “Kellogg Agrees It Won't Run Some Cereal Ads,” (August 29) p. A-14.