An Evaluation of the Magnuson-Moss Warranty and Federal Trade Commission Improvement Act of 1975

Abstract

A quasi-experimental design is used to investigate whether the Magnuson-Moss Act succeeded in its efforts to transform a products warranty into an accurate signal of a products reliability, and to improve the overall level of warranty protection. The paradox of how an information remedy could create an accurate signal without changing how consumers process information is addressed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atlantic Richfield Company (1983), Consumerism in the Eighties, Los Angeles, CA: Concept Services Atlantic Richfield Company.

Beales

Howard

, Craswell

Richard

, and Salop

Steven

(1981), “The Efficient Regulation of Consumer Information,” Journal of Law and Economics, 24 (December), 491–539.

Beales

Howard

, Craswell

Richard

, and Salop

Steven

, Mazis

Michael

, Salop

Steven

, and Staelin

Richard

(1981), “Consumer Search and Public Policy,” Journal of Consumer Research, 8 (June), 11–22.

Consumers Reports (1979), “The Trouble with Auto Warranties,” Consumer Reports, (October), 598–600.

Consumers Reports (1984) “Is that Warranty Any Good?” July, 408–410.

Consumers Reports (1972) “Black and White TVs,” March, 148–151.

Consumers Reports (1967), “Large-Screen Color TV,” January, 9–13.

Consumers Reports (1968), “Large-Screen Color TV,” January, 16–20.

Consumers Reports (1969), “Color TV Frequency of Repair Records,” May, 258–259.

10.

Consumers Reports (1971), “Vacuum Cleaners,” April, 24–249.

11.

Consumers Reports (1971), “Steam/Spray Irons,” February, 74–80.

12.

Consumers Reports (1972), “Color TV Consoles,” January, 8–14.

13.

Consumers Reports (1972), “Washing Machines,” September, 573–581.

14.

Consumers Reports (1972), “Clothes Dryers,” September, 582–587.

15.

Consumers Reports (1973), “19 inch Color TV,” January, 8–13.

16.

Consumers Reports (1973), “Table Radios,” September, 568–571.

17.

Consumers Reports (1973), “Toasters and Toaster Ovens,” August, 501–505.

18.

Consumers Reports (1973), “Room Air Conditioners,” July, 443–451.

19.

Consumers Reports (1974), “Room Air Conditioners,” July, 516–522.

20.

Consumers Reports (1974), “Gas & Electric Ranges,” July, 526–533.

21.

Consumers Reports (1974), “Undercounter Dishwashers,” May, 385–390.

22.

Consumers Reports (1974), “Top-Freezer Refrigerators,” November, 808–815.

23.

Consumers Reports (1974), “Color TV Consoles,” January, 30–34.

24.

Consumers Reports (1975), “19-inch Color TV,” Janaury, 24–29.

25.

Consumers Reports (1975), “Washing Machines,” October, 611–615.

26.

Consumers Reports (1975), “Room Air Conditioners,” July, 410–416.

27.

Consumers Reports (1975), “No-Frost Refrigerators,” September, 564–569.

28.

Consumers Reports (1975), “FM/AM Portable Radios,” July, 436–439.

29.

Consumers Reports (1976), “FM/AM Table Radios,” September, 510–513.

30.

Consumers Reports (1970), “Frequency of Repair Records 1972–5,” April, 230–238.

31.

Consumers Reports (1977), “Color TV Consoles,” January, 11–15.

32.

Consumers Reports (1977), “Small Black-and-White TV Sets,” March, 158–161.

33.

Consumers Reports (1977), “High-Efficiency Air Conditioners,” July, 417–423.

34.

Consumers Reports (1977), “Frequency-of-Repair Records 1972–6,” April, 230–238.

35.

Consumers Reports (1978), “19-inch Color TV's,” January, 13–17.

36.

Consumers Reports (1978), “Multiband Portable Radios,” August, 452–455.

37.

Consumers Reports (1978), “Washing Machines,” October, 572–577.

38.

Consumers Reports (1978), “Top-Freezer Refrigerators,” January, 23–29.

39.

Consumers Reports (1978), “Frequency of Repair Records 1973–1977,” April, 231–240.

40.

Consumers Reports (1978), “Side-by-Side Refrigerator/Freezers,” November, 624–629.

41.

Consumers Reports (1979), “Electric and Gas Ranges,” August, 461–467.

42.

Consumers Reports (1979), “Vacuum Cleaners,” September, 515–521.

43.

Consumers Reports (1979), “Air Conditioners,” July, 404–409.

44.

Consumers Reports (1980), “Small Black-and-White Television Sets,” March, 205–207.

45.

Consumers Reports (1980), “Built-in Dishwasher,” June, 366–370.

46.

Consumers Reports (1980), “High Efficiency Air-Conditioners,” July, 428–433.

47.

Consumers Reports (1981), “19-inch Color TV's,” January, 34–39.

48.

Consumers Reports (1980), “Color TV Consoles,” January, 13–17.

49.

Consumers Reports (1982), “Clothes Dryers,” January, 31–37.

50.

Consumers Reports (1983), “Steam Irons,” February, 82–85.

51.

Consumers Reports (1984), “Is that Warranty Any Good,” July, 408–410.

52.

Consumers Reports (1986), “Toasters,” February, 104–107.

53.

Consumers Reports (1986), “Large-Screen TV Sets,” January, 12–17.

54.

Federal Trade Commission (1968), Staff Report on Automobile Warranties.

55.

Federal Trade Commission (1979), Consumer Information Remedies.

56.

Federal Trade Commission (1981), Comparative Performance Information Remedies.

57.

Federal Trade Commission (1979), Warranties Rules Consumer Baseline Study.

58.

Federal Trade Commission (1979), Warranties Rules Warranty Content Analysis.

59.

Federal Trade Commission (1985), An Evaluation of the Warranty Rules of the Magnuson-Moss Act.

60.

Feldman

Lawrence

(1976), “New Legislation and the Prospect for Real Warranty Reform,” Journal of Marketing, 40 (July), 41–47.

61.

Fisk

George

(1970), “Guidelines for Warranty Service After Sale,” Journal of Marketing, 34 (January), 63–67.

62.

Ford

Gary

and Calfee

John

(1986), “Recent Developments in FTC Policy on Deception,” Journal of Marketing, 50 (July), 82–103.

63.

Gerner

Jennifer

, and Bryant

Keith

(1981), “Appliance Warranties as a Market Signal,” The Journal of Consumer Affairs, 15 (Summer), 75–86.

64.

Kelly

Craig

(1986), “Consumer Product Warranties Under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act: A Review of the Literature,” in AMA Educators’ Conference Proceedings, ed. Shimp

, 369–373.

65.

Lehman

John C

, Manzer

L. Lee

, Gentry

James W.

, and Ellis

Hal W.

(1983), “The Readability of Warranties: Did They Improve After the Magnuson-Moss Act and Are They More Complex than Other Related Communications?” Proceedings, Houston, TX: Southwest Marketing Association Conference, 19–22.

66.

Major Appliance Consumer Action Panel (1983), “Statistical Report,” unpublished report, Chicago, IL.

67.

Major Appliance Consumer Action Panel (1986), “Statistical Report,” unpublished report, Chicago, IL.

68.

Mazis

Michael

, Staelin

Richard

, Beales

Howard

, and Salop

Steven

(1981), “A Framework for Evaluating Consumer Information Regulations,” Journal of Marketing, 45 (Winter), 11–22.

69.

Mazis

Michael

, Staelin

Richard

(1982), “Using Information Processing Principles in Public Policy Making,” Journal of Marketing and Public Policy, 1, 3–14.

70.

Preston

Ivan

, and Richards

Jeff

(1986), “The Relationship of Miscomprehension to Deceptiveness in Recent FTC Cases,” in Advances in Consumer Research, (13), ed. Lutz

, 138–142.

71.

Russo

Jay

, Metcalf

Barbara

, and Stephens

Debra

, (1981), “Identifying Misleading Advertising,” Journal of Consumer Research, 8 (September), 119–131.

72.

Salop

Steven

(1979), “Parables of Information Transmission in Markets,” in The Effect of Information on Consumer Market Behavior, ed. Mitchell

, Chicago: American Marketing Association. 3–12.

73.

Schmitt

Jacqueline

, Kanter

Lawrence

, and Miller

Rachel

(1980), “Impact Report on the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act: A Comparison of 40 Major Consumer Product Warranties from Before and After the Act,” Bureau of Consumer Protection.

74.

Shuptrine

F. Kelly

and Moore

Ellen M.

(1980), “Even After the Magnuson-Moss Act of 1975, Warranties Are Not Easy to Understand,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 14 (Winter), 394–404.

75.

Stern

Louis

, and Eovaldi

Thomas

(1984), Legal Aspects of Marketing Strategy, Prentice-Hall Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ.

76.

Thorelli

Hans

and Engledow

Jack

(1980), “Information Seekers and Information Systems: A Policy Perspective,” Journal of Marketing, 44 (Spring), 9–27.

77.

U.S. House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce (1970), Hearings on Warranties and Guarantees, 91st Cong., 2d sess.

78.

U.S. House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce (1972), Hearings on Consumer Warranty Protection, 92d Cong., 1st sess.

79.

U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce (1970), Hearings on Consumer Products Guaranty Act, 91st Cong., 2d sess.

80.

U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce (1973), Magnuson-Moss Warranty-Federal Trade Commission Improvement Act, 93d Cong., S. Rept. 93–151, Serial Set 13017–2.

81.

U.S. Senate (1973), “Magnuson-Moss Warranty-Federal Trade Commission Improvement Act,” 93d Cong., Washington, D.C.: Report of the Committee on Commerce.

82.

Wiener

Joshua

(1985), “Are Warranties Accurate Signals of Product Reliability,” Journal of Consumer Research, 12 (September), 245–250.

83.

Wiener

Joshua

(1985), “The Inferences Consumers Draw from a Warranty: Did They Become More Accurate After the Magnuson-Moss Act?” in AMA Educators’ Conference Proceedings, ed. Lusch

, 309–312.

84.

Wiener

Joshua

and Murphy

Patrick

(1985), “A Case for Comparitive Performance Information,” Journal of Macromarketing, 5 (Fall), 32–42.

85.

Wilkie

William

(1975), “How Consumers Use Product Information,” Report for NSF (Rann).

86.

Winer

Russell

and Ryan

Michael

(1979), “Analyzing Cross-Classification Data: An Improved Method for Predicting Events,” Journal of Marketing Research, 16 (November), 539–544.