This article examines the distinction between courts’ treatments of goods and the courts’ treatment of services in product liability litigation. Both public policy arguments and judicial reasons for the application of strict liability to services transactions are reviewed. Implications for marketers are presented from both legal and marketing perspectives.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhtolaOlli T. (1985), “The Conceptual Meaning of Marketing Services,” in Services Marketing in a Changing Environment, BlochT.M., UpahG.D., and ZeithamlV.A., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association91–93.
2.
Art Metal Products Co. v. Royal Equipment Co. (1984), 670 S.W.2d 152, 38 UCCRS 1202 (Mo. Ct. App.).
3.
BaldwinFrancis Scott (1977), “Products Liability as It Applies to Service Transactions,”Journal of Air Law & Commerce43 (No. 2), 323–39.
BatesonJohn (1977), “Do We Need Service Marketing?” in Marketing Consumer Services: New Insights, EiglierP.E., LangeardE., LovelockC.H., BatesonJ.E.G., and YoungR.F., eds. Cambridge, MA: Marketing Science Institute, report #77–115, 1–30.
6.
Becker v. IBM Corp. (1983), 192 Cal. Rptr. 570 (Cal. Ct. App.).
7.
BellMartin L. (1981), “A Matrix Approach to the Classification of Marketing Goods and Services,” in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 208–12.
Bichler v. Willing (1977), 58 A.D.2d 331, 397 N.Y.S.2d 57.
10.
BloisK.J. (1974), “The Marketing of Services: An Approach,”European Journal of Marketing8 (Summer), 137–49.
11.
BloomPaul N. (1981), “What Marketers Need to Know about the Marketing of Professional Services,” in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 86–87.
12.
Boatland of Houston v. Bailey (1980), 609 S.W.2d 743 (Tex.).
13.
Bolduc v. Herbert Schneider Corp. (1977), 374 A.2d 1187 (N.H.).
14.
Bonebrake v. Cox (1974), 499 F.2d 951 (8th Cir.).
15.
BoomsBernard H. and BitnerMary J. (1981), “Marketing Strategies and Organization Structures for Services Firms,” in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 47–51.
16.
BoomsBernard H. and NyquistJody L. (1981), “Analyzing the Customer/Firm Communication Component of the Service Marketing Mix, in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 172–77.
17.
Brody v. Overlook Hospital (1974), 127 N.J. Super. 331, 317 A. 2d 392, aff'd per curiam, 66 N.J. 448, 332 A.2d 596 (1975).
18.
BrownJames R. and FernEdward F. (1981), “Goods Vs. Services: A Divergent Perspective,” in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 205–7.
19.
BrownJohn Prather (1973), “Toward an Economic Theory of Liability,”Journal of Legal Studies2 (June), 323–49.
20.
Broyles v. Brown Engineering Co. (1963), 275 Ala. 35, 151 So. 2d 767.
Comment (1973), “Professional Negligence,”University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 121 Can.), 627–90.
26.
Cunningham v. Macneal Memorial Hospital (1970), 266 N.E.2d 897 (Ill.).
27.
CrumpDavid and MaxwellLarry A. (1982), “Should Health Services Providers Be Strictly Liable for Product-Related Injuries? A Legal and Economic Analysis,”Southwestern Law Journal36 (Sept.), 831–56.
28.
DixonDonald F. and SmithMichael F. (1983), “Theoretical Foundations for Services Marketing Strategy,” in Emerging Perspectives on Services Marketing, BerryL.L., ShostackG.L., and UpahG.D., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 77–81.
29.
Dubin v. Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center (1980), 74 Ill. App. 3d 932, 393 N.E.2d 588 (1979), 83 Ill. 2d 277, 47 Ill. Dec. 345, 415 N.E.2d 350.
30.
DubinskyAlan J., and RudeliusWilliam (1980–81), “Selling Techniques for Industrial Products and Services: Are They Different?”Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management, 1 (Fall-Winter), 66–75.
31.
DubinskyAlan J., IngramThomas N., and RudeliusWilliam (1985), “Industrial Selling: How Product and Service Salespeople Compare,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 13 (Winter), 160–70.
32.
Escola v. Coca Cola Bottling Co. (1944), 24 Cal.2d 453, 150 P.2d 436.
33.
FletcherGeorge P. (1972), “Fairness and Utility in Tort Theory,”Harvard Law Review85 (Jan.), 537–73.
34.
Friend v. Childs Dining Hall Co. (1918). 120 N.E. 407 (Mass.).
35.
GeorgeWilliam R., KellyJ. Patrick, and MarshallClaudia E. (1983), “Personal Selling in Services Industries,” in Emerging Perspectives on Services Marketing, BerryL.L., ShostackG.L., and UpahG.D., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 65–67.
36.
GillyMary C. and DeanDebra L. (1985), “A Market-Oriented Taxonomy of Public Services: Implications for Marketing Management,” in Services Marketing in a Changing Environment, BlochT.M., UpahG.D., and ZeithamlV.A., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 94–97.
37.
GoodmanMichael (1983), “Strict Liability and the Professional Service Transaction,”Insurance Counsel Journal50 (April), 201–21.
38.
Greenman v. Yuba Power Products, Inc. (1962), 59 Cal.2d 57, 27 Cal.Rptr. 697, 377 P. 2d 897.
39.
GroveStephen J. and FiskRaymond P. (1983), “The Dramaturgy of Services Exchange: An Analytical Framework for Services Marketing,” in Emerging Perspectives in Services Marketing, BerryL.L., ShostackG.L., and UpahG.D., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 45–49.
40.
GuiltinanJoseph P. (1987), “The Price Bundling of Services: A Normative Framework,”Journal of Marketing51 (April), 74–85.
41.
GusemanDennis S. (1981), “Risk Perceptions and Risk Reduction in Consumer Services,” in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 200–4.
42.
Hall v. State (1981), 435 N.Y.S.2d 663 (Ct. Cl.).
43.
HarrisBrian F. (1981), “Strategies for Marketing Professional Services: Current Status and Research Directions,” in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 88–90.
44.
Helene Curtiss Industries, Inc. v. Pruitt (1967), 385 F.2d 841 (5th Cir.), cert. denied, 391 U.S. 913 (1968).
Hunt v. Guarantee Electrical Co. of St. Louis (1984), 667 S.W.2d 9 (Mo. Ct. App.).
47.
Industrial Risk Insurers v. Creole Production Services, Inc. (1984), 746 F.2d 526 (9th Cir.).
48.
JuddRobert C. (1964), “The Case for Redefining Services,”Journal of Marketing28 (Jan.), 58–59.
49.
KlemmeHoward C. (1976), “The Enterprise Liability Theory of Torts,”University of Colorado Law Review47 (Winter), 153–232.
50.
KotlerPhilip and BloomPaul N., (1984), Marketing Professional Services, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
51.
Lechuga, Inc. v. Montgomery (1970), 12 Ariz. App. 32, 467 P.2d 256.
52.
Lee v. Griffin (1861), 121 Eng. Rep. 716 (K.B.).
53.
Lehr, Karl Fulton (1981), “The Application of Products Liability Principles to Professional Services,”Insurance Counsel Journal48 (July), 434–51.
54.
Lewis v. Big Powderhorn Mountain Ski Corp. (1976), 69 Mich. App. 437, 245 N.W.2d 81 (Ct. App.)
55.
Ligocky v. Wilcox (1980), 620 P.2d 1300 (N.M. Ct. App.)
56.
LovelockChristopher H. (1980). “Toward a Classification of Services,” in Theoretical Developments in Marketing,” LambC.W. and DunneP.M., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 72–78.
57.
LovelockChristopher H. (1983a), “Classifying Services to Gain Strategic Marketing Insights,”Journal of Marketing47 (Summer), 9–20.
58.
LovelockChristopher H. (1983b), “Think Before You Leap in Services Marketing,” in Emerging Perspectives on Services Marketing, BerryL.L., ShostackL.G., and UpahG.D., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 115–19.
59.
Lynch v. Hotel Bond Co. (1933), 167 A. 99 (Conn.).
60.
Magrine v. Krasnica (1969), 94 N.J. Super. 228, 227 A.2d 539 (Law Div. 1967), aff'd sub nom, Magrine v. Spector, 100 N.J. Super. 223, 241 A.2d 637 (App. Div. 1968), aff'd per curiam, 53 N.J. 259, 250 A. 2d 129.
61.
Markle v. Mulholland's, Inc. (1973), 265 Ore. 259, 509 P. 2d 529.
62.
Merrill v. Hedson (1914), 91 A. 533 (Conn.).
63.
MorganFred W. (1982), “Marketing and Product Liability: A Review and Update,”Journal of Marketing46 (Summer), 69–78.
Schuler v. Union News Co. (1936), 4N.E.2d 465 (Mass.).
80.
ShostackG. Lynn (1987), “Service Positioning through Structural Change,”Journal of Marketing51 (Jan.), 34–43.
81.
Sicilano v. Capitol City Shows, Inc. (1984), 475 A. 2d 19 (N.H.).
82.
SilpakitPatriya and FiskRaymond P. (1985), “‘Participatizing’ the Service Encounter: A Theoretical Framework,” in Services Marketing in a Changing Environment, BlochT.M., UpahG.D., and ZeithamlV.A., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 117–21.
83.
Silverhart v. Mt. Zion Hospital (1971), 20 Cal.App.3d 1022, 98 Cal.Rptr. 187.
84.
Simon v. Zipperstein (1986), C.P. No. 82-2777, slip op. (Ohio Ct. App.).
85.
SmithRuth A. and HoustonMichael J. (1983), “Script-Based Evaluations of Satisfaction with Services,” in Emerging Perspectives in Services Marketing, BerryL.L., ShostackG.L., and UpahG.D., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 59–62.
86.
SolomonMichael R., SurprenantCarol, CzepielJohn A., and GutmanEvelyn G. (1985), “A Rule Theory Perspective on Dyadic Interactions: The Service Encounter,”Journal of Marketing49 (Winter), 99–111.
87.
SurprenantCarol F. and SolomonMichael R. (1985), “Dimensions of Personalization,” in Services Marketing in a Changing Environment, BlochT.M., UpahG.D., and ZeithamlV.A., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 56–59.
88.
SurprenantCarol F. and SolomonMichael R. (1987), “Predictability and Personalization in the Service Encounter,”Journal of Marketing51 (April), 86–96.
89.
Thomas v. St. Joseph Hospital (1981), 618 S.W.2d 791 (Tex. Civ. App.), writ ref'd n.r.e.
90.
Time (1986), “Sorry, Your Policy Is Cancelled,” (March 24), 16–20, 23–26.
91.
Turner v. General Motors Corp. (1979), 584 N.W.2d 844 (Tex.).
92.
UhlKenneth P. and UpahGregory D. (1983), “The Marketing of Services: Why and How Is It Different?” in Research in Marketing6, ShethJ.N., ed. New York: Elsevier, 44–48.
93.
Uniform Commercial Code (1978), American Law Institute.
94.
U.S. News & World Report (1985), “As Liability-Insurance Squeeze Hits Everyone” (Oct. 7), 56–57.
95.
U.S. News & World Report (1986), “Sky-High Damage Suits” (Jan. 27), 35–39, 42–43.
96.
Vandermark v. Ford Motor Co. (1965), 61 Cal.2d 256, 37 Cal.Rptr. 896, 391 P.2d 168.
97.
VenkatesanM. and AndersonBeverlee B. (1985), “Time Budgets and Consumer Services,” in Services Marketing in a Changing Environment, BlochT.M., UpahG.D., and ZeithamlV.A., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 52–55.
98.
WestfallPamela T. (1986), “Hepatitis, AIDS and the Blood Product Exemption from Strict Products Liability in California: A Reassessment,”Hastings Law Journal37 (July), 1101–72.
99.
WeynaTerry M. (1981), “Dubin v. Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center: Seeing through the Product/Service Distinction,”Insurance Counsel Journal48 (July), 399–410.
100.
Winans v. Rockwell International Corp. (1983), 705 F.2d 1449 (5th Cir.).
101.
WunschJohn C. (1983), “The Definition of a Product for the Purposes of Section 402A,”Insurance Counsel Journal50 (July), 344–64.
102.
ZeithamlValerie A. (1981), “How Consumer Evaluation Processes Differ between Goods and Services,” in Marketing of Services, DonnellyJ.H. and GeorgeW.R., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 186–90.
103.
ZeithamlValerie A., ParasuramanA., and BerryLeonard L. (1985), “Problems and Strategies in Services Marketing,”Journal of Marketing49 (Spring), 33–46.
