Presented here are the advantages and disadvantages of using the increasingly controversial tactic of televised political advertising. An agenda for needed research to shed light on this issue is put forward, along with an articulation of several public policy options for adjusting the existing process.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArtertonF. Christopher (1984), Media Politics—The News Strategies of Presidential Campaigns.Massachusetts: Lexington Books.
2.
AtkinCharles K., BowenLawrence, NaymanOguz B., and SheinkopfKenneth G. (1973), “Quality Versus Quantity in Televised Political Ads,”Public Opinion Quarterly37 (Spring), 209–24.
3.
AtkinCharles K. and HealdGary (1976), “Effects of Political Advertising,”Public Opinion Quarterly40 (Summer), 216–28.
4.
BlumenthalSidney (1980), The Permanent Campaign.New York: Simon and Schuster.
5.
BlumenthalSidney (1981), “Marketing the President,”New York Times Magazine, (Sept. 13), 435.
6.
BoddewynJ.J. (1985), “Advertising Self-Regulation: Private Government and Agent of Public Policy,”Journal of Public Policy and Marketing4, 129–42.
7.
BowersJ. A. (1972), “Issues and Personality Information in Newspaper Political Advertising,”Journalism Quarterly49, no. 3, 552–56.
8.
BowersJ. A. (1973), “Newspaper Political Advertising and Agenda Setting Function,”Journalism Quarterly50, no. 3, 552–56.
9.
BroomGlen M. (1978), “Coorientational Measurement of Public Issues,”Public Relations Review (Winter), 110–19.
10.
CaywoodClarke L. and LaczniakGene R. (1985), “Unethical Political Advertising: Decision Considerations for Policy and Evaluation,” in Marketing Communications—Theory and Research, HoustonMichael J. and LutzRichard J., eds. AMA Proceedings Series, 37–41.
11.
ChaffeeSteven H. (1972), “The Interpersonal Context of Communications,” in Current Perspectives in Mass Communication Research, KlineF. Gerald and TichenonPhillip J. eds. California: Sage.
12.
ChaffeeSteven H. (1980), “Mass Media Effects—New Research Perspective,”Mass Communication Review Yearbook.California: Sage, 77–101.
13.
ColfordSteven W. (1985), “No Ad Curbs: …,”Advertising Age (Dec. 2).
14.
ColfordSteven W. (1986), “Pols Accentuated Negative,”Advertising Age (Nov. 10), 3.
15.
DeFleurMelvin L. and Ball-RokeachSandra (1975), Theories of Mass Communications.New York: David McKay Company.
16.
DeVriesWalter (1975), “Taking the Voter's Pulse,” in The Political Image Merchants’ Strategies for the Seventies.HiebertRay E., ed. Washington D.C.: Acropolis Books.
17.
DiamondEdwin and BatesStephen (1984), The Spot: The Rise of Political Advertising on Television.Massachusetts: The MIT Press.
18.
ElebashCamille and RoseneJames (1982), “Issues in Political Advertising in a Deep South Gubernatorial Race,”Journalism Quarterly59 (Autumn), 420–23.
19.
EngelJames F. and BlackwellRoger D. (1982), Consumer Behavior, Fourth ed., Illinois: Dryden Press.
20.
EngelJames F., WarshawMartin R., and KinnearThomas C. (1986), Promotional Strategy, 6th ed. Homewood, Ill.: Richard D. Irwin.
21.
FaberRonald J. and StoreyM. Claire (1984), “Recall of Information From Political Advertising,”Journal of Advertising13, no. 3, 39–44.
22.
FarneyDennis (1986), “Victor in Nasty Texas Governor's Race …,”The Wall Street Journal (Oct. 27), 52.
23.
FialkaJohn J. (1986), “Intense Mudslinging in South Dakota …,”The Wall Street Journal (Nov. 15), 60.
24.
FialkaJohn J. (1987), “House Incumbents …,”The Wall Street Journal (April 8), 58.
25.
GarramoneGina M. (1984), “Voter Responses to Negative Political Ads,”Journalism Quarterly61 (Summer), 250–59.
26.
GraberDorothy (1976), “Effects of Incumbency in Covering Patterns in 1972 Presidential Campaigns,”Journalism Quarterly53, no. 3, 497–508.
27.
GraberDorothy (1980), Mass Media and American Politics.Washington D.C.: Congressional Quarterly Press.
28.
HillDavid B. (1984), “Political Campaigns and Madison Avenue: A Wavering Partnership,”Journal of Advertising13, no. 3, 21–26, 58.
29.
HofstetterRichard C. and ZurkinCliff (1979), “TV Network News and Advertising in the Nixon and McGovern Campaigns,”Journalism Quarterly56 (Spring), 106–15.
30.
House Bill 2490 (1983), 96th Congress, 2d. Session.
31.
House Bill 5307 (1985), 98th Congress, 2nd Session.
32.
HowardJohn A. and ShethJagdish N. (1969), The Theory of Buyer Behavior.New York: John Wiley and Sons.
33.
HumkeRonald G., SchmittRaymond L. and GuppStanley E. (1975), “Candidates, Issues and Party in Newspaper Political Advertisements,”Journalism Quarterly49 no. 3, 499–504.
34.
JacobsonGary C. (1978), “The Effects of Campaign Spending in Congressional Elections,”The American Political Science Review36, no. 3, 157–70.
35.
JoslynRichard A. (1980), “The Content of Political Spot Ads,”Journalism Quarterly57 (Spring), 92–98.
36.
KastenRobert (1987), U.S. Senator (R. WI), Interview with author (Jan. 30), Madison, Wisconsin.
37.
KaidLynda Lee (1976), “Measure of Political Advertising,”Journal of Advertising Research16 (Oct.), 49–53.
38.
KaidLynda Lee and SandersKeith R. (1978), “Political Television Commercials …,”Communication Research.5, no. 1, 57–70.
39.
KatzJeffrey L. (1986), “Negative Attacks Cited in Lower Senate Voting,”The Milwaukee Journal (Nov. 6), 1, 19A.
40.
KlineF. Gerald (1972), “Theory in Mass Communication Research,” in Current Perspectives in Mass Communication Research, KlineF.G. and TichenorP.J. eds. California: Sage.
41.
LaczniakGene R., LuschRobert F. and MurphyPatrick E. (1979), “Social Marketing: Its Ethical Dimensions,”Journal of Marketing43 (Spring), 29–36.
42.
LaczniakGene R., LuschRobert F. and StrangWilliam A. (1981), “Ethical Marketing: Perceptions of Economic Goods and Social Problems,”Journal of Macromarketing1 (Spring), 49–57.
43.
LatimerMargaret K. (1985), “Political Advertising for Federal and State Elections: Images or Substance?”Journalism Quarterly62 (Winter), 861–68.
44.
LewinKurt (1958), “Group Decision and Social Change,” in Readings in Social Psychology, MaccobyEleanor, eds. New York: Henry Holt.
45.
McCombsMaxwell F. and ShawDonald I. (1972), “The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media,”Public Opinion Quarterly36 (Summer), 176–87.
46.
MeadowRobert G. and SigelmanLee (1982), “Some Effects and Noneffects of Campaign Commercials: An Experimental Study,”Political Behavior4, no. 2, 163–75.
47.
MerrittSharyne (1984), “Negative Political Advertising: Some Empirical Findings,”Journal of Advertising13, no. 3, 27–38.
48.
Mills v. Alabama (1966), 384 U.S. 214, 16 L. Ed. 2d 484, 565. Ct. 1434, 1 Media L.R. 1334.
49.
MulderRonald (1979), “The Effects of Televised Political Ads in the 1975 Chicago Mayoral Election,”Journalism Quarterly56 (Summer), 336–40.
50.
NewmanBruce I. and ShethJagdiah N. (1985), “A Model of Primary Voter Behavior,”Journal of Consumer Research12 (Sept.), 178–87.
51.
NicosiaFrancesco M. (1966), Decision Processes: Marketing and Advertising Implications, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
52.
OgilvyDavid (1983), Ogilvy on Advertising.New York: Vintage Books, 213.
53.
O'KeefeGarrett J. (1980), “Political Malaise and Reliance on Media,”Journalism Quarterly57 (Spring), 122–28.
54.
O'Leary/Kamber Report, “Negative Campaign Advertising: Pro and Con,” 1 (5).
55.
PackardVance (1957), The Hidden Persuaders.New York: D.D. McKay Company.
56.
PaldaK.S., (1975), “The Effect of Expenditure in Political Science,”Journal of Law and Economics, (Dec.), 745–71.
57.
PattersonThomas E. and McClureRobert D. (1973), Political Advertising: Voter Reaction to Televised Political Commercials.New Jersey: Citizens’ Research Foundation.
58.
Postal v. Schwartz, (1976), 423 U.S. 1041, 46 L. Ed. 2d 630, 965. Ct. 763.
59.
ReidLeonard N. and SoleyLawrence C. (1983), “Promotional Spending Effects in High Involvement Elections: An Examination of the Voter Involvement Explanation,”Journal of Advertising12, no. 2, 43–50.
60.
RestonJames (1986), “Campaign ‘86 was a Disgrace to Democracy …,”The Milwaukee Journal (Nov. 6), 21A.
61.
RobertsSteven V. (1986), “Politicking Goes High-Tech,”The New York Times Magazine (Nov. 22), 38.
62.
RothschildMichael L. (1978), “Political Advertising: A Neglected Policy Issue in Marketing,”Journal of Marketing Research15, no. 1, 58–71.
63.
RotzollKim B. and HaefnerJames E. (1986), Advertising in Contemporary Society.Cincinnati: Southwestern Publishing Co.
64.
RustRonald T., BajajMukesh, and HaleyGeorge (1984), “Efficient and Inefficient Media for Political Campaign Advertising,”Journal of Advertising, 13, no. 3, 45–49.
65.
SabatoLarry J. (1981), The Rise of Political Consultants.New York: Basic Books, Inc.
66.
SchlesingerArthurJr. (1986), “Election Aftermath: Money and Meaning,”The Wall Street Journal (Nov. 18), 36.
67.
SchrammWilber L. and RobertsDonald P. (1971), The Process and Effects of Mass Communication.New York: Random House.
68.
Senate Bill 2509 (1985), 98th Congress, 2nd Session.
69.
ShribmanDavid (1987), “Conduct Code Barring Party Bashing…”The Wall Street Journal (March 12), 62.
SoleyLawrence C. and ReidLeonard N. (1982), “Promotional Expenditures in U.S. Congressional Elections,”Journal of Marketing and Public Policy1, 147–55.
72.
SorensonTheodore C. (1984), A Different Kind of Presidency.New York: Harper and Row.
73.
SurlinStuart and GordonThomas F. (1976), “Selective Exposure and Retention of Political Advertising,”Journal of Advertising1, 32–37, 44.
74.
SurlinStuart and GordonThomas F. (1977), “How Values Affect Attitudes Toward Direct Reference Political Advertising,”Journalism Quarterly54 (Spring), 89–98.
75.
SzybilloGeorge J. and HartenbaumRonald F. (1976), “Political Advertising and the Broadcast Media,”Journal of Advertising5, no. 4, 42–46.
76.
TaylorPaul (1986), “Accentuating the Negative…”The Washington Post National Weekly Edition, (Oct. 20), 6–8.
77.
TaylorPaul (1985), “Incumbents Take Negative View of Election Ads,”The Milwaukee Journal, (Nov. 28), 38.
78.
TaylorStuartJr. (1987), “Citing Chronic Deadlock, Panel Urges Altering Political Structure,”The New York Times, (Jan. 11), 1, 10.
79.
The Wall Street Journal (1986), “Voter Turnout of 37.3% was the lowest since 1942,” (Nov. 6), 19.
80.
TribeLaurence H. (1978), American Constitutional Law.New York: The Foundation Press, Inc.
81.
USA Today (1986), “Garvey Outspent, Undaunted,” (Nov. 6), 2C.
82.
Vanasco v. Schwartz, (1974, CA2 NY) 506 F2d 524, on remand Vanasco v. Schwartz, (1975, ED NY) 401 F. Supp. 87, affd. Schwartz v. Vanasco, (1976), 423 U.S. 1041, 46 L. Ed. 2d 630;, 96 S.Ct. 763, and affd. Schwartz v. Postal, (1976), 423 U.S. 1041, 46 L. Ed. 2d 630, 96 S.Ct. 763.
83.
Wilson v. Superior Court of Los Angeles County, 13 Cal. 3d 652 119 Cal. Rptrs 468 532 P.2d 166 (1976).
