Financial Education Effects on Financial Behavior and Well-Being: The Mediating Roles of Improved Objective and Subjective Financial Knowledge and Parallels in Physical Health
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online October, 2024
Financial Education Effects on Financial Behavior and Well-Being: The Mediating Roles of Improved Objective and Subjective Financial Knowledge and Parallels in Physical Health
How does financial education lead to improved financial behavior and higher financial well-being? An influential Consumer Financial Protection Bureau model introduced in 2015 proposes that the goal of financial education is to improve financial well-being and that financial education does so by increasing financial knowledge, which improves financial behavior, which improves financial well-being. In this study, the authors test links in the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau model, examining the differential roles of objective and subjective knowledge. They also test whether an analogous model might capture effects of physical health education on physical health knowledge, behavior, and well-being. They report a quasi-experiment comparing changes in financial and physical health knowledge, behavior, and well-being at two time points in a semester for students enrolled in a personal finance class, a personal health class, or neither. This study reports the first causal estimates of flow from financial education to financial knowledge to financial behaviors to a validated measure of subjective financial well-being. Financial education caused large changes in both objective and subjective knowledge. Yet only subjective knowledge mediated the large effects of financial education on changes in downstream behaviors. The authors find weaker but similar results for physical health. The findings suggest that financial education efforts should be refocused to foster subjective knowledge and improved behavior.
AlbaJoseph W.HutchinsonJ. Wesley (1987), “Dimensions of Consumer Expertise,” Journal of Consumer Research, 13 (4), 411–54.
2.
AlbaJoseph W.HutchinsonJ. Wesley (2000), “Knowledge Calibration: What Consumers Know and What They Think They Know,” Journal of Consumer Research, 27 (2), 123–56.
3.
AllgoodSamWalstadWilliam B. (2016), “The Effects of Perceived and Actual Financial Literacy on Financial Behaviors,” Economic Inquiry, 54 (1), 675–97.
4.
AndersonAndersBakerForestRobinsonDavid T. (2017), “Precautionary Savings, Retirement Planning and Misperceptions of Financial Literacy,” Journal of Financial Economics, 126 (2), 383–98.
5.
AndersonLaurelSpanjolJelenaJeffriesJosephine GoOstromAmy L.BakerCourtney NationsBoneSterling A.DowneyHilaryMendeMartinRappJustine M. (2016), “Responsibility and Well-Being: Resource Integration Under Responsibilization in Expert Services,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 36 (1), 1–18.
6.
AngristJoshua D.PischkeJörn-Steffen (2008), Mostly Harmless Econometrics. Princeton University Press.
7.
AtlasStephenPortoNiltonWeirMichael J.XiaoJing Jian (2019), “Financial Education and Financial Confidence Among Young Adults,” paper presented at the American Council on Consumer Interests Conference, Washington, DC (May 21–23).
8.
AtlasStephenPortoNiltonXiaoJing Jian (2018), “Financial Education and Confidence in Financial Knowledge,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 46, GershoffAndrewKozinetsRobertWhiteTiffany, eds. Association for Consumer Research, 23–27.
9.
BayukJuliaAltobelloSuzanne A. (2019), “Can Gamification Improve Financial Behavior? The Moderating Role of App Expertise,” International Journal of Bank Marketing, 37 (4), 951–75.
10.
BeardenWilliam O.HardestyDavid M.RoseRandall L. (2001), “Consumer Self Confidence: Refinements in Conceptualization and Measurement,” Journal of Consumer Research, 28 (1), 121–34.
11.
BiehalGabrielChakravartiDipankar (1983), “Information Accessibility as a Moderator of Consumer Choice,” Journal of Consumer Research, 10 (1), 1–14.
12.
BirnbaumMichael H.MellersBarbara A. (1979), “One-Mediator Model of Exposure Effects Is Still Viable,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37 (6), 1090–96.
13.
BishopWendy P.Craddock LeeSimon J.SkinnerCelette SuggJonesTiffany M.McCallisterKatherineTiroJasmin A. (2016), “Validity of Single-Item Screening for Limited Health Literacy in English and Spanish Speakers,” American Journal of Public Health, 106 (5), 889–92.
14.
BoltonLisa E.BhattacharjeeAmitReedAmericus (2015), “The Perils of Marketing Weight-Management Remedies and the Role of Health Literacy,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 34 (1), 50–62.
15.
BoltonLisa E.BloomPaul N.CohenJoel B. (2011), “Using Loan Plus Lender Literacy Information to Combat One-Sided Marketing of Debt Consolidated Loans,” Journal of Marketing Research, 48, S51–59.
16.
BrownMetaGrigsbyJohnvan der KlaauwWilbertWenJayaZafarBasit (2016), “Financial Education and the Debt Behavior of the Young,” Review of Financial Studies, 29 (9), 2490–522.
17.
BruggenElisabeth C.HogreveJensHilmlundMariaKabadayiSertanLofgrenMartin (2017), “Financial Well-Being: A Conceptualization and Research Agenda,” Journal of Business Research, 79, 228–37.
18.
BrugiaviniAgarCavapozziDaniloMarioPadulaPettinicchiYuri (2020), “On the Effect of Financial Education on Financial Literacy: Evidence from a Sample of College Students,” Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, 19 (3), 344–52.
19.
CarlsonJay P.VincentLeslie H.HardestyDavid M.BeardenWilliam O. (2009), “Objective and Subjective Knowledge Relationships: A Quantitative Analysis of Consumer Research Findings,” Journal of Consumer Research, 35 (5), 864–76.
20.
CarpenaFenellaColeShawnShapiroJeremyZiaBilal (2019), “The ABCs of Financial Education: Experimental Evidence on Attitudes, Behavior, and Cognitive Biases,” Management Science, 65 (1), 346–69.
ChenGiladGullyStanley M.EdenDov (2001), “Validation of a New General Self-Efficacy Scale,” Organizational Research Methods, 4 (1), 62–83.
23.
ChinAlyciaWilliamsAlanna K. (2020), “Take-Up of Financial Education: Demographic Characteristics and Prior Knowledge,” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 39 (3), 313–33.
24.
ChopraFelix (2021), “Media Persuasion and Consumption: Evidence from the Dave Ramsey Show,” SSRN (December 23), https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3992358.
CookThomas D.CampbellDonald T. (1979), Quasi-Experimentation: Design & Analysis for Field Settings. Houghton Mifflin.
30.
CookThomas D.ReichardtCharles S. (1979), Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Evaluation Research. Sage.
31.
DholakiaUtpalTamLeonaYoonSunyeeWongNancy (2016), “The Ant and the Grasshopper: Understanding Personal Savings Orientation of Consumers,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (1), 134–55.
DrexlerAlejandroFischerGregSchoarAntoinette (2014), “Keeping It Simple: Financial Literacy and Rules of Thumb,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 6 (2), 1–31.
34.
ElgaddalNazikKramarowEllen A.ReubenCynthia A. (2022), “Physical Activity Among Adults Aged 18 and Over: United States, 2020,” NCHS Data Brief No. 443 (August), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics, https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db443.pdf.
GillManpreetSridharShrihariGrewalR. (2017), “Return on Engagement Initiatives: A Study of a Business-to-Business Mobile App,” Journal of Marketing, 81 (4), 45–66.
HadarLiatSoodSanjayFoxCraig R. (2013), “Subjective Knowledge in Consumer Financial Decisions,” Journal of Marketing Research, 50 (3), 303–16.
42.
HampsonSarah EEdmondsGrant W.GoldbergLewis (2018), “The Health Behavior Checklist: Factor Structure in Community Samples and Validity of a Revised Good Health Practices Scale,” Journal of Health Psychology, 24 (8), 1103–09.
HayesAndrew F. (2018), Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis, 2nd ed.Guilford Press.
45.
HaysRon D.HayashiToshiStewartAnita (1989), “A Five-Item Measure of Socially Desirable Response Set,” Educational and Psychological Measurement, 49 (3), 629–36.
46.
HornSamanthaJamisonJulianKarlanDeanZinmanJonathan (2023), “Five-Year Impacts of Group-Based Financial Education and Savings Promotion for Ugandan Youth,” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 28011 (October 2020, revised January 2023), https://doi.org/10.3386/w28011.
47.
HoutsCarrie R.KnollMelissa A.Z. (2020), “The Financial Knowledge Scale: New Analyses, Findings, and Development of a Short Form,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 54 (2), 775–800.
48.
HutchinsonJ. WesleyKamakuraWagner A.LynchJohn G.Jr. (2000), “Unobserved Heterogeneity as an Alternative Explanation for ‘Reversal’ Effects in Behavioral Research,” Journal of Consumer Research, 27 (3), 324–44.
49.
JacksonNickiWatersElizabeth (2004), “Criteria for the Systematic Review of Health Promotion and Public Health Interventions,” Health Promotion International, 20 (4), 367–74.
50.
KaiserTimLusardiAnnamariaMenkhoffLukasUrbanCarly (2022), “Financial Education Affects Financial Knowledge and Downstream Behaviors,” Journal of Financial Economics, 20 (2), 255–72.
51.
KaiserTimMenkhoffLukas (2020), “Financial Education in Schools: A Meta-Analysis of Experimental Studies,” Economics of Education Review, 78, 101930.
52.
KimKyoung TaeLeeJongheeHannaSherman D. (2020), “The Effects of Financial Literacy Overconfidence on the Mortgage Delinquency of US Households,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 54 (2), 517–40.
53.
KühnLucasBachertPhilipHildebrandClaudiaKunkelJuleReitermayerJörgWäscheHagenWollAlexander (2022), “Health Literacy Among University Students: A Systematic Review of Cross-Sectional Studies,” Frontiers in Public Health, 9, 680999.
54.
LeeJai MinLeeJongheeKimKyoung Tae (2020), “Consumer Financial Well-Being: Knowledge Is Not Enough,” Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 41 (2), 218–28.
55.
LiKathleen T (2020), “Statistical Inference for Average Treatment Effects Estimated by Synthetic Control Methods,” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 115 (532), 2068–83.
56.
LinJudy T.BumcrotChristopherMottolaGaryValdesOliviaGanemRobertKiefferChristineLusardiAnnamariaWalshGerri (2022), “Financial Capability in the United States: Highlights from the FINRA Foundation National Financial Capability Study,” 5th ed., FINRA Investor Education Foundation (July), https://www.FINRAFoundation.org/NFCSReport2021.
57.
LinchevskiLioraKutscherBilha (1998), “Tell Me with Whom You’re Learning, and I’ll Tell You How Much You’ve Learned: Mixed-Ability Versus Same-Ability Grouping in Mathematics,” Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 29 (5), 533–54.
58.
LindThereseAhmedAliSkagerlundKennyStrombackCamillaFastfjallDanielTinghogGustav (2020), “Competence, Confidence, and Gender: The Role of Objective and Subjective Financial Knowledge in Household Finance,” Journal of Family Economic Issues, 41, 626–38.
59.
LongAndrew R.FernbachPhilip M.De LangheBart (2018), “Circle of Incompetence: Sense of Understanding as an Improper Guide to Investment Risk,” Journal of Marketing Research, 55 (4), 474–88.
60.
LusardiAnnamariaMitchellOlivia S. (2014), “The Economic Importance of Financial Literacy: Theory and Evidence,” Journal of Economic Literature, 52 (1), 5–44.
61.
LusardiAnnamariaMitchellOlivia S.CurtoVilsa (2010), “Financial Literacy Among the Young,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 44 (2), 358–80.
62.
LustriaMia Liza A.NoarSeth M.CorteseJuliannvan SteeStephanie K.GlueckaufRobert L.LeeJunga (2013), “A Meta-Analysis of Web-Delivered Tailored Health Behavior Change Interventions,” Journal of Health Communication, 18 (9), 1039–69.
McKenzieDavid (2012), “Beyond Baseline and Follow-Up: The Case for More T in Experiments,” Journal of Development Economics, 99 (2), 210–21.
65.
McShaneBlakeley B.BradlowEric T.LynchJohn G.MeyerRobert J. (2024), “‘Statistical Significance’ and Statistical Reporting: Moving Beyond Binary,” Journal of Marketing, 88 (3), 1–19.
66.
MendeMartinvan DoornJenny (2015), “Coproduction of Transformative Services as a Pathway to Improved Customer Well-Being: Findings from a Longitudinal Study on Financial Counseling,” Journal of Service Research, 18 (3), 351–68.
67.
MillerMargaretReichelsteinJuliaSalasChristianZiaBilal (2014), “Can You Help Someone Become Financially Capable? A Meta-Analysis of the Literature,” World Bank Research Observer, 30 (2), 220–46.
68.
MoormanChristineDiehlKristinBrinbergDavidKidwellBlair (2004), “Subjective Knowledge, Search Locations, and Consumer Choice,” Journal of Consumer Research, 31 (3), 673–80.
69.
MrkvaKellenPosnerNathaniel A.ReeckCrystalJohnsonEric J. (2021), “Do Nudges Reduce Disparities? Choice Architecture Compensates for Low Consumer Knowledge?” Journal of Marketing, 85 (4), 67–84.
70.
Nagy-PénzesGabriellaVinczeFerencSándorJanosBíroEva (2020), “Does Better Health-Related Knowledge Predict Favorable Health Behavior in Adolescents?” International Journal of Environmental Research & Public Health, 17 (5), 1680.
NetemeyerRichard G.FernandesDanielWarmathDee (2024), “Financial Advice, Financial Self-Efficacy, and Financial Well-Being,” working paper.
74.
NetemeyerRichard G.WarmathDeeFernandesDanielLynchJohn G.Jr. (2018), “How Am I Doing? Perceived Financial Well-Being, Its Potential Antecedents, and Its Relation to Overall Well-Being,” Journal of Consumer Research, 45 (1), 68–89.
75.
NutbeamDon (2008), “The Evolving Concept of Health Literacy,” Social Science & Medicine, 67 (12), 2072–78.
76.
OsborneRichardBatterhamRoy W.ElsworthGerald R.HawkinsMelanieBuchbinderRachelle (2013), “The Grounded Psychometric Development and Initial Validation of the Health Literacy Questionnaire,” BMC Public Health, 13 (1), 1–17.
77.
PunjGirish N.StaelinRichard (1983), “A Model of Consumer Information Search Behavior for New Automobiles,” Journal of Consumer Research, 9 (4), 366–80.
RatzanScott C.ParkerRuth M. (2000), “Introduction,” in National Library of Medicine Current Bibliographies in Medicine: Health Literacy, SeldenC.R.ZornM.RatzanS.C.ParkerR.M., eds. National Institutes of Health, v–vii.
80.
RemundDavid L (2010), “Financial Literacy Explicated: The Case for a Clearer Definition in an Increasingly Complex Economy,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 44 (2), 276–95.
81.
RiitsaluLeonoreMurakasRein (2019), “Subjective Financial Knowledge, Prudent Behaviour and Income: The Predictors of Financial Well-Being in Estonia,” International Journal of Bank Marketing, 37 (4), 934–50.
82.
RobbCliff A.WoodyardAnn S. (2011), “Financial Knowledge and Best Practice Behavior,” Journal of Financial Counseling and Planning, 22 (1), 60–70.
83.
RyuSoominFanLu (2023), “The Relationship Between Financial Worries and Psychological Distress Among U.S. Adults,” Journal of Family & Economic Issues, 44 (1), 16–33.
84.
SchickedanzAdamPeralesLorraineHolguinMoniqueRhone-CollinsMichelleRobinsonHelahTehraniNiloufarSmithLynneChungPaul J.SzilagyiPeter G. (2023), “Clinic-Based Financial Coaching and Missed Pediatric Preventive Care: A Randomized Trial,” Pediatrics, 151 (3), e2021054970.
85.
SeridoJoyceShimSoyeonTangChuanyi (2013), “A Developmental Model of Financial Capability: A Framework for Promoting a Successful Transition to Adulthood,” International Journal of Behavioral Development, 37 (4), 287–97.
86.
Sexton-RadekKathy (2016), “An Examination of College Student Health Knowledge,” Journal of Health Education Research and Development, 4 (3), 1–3.
87.
ShadishWilliam R.CookThomas D.CampbellD. Thomas (2002), Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference. Houghton Mifflin.
88.
ShephardDaniel D.KanezaYves V.MoclairPaul (2017), “What Curriculum? Which Methods? A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial of Social and Financial Education in Rwanda,” Children and Youth Services Review, 82, 310–20.
89.
SimmonsCarolyn J.LynchJohn G.Jr. (1991), “Inference Effects Without Inference Making? Effects of Missing Information on Discounting and use of Presented Information,” Journal of Consumer Research, 17 (4), 477–91.
90.
SimondsScott K. (1974), “Health Education as Social Policy,” Health Education Monographs, 2(1, Suppl.), 1–10.
91.
SkimmyhornWilliam L.DaviesEvan R.MunDavidMitchellBrian (2016), “Assessing Financial Education Methods: Principles vs. Rules-of-Thumb Approaches,” Journal of Economic Education, 47 (3), 193–210.
92.
SnyderLeslie B.HamiltonMark A.MitchellElizabeth W.Kiwanuka-TondoJamesFleming-MiliciFranProctorDwayne (2004), “A Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Mediated Health Communication Campaigns on Behavior Change in the United States,” Journal of Health Communication, 9 (Suppl. 1), 71–96.
93.
StiermanBryanAffulJosephCarrollMargaret D.ChenTe-ChingDavyOrlandoFinkStevenFryarCheryl D.GuQiupingHalesCraig M.HughesJeffery P.OstchegaYechiamStorandtRenee J.AkinbamiLara J.. (2021), “National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2017–March 2020 Prepandemic Data Files, Development of Files and Prevalence Estimates for Selected Health Outcomes,” National Health Statistics Reports No. 158 (June 14), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics, https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhsr/nhsr158-508.pdf.
94.
SussmanAbigail B.HershfieldHal E.NetzerOded (2023), “Consumer Financial Decision Making: Where We’ve Been and Where We’re Going,” Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 8 (4), 365–72.
95.
TransUnion (2023), “Credit Card and Unsecured Personal Loan Balances Remain at or Near-Record Levels as Consumers Navigate Challenging Economic Climate,” (May 11), https://newsroom.transunion.com/q1-2023-ciir/.
96.
UbelPeter A. (2019), Sick to Debt: How Smarter Markets Lead to Better Care. Yale University Press.
VozenilekJohnHuffStephen J.ReznekM. MartinGordonJames A. (2004), “See One, Do One, Teach One: Advanced Technology in Medical Education,” Academic Emergency Medicine, 11 (11), 1149–54.
100.
WangYanwenZhaiMuxinLynchJohn G.Jr. (2023), “Cashing Out Retirement Savings at Job Separation,” Marketing Science42 (4), 679–703.
101.
WardAdrianLynchJohn G.Jr. (2019), “On a Need-to-Know Basis: Divergent Trajectories of Financial Expertise in Couples and Effects on Independent Search and Decision Making,” Journal of Consumer Research, 45 (5), 1013–36.
102.
WardAdrianZhengJianqing (Frank)BroniarczykSusan M. (2022), “I Share, Therefore I Know? Sharing Online Content—Even Without Reading It—Inflates Subjective Knowledge,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 33 (3), 1–20.
103.
WatersErika A.BiddleCaitlanKaphingstKimberly A.SchofieldElizabethKiviniemiMarc T.OromHeatherLiYuelinHayJennifer L. (2018), “Examining the Interrelations Among Objective and Subjective Health Literacy and Numeracy and Their Associations with Health Knowledge,” Journal of General Internal Medicine, 33, 1945–53.
104.
WellerJoshua A.DieckmannNathan F.TuslerMartinMertzC.K.BurnsWilliam J.PetersEllen (2012), “Development and Testing of an Abbreviated Numeracy Scale: A Rasch Analysis Approach,” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 26 (2), 198–212.
105.
WernerEmilyBetzHeather Hayes (2020), “Knowledge of Physical Activity and Nutrition Recommendations in Students,” Journal of American College Health, 70 (2), 340–46.
106.
WoodStacy L.LynchJohn G.Jr. (2002), “Prior Knowledge and Complacency in New Product Learning,” Journal of Consumer Research, 29 (3), 416–26.
107.
WoodyardAnn S.RobbCliff A. (2016), “Consideration of Financial Satisfaction: What Consumers Know, Feel and Do from a Financial Perspective,” Journal of Financial Therapy, 7 (2), 4.
108.
XiaoJing JianAhnSun YoungSeridoJoyceShimSoyeon (2014), “Earlier Financial Literacy and Later Financial Behaviour in College Students,” International Journal of Consumer Studies, 38 (6), 593–601.
109.
XiaoJing JianChenChengChenFuzhong (2014), “Consumer Financial Capability and Financial Satisfaction,” Social Indicators Research, 118 (1), 415–32.
110.
ZhangFanOrPeggy Pui-LaiChungJoanne Wai-Yee (2020), “The Effects of Health Literacy in Influenza Vaccination Competencies Among Community-Dwelling Older Adults in Hong Kong,” BMC Geriatrics, 20 (1), 1–7.
111.
ZhaoXinshuLynchJohn G.Jr.ChenQimei (2010), “Reconsidering Baron and Kenny: Myths and Truths About Mediation Analysis,” Journal of Consumer Research, 37 (2), 197–206.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
