Integration for persons with disabilities is progressing very slowly in the Federal Republic of Germany, in contrast with other European countries. This article provides an overview of European trends and reviews German disability services, emphasizing their historical and political context.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Amir, Y. (1969). Contact hypothesis in ethnic relations.Psychological Bulletin, 71, 319–343.
2.
Baker, D., Esmer, Y., Lenhardt, G.,& Meyer, J. (1985). Effects of immigrant workers on educational stratification in Germany.Sociology of Education58, 213–227.
3.
Biklen, D. (1985). Achieving the complete school: Effective strategies for mainstreaming.New York: Teacher's College Press.
4.
Bjarnasson, D. (1990, June). A report on the first formal experiment in integration of a severely disabled child into regular school in Iceland. Paper presented at the International Conference on Integration in School, Leisure, and Transition to Work, The Institute for Integration, Stockholm.
5.
Bodelschwinghsche Anstalten Bethel. (1990). Leben in Bethel (Heft 2): Menschen mit Behinderungen (Life in Bethel. Vol. 2: People with handicaps).Bielefeld, Germany: Bodelschwinghsche Anstalten Bethel, Dankort, Material-verwaltung.
6.
Bundesminsisterium fur Bildung und Wissenschaft (1982). Modellvereuche BLK Behinderung: Gemeinsame [sic] Foerderung behinderter und nicht-behinderter Kinder und Juggendlicher in Schule und Kindergarten (Integration) (Model research BLK handicap: Common advancement of handicapped and nonhandicapped children and youth in school and kindergarten [integration]). Unpublished computerized list of federally subsidized projects, Natioanl Ministry of Science and Education, Bonn.
7.
Bundesvereinigung Lebenshilfe. (1990a, June). In Wirklich-keit noch schlimmer? (In reality even worse?).Die Leben-schilfe Zeitung, 3, p. 3.
8.
Bundesvereinigung Lebenshilfe. (1990b). Probleme im Zusammenhang mit der Ermittlung von Bedarfszahlen im Bereich des gemeinwesenintegrierten Wohnes erwach-sener Menschen mit einer geistigen Behinderung in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland(Problems associated with the ascertainment of persons with mental retardation in need of fully integrated residences in the Federal Republic of Germany). Marburg, Germany: Bundesvereinigung Lebenshilfe.
9.
Centre for Educational Research and Innovation (CERI). (1981). The education of the handicapped adolescent: Integration in the school.Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.
10.
Centre for Educational Research and Innovation (CERI). (in press). OECD report: Employment and disability.Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.
11.
Commission des Communautes Europeennes. (1980). Special education in the European Community. Luxembourg: Office Publications of the EEC. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 203548)
12.
Commission of the European Communities. (1980, May). The European Community and the handicapped: European file.Brussels: Directorate-General for Information.
13.
Dahrendorf, R. (1969). Society and democracy in Germany.New York: Anchor Books.
14.
Dietze, L. (1988). Der juristisch Aspekt: Das Recht des behinderten Kindes auf Besuch der allgemeinen Grund-schule und das Elternrecht (The legal aspect: The right of the handicapped child to attend regular primary school and parent rights). In M. Rosenberger(Ed.), Ratgeber gegen aussonderung (pp. 137–158). Heidelberg: Edition Schindele.
15.
Diniz, F., & Kropveld, P. (1983). Teacher training and special education in the eighties.Brussels: Association for Teacher Education in Europe. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 271 410)
16.
Donaldson, J. (1980). Changing attitudes toward handicapped persons: A review and analysis of research.Exceptional Children,46, 504–513.
17.
Economic and Social Committee. (1981). Opinion of the Economic and Social Committee on the situation andprob-lems of the handicapped.Brussels: European Economic Community-CES.
18.
Ellger-Ruttgardt, S. (1988). Die Hilfsschule im National-soziallismus und ihre Erforschung dutch die Behinderten-padagogik (The "help schools" in National Socialism and their investigation through special education). In W. Keim(Ed.), Padagogen und Padagogik in National Socialism Ein unerledigtes Problem der Erziehungswissenschaft (Paedagogs and Paedagogy in National Socialism-An unresolved problem for educational research). Frankfurt: Lang.
19.
Erath, P. (1987) Vergessen und milibraucht. "Lernbehin-derte"als Opfer allgemeinpadagogischer Ignoranz und sonderpadagogischer Eigeninteressen(Forgotten and ill-used. "Learning-handicapped" as the victims of general-educational ignorance and special-educational self: interests). Frankfurt: Lang.
20.
Evelyn und die Burokratie. (1990, May 9). Frankfurter Rundschau, p. 24.
21.
Ferro, N. (1990, June). Trends in philosophy andpractice. Paper presented at the International Conference on Integration in School, Leisure, and Transition to Work, The Institute for Integration, Stockholm.
22.
Feuser, G. (1985a). Gemeinsam Erziehung behinderter und nichtbehinderter Kinder (Integration) als Regelfall?! (The common education of handicapped and nonhandicapped children [integration] as usual practice?!). In G. Feuser & I. Wehrmann(Eds.), Informationen ZUT Gemeinsam Erziehung und Bildung dehinderter und nichtbehinderter Kinder (In tegration) in Kindergarten, Kinder-tagescheim und Schule (pp. 21–70). Bremen, Germany: Diakonisches Werk Bremen/Landesverband fur Ev. Kindertagesstatten in Bremen.
23.
Feuser, G. (1985b). Integration mufi in den Kopfen beginnen-Bedarf es einer eigenen Padagogik zur gemeinsamen Erziehung Behinderter and Nichtbehinderter? (Integration must begin in the head-Does each one need his own pedagogy for the common rearing of handicapped and nonhandicapped children?) In G. Feuser & I. Wehrmann(Eds.), Informationen zur Gemeinsam Erziehung und Bildung behinderter und nichtbehinderter Kinder (Integration) in Kindergarten, Kindertagesheim und Schule (pp. 14–21). Bremen, Germany: Diakonisches Werk Bremen/Landesverband fur Ev. Kindertagesstatten in Bremen.
24.
Feuser, G., & Wehrmann, I. (Eds.). (1985). Informationen zur Gemeinsam Erzlehung und Bildung bebinderter und nichtbehinderter Kinder (Integration) in Kindergarten, Kindertagesheim und Schule(Information on raising and educating handicapped and nonhandicapped children together [integration] in kindergarten, day-care centers, and school). Bremen, Germany: Diakonisches Werk Bremen/Landesverband fur Ev. Kindertagesstatten in Bremen.
25.
Frankfurt American High School. (1991). NCA report: The independent living classes. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Defense Dependents Schools, Frankfurt American High School.
26.
Für bessere Integration von geistig Behinderten (For better integration of the mentally handicapped). (1990, June 18). Frankfurter Rundschau, p . 22.
27.
Fussek, C. (1988). Wohnen ohne Heime-Ambulante Dienste Zur Vermeidung von Aussonderung am Beispiel der VIF in Munchen (Living without homes-ambulant services to avoid separation as seen in the example of the VIF in Munich). In M. Rosenburger(Ed.), Ratgeber gegen aussonderung (pp. 242–247). Heidelberg: Edition Schindele.
28.
Gallagher, H. (1989). The relevance of the Nazi euthanasia program to contemporary sociomedical dilemmas.International Rehabilitation Review, 40, 12–15.
29.
Gartner, A., Kerzner Lipsky, D., & Turnbull, A. (1991). Supporting families with a child with a disability: An international outlook.Baltimore: Brookes.
30.
Gaylord-Ross, R. (1987). School integration for students with mental handicaps: A cross-cultural perspective. TheEuropean Journal of Special Needs Education, 2(2), 117–129.
31.
Gerry, M. (1989). The Genoa approach to supporting the transition of young persons with disabilities from school to adult and working life.Washington, DC: The Fund for Equal Access to Scoiety.
32.
Gétz, B. (1988). (Neo)konservative Bildungspolitik (Neo-conservative education-politics). In K. Zah(Ed.), Treffen der BundesArbeitsGemeinschaft Eltern gegen Aussonderung von Kindern tnit Behinderungen (pp. 83–101). Reutlingen, Germany: Arbeitsgemeinschaft Integration Reutlingen.
33.
Grunewald, K. (1986). The intellectually handicapped in Sweden-New legislation in a bid for normalisation. Stockholm, Svenska Institutet.
34.
Haasen, K. (1990). The unification of Germany: Implications for the integration of individuals with developmental disabilities. University of Illinois at Chicago: University Affilliated Program in Developmental Disabilities.
35.
Hamilton, S.F. (1986). Excellence and the transition to work.Phi Delta Kappan,68(4), 239–242.
36.
Haupt, U. (1984). Die schulisce Integration von Behinderten (Integration of the handicapped in school). In U. Bleidick(Ed.), Theorie der Behindertenpadagogik: Hatld-buch der Sonderpiidagogik, Bd. I (pp. 1–66). Berlin: Marhold.
37.
Husen, T. (1983). Are standards in U.S. schools really lagging behind those in other countries?Phi Delta Kappan.64(7), 455–461.
38.
Jacobs, K. (1988). Das gegenwfrtige System der Berufsaus-bildung und Berufseingliederung von Menschen mit besonderen Lebenserschwernissen, inbesondere unter dem Aspekt der Beschaftigung in den Werkstatten fiir Behinderte (Today's system of vocational education and vocational incorporation in people with special living difficulties, especially with regard to aspect of occupation in workshops for the handicapped). In M. Rosen-berger(Ed.), Ratgeber gegen Aussonderung (pp. 176–197). Heidelberg: Edition Schindele.
39.
Jocheim, K.A. (1985). Quota system policy in the Federal Republic of Germany. In R. Habeck, D. Galvin, W. Frey, L. Chadderton, & D. Tate(Eds.), Economics and equity in the employment of people w ith disabilities.-International policies and practices (pp. 106–110). East Lansing: Michigan State University Center for International Rehabilitation.
40.
Johnson, D.W., & Johnson, R.T. (1980). Integrating handicapped students into the mainstream.Exceptional Children, 47, 90–98.
41.
Jorgenson, T.O. (1990, June). Learning for integration. Paper presented at the International Conference on Integration in School, Leisure, and Transition to Work, The Institute for Integration, Stockholm.
42.
Juul, K. (1978, May). Impressions from Anthroposophic communities. Paper presented at the annual international conference of The Council for Exceptional Children, Kansas City, Missouri. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 153 412)
43.
KerznerLipsky, D., & Gartner, A. (1989). Beyond separate education: Quality education for all.Baltimore: Brookes.
44.
Klee, E. (1985). Euthanasie im NS-Staat(Euthanasia in the National Socialist State). Frankfurt: Fischer Verlag.
45.
Konig, U. (1990, June 7) Gefangen, gequflt, und vergessen (Imprisoned, tormented, and forgotten). Stern, pp. 26-36.
46.
Kraeling, K. (1989). Was verstehen wir unter Wohnstatteu fur erwachsene Menschen mit geistiger Behinderung?(What do we mean by residences for adults with mental retardation?). Marburg, Germany: Bundesvereinigung Lebenshilfe.
47.
Krane, J. (1990). Gerechtigheit und Gleichbehandlung: Zum Stand der "Integration" in Norwegen und den USA (Justice and equal treatment: On the status of integration in Norway and the USA).Gemeinsam Leben, 8, 21–25.
48.
Lingens, H.G., & Lingens, B. (1980). Education in Germany: A quest for excellence(Fastback 140). Bloomington, IN: Phi Delta Kappa Educational Foundation.
49.
Marshall, S. (1989). The German Perspective.Comparative Education, 25(3), pp. 309–317.
50.
Muller-Munch I. (1990, October 30). Wdrterbuch des Unmenschen-Wieder geoffnet (Dictionary of inhumanity-opened again). Frankfurter Rundschau, p. 6.
51.
Murray-Seegert, C. (1989). Nasty girls, thugs, and humans like us. Baltimore: Brookes.
52.
Murray-Seegert, C., Claesson-Westberg, I., Cohen, J., Dan-goor, N., Kerzner-Lipsky, D., & Rothschild, S. (1987, October). Cross-culturalperspectives on community integration and employment: Israel, Sweden, the United States and West Germany. Paper presented at the annual conference of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, Chicago. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 296 503)
53.
Muth, J. (1988). Integration und gesellschaftliche Wertvor-stellungen (Integration and the assignment of social worth). In K. Zah(Ed.) 6. Treffen der BundesArbeits-Gemeinschaft Eltern gegen Aussonderung von Kindern mit Behinderungen (pp. 19–26). Reutlingen, Germany: Arbeitsgemeinschaft Integration Reutlingen.
54.
Niehoff, U. (1990). Tendenzen einer neuen (alten) Behinder-tenfeindlichkeit (Tendencies of a new [old] handicapped-enmity).Behindertenpiidagogik,29(1), 86–103.
55.
Peine, S. (1990, June 19). Gefuttert, gewaschen, verwahrt, aber nicht gefordert (Fed, washed, watched over, but not helped to improve). Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, p. D2.
56.
Preuss-Lausitz, U. (1988a). Bildungspolitische Aspekte der Integration in der Bundesrepublik (Educational-political aspects of integration in West Germany). In K. Zah(Ed.), 6. Treffen der BundesArbeitsGemeinschaft Eltern gegen Aussonderung von Kindern mit Behinderungen (pp. 10–18). Reutlingen, Germany: Arbeitsgemeinschaft Integration Reutlingen.
57.
Preuss-Lausitz, U. (1988b). Nichtaussondernde Schule-Ein Konzept fur die Zukunft. In M. Rosenberger(Ed.), Ratge-ber gegen aussonderung (pp. 94–98). Heidelberg: Edition Schindele.
58.
Ramisch-Kormann, B. (1990). Zur Bewahrung eines umfas-senden Bildungsbegriffes in Extremsituation angesichts der erneuten Forderung nach Euthanasie (Testing an all-embracing idea of education in confrontation with the extreme situation of the renewed call for euthanasia).Behindertenpiidagogik,29(1), 7–22.
59.
Reichmann, E. (1985, October). Geschichte undFormen der Aussonderung Behinderter (History and the forms of separating-out the handicapped). Paper presented at the Conference on Integration in Kindergarten and School, Diakonisches Werk Bremen, Breman, West Germany.
60.
Reiser, H. (1987). Stellenwert von integration Behinderter in der Grunen Bildungspolitik (The place of the integration of the handicapped in Green-party education politics). In B. Seliger(Ed.), Integration Behinderter Kinder in der Regelschule (pp. 7–14). Fulda: GAK Pub-likationen Nr. 3 (Fruhjahr).
61.
Roebke, C. (1988). Unser weg (Our way). In M. Rosenberger(Ed.), Ratgebergegen aussonderung (pp. 28–31). Heidelberg: Edition Schindele.
62.
Roebke, C. (1990, May). Grossere dynamik (Larger dynamics).BAG INFRO,5, pp. 20–22.
63.
Rosenberger, M. (1988). Eine Elternbewegung ist enstanden: ('Gemeinsam leben-Gemeinsam lernetl/Eltern gegen Assonderung." In M. Rosenberger(Ed.), Ratgeber gegen aussonderung (pp. 10–18). Heidelberg: Edition Schindele.
64.
Sailor, W. (in press). Successful approaches. In Centre for Educational Research and Innovation, OECD report: Employment and disability.Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.
65.
Sailor, W., Anderson, J., Halvorsen, A., Doering, K., Filler, J., & Gortz, L. (1989). The comprehensive local school: Regular education for all students with disabilities.Baltimore: Brookes.
66.
Sailor, W., Gerry, M., & Wilson, W. (in press). Disability and school integration. In T. Husen & T.N. Postlethwaite(Eds.), International encyclopedia of education: Research and studies(2nd suppl.). New York: Pergamon Press.
67.
Sander, A. (1988). Das bisherige Konzept SOnderpadagOg-ischer schulischer Forderung in kritischer Sicht (The up-to-now concept of special education school development from a critical viewpoint). In M. Rosenberger(Ed.), Ratgeber gegen Aussonderung (pp. 88–93). Heidelberg: Edition Schindele.
68.
Scheerengerger, R.C. (1983). A history of mental retardation.Baltimore: Brookes.
69.
Scheerenberger, R.C. (1987). A history of mental retardation: A quarter cen tury of progress.Baltimore: Brookes.
70.
Sengstock, W., Magerhans-Hurley, H., & Sprotte, A. (1990a). Germany, cradle of American special education.Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded, 25(1), 4–14.
71.
Sengstock, W., Magerhans-Hurley, H., & Sprotte, A. (1990b). The role of special education in the Third Reich.Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded,25, 225–236.
72.
Sonderschulen-"Bewahrt und differenziert" (1987, February 2), TAZ, p. 12.
73.
Turnbull, H., Turnbull, A., Bronicki, G., Summers, J.A., & Roeder-Gordon, C. (1989). Disability and the family: A guide to decisions for adulthood.Baltimore: Brookes.
74.
Will, M. (1984). Let us pause to reflect, but not too long.Exceptional Children,51, 11–16.
75.
Wolfensberger, W. (1981). The extermination of handicapped people in World War II Germany.Mental Retardation,19, 1–7.
76.
Wolfensberger, W. (1990). Book review (Racial hygiene: Medicine under the Nazis).American Journal on Mental Retardation,95, 362–367.
