More than 2 decades ago, Hallahan and Kauffman and others suggested a cross-categorical approach to teaching students identified with high-incidence disabilities (i.e., emotional— behavioral disabilities, learning disabilities, and mild intellectual disabilities) because their behavioral and academic characteristics were seen to be more similar than different. Since that time, more than 150 articles and other works have discussed and compared the characteristics of students across these high-incidence disability categories. This descriptive review examined 34 studies comparing various characteristics of students with high-incidence disabilities. The results indicate that students with emotional— behavioral disabilities, learning disabilities, and mild intellectual disabilities do not differ markedly in social adjustment, but do display considerably different cognitive and behavioral profiles. Implications for instruction and placement are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
*Affleck, J.Q., Edgar, E., Levine, P., & Kortering, L. (1990). Postschool status of students classified as mildly mentally retarded, learning disabled, or nonhandicapped: Does it get better with time?Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded , 25, 315—324.
2.
*Algozzine, B., Morsink, C.V., & Algozzine, K.M. (1998). What's happening in self-contained special education classrooms?Exceptional Children, 55, 259—265.
*Barona, A., Santos de Barona, M., & Faykus, S.P. (1993). The simultaneous effects of sociocultural variables and WISC-R factors on MR, LD, and nonplacement of ethnic minorities of special education. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded , 28, 66—74.
5.
Bateman, B.D. (1994). Who, how, and where: Special education's issues in perpetuity. The Journal of Special Education, 27, 509—520.
6.
Beirne-Smith, M., Ittenbach, R.F., & Patton, J.R. (2006). Mental retardation (7th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill/Prentice Hall.
7.
*Bernard, R., & Clarizio, H. (1981). Socioeconomic bias in special education placement decisions. Psychology in the Schools, 18, 178—183.
8.
*Botuck, S., Levy, J.M., & Rimmerman, A. (1996). Gender-related differences in placements rates of young adults with mental retardation and severe learning disabilities. International Journal of Rehabilitation Research. Internationale Zeitschrift fur Rehabilitationsforschung. Revue Internationale de Recherches de Readaptation , 19, 259—263.
9.
*Boucher, C.R., & Deno, S.L. (1979). Learning disabled and emotionally disturbed: Will the labels affect teacher planning?Psychology in the Schools , 16, 395—402.
10.
*Clarizio, H., & Bernard, R. (1981). Recategorized WISC-R scores of learning disabled children and differential diagnosis. Psychology in the Schools , 18, 5—12.
11.
Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum.
12.
Denning, C.B., Chamberlain, J.A., & Polloway, E.A. (2000). An evaluation of state guidelines for mental retardation: Focus on definition and classification practices. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities, 35, 226—232.
13.
*Downing, J.A., Simpson, R.L., & Myles, B.S. (1990). Regular and special educator perceptions of nonacademic skills needed by mainstreamed students with behavioral disorders and learning disabilities. Behavioral Disorders, 15, 217—226.
14.
*Elliott, S.N., & Boeve, K. (1987). Stability of WISC-R: An investigation of ethnic differences overtime. Educational and Psychological Measurement , 47, 461—465.
15.
*Elmquist, D.L., Morgan, D.P., & Bolds, P.K. (1992). Alcohol and other drug use among adolescents with disabilities. The International Journal of the Addictions , 27, 1475—1483.
16.
Epstein, M.H., & Sharma, J. (1998). Behavioral and emotional ratings scale: A strength-based approach to assessment. Austin, TX: PRO-ED.
17.
Forness, S.R., Kavale, K.A., Blum, I.M., & Lloyd, J.W. (1997). Mega-analysis of meta-analyses: What works in special education and related services. Teaching Exceptional Children, 30(4), 4—9.
18.
*Gadow, K.D., Sprafkin, J., & Grayson, P. (1990). The help—hurt game as a measure of aggression in children with leaning and behavior disorders. Learning and Individual Di ferences, 2, 337—351.
19.
Gajar, A.H. (1980). Characteristics across exceptional categories: EMR, LD, and ED. The Journal of Special Education, 14, 165-173.
20.
*Gelb, S.A., & Mizokawa, D.T. (1986). Special education and social structure: The commonality of “exceptionality.” American Educational Research Journal, 23, 543—557.
21.
Greenbaum, B.E., Dedrick, R.F., Friedman, R.M., Kutash, K., Brown, E.C., Lardieri, S.P., et al. (1996). National adolescent and child treatment study (NACTS): Outcomes for children with serious emotional and behavioral disturbance. Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders , 4, 130—146.
22.
Gresham, F.M., Elliot, S.N., & Black, F.L. (1987). Factor structure replication and bias investigation of the teacher rating of social skills. Journal of School Psychology, 17, 82—91.
23.
Hallahan, D.P., & Kauffman, J.M. (1976). Introduction to learning disabilities: A psycho-behavioral approach. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
24.
Hallahan, D.P., & Kauffman, J.M. (1977). Labels, categories, behaviors: ED, LD, and EMR reconsidered. The Journal of Special Education , 11, 139—149.
25.
*Handwerk, M.L., & Marshall, R.M. (1998). Behavioral and emotional problems of students with learning disabilities, serious emotional disturbance, or both conditions. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 31, 327— 338.
26.
*Jaben, T.H. (1986). Impact of instruction on behavior disordered and learning disabled students' creative behavior. Psychology in the Schools, 23, 401—405.
27.
Kauffman, J.M. (2005). Characteristics of emotional and behavioral disorders of children and youth (8th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
28.
Kauffman, J.M., & Landrum, T.J. (2006). Children and youth with emotional and behavioral disorders: A history of their education. Austin, TX: PRO-ED.
29.
Kavale, K.A. (2001). Meta-analysis: A primer. Exceptionality , 9, 175—184.
30.
*Leigh, J.E., Huntze, S.L., & Lamorey, S. (1995). Topical issues education: Teaching controversial or sensitive topics to students with learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 28, 353—363.
31.
*Levy, J.M., Murphy, B.S., Levy, P.H., Kramer, M.E., Rimmerman, A., & Botuck, S. (1993). Monitoring process and employment outcomes over time: The YAI Employment Project. Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities, 5, 167—179.
Luckasson, R., Coulter, D.L., Polloway, E.A., Reiss, S., Schalock, R.L., Snell, M.E., et al. (1992). Mental retardation: Definition, classification, and systems of supports. Washington, DC: American Association on Mental Retardation.
34.
*MacMillan, D.L., Gresham, F.M., & Bocian, K.M. (1998). Curing mental retardation and causing learning disabilities: Consequences of using various WISC-III tests to estimate aptitude of Hispanic students. Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment , 16, 36—54.
35.
*Margalit, M. (1989). Academic competence and social adjustment of boys with learning disabilities and boys with behavior disorders. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 41—50.
36.
*Margalit, M. (1995). Social skills learning for students with learning disabilities and students with behavior disorders. Educational Psychology, 15, 445—456.
37.
*Margalit, M., & Roth, Y.B. (1989). Strategic keyboard training and spelling improvement among children with learning disabilities and mental retardation. Educational Psychology, 9, 321—329.
38.
*McConaughy, S.H., Mattison, R.E., & Peterson, R.L. (1994). Behavioral/ emotional problems of children with serious emotional disturbances and learning disabilities . School Psychology Review, 23, 81—98.
39.
*Morgan, S.R. (1986). Locus of control in children labeled learning disabled, behaviorally disordered, and learning disabled/behaviorally disordered . Learning Disabilities Research, 2, 10—13.
40.
*Moore, S.R., & Simpson, R.L. (1983). Teacher—pupil and peer verbal interactions of learning disabled, behavior-disordered, and nonhandicapped students. Learning Disability Quarterly, 6, 273—282.
41.
O'Sullivan, P.J., Ysseldyke, J.E., Christenson, S.L., & Thurlow, M.L. (1990). Mildly handicapped elementary students' opportunity to learn during reading instruction in mainstream and special education settings . Reading Research Quarterly, 25, 131—146.
42.
Oswald, D.P., & Coutinho, M.J. (1996). Leaving school: The impact of state economic and demographic factors for students with serious emotional disturbance. Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders , 4, 114— 125.
43.
*Petersen, C.R., & Hart, D.H. (1978). Use of multiple discriminant function analysis in evaluation of a state-wide system for identification of educationally handicapped children. Psychological Reports, 43, 743—755.
44.
*Potter, M.L., Ysseldyke, J.E., Reagan, R.R., & Algozzine, B. (1983). Eligibility and classification decisions in educational settings: Issuing “passports” in a state of confusion. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 8, 146—157.
45.
Reid, R., Epstein, M.H., Pastor, D.A., & Ryser, G.R. (2000). Strengths-based assessment differences across students with LD and EBD. Remedial and Special Education, 21, 346—355.
46.
Reschly, D. J., Tilly, W. D., & Grimes, J. (Eds.). (1999). Special education in transition: Functional assessment and noncategorical programming. Longmont, CO: Sopris West.
47.
*Rimmerman, A., Botuck, S., & Levy, J.M. (1995). Job placement for individuals with psychiatric disabilities in supported employment. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 19, 37—43.
48.
*Rizzo, T.L., & Kirkendall, D.R. (1995). Teaching students with mild disabilities: What affects attitudes of future physical educators?Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 12, 205—216.
49.
Sabornie, E.J., Cullinan, D., Osborne, S.S., & Brock, L.M. (2005). Intellectual, academic, and behavioral functioning of students with high-incidence disabilities: A cross-categorical meta-analysis . Exceptional Children, 72, 47-63.
50.
*Simpson, R.L., & Myles, B. (1989). Parents' mainstreaming modification preferences for children with educable mental handicaps, behavior disorders, and learning disabilities. Psychology in the Schools, 26, 292—301.
51.
*Singh, N.N., Epstein, M.H., Stout, C., Luebke, J., & Ellis, C.R. (1994). Psychopharmacological intervention III: A comparison of teacher perceptions of psychotropic medication for students with learning disabilities or serious emotional disturbance. Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities, 6, 101—113.
52.
*Sindelar, P.T., King, M.C., Cartland, D., Wilson, R.J., & Meisel, C.J. (1985). Deviant behavior in learning disabled and behaviorally disordered students as a function of level and placement. Behavioral Disorders, 10, 105—112.
53.
*Slate, J.R. (1995). Discrepancies between IQ and index scores for a clinical sample of students: Useful diagnostic indicators?Psychology in the Schools, 32, 103—108.
54.
*Stern, R., Kendall, A., & Eberhard, P. (1991). Children of alcoholics in the schools: Where are they? Their representation in special education. Psychology in the Schools, 28, 116—123.
55.
Wagner, M. (1995). Outcomes for youths with serious emotional disturbance in secondary school and early adulthood. The Future of Children: Critical Issues for Children and Youths, 5, 90—112.
56.
Wang, M.C., & Bushman, B.J. (1999). Integrating results through meta-analytic review using SAS software. Cary, NC: SAS Institute.
57.
Wechsler, D. (1974). Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised . San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.
58.
Wortman, P.M. (1994). Judging research quality. In H. Cooper & L. V. Hedges (Eds.), The handbook of research synthesis (pp. 97—110). New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
59.
*Ysseldyke, J.E., & Algozzine, B. (1981). Diagnostic classification decisions as a function of referral information. The Journal of Special Education , 15, 429—435.
60.
*Ysseldyke, J.E., Thurlow, M.L., Christenson, S.L., & Muyskens, P. (1991). Classroom and home learning differences between students labeled as educable mentally retarded and their peers. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded, 26, 3—17.
61.
Zigler, E. (1975). Cognitive—developmental and personality factors in behavior. In J. M. Kauffman & J. S. Payne (Eds.), Mental retardation: Introduction and personal perspectives. Columbus, OH: Merrill.
