State and district accountability systems are increasingly including retention in grade for young students who do not demonstrate adequate reading achievement levels. This article examines the research on the effectiveness of retention and other responses, including social promotion, and the growing parental practice of “academic redshirting” of children by delaying their entry into kindergarten. Recommendations for future research are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abidin, R.R., Golladay, W.M., & Howerton, A.L. (1971). Elementary school retention: An unjustifiable, discriminatory, and noxious policy. Journal of School Psychology, 9, 410—414.
2.
Alexander, K.L., Entwisle, D.R., & Dauber, S.L. (1994). On the success of failure: A reassessment of the e fects of retention in the primary grades. New York: Cambridge University Press.
3.
American Academy of Pediatrics. (1995). The inappropriate use of school “readiness” tests. Pediatrics, 95, 437—438.
4.
Ayres, L.P. (1909). Laggards in our schools: A study of retardation and elimination in city school systems. Philadelphia: Russell Sage.
5.
Barro, S.M., & Kolstad, A.J. (1987). Who drops out of high school? Findings from high school and beyond (Technical Report no. CS 87-397c). Retrieved August 22, 2001, from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=87397
6.
Binet, A. (1969). The experimental psychology of Alfred Binet: Selected papers (R. H. Pollack & M. J. Brenner, Trans.). New York: Springer.
7.
Binet, A., & Simon, T. (1916). The development of intelligence in children: The Binet-Simon scale. Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins.
8.
Bracey, G.W. (2000). A children's garden no more. Phi Delta Kappan,81, 712—713.
9.
Bredekamp, S., & Shepard, L. (1989). How best to protect children from inappropriate school expectations, practices, and policies. Young Children , 44(3), 14—24.
10.
Bruner, J. (1960). The process of education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
11.
Bureau of the Census. (1995). Current population survey. Washington, DC: Author.
12.
Byrnes, D.A. (1989). Attitudes of students, parents, and educators toward repeating a grade. In L. A. Shepard & M. L. Smith (Eds.), Flunking grades: Research and policies on retention (pp. 108—131). New York: Falmer Press.
13.
Byrnes, D., & Yamamoto, K. (1985). Academic retention: A look inside. Education, 106, 208—214.
14.
Cannella, G.S., & Reiff, J.C. (1989). Mandating early childhood entrance/retention assessment: Practices in the United States. Child Study Journal, 19(2), 83—99.
15.
Chicago Panel on School Policy. (2001). Initiatives status report: Transition centers. Retrieved August 19, 2001, from http://www.chicagopanel.org/chicago%20panel/isr.htm
16.
Children's Defense Fund. (2003). Prekindergarten initiatives: E forts to help children enter school ready to succeed. Retrieved January 14, 2004 from www.childrensdefense.org/earlychildhood/prekindergarten/keyfacts2003_prekindergarten.pdf
17.
Clinton, W. (1998). 1998 State of the union address: Full text. Retrieved August 21, 2001, from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wsrv/politics/special/states/docs/sou98
18.
Cosden, M., Zimmer, J., & Tuss, P. (1993). The impact of age, sex, and ethnicity on kindergarten entry and retention decisions. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 15, 209—222.
19.
Cunningham, P.M., Hall, D.P., & Defee, M. (1998). Nonability-grouped, multilevel instruction: Eight years later. The Reading Teacher, 51, 652— 664.
20.
Dauber, S.L., Alexander, K.L., & Entwisle, D.R. (1993). Characteristics of retainees and early precursors of retention in grade: Who is held back?Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 39, 426—433.
21.
Dawson, P. (1998). A primer on student retention: What the research says. Communique (Milwaukee, WI), 26(8), 28—30.
22.
Dever, M.T., & Barta, J. (2001). Standardized entrance assessment in kindergarten: A qualitative analysis of the experiences of teachers, administrators, and parents. Journal of Research in Childhood Education, 15, 220—233.
23.
Dewey, J. (1998). Experience, knowledge, and value: A rejoinder . In J. A. Boydston (Ed.), John Dewey: The later works, 1925—1953 (Vol. 15, pp. 3—90). Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press (Original work published 1939 ).
24.
Dickinson, D.K., & Sprague, K.E. (2001). The nature and impact of early childhood care environments on the language and literacy development of children from low-income families. In S. B. Neuman & D. K. Dickinson (Eds.), Handbook of early literacy research (pp. 263—280). New York: Guilford.
25.
Ellwein, M.C., Walsh, D.J., & Eads, G.M., II. (1991). Using readiness tests to rout kindergarten students: The snarled intersection of psychometrics, policy, and practice . Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 13, 159—175.
26.
Gates, A.I., & Pritchard, M.C. (1942). Teaching reading to slow-learning pupils: A report on an experiment in New York City public school 500 (Speyer School). New York: Columbia University .
27.
Gastright, J.F. (1989, March). The nation reacts: A survey of promotion/ retention rates in 40 urban school districts. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, CA. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED307-714)
28.
Gnezda, M.T., Garduque, L., & Schultz, T. (1991). Improving instruction and assessment in early childhood education. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
29.
Gould, S.J. (1996). The mismeasure of man. New York: Norton.
30.
Graue, M.E., & DiPerna, J. (2000). Redshirting and early retention: Who gets the “gift of time” and what are its outcomes?American Educational Research Journal, 37, 509—534.
31.
Gredler, G. (1992). School readiness: Assessment and educational issues . Brandon, VT: Clinical Psychology .
32.
Gullo, D.F., & Burton, C.B. (1992). Age of entry, preschool experience, and sex as antecedents of academic readiness in kindergarten. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 7, 175—186.
33.
Gurewitz, S., & Kramer, J. (1995). Retention across elementary schools in a midwestern school district. Research in the Schools, 2(2), 15—21.
34.
Hagborg, W.J., Masella, G., Palladino, P., & Shepardson, J. (1991). A follow-up study of high school students with a history of grade retention. Psychology in the Schools, 28, 310—317.
35.
Haney, W. (2001, January). Revisiting the myth of the Texas miracle in education: Lessons about dropout research and dropout prevention. Paper presented at the Dropout Research Conference, Cambridge, MA.
36.
Hofstadter, R. (1955). Social Darwinism in American thought (rev. ed.) . Boston: Beacon Press.
37.
Holmes, C.T. (1989). Grade level retention effects: A meta-analysis of research studies. In L. A. Shepard & M. L. Smith (Eds.), Flunking grades: Research and policies on retention (pp. 16—33). New York : Falmer Press.
38.
Holmes, C.T., & Matthews, K.M. (1984). The effects of nonpromotion on elementary and junior high school pupils: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 54, 225—236.
39.
Holmes, C.T., & Saturday, J. (2000). Promoting the end to retention. Journal of Curriculum and Supervision, 15, 300—314.
40.
House, E.R. (1989). Policy implications of retention research. In L. A. Shepard & M. L. Smith (Eds.), Flunking grades: Research and policies on retention (pp. 202—213). New York: Falmer Press.
41.
Jackson, G.B. (1975). The research evidence on the effect of grade retention . Review of Educational Research, 45, 438—460.
42.
James, W. (1899). Talks to teachers on psychology: And to students on some of life's ideals. New York: Henry Holt.
43.
Jimerson, S.R. (1999). On the failure of failure: Examining the association between early grade retention and education and employment outcomes during late adolescence. Journal of School Psychology, 37, 243—272.
44.
Jimerson, S., Carlson, E., Rotert, M., Egeland, B., & Sroufe, L.A. (1997). A prospective, longitudinal study of the correlates and consequences of early grade retention. Journal of School Psychology, 35, 3—25.
45.
Jimerson, S.R., & Schuder, M.R. (1996). Is grade retention an appropriate academic intervention? Longitudinal data provide further insights. Paper presented at the Head Start National Research Conference, Washington, DC.
46.
Johnson, E.R., Merrell, K.W., & Stover, L. (1990). The effects of early grade retention on the academic achievement of fourth-grade students. Psychology in the Schools , 27, 333—338.
Karweit, N.L. (1999). Grade retention: Prevalence, timing, and e fects. Technical Report, Center for Research on the Education of Students Placed at Risk. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University.
49.
Kelly, K. (1999, January—February). Retention vs. promotion: Schools search for alternatives. Harvard Education Letter Research Online. Retrieved August 20, 2001, from http://www.edletter.org/past/issues/1999-jf/retention/shtml
50.
Kundert, D.K., May, D.C., & Brent, R. (1995). A comparison of students who delay kindergarten entry and those who are retained in grades K—5. Psychology in the Schools, 32, 202—209.
51.
Lamberty, G., & Crnic, K. (1994). School readiness conference: Recommendations. Early Education and Development, 5, 165—176.
52.
La Paro, K.M., & Pianta, R.C. (2000). Predicting children's competence in the early school years: A meta-analytic review. Review of Educational Research, 70, 443—484.
53.
Lapp, D., Fisher, D., Flood, J., & Moore, K. (2002). “I don't want to teach it wrong”: An investigation of the role families believe they should play in the early literacy development of their children. In D. L. Schallert, C. M. Fairbanks, J. Worthy, & B. Maloch , & J. V. Hoffman, (Eds.), National Reading Conference Yearbook, 51, (pp. 275—286). Oak Creek, WI: National Reading Conference.
54.
McCoy, A.R., & Reynolds, A.J. (1999). Grade retention and performance: An extended investigation. Journal of School Psychology, 37, 273—298.
55.
McMillen, M., & Kaufman, P. (1993). Dropout rates in the United States: 1993 (NCES Rep. No. 90—659). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics.
56.
Meisels, S.J. (1987). Uses and abuses of developmental screening and school readiness testing. Young Children, 42(2), 4—6.
57.
Meisels, S.J. (1992). Doing harm by doing good: Iatrogenic effects of early childhood enrollment and promotion policies. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 7, 155—174.
58.
Meisels, S.J. (1999). Assessing readiness. In R. C. Pianta & M. Cox (Eds.), The transition to kindergarten: Research, policy, training, and practice (pp. 39—66). Baltimore: Brookes.
59.
Meisels, S.J., & Liaw, F. (1993). Failure in grade: Do retained students catch up?The Journal of Educational Research, 87, 69—77.
60.
Miedel, W.T., & Reynolds, A.J. (1998). Parent involvement in early intervention for disadvantaged children: Does it matter?Journal of School Psychology, 37, 379—402.
61.
Monaghan, E.J., & Barry, A.L. (1999). Writing the past: Teaching reading in colonial America and the United States 1640—1940. Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
62.
Mondale, S., & Patton, S.B. (2001). School: The story of American public education . Boston: Beacon Press.
63.
Morris, D.R. (2001). Assessing the implementation of high-stakes reform: Aggregate relationships between retention rates and test results. NASSP Bulletin, 85, 18—34.
64.
National Association for the Education of Young Children. (1990). Guidelines for appropriate curriculum content and assessment in programs serving children ages 3 through 8. Retrieved July 16, 2002, from www.naeyc.org/resources/position_statements
65.
National Commission on Excellence in Education. ( 1983). A nation at risk: The imperative for educational reform . Washington, DC: Author.
66.
Osterlind, S.J. (1980—1981). Preschool impact on children: Its sustaining effects into kindergarten. Educational Research Quarterly, 5(4), 21—30.
67.
Pierson, L.H., & Connell, J.P. (1992). Effect of grade retention on self-system processes, school engagement, and academic performance. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84, 300—307.
68.
Pulliam, J.D., & Van Patten, J. (1995). History of education in America (6th ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Merrill.
69.
Resnick, M.D., Bearman, P.S., Blum, R.W., Bauman, K.E., Harris, K.M., Jones, J., et al. (1997). Protecting adolescents from harm: Findings from the national longitudinal study on adolescent health. Journal of theAmerican Medical Association, 278, 823—832.
70.
Reynolds, A.J. (1992). Mediated effects of preschool intervention. Early Education and Development, 3, 139—164.
71.
Roderick, M.R. (1995). Grade retention and school dropouts: Investigating the association. American Educational Research Journal, 31, 729—759.
72.
Royce, J., Darlington, R., & Murray, H. (1983). Pooled analyses: Findings across studies. In the Consortium for Longitudinal Studies (Eds.), As the twig is bent: Lasting e fects of preschool programs (pp. 411—459). Hills-dale, NJ: Erlbaum.
73.
Rumberger, R.W. (1987). High school dropouts: A review of issues and evidence . American Educational Research Journal, 32, 101—121.
74.
Rumberger, R. (1995). Dropping out of middle school: A multilevel analysis of students and schools. American Educational Research Journal , 32, 583—625.
75.
Rush, S., & Vitale, P.A. (1994). Analysis for determining factors that place elementary students at risk. The Journal of Educational Research, 87, 325—333.
76.
San Diego Unified School District. (2001, March). The blueprint for student success: Expanded strategies for prevention, intervention, and retention. San Diego, CA : Author.
77.
Shepard, L.A., & Smith, M.L. (1988). Escalating academic demand in kindergarten: Counterproductive policies. Elementary School Journal, 89, 135—145.
78.
Shepard, L.A., & Smith, M.L. (1989). Flunking grades: Research and policies on retention . London: Falmer Press.
79.
Snow, C.E., Burns, S.M., & Griffin, P. (1998). Preventing reading di ficulties in young children . Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
80.
Southern Regional Education Board. (2001). Finding alternatives to failure: Can states end social promotion and reduce retention rates? (SREB Rep. No. 00H03). Atlanta, GA: Author.
Thomas, V.G. (2000). Ending social promotion: Help or hindrance?Kappa Delta Pi Record, 37(1), 30—32.
83.
U.S. Department of Education. (1999). Taking responsibility for ending social promotion: A guide for educators and state and local leaders. Washington, DC: Author.
84.
Vellutino, F.R., & Scanlon, D.M. (2001). Emergent literacy skills, early instruction, and individual differences as determinants of difficulties in learning to read: The case for early intervention. In S. B. Neuman & D. K. Dickinson (Eds.), Handbook of early literacy research (pp. 295—321). New York: Guilford.
85.
Vuko, E. (2002, February 12). Teachers say. Messages posted to http://discuss.washingtonpost.com/wpsrv/zforum/02/education_vuko021202.htm
86.
Wechsler, D. (1997). Wechsler adult intelligence scale (3rd ed.). San Antonio, TX: Harcourt Assessment.
87.
Westbury, M. (1994). The effect of elementary grade retention on subsequent school achievement and ability. Canadian Journal of Education , 19, 241—250.
88.
Wheat, H.G. (1923). The teaching of reading: A textbook of principles and methods. Boston: Ginn.
89.
Zill, N., Loomis, L.S., & West, J. (1997). The elementary school performance and adjustment of children who enter kindergarten late or repeat kindergarten: Findings from the National Surveys. Washington, DC: Office of Educational Research and Improvement.
