Parents, professionals, and researchers have been concerned about the most appropriate placement for children with mental retardation. To shed light on the efficacy of integration, 36 studies were reviewed on the academic and social attainments of school-age children with mental retardation. Results show that children in general education classes do not attain social acceptance ratings at as high a level as do their typically developing peers. When comparing children with mental retardation in general education and special education classrooms, integrated students perform better than their comparable segregated students on measures of academic achievement and social competence. Other variables are discussed that might affect child outcomes, and related recommendations are given for future research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Altman, R., & Kanagawa, L. (1994). Academic and social engagement of young children with developmental disabilities in integrated and nonintegrated settings. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities , 29, 184-193.
2.
Baker, E.T., Wang, M.C., & Walberg, H.J. (1994-1995). The effects of inclusion on learning. Educational Leadership, 52, 33-35.
3.
Baldwin, W.K. (1958). The social position of the educable mentally retarded child in the regular grades in public schools. Exceptional Children, 25, 106-108.
4.
Bradfield, R., Brown, J., Kaplan, P., Rickert, E., & Stannard, R. (1973). The special child in the regular classroom. Exceptional Children, 39, 384-390.
5.
Brewer, N., & Smith, J. (1989). Social acceptance of mentally retarded children in regular schools in relation to years mainstreamed. Psychological Reports, 64, 375-380.
6.
Brinker, R.P. (1985). Interactions between severely mentally retarded students and other students in integrated and segregated public school settings . American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 89, 587-594.
7.
Brinker, R.P., & Thorpe, M.E. (1984). Integration of severely handicapped students and the proportion of IEP objectives achieved. Exceptional Children , 51, 168-175.
8.
Bruininks, R.H., Rynders, J.E., & Gross, J.C. (1974). Social acceptance of mildly retarded pupils in resource rooms and regular classes. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 78, 377-383.
9.
Budoff, M., & Gottlieb, J. (1976). Special-class EMR children mainstreamed: A study of an aptitude (learning potential) X treatment interaction. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 81, 1-11.
10.
Bunch, G. (1991). Full inclusion: Parent and educator objective for students with challenging needs. Developmental Disabilities Bulletin, 19, 80-101.
11.
Buysse, V., & Bailey, D.B. (1993). Behavioral and developmental outcomes in young children with disabilities in integrated and segregated settings: A review of comparative studies. The Journal of Special Education, 26, 434-461.
12.
Calhoun, G., & Elliott, R.N. (1977). Self-concept and academic achievement of educable retarded and emotionally disturbed pupils. Exceptional Children , 43, 279-380.
13.
Campbell, D.T., & Stanley, J.C. (1966). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research. Chicago: Rand McNally .
14.
Carlberg, C., & Kavale, K. (1980). The efficacy of special versus regular class placement for exceptional children: A meta-analysis. The Journal of Special Education, 14, 295-305.
15.
Carroll, A.W. (1967). The effects of segregated and partially integrated school programs on self-concept and academic achievement of educable mental retardates. Exceptional Children, 34, 93-99.
16.
Casey, W., Jones, D., Kugler, B., & Watkins, B. (1988). Integration of Down's syndrome children in the primary school: A longitudinal study of cognitive development and academic attainments. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 38, 279-286.
17.
Chesley, G.M., & Calaluce, P.D. (1997). The deception of inclusion . Mental Retardation, 35, 488-490.
18.
Coie, J.D., Dodge, L.A., & Kupersmidt, J.B. (1990). Peer group behavior and social status. In S. R. Asher & J. D. Coie (Eds.), Peer rejection in childhood: Cambridge studies in social and emotional development (pp. 17-59). New York: Cambridge University Press.
19.
Cole, D.A., & Meyer, L.H. (1991). Social integration and severe disabilities: A longitudinal analysis of child outcomes. The Journal of Special Education, 25, 340-351.
20.
Dahloff, U.S. (1971). Ability grouping, content validity, and curriculum process analysis. New York: Teachers College Press.
21.
Espiner, D., Wilton, K., & Glynn, T. (1985). Social interaction and acceptance of mildly retarded children in a mainstream special education setting. The AustralianJournal of Special Education, 9, 8-15.
22.
Evans, I.M., Salisbury, C.L., Palombaro, M.M., Berryman, J., & Hollowood, T.M. (1992). Peer interactions and social acceptance of elementary-age children with severe disabilities in an inclusive school. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 17, 205-212.
23.
Farmer, T.W., & Farmer, E.M.Z. (1996). Social relationships of students with exceptionalities in mainstream classrooms: Social networks and homophily. Exceptional Children, 62, 431-450.
24.
Ferencz-Stager, S., & Young, R.D. (1981). Intergroup contact and social outcomes for mainstreamed EMR adolescents. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 85, 497-503.
25.
Fox, N.E., & Ysseldyke, J.E. (1997). Implementing inclusion at the middle school level: Lessons from a negative example. Exceptional Children, 64, 81-98.
26.
Fryxell, D., & Kennedy, C.H. (1995). Placement along the continuum of services and its impact on students' social relationships. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 20, 259-269.
27.
Gilkey, G.L., & Zetlin, A.G. (1987). Peer relations of mentally handicapped adolescent pupils at an ordinary school. British Journal of Mental Sub-normality , 33, 50-66.
28.
Gottlieb, J. (1981). Mainstreaming: Fulfilling the promise?American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 86, 115-126.
29.
Gottlieb, J., & Budoff, M. (1973). Social acceptability of retarded children in nongraded schools differing in architecture. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 78, 15-19.
30.
Greenspan, S., & Granfield, J.M. (1992). Reconsidering the construct of mental retardation: Implications of a model of social competence. American Journal on Mental Retardation, 96, 442-453.
31.
Gresham, F.M. (1982). Misguided mainstreaming: The case for social skills training with handicapped children. Exceptional Children, 48, 422-433.
32.
Gresham, F.M., & MacMillan, D.L. (1997). Social competence and affective characteristics of students with mild disabilities. Review of Educational Research, 67, 377-415.
33.
Guralnick, M.J. (1999). The nature and meaning of social integration for young children with mild developmental delays in inclusive settings. Journal of Early Intervention, 22, 70-86.
34.
Hallenbeck, B.A., & Kauffman, J.M. (1995). How does observational learning affect the behavior of students with emotional or behavioral disorders? A review of the research. The Journal of Special Education , 29, 45-71.
35.
Helmstetter, E., Peck, C., & Giangreco, M.F. (1994). Outcomes of interactions with peers with moderate or severe disabilities: A statewide survey of high school students. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 19, 263-276.
36.
Hudson, A., & Clunies-Ross, G. (1984). A study of the integration of children with intellectual handicaps into regular schools. Australia and New Zealand Journal of Developmental Disabilities, 10, 165-177.
37.
Hunt, P., Farron-Davis, F., Beckstead, S., Curtis, D., & Goetz, L. (1994). Evaluating the effects of placement of students with severe disabilities in general education versus special classes. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 19, 200-214.
38.
Hunt, P., & Goetz, L. (1997). Research on inclusive educational programs, practice, and outcomes for students with severe disabilities. The Journal of Special Education, 31, 3-29.
39.
Iano, R.P., Ayers, D., Heller, H.B., McGettigan, J.F., & Walker, V.S. (1974). Sociometric status of retarded children in an integrative program. Exceptional Children, 40, 267-271.
40.
Individuals with Disabilities Education Act of 1990, 20 U.S.C. ยง 12101 et seq.
41.
Kauffman, J.M., & Hallahan, D.P. (1993). Towards a comprehensive delivery system for special education. In J. I. Goodlad & T. C. Lovitt (Eds.), Integrating general and special education (pp. 73-102). New York: Merrill.
42.
Kennedy, C.H., & Itkonen, T. (1994). Some effects of regular class participation on the social contacts and social networks of high school students with severe disabilities. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 19, 1-10.
43.
Kennedy, C.H., Shukla, S., & Fryxell, D. (1997). Comparing the effects of educational placement on the social relationships of intermediate school students with severe disabilities . Exceptional Children, 64, 31-47.
44.
Klassen, R. (1994). Research: What does it say about mainstreaming . Education Canada, 34, 27-35.
45.
Kliewer, C. (1998). The meaning of inclusion. Mental Retardation, 36, 317-321.
46.
Kliewer, C. (1999). Seeking the functional. Mental Retardation, 37, 151-154.
47.
Kozleski, E.B., & Jackson, L. (1993). Taylor's story: Full inclusion in her neighborhood elementary school. Exceptionality, 4, 153-175.
48.
Kupersmidt, J.B., DeRosier, M.E., & Patterson, C.P. (1995). Similarity as the basis for children's friendships: The roles of sociometric status, aggressive and withdrawn behavior, academic achievement and demographic characteristics. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 12, 439-452.
49.
Lapp, E.R. (1957). A study of the social adjustment of slow learning children who were assigned part-time to regular classes. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 62, 254-262.
50.
Leinhardt, G., & Pallay, A. (1982). Restrictive educational settings: Exile or haven?Review of Educational Research, 52, 557-578.
51.
Lipsky, D.K., & Gartner, A. (1995). The evaluation of inclusive education program . The National Center on Educational Restructuring and Inclusion , 2(2), 2-7.
52.
Lipsky, D.K., & Gartner, A. (1997). Inclusion and school reform: Transforming America's classrooms. Baltimore: Brookes.
53.
Logan, K.R., Bakeman, R., & Keefe, E.B. (1997). Effects of instructional variables on engaged behavior of students with disabilities in general education classrooms. Exceptional Children, 63, 481-497.
54.
Luckasson, R., Coulter, D., Polloway, E.A., Reiss, S., Schalock, R., Snell, M., Spitalnik, D., & Stark, J. (1992). Mental retardation: Definition, classification, and systems of supports (9th ed.). Washington, DC: American Association on Mental Retardation .
55.
MacMillan, D., Siperstein, G., & Gresham, F. (1996). A challenge to the viability of mild mental retardation as a diagnostic category. Exceptional Children, 62, 356-371.
56.
Madden, N., & Slavin, R. (1983). Mainstreaming students with mild handicaps: Academic and social outcomes. Review of Educational Research, 53, 519-569.
57.
McDonnell, A., McDonnell, T., Hardman, M., & McCune, A. (1991). Educating students with severe disabilities in their neighborhood school: The Utah Elementary Integration Model. Remedial and Special Education, 12, 34-45.
58.
McFall, R.M. (1982). A review and reformulation of the concept of social skills. Behavioral Assessment, 4, 1-33.
59.
Meisel, C.J., & Blumberg, C.J. (1990). The social comparison choices of elementary and secondary school students: The influence of gender, race, and friendship. Contemporary Educational Psychology , 15, 170-182.
60.
Meyerowitz, J.H. (1967). Peer groups and special classes. Mental Retardation, 5(5), 23-26.
61.
Miller, K.J., Fullmer, S.L., & Walls, R.T. (1996). A dozen years of mainstreaming literature: A content analysis. Exceptionality, 6, 99-109.
62.
Polloway, E.A. (1984). The integration of mildly retarded students in the schools: A historical review. Remedial and Special Education , 5, 18-28.
63.
Psychological Corp. (1973). Stanford achievement test. San Antonio: Author.
64.
Roberts, C., & Zubrick, S. (1992). Factors influencing the social status of children with mild academic disabilities in regular classrooms. Exceptional Children, 59, 192-202.
65.
Rotter, J. (1954). Social learning and clinical psychology. New York: Prentice Hall.
66.
Rucker, C.N., Howe, C.E., & Snider, B. (1969). The participation of retarded children in junior high academic and nonacademic regular classes. Exceptional Children, 35, 597-608.
67.
Saint-Laurent, L., & Lessard, J.C. (1991). Comparisons of three educational programs for students with moderate mental retardation integrated in regular schools. Education and Training in Mental Retardation, 26, 370-380.
68.
Salisbury, C.L., Gallucci, C.L., Palombaro, M.M., & Peck, C. (1995). Strategies that promote social relations among elementary students with and without severe disabilities in inclusive schools . Exceptional Children, 62, 125-137.
69.
Sandler, A.G. (1999). Short-changed in the name of socialization? Acquisition of functional skills by students with severe disabilities. Mental Retardation, 37, 148-150.
70.
Schnorr, R.F. (1990). "Peter? He comes and goes ... ": First graders' perspectives on a part-time mainstream student. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 15, 231-240.
71.
Semmel, M.I., Abernathy, T.V., Butera, G., & Lesar, S. (1991). Teacher perceptions of the Regular Education Initiative . Exceptional Children, 58, 9-23.
72.
Sharpe, M.N., York, J.L., & Knight, J. (1994). Effects of inclusion on the academic performance of classmates without disabilities: A preliminary study. Remedial and Special Education, 15, 281-287.
73.
Simons, J. (1998). Response to Chesley and Calaluce on inclusion . Mental Retardation, 36, 322-324.
74.
Sindelar, P.T., & Deno, S.L. (1978). The effectiveness of resource programming. The Journal of Special Education, 12, 17-28.
75.
Siperstein, G.N., & Leffert, J.S. (1997). Comparison of socially accepted and rejected children with mental retardation. American Journal of Mental Retardation , 101, 339-351.
76.
Slavin, R.E. (1984). Meta-analysis in education: How has it been used?Educational Researcher, 13(8), 6-15.
77.
Stainback, S., & Stainback, W. (1992). Curriculum considerations in inclusive classrooms: Facilitating learning for all students. Baltimore: Brookes.
78.
Strully, J.L., & Strully, C. (1996). Friendship as an educational goal: What we have learned and where we are headed. In S. Stainback & W. Stainback (Eds.), Inclusion: A guide for educators (pp. 141-154). Baltimore: Brookes.
79.
Summey, H.K., & Strahan, D.B. (1997). An exploratory study of mainstreamed seventh graders' perceptions of an inclusive approach to instruction. Remedial and Special Education, 18, 36-45.
80.
Vygotsky, L.S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
81.
Walker, V.S. (1974). The efficacy of the resource room for educating retarded children. Exceptional Children, 40, 288-289.
82.
Wang, M.C., Peverly, S., & Randolph, D. (1984). An investigation of the implementation and effects of a full-time mainstream program. Remedial and Special Education , 5, 21-32.
83.
York, J., Vandercook, T., MacDonald, C., & Heise-Neff, C. (1992). Feedback about integrating middle-school students with severe disabilities in general education classes . Exceptional Children, 58, 244-258.
84.
Ziegler, S., & Hambleton, D. (1976). Integration of young TMR children into a regular elementary school. Exceptional Children, 42, 459-461.
