The purpose of this study was to clarify dominant perspectives on women in adult education publications. Qualitative content analysis was used to analyze 112 articles in four major adult education journals. Five dominant perspectives were identified, along with a sixth potentially emergent perspective. Strengthsandlimitationsofeachperspectivearediscussedinrelationship to key themes in feminist scholarship.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agin, A.
& Prather, J. (1977). Emerging women: Implications for the community college and the business-industrial community. Adult Leadership, 25(10),299-300, 316.
2.
Aird, E.
(1980). NOW courses and the changing pattern of adult education. Studies in Adult Education, 12(1), 39-44.
3.
Aird, E.
, & Peacock, G., & Brown, J. (1980). The Newcastle NOW/OU project: A case study in continuing education. Adult Education (U. K.), 53(1), 32-38.
4.
Altheide, D.
(1987). Ethnographic content analysis. Qualitative Sociology, 10(1), 65-77.
5.
Atkin, G.
& Hutchinson, E. (1981). Women in search of education. Adult Education (U.K.), 53(6), 361-365.
6.
Barbier, M.
(1971). Counseling the mature woman. Adult Leadership, 20(5),187-189, 200.
7.
Bateson, B.
& Bateson, G. (1989). Women's education: Definition and content. Adults Learning, 1(4), 100-103.
8.
Beer, C.
& Darkenwald, G. (1989). Gender differences in adult student perceptions of college classroom social environments. Adult Education, 40(1), 33-42.
9.
Belenky, M.
, Clinchy, B., Goldberger, N., & Tarule, J. (1986). Women's ways of knowing: The development of self voice, and mind. New York: Basic Books.
10.
Berry, J.
(1969). Effects of poverty on culturally disadvantaged women. Adult Leadership, 18(1), 9-13.
11.
Blais, J.
, & Duquette, A., & Painchaud, G. (1989). Deterrents to women's participation in work-related educational activities. Adult Education, 39(4), 224-234.
12.
Bolton, E.
(1980). A conceptual analysis of the mentor relationship in the career development of women. Adult Education, 30(4), 195-207.
13.
Bostock, S.
& Seifert, R. (1987). The effects of learning environment and gender on the attainment of computer literacy. Studies in the Education of Adults, 19(1),37-45.
Boyd, B.
& Griffith, M. (1973). A critical professional need: The counselor for women. Adult Leadership, 22(5), 161-162.
16.
Brebner, R.
& Sundre, S. (1982). Deciders, explorers, dabblers, evaders: Women in career development transition. Lifelong Learning, 6(4), 14-15, 23, 26.
17.
Bross, D.
(1967). Night college courses for the older woman. Adult Leadership, 15(7), 233-234.
18.
Brown, J.
(1987). Professionalism and the role of the part-time ESL tutor. Adult Education (U.K.), 60(2), 138-143.
19.
Bruce, M.
& Kirkup, G. (1985). Post-experience courses in technology for women. Adult Education (U.K.), 58(1), 40-50.
20.
Buckey, A.
, Freeark, K., O'Barr, J. (1976). Support for returning students. Adult Leadership, 25(1), 21-23.
21.
Burrow, M.
(1985). Wider opportunities for women and work. Adult Education (U.K.), 58(2), 158-162.
22.
Caffarella, R.
& Olson, S. (1993). Psychosocial development of women: A critical review of the literature. Adult Education Quarterly, 43(3), 125-151.
23.
Casling, M.
(1986). `Women's subjects'-their place in adult education. Adult Education (U.K.), 59(1),40-43.
24.
Catlett, J.
(1986). Reaching workers off the job: The Southern School for Union Women. Lifelong Learning, 9(6), 4-5.
25.
Clarke, M.
(1975). Transitional women: Implications for adult educators. Adult Leadership, 24(4), 123-127.
26.
Clayton, D.
& Smith, M. (1987). Motivational typology of reentry women. Adult Education, 37(2), 90-104.
27.
Coats, M.
(1989). Support for women learners: Requirements and resources. Adults Learning, 1 (4),104-105.
28.
Cohen, R.
(1980). Sex-role stereotypical behavior: Effects on a participation training group. Lifelong Learning, 3(7), 20-23.
29.
Cooke, B.
, Ellis, M. & Jotham, D. (1985). Women and computers. Adult Education (U.K.), 58 (3), 246-248.
30.
Cousin, G.
(1990). Women in liberal adult education. Adults Learning, 2(2), 38-39.
31.
Crawford, M.
& Marecek, J. (1989). Psychology reconstructs the female. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 13(2), 147-165.
32.
Crowcroft, J.
(1983). Housewife into student. Adult Education (U.K.), 55(4), 378-380.
33.
Davidson, E.
(1976). COPE's educationally disadvantaged, low-income mothers who areheads of households. Adult Leadership, 24 (8), 267-270.
34.
Dillon, M.
(1975). A perspective on a national clearing house for IWY. Adult Leadership, 24(4), 143-144.
35.
Dolan, T.
, Fitzgerald, C., Messer, J., Townsend, M. (1984). New opportunities for women. Adult Education (U.K.), 57(2), 140-142.
36.
Dubois, E.C.
, Kelly, G.P., Kennedy, E.L., Korsmeyer, C.W.,& Robinson, L.S. (1985). Feminist scholarship: Kindling in the groves of academe. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
37.
Ellwood, C.
(1968). Second chance for women. Adult Education (U.K.), 41(4), 221-224.
38.
Elshof, A.
& Konek, C. (1977). Providing are-entry bridge for women: A need-centered continuing education program. Adult Leadership, 25(8), 239-241, 245.
39.
Fagin, M.
(1971). Analysis of the performance of adult women in Missouri on three general examinations of the college level examination program. Adult Education, 21(3), 148-165.
40.
Farley, J.
(1976). Adult education and women's studies: Natural partners. Adult Leadership, 25(3),74, 80.
41.
Gaffga, R.
(1976). Employment of women and their education. Adult Leadership, 25(1), 13-14, 32.
42.
Gaillard, C.
(1979). CEW programs on college campuses: A review of research and literature. Lifelong Learning, 2(5), 8-9, 29, 37.
43.
Gaskell, J.
& McLaren, A. (1987). Women and education: A Canadian perspective. Calgary: Detselig Enterprises.
44.
Gilligan, C.
(1982). Ina different voice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
45.
Gray, R.
& Hughes, M. (1980). Halfour future Adult Education (U.K.), 52(5), 301-306.
46.
Greenblatt, A.
(1968). For women only. Adult Leadership, 16(8), 287-288.
47.
Hall, D.
(1988). Training as an agent for rural development: NFWI community action training scheme. Adult Education (U.K.), 61(3), 247-249.
48.
Hampton, P.
(1975). Vo-Libtraining for neglected adult women. Adult Leadership, 24(3), 107-110.
49.
Hart, M.
, Karlovic, N., Loughlin, K., & Meyer, C. (1991). Reconstructing the adult education enterprise: The value of feminist theory for adult education. Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Adult Education Research Conference, Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma.
50.
Hartree, A.
(1986.) Valuing your experience—a project for women. Adult Education (U.K.), 59(2), 115-120.
51.
Hayes, E.
(1991). Adult education's response to the feminist critique: A comparison of trends in the literature. Initiatives: Journal of the National Association for Women Deans, Administrators, and Counselors, 54(1), 29-38.
52.
Hayes, E.
(1992). The impact of feminism on adult education publications: An analysis of British and American journals. International Journal of Lifelong Education, 11, 125-138.
53.
Hayes, E.
& Smith, L. (1990). The impact offeminism on adult education: An analysis oftrends in scholarship. Proceedings of the 1991 Adult Education Research Conference, Athens, GA: University of Georgia.
54.
Hayes, E.
& Smith, L. (1992). Women in adult education: An analysis of perspectives in major journals. Paper presented at the 1992 American Educational Research Association Conference, San Franciso, CA(ERIC Document Reproduction No. ED 344107).
55.
Highet, G.
(1986). Gender and education: A study of the ideology and practice of community based women's education as observed in three groups operating with in the city of Glasgow. Studies in the Education of Adults, 18(2), 118-129.
56.
Hill, L.
(1984). New horizons/new opportunities for women. Adult Education (U.K.), 57(3), 262-263.
57.
Hill, M.
(1989). Celebrating the adult learner. Adults Learning, 1(4), 118-119.
58.
Hochman, J.
(1981). Being seventy and female. Lifelong Learning, 4(6), 12-13.
59.
Hoist, M.
& Rouls, J. (1972). Meeting the changing times. Adult Leadership, 21(1), 28-29.
60.
Holsti, O.R.
(1969). Content analysis for the social sciences and humanities. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
61.
Holt, M.
(1982). Myth understanding for mid-life women. Lifelong Learning, 6(3), 20-21, 30.
62.
Hughes, M.
(1990). Rediscovering women adult educators: Women who have influenced adult education policy. Adults Learning, 2(4), 12-14.
63.
Hughes, M.
(1973). Educating women. Adult Education (U.K.), 46(3), 166-169.
64.
Hugo, J.
(1990). Adult education history and the issue of gender: Toward a different history of adult education in America. Adult Education, 41(1),1-16.
65.
Hutchinson, E.
(1971). Few women at the top. Adult Education (U.K.),44(4), 241-244.
66.
Jacobs, R.
(1982). Displaced home makers: An adult educator's checklist. Lifelong Learning, 5(7), 9, 27.
67.
Jenkins, T.
(1989). All change: Staff development and really equal opportunities. Adults Learning, 1(4), 108-109.
68.
Johnson, D.
, Shearon, R., & Britton, G. (1974). Correctional education and recidivism in a women's correctional center. Adult Education, 24(2), 121-129.
69.
Kasworm, C.
(1990). Adult undergraduates in higher education: A review of past research perspectives. Review of Educational Research, 60(3), 345-372.
70.
Kazemek, F.
(1988). Women and adult literacy: Considering the other half of the house. Lifelong Learning, 11(4), 23-24, 15.
71.
Kelly, J.
(1988). Adult education's role in providing women-friendly training and work opportunities. Adult Education (U.K.),61(1), 20-24.
72.
Kidd, J.R.
(1975). Confessions of a male suffragist. Adult Leadership, 24(4), 134-136.
73.
Kirk, P.
(1982). Return to study provision for women. Adult Education (U.K.), 55(3), 241-248.
74.
Knapp, M.
(1981). Response to a neglected need: Resocializing dependent women. Lifelong Learning, 5(2), 12-13, 25.
75.
Krajnc, A.
(1975). Let's do away with "toy" education for women. Adult Leadership, 24(4), 120-122, 156.
76.
Lambert, P.
(1989). Women into educational management. Adults Learning, 1(4), 106-107.
77.
Lengrand, P.
(1975). The educational aspect of the mutual relationship between men and women. Adult Leadership, 24(4),145, 156.
78.
Lewis, E.
(1969). Emerging social patterns and the potential of women. Adult Leadership, 18(1), 18-21.
79.
Lewis, L.
(1983). Coping with change. Lifelong Learning, 7(1), 8-9, 28, 31.
80.
Liley, M.
(1969). The biological potential of women. Adult Leadership, 18(1), 27-31.
Long, H.
(1975). Women's education in colonialAmerica Adult Education, 25(2), 90-106.
83.
Loring, R.
(1975). Reflections on continuing education for women in Australia and New Zealand. Adult Leadership, 24(4),142, 147.
84.
Loring, R.
(1969). We shall become. Adult Leadership, 18(1), 5-8.
85.
Lovell, A.
(1980). Fresh horizons for some. Adult Education (U.K.), 53(4), 219-224.
86.
Mace, J.
& Wolfe, M. (1988). Women, work and release. Adult Education (U.K.), 61(1), 49-54.
87.
Merriam, S.
(1985). On being a woman professor of adult education. Lifelong Learning, 8(8),4-6.
88.
Merriam, S.
& Mullins, L. (1981). Havighurst's adult developmental tasks: A study of their importance relative to income, age, and sex. Adult Education, 31(3), 123-141.
89.
Mitchell, B.
(1967). Oregon's campus day for women program. Adult Leadership, 15(10), 359-360.
90.
Modi, P.
(1989). Choices. Adults Learning, 1(4), 110-111.
91.
Mumba, E.
(1988). Training for women in Zambia: A review of selected research. Studies in the Education of Adults, 20(2), 144-152.
92.
Murphy, P.
(1989). Time for women in information technology in Northern Ireland. Adults Learning, 1(4), 113-115.
93.
Ntiri, D.
(1979). African student wives--their participation in continuing education. Lifelong Learning, 3(4), 10-11, 22-23.
94.
Oglesby, K.
(1976). General education courses for adults. Adult Education (U.K.), 49(1), 11-17.
95.
Osborn, R.
(1971). Developing new horizons for women. Adult Leadership, 19(10), 326-328, 350-351, 360.
96.
Osborn, R.
(1975). Toward the 21st century for women. Adult Leadership, 24(4), 116-119.
97.
Park, R.
(1977). Women in adult basic education. Lifelong Learning, 1(4), 12-13, 21.
98.
Parsons, S.
(1990). Feminist challenges to curriculum design. Studies in the Education of Adults, 22(1), 49-58.
99.
Patton, M.
(1990). Qualitative evaluation and research methods (2nd ed.). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
100.
Pearson, A.
(1971). Education in the new Holloway Prison for Women. Adult Education (U.K.), 44(1), 33-36.
101.
Purdey, M.
(1989). Models, aspirations and progression: Replan development work with black women. Adults Learning, 1(4), 116-117.
102.
Purdey, M.
(1990). Routes: Catterick Garrison. Adults Learning, 1(7), 188-189.
103.
Rice, J.
(1979). Continuing education for women: A clarion. Lifelong Learning, 3(2), 16-19, 25.
104.
Rice, J.
(1979). Self esteem, sex-role orientation, and perceived spouse support for a return to school. Adult Education, 29(4), 215-233.
105.
Rice, J.
(1982). Spouse support: Couples in educational transition. Lifelong Learning, 6(1), 4-6.
106.
Roehl, J.
(1980). Self-concept and the reentry woman student. Lifelong Learning, 3(10), 12-13, 22.
107.
Rosenstiel, A.
(1969). The Great Neck college community project. Adult Leadership, 18(6), 168-170, 195-196.
108.
Rossi, A.
(1967). Ambivalence in women: Should we plan for the real or the ideal Adult Leadership, 16(3), 100-102, 118.
109.
Rowlands, D.
(1976). A summer school for housewives. Adult Education (U.K.), 48(6), 380-385.
110.
Salisbury, J.
(1977). `The Monday Course'—for isolated mothers and young children. Adult Education (U.K.), 50(2), 105-108.
Simmts, J.
(1977). The education of matureakid able women. Adult Education (U.K.), 50(3), 174-175.
113.
Somerville, R.
(1975). China and sex role changes. Adult Leadership, 24(1), 137-141, 155.
114.
Stamper, A.
(1986). Education and the women's institutes. Adult Education (U.K.), 59(1), 33-38.
115.
Stamper, A.
(1989). Learning from volunteering. Adults Learning, 1(4), 112.
116.
Stamper, A.
& Jones, G. (1989). Training, education and enterprise. Adults Learning, 1(4), 120.
117.
Strychar, I.
, Griffith, W., Conry, R., & Sork, T. (1990). How pregnant women learn about selected health issues: Learning transaction types. Adult Education Quarterly, 41(1), 17-28.
118.
Swarbrick, A.
(1978). Backgrounds, developments, futures: A study of twelve OU women graduates. Studies in Adult Education, 10(2), 168-182.
119.
Tetrault, M.K.
(1985). Feminist phase theory: An experience-driven model. Journal of Higher Education, 56(4), 363-384.
120.
Thom, P.
, Ironside, A., Hendry, E. (1975). The women's resources centre: An educational model for counseling women. Adult Leadership, 24(4), 129-132.
121.
Thompson, W.
, Ameiss, A., Wood, H., & Fagin, M. (1970). Ananswer to the computer programmer shortage. Adult Leadership, 18(7), 213-214, 234.
122.
Tucker, B.
& Huerta, C. (1987). A study of developmental tasks as perceived by young adult Mexican-American females. Lifelong Learning, 10(4), 4-7.
123.
Tucker, S.
(1969). Humanness and the sexes. Adult Leadership, 18(1), 14-17.
124.
Ward, K. B.
& Grant, L. (1985). The feminist critique and a decade of published research in sociology journals. The Sociological Quarterly, 26(2), 139-157.
125.
Weidenbach, C.
(1976). College for the privileged adult women. Adult Leadership, 24(5), 162.
126.
Weiler, K.
(1988). Women teaching for change: Gender, class & power. South Hadley, MA: Bergin & Garvey.
127.
Westwood, S.
(1984). Learning and working: A study of women on the shop floor. Studies in the Education of Adults, 16, 3-19.
128.
Wilson, A.
(1990). Immigrant women as advocates. Adult Learning, 2(3), 12-13.
129.
Wilson, V.
(1985). Wider opportunities for women-—a case-study approach. Adult Education (U.K.), 57(4), 310-314.
130.
Wolf, M.
(1986). Growth and development with older women religious: An exploration in life review. Lifelong Learning, 9(4), 7-10, 28.
131.
Wong, J.
(1979). The displaced homemakers' center. Lifelong Learning, 3(4), 6-7, 27.
