Essay Prompts and Topics

Abstract

These studies investigated the degree to which prompts and topic types affect the writing performance of college freshmen. The students (N = 3,452) taking the 1989 and 1990 Manoa Writing Placement Examination (MWPE) were required to write in response to two types of topics (for a total of 6,904 essays): one in response to a reading passage and another in response to a question based on personal experience. Ten such prompt sets were used in this study. Study 1 indicated that the MWPE testing procedures were reasonably reliable and consistent across semesters but that student responses to individual prompts and prompt sets were significantly different from each other. Study 2 showed that if two topic types and a large number of prompts are involved, the differences that arise in the performance on prompts or topic types can be minimized by examining the students' mean scores and changing the pairings so that the prompt sets are more equitable in subsequent administrations.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anson, C. M. , Brown, R. L., Jr. , & Bridwell-Bowles, L. (1988). Portfolio assessment across the curriculum: Early conflicts. Notes from the National Testing Network in Writing, 8, 6-7.

Brown, J. D. (1988). 1987 Manoa Writing Placement Examination (Manoa Writing Board Technical Report No. 1). Honolulu: Manoa Writing Program, University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Brown, J.D. (1989). 1988 Manoa Writing Placement Examination (Manoa Writing Board Technical Report No. 2). Honolulu: Manoa Writing Program, University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Brown, J. D. (1990). 1989 Manoa Writing Placement Examination (Manoa Writing Board Technical Report No. 5). Honolulu: Manoa Writing Program, University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Brown, J. D. (1991). 1990 Manoa Writing Placement Examination (Manoa Writing Board Technical Report No. 14). Honolulu: Manoa Writing Program, University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Brossell, G. C. (1983). Rhetorical specification in essay examination topics. College English, 45, 165-173.

Brossell, G. C. , & Ash, B. H. (1984). An experiment with wording of essay topics. College Composition and Communication, 35, 423-425.

Despain, N.L.-R. , & Hilgers, T. (1990). Raters' experiences during assessment of portfolios of writing. (Manoa Writing Board Technical Report No. 4). Honolulu: Manoa Writing Program, University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Ebel, R. L. (1979). Essentials of educational measurement (3rd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

10.

Elbow, P. , & Belanoff, P. (1986a). Portfolios as a substitute for proficiency examinations. College Composition and Communication, 37, 336-339.

11.

Elbow, P. , & Belanoff, P. (1986b). Using portfolios to judge writing proficiency at SUNY Stony Brook. In P. Connolly & T. Vilardi (Eds), New methods in college writing programs. New York: Modern Language Association.

12.

Greenberg, K. (1981). The effects of variations in essay questions on the writing performance of CUNY freshmen. New York: Instructional Resources Center, City University of New York.

13.

Hoetker, J. , Brossell, G. (1989). The effects of systematic variations in essay topics on the writing performance of college freshmen. College Composition and Communication, 40, 414-421.

14.

Huot, B. (1990). The literature of direct writing assessment: major concerns and prevailing trends. Review of Educational Research, 60, 237-263.

15.

McAndrew, D. A. (1981). The effect of an assigned rhetorical context on the holistic quality and syntax of the writing of high and low ability college writers. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 235 481)

16.

Quellmalz, E. S. , Capell, F. , & Chou, C.P. (1982). Effects of discourse and response mode on the measurement of writing competence. Journal of Educational Measurement, 19, 241-258.

17.

Reed, W. M. , Burton, J.K. , & Kelly, P.P. (1985). The effects of writing ability and mode of discourse on cognitive capacity engagement. Research in the Teaching of English, 23, 77-108.

18.

Rosen, H. (1969). An investigation of the effects of differential writing assignments on the performance in English composition of a selected group of 15-to-16 year old pupils. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of London.

19.

Smith, W. L. , Hull, G. A. , Land, R. E. , Moore, M. T. , Ball, C. , Durham, D. E. , Hickey, L. S. , & Ruzich, C. W. (1985). Some effects of varying the structure of a topic on college students' writing. Written Communication, 2, 73-89.