Soil health is critical for healthy cities, yet little is known about how communities experience and address soil contamination. Contamination of soils can expose residents to heavy metals, which may have detrimental health effects. This study focuses on Buffalo, NY, using a mixed-methods approach to understand community experiences surrounding soil contaminants, planning, and policy. Findings reveal that spatial patterns of lead contaminants mirror segregation patterns, echoing environmental justice concerns. Residents engage in individual self-help actions, but some adopt risk-averse behaviors. Key takeaways include how policy tools are used to address issues of soil contamination and recommendations for addressing this issue.
AgyemanAgyemanEvansBob. 2004. “‘Just Sustainability’: The Emerging Discourse of Environmental Justice in Britain?” Geographical Journal170 (2): 155–64.
2.
AgyemanJulian. 2005. Sustainable Communities and the Challenge of Environmental Justice. NYU Press.
3.
AgyemanJulian. 2013. Introducing Just Sustainabilities: Policy, Planning, and Practice. NBN International.
4.
AhmadWaqarAlharthyRima D.ZubairMuhammadAhmedMahmoodHameedAbdulRafiqueSajjad. 2021. “Toxic and Heavy Metals Contamination Assessment in Soil and Water to Evaluate Human Health Risk.” Scientific Reports11 (1): 17006.
5.
American Community Survey. n.d. “5-Year Estimates.”
6.
AnguelovskiIsabelle. 2016. “From Toxic Sites to Parks as (Green) LULUs? New Challenges of Inequity, Privilege, Gentrification, and Exclusion for Urban Environmental Justice.” Journal of Planning Literature31 (1): 23–36.
7.
BalotinLaurenDistlerSamanthaWilliamsAntoinettePetersSamuel J. W.HunterCandis M.ThealChrisFrankGil, et al2020. “Atlanta Residents’ Knowledge Regarding Heavy Metal Exposures and Remediation in Urban Agriculture.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health17 (6): 2069. doi:10.3390/ijerph17062069.
8.
BanzhafSpencerMaLalaTimminsChristopher. 2019. “Environmental Justice: The Economics of Race, Place, and Pollution.” Journal of Economic Perspectives33 (1): 185–208.
9.
BecerraMarisol. 2013. “Environmental Justice for Whom? Brownfield Redevelopment and Gentrification in Chicago 1990-2010.”
10.
BenfordR. D.2005. “The Half-Life of the Environmental Justice Frame: Innovation, Diffusion, and Stagnation.” In Power, Justice, and the Environment: A Critical Appraisal of the Environmental Justice Movement, edited by PellowDavid N.BrulleRobert J.MIT Press.
11.
BermanElizabeth A.2017. “An Exploratory Sequential Mixed Methods Approach to Understanding Researchers’ Data Management Practices at UVM: Integrated Findings to Develop Research Data Services.
12.
BillingsStephen B.SchnepelKevin T.2018. “Life after Lead: Effects of Early Interventions for Children Exposed to Lead.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics10 (3): 315–44. doi:10.1257/app.20160056.
13.
BravoMercedes A.ZephyrDominiqueKowalDanielEnsorKatherineMirandaMarie Lynn. 2022. “Racial Residential Segregation Shapes the Relationship between Early Childhood Lead Exposure and Fourth-Grade Standardized Test Scores.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences119 (34): e2117868119. doi:10.1073/pnas.2117868119.
14.
BrinkleyCatherineWagnerJenny. 2024. “Who Is Planning for Environmental Justice—and How?” Journal of the American Planning Association90 (1): 63–76. doi:10.1080/01944363.2022.2118155.
15.
BullardRobert D.1994. “Environmental Justice for All: It’s the Right Thing to Do.” Journal of Environmental Law and Litigation9.
16.
BullardRobert D.MohaiPaulSahaRobinWrightBeverly. 2007. Toxic Wastes and Race at Twenty: 1987-2007. Cleveland, OH: United Church of Christ.
17.
BullardRobert D.WrightBeverly. 2008. “Disastrous Response to Natural and Man-Made Disasters: An Environmental Justice Analysis Twenty-Five Years after Warren County.” UCLA Journal of Environmental Law and Policy26:217.
18.
CameronRoslyn. 2009. “A Sequential Mixed Model Research Design: Design, Analytical and Display Issues.” International Journal of Multiple Research Approaches3 (2): 140–52.
19.
CameronTrudy AnnCrawfordGraham D.McConnahaIan T.2012. “Superfund Taint and Neighborhood Change.” The Political Economy of Environmental Justice137.
20.
City of Buffalo Department of Permit and Inspections.2020. “Proactive Rental Inspections.” City of Buffalo Department of Permit and Inspections.
21.
ClarkScottGalkeWarrenSuccopPaulGroteJoAnnMcLainePatWilsonJonathanDixonSherryMenrathWilliamRodaSandyChenMei. 2011. “Effects of HUD-Supported Lead Hazard Control Interventions in Housing on Children’s Blood Lead.” Environmental Research111 (2): 301–11.
22.
CuttsBethany B.LondonJonathan K.MeinersShainaSchwarzKirstenCadenassoMary L.2017. “Moving Dirt: Soil, Lead, and the Dynamic Spatial Politics of Urban Gardening.” Local Environment22 (8): 998–1018.
23.
DasuKavithaXiaXiaoyanSiriwardenaDinushaKlupinskiTheodore P.SeayBrannon. 2022. “Concentration Profiles of Per-and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in Major Sources to the Environment.” Journal of Environmental Management301:113879.
24.
DefoePhillip P.HettiarachchiGanga M.BenedictChristopherMartinSabine. 2014. “Safety of Gardening on Lead-and Arsenic-Contaminated Urban Brownfields.” Journal of Environmental Quality43 (6): 2064–78.
25.
DemetilloMary Angelique G.HarkinsColinMcDonaldBrian C.ChodrowPhilip S.SunKangPusedeSally E.2021. “Space-Based Observational Constraints on NO2 Air Pollution Inequality From Diesel Traffic in Major US Cities.” Geophysical Research Letters48 (17): e2021GL094333. doi:10.1029/2021GL094333.
26.
DennyMaxBaskaranMarkBurdickScottTummalaChandraDittrichTimothy. 2022. “Investigation of Pollutant Metals in Road Dust in a Post-Industrial City: Case Study from Detroit, Michigan.” Frontiers in Environmental Science10:974237.
27.
DeproBrooksTimminsChristopherO’neilMaggie. 2015. “White Flight and Coming to the Nuisance: Can Residential Mobility Explain Environmental Injustice?” Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists2 (3): 439–68.
28.
EgendorfSara PerlChengZhongqiDeebMahaFloresVictorPaltsevaAnnaWalshDanielGroffmanPeterMielkeHoward W.2018. “Constructed Soils for Mitigating Lead (Pb) Exposure and Promoting Urban Community Gardening: The New York City Clean Soil Bank Pilot Study.”; Landscape and Urban Planning175 (July): 184–94. doi:10.1016/j.landurbplan.2018.03.012.
29.
EgendorfSara PerlMielkeHoward W.Castorena-GonzalezJorge A.PowellEric T.GonzalesChristopher R.2021. “Soil Lead (Pb) in New Orleans: A Spatiotemporal and Racial Analysis.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health18 (3): 1314. doi:10.3390/ijerph18031314.
30.
Engel-Di MauroSalvatore. 2021. “Atmospheric Sources of Trace Element Contamination in Cultivated Urban Areas: A Review.” Journal of Environmental Quality50 (1): 38–48.
31.
Engel-Di MauroSalvataoreMartinGeorge. 2021. Urban Food Production for Ecosocialism: Cultivating the City. Taylor & Francis Group.
32.
EssokaJonathan D.2010. “The Gentrifying Effects of Brownfields Redevelopment.” Western Journal of Black Studies34 (3): 299.
33.
FeredayJenniferMuir-CochraneEimear. 2006. “Demonstrating Rigor Using Thematic Analysis: A Hybrid Approach of Inductive and Deductive Coding and Theme Development.” International Journal of Qualitative Methods5 (1): 80–92.
34.
FettersMichael D.CurryLeslie A.CreswellJohn W.2013. “Achieving Integration in Mixed Methods Designs—Principles and Practices.” Health Services Research48 (6pt2): 2134–56.
35.
ForkenbrockDavidSchweitzerLisa. 1999. “Environmental Justice in Transportation Planning.” Journal of the American Planning Association65 (1): 96–112. doi:10.1080/15480755.2007.10394433.
HardyDean. 2023. “Flood Risk as Legacy Vulnerability: Reading the Past into the Present for Environmental Justice.” Geoforum142:103757.
39.
HarmsAshley Marie RaesPresleyDeAnn R.HettiarachchiGanga M.ThienStephen J.2013. “Assessing the Educational Needs of Urban Gardeners and Farmers on the Subject of Soil Contamination.” Journal of Extension51 (1): 1FEA10.
40.
HeafnerHolly L.PaltsevaAnna A.2024. “Mapping Legacy Lead: Socioeconomic and Demographic Connections in Urban Soil Contamination in Lafayette, LA.” Journal of Soils and Sediments25: 484–509.
41.
HegedusCristinaAndronieLuisaUiuiuPaulJurcoEugenLazarEva AndreaPopescuSilvana. 2023. “Pets, Genuine Tools in Detecting Environmental Pollutants. Sentinels and Biomonitors.”
42.
HendricksMarccus D.Van ZandtShannon. 2021. “Unequal Protection Revisited: Planning for Environmental Justice, Hazard Vulnerability, and Critical Infrastructure in Communities of Color.” Environmental Justice14 (2): 87–97.
43.
HollanderJustinKirkwoodNiallGoldJulia. 2010. Principles of Brownfield Regeneration: Cleanup, Design, and Reuse of Derelict Land. Island Press.
44.
HuntAndrewJohnsonDavid L.2012. “Suspension and Resuspension of Dry Soil Indoors Following Track-in on Footwear.” Environmental Geochemistry and Health34:355–63.
45.
HunterCandis M.WilliamsonDana H. Z.GribbleMatthew O.BradshawHallePearsonMelanieSaikawaEriRyanP. BarryKeglerMichelle. 2019. “Perspectives on Heavy Metal Soil Testing among Community Gardeners in the United States: A Mixed Methods Approach.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health16 (13): 2350.
JafariShaghayegh. 2022. Use of Pets as Indicators of Heavy Metal Exposure across Sydney.” Macquarie University.
48.
JenningsAaron A.PetersenElijah J.2006. “Variability of North American Regulatory Guidance for Heavy Metal Contamination of Residential Soil.” Journal of Environmental Engineering and Science5 (6): 485–508.
49.
KaiserMichelle L.WilliamsMichele L.BastaNicholasHandMichelleHuberSarah. 2015. “When Vacant Lots Become Urban Gardens: Characterizing the Perceived and Actual Food Safety Concerns of Urban Agriculture in Ohio.” Journal of Food Protection78 (11): 2070–80.
50.
KaufmanJerome L.BailkeyMartin. 2000. Farming inside Cities: Entrepreneurial Urban Agriculture in the United States. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
51.
KennedyChinaroLordoRobertSucoskyMarissa ScaliaBoehmRonaBrownMary Jean. 2016. “Evaluating the Effectiveness of State Specific Lead-Based Paint Hazard Risk Reduction Laws in Preventing Recurring Incidences of Lead Poisoning in Children.” International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health219 (1): 110–17.
52.
KimBrent F.PoulsenMelissa N.MarguliesJared D.DixKatie L.PalmerAnne M.NachmanKeeve E.2014. “Urban Community Gardeners’ Knowledge and Perceptions of Soil Contaminant Risks.” PLOS ONE9 (2): e87913.
53.
KirkwoodNiall. 2003. Manufactured Sites: Rethinking the Post-industrial Landscape. Taylor & Francis.
LaidlawMark A. S.FilippelliGabriel M.BrownSallyPaz-FerreiroJorgeReichmanSuzie M.NetherwayPacianTruskewyczAdamBallAndrew S.MielkeHoward W.2017. “Case Studies and Evidence-Based Approaches to Addressing Urban Soil Lead Contamination.” Applied Geochemistry83:14–30.
56.
LaidlawMark A. S.MielkeHoward W.FilippelliGabriel M.JohnsonDavid L.GonzalesChristopher R.2005. “Seasonality and Children’s Blood Lead Levels: Developing a Predictive Model Using Climatic Variables and Blood Lead Data from Indianapolis, Indiana, Syracuse, New York, and New Orleans, Louisiana (USA).” Environmental Health Perspectives113 (6): 793–800. doi:10.1289/ehp.7759.
57.
LeechTamara G. J.AdamsElizabeth A.WeathersTess D.StatenLisa K.FilippelliGabriel M.2016. “Inequitable Chronic Lead Exposure: A Dual Legacy of Social and Environmental Injustice.” Family and Community Health39 (3): 151–59. doi:10.1097/FCH.0000000000000106.
58.
LiottaCharlotteKervinioYannLevrelHaroldTardieuLéa. 2020. “Planning for Environmental Justice-Reducing Well-Being Inequalities through Urban Greening.” Environmental Science & Policy112:47–60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2020.03.017
59.
LouresLuisVazEric. 2018. “Exploring Expert Perception towards Brownfield Redevelopment Benefits According to Their Typology.” Habitat International72:66–76.
60.
MagavernSam.2018. “Policies to Reduce Lead Exposure: Lessons from Buffalo and Rochester.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health15 (10): 2197.
61.
MaloneMelanie. 2022. “Seeking Justice, Eating Toxics: Overlooked Contaminants in Urban Community Gardens.” Agriculture and Human Values39 (1): 165–84.
62.
McBrideMurray B.ShaylerHannah A.SpliethoffHenry M.MitchellRebecca G.Marquez-BravoLydia G.FerenzGretchen S.Russell-AnelliJonathan M.CaseyLindaBachmanSharon. 2014. “Concentrations of Lead, Cadmium and Barium in Urban Garden-Grown Vegetables: The Impact of Soil Variables.” Environmental Pollution194:254–61.
63.
McClintockNathan. 2012. “Assessing Soil Lead Contamination at Multiple Scales in Oakland, California: Implications for Urban Agriculture and Environmental Justice.” Applied Geography35 (1): 460–73. doi:10.1016/j.apgeog.2012.10.001.
64.
MessagerMathis L.EttingerAilene K.Murphy-WilliamsMaiaLevinPhillip S.2021. “Fine-Scale Assessment of Inequities in Inland Flood Vulnerability.” Applied Geography133:102492.
65.
MeyerPamela A.StaleyForrestStaleyPaulaCurtisJerryBlantonCurtisBrownMary Jean. 2005. “Improving Strategies to Prevent Childhood Lead Poisoning Using Local Data.” International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health208 (1–2): 15–20.
66.
MeyerPeter B.LyonsThomas S.2000. “Lessons from Private Sector Brownfield Redevelopers: Planning Public Support for Urban Regeneration.” Journal of the American Planning Association66 (1): 46–57. doi:10.1080/01944360008976083
67.
MielkeHoward W.AndersonJ. C.BerryK. J.MielkeP. W.ChaneyR. L.LeechM.1983. “Lead Concentrations in Inner-City Soils as a Factor in the Child Lead Problem.” American Journal of Public Health73 (12): 1366–69. doi:10.2105/AJPH.73.12.1366
68.
MielkeHoward W.GonzalesChristopher R.SmithM. KelleyMielkePaul W.1999. “The Urban Environment and Children’s Health: Soils as an Integrator of Lead, Zinc, and Cadmium in New Orleans, Louisiana, USA.” Environmental Research81 (2): 117–29.
69.
MillerCarol J.Runge-MorrisMelissaCassidy-BushrowAndrea E.StraughenJennifer K.DittrichTimothy M.BakerTracie R.PetrielloMichael C., et al2020. “A Review of Volatile Organic Compound Contamination in Post-Industrial Urban Centers: Reproductive Health Implications Using a Detroit Lens.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health17 (23): 8755. doi:10.3390/ijerph17238755.
70.
MitchellRebecca G.SpliethoffHenry M.RibaudoLisa N.LoppDonna M.ShaylerHannah A.Marquez-BravoLydia G.LambertVeronique T.FerenzGretchen S.Russell-AnelliJonathan M.StoneEdie B.2014. “Lead (Pb) and Other Metals in New York City Community Garden Soils: Factors Influencing Contaminant Distributions.” Environmental Pollution187:162–69.
71.
MoraisSimone F.CostaGarciade Lourdes PereiraM.2012. “Heavy Metals and Human Health.” In Environmental Health–Emerging Issues and Practice, edited by OosthuizenJacques, 227–45.
72.
NakazawaDonna Jackson. 2009. The Autoimmune Epidemic: Bodies Gone Haywire in a World Out of Balance. New York: Touchstone/Simon & Schuster.
73.
NaranjoValeria I.HendricksMichaelJonesKimberly S.2020. “Lead Toxicity in Children: An Unremitting Public Health Problem.” Pediatric Neurology113 (December): 51–55. doi:10.1016/j.pediatrneurol.2020.08.005.
74.
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. 2005. “Record of Decision Amendment 858 East Ferry Street Site City of Buffalo, Erie County, New York Site Number 9-15-175.” New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.
PearsallHamil. 2013. “Superfund Me: A Study of Resistance to Gentrification in New York City.” Urban Studies50 (11): 2293–310.
78.
PellowDavid N.2018. What Is Critical Environmental Justice?Medford, Massachusetts: Polity.
79.
PopeRonaldWuJianguoBooneChristopher. 2016. “Spatial Patterns of Air Pollutants and Social Groups: A Distributive Environmental Justice Study in the Phoenix Metropolitan Region of USA.” Environmental Management58:753–66.
80.
ProudfootKevin. 2023. “Inductive/Deductive Hybrid Thematic Analysis in Mixed Methods Research.” Journal of Mixed Methods Research17 (3): 308–26.
81.
Ramirez-AndreottaMonica D.TapperAbigailCloughDiamondCarreraJennifer S.SandhausShana. 2019. “Understanding the Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations Associated with Community Gardening to Improve Environmental Public Health Prevention and Intervention.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health16 (3): 494.
82.
ReynoldsKristin. 2015. “Disparity despite Diversity: Social Injustice in New York City’s Urban Agriculture System.” Antipode47 (1): 240–59.
83.
RiveraDanielle Zoe. 2023. “Unincorporated and Underserved: Critical Stormwater Infrastructure Challenges in South Texas Colonias.” Environmental Justice16 (3): 203–209.
84.
SalkinPatricia. 2003. “Environmental Justice and Land Use Planning and Zoning.” Real Estate Law Journal32:429–48.
85.
SchlosbergDavid. 2004. “Reconceiving Environmental Justice: Global Movements and Political Theories.” Environmental Politics13 (3): 517–40. doi:10.1080/0964401042000229025.
86.
SchuslerTania M.KringsAmyMelstromRichard T.2023. “Experiences with Environmental Gentrification: Evidence from Chicago.” Landscape and Urban Planning236:104765.
87.
SchwarzKirstenCuttsBethany B.LondonJonathan K.CadenassoMary L.2016. “Growing Gardens in Shrinking Cities: A Solution to the Soil Lead Problem?” Sustainability8 (2): 141. doi:10.3390/su8020141.
88.
SchwarzKirstenPickettSteward T. A.LathropRichard G.WeathersKathleen C.PouyatRichard V.CadenassoMary L.2012. “The Effects of the Urban Built Environment on the Spatial Distribution of Lead in Residential Soils.” Environmental Pollution163 (April): 32–39. doi:10.1016/j.envpol.2011.12.003.
89.
SchwarzKirstenWohldmannErica L.ChenYujuanPouyatRichard V.GonzalezAndresMaoSelenaDaySusan D.2022. “Community Knowledge and Concerns About Urban Soil Science, Practice, and Process: Perspectives From the Healthy Soils for Healthy Communities Initiative in Los Angeles, CA, United States.” Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 9. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fevo.2021.781587.
90.
SharmaKuhukBastaNicholas T.GrewalParwinder S.2015. “Soil Heavy Metal Contamination in Residential Neighborhoods in Post-Industrial Cities and Its Potential Human Exposure Risk.” Urban Ecosystems18 (1): 115–32. doi:10.1007/s11252-014-0395-7.
91.
SharmaKuhukChengZhiqiangGrewalParwinder S.2015. “Relationship between Soil Heavy Metal Contamination and Soil Food Web Health in Vacant Lots Slated for Urban Agriculture in Two Post-Industrial Cities.” Urban Ecosystems18 (3): 835–55. doi:10.1007/s11252-014-0432-6.
92.
SilvermamRobert MarkPattersonKelly L.LewisJade. 2013. “Chasing a Paper Tiger: Evaluating Buffalo’s Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice.” Current Urban Studies1 (3): 28.
93.
TaylorHenry LouisJungJin-KyuDashEvan. 2021. The Harder We Run: The State of Black Buffalo in 1990 and the Present. State University of New York at Buffalo.
94.
UBRI. 2012. Mapping Waste: Setting the Stage to Clean-up Niagara. Buffalo, NY: UB Regional Institute.
WolvertonAnn. 2009. “Effects of Socio-Economic and Input-Related Factors on Polluting Plants’ Location Decisions.” The BE Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy9 (1).
98.
WongRogerGableLeahRivera-NúñezZorimar. 2018. “Perceived Benefits of Participation and Risks of Soil Contamination in St. Louis Urban Community Gardens.” Journal of Community Health43:604–10.
99.
YeterDenizBanksEllen C.AschnerMichael. 2020. “Disparity in Risk Factor Severity for Early Childhood Blood Lead among Predominantly African-American Black Children: The 1999 to 2010 US NHANES.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health17 (5): 1552. doi:10.3390/ijerph17051552.
100.
YinLiYinFuzhenSilvermanRobert M.2023. “Spatial Clustering of Property Abandonment in Shrinking Cities: A Case Study of Targeted Demolition in Buffalo, NY’s African American Neighborhoods.” Urban Geography44 (10): 2251–70. doi:10.1080/02723638.2022.2142404.
