Long Commutes,Work-Life Balance,and Well-Being: A Mixed-Methods Study of Hong Kong’s New-Town Residents

Abstract

Spanish

Chinese

This study examines the cascading effects of long commutes on the work-life balance and subjective well-being of commuters from Hong Kong’s new towns. We collected questionnaire surveys and developed a structural equation model. Our results show that new-town commuters experienced lower levels of travel satisfaction, work-life balance, and subjective well-being. Meanwhile, our qualitative analysis of interview transcripts reveals that new-town residents endure longer commutes for various reasons but primarily to enjoy the better natural environment and living conditions available in suburban areas. However, the inadequate supply of public amenities and social and cultural venues in the suburbs can undermine well-being.

Keywords

new town commute work-life balance well-being mixed-methods

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abou-Zeid

Ben-Akiva

2011. “The Effect of Social Comparisons on Commute Well-Being.” Transportation Research Part A 45 (4): 345–61.

Alexander

2009. Britain’s New Towns: Garden Cities to Sustainable Communities. London: Routledge.

Bai

Gopalan

Beutell

Ren

2021. “Impact of Absolute and Relative Commute Time on Work–Family Conflict: Work Schedule Control, Child Care Hours, and Life Satisfaction.” Journal of Family and Economic Issues 42:586–600.

Burnard

1991. “A Method of Analysing Interview Transcripts in Qualitative Research.” Nurse Education Today 11 (6): 461–66.

Byrne

B. M.

2001. “Structural Equation Modeling: Perspectives on the Present and the Future.” International Journal of Testing 1 (3–4): 327–34.

Census and Statistics Department. 2022. Labour Force, Employment and Unemployment. https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/en/scode200.html.

Cervero

1995a. “Planned Communities, Self-Containment and Commuting: A Cross-National Perspective.” Urban Studies 32 (7): 1135–61.

Cervero

1995b. “Sustainable New Towns: Stockholm’s Rail-Served Satellites.” Cities 12 (1): 41–51.

Cervero

1998. “Sub-centring and Commuting: Evidence from the San Francisco Bay Area, 1980-90.” Urban Studies 35 (7): 1059–76.

10.

Clark

S. C.

2000. “Work/Family Border Theory: A New Theory of Work/Family Balance.” Human Relations 53 (6): 747–70.

11.

Day

2013. “Effects of Residential Relocation on Household Satisfaction in Shanghai, China.” Urban Policy and Research 31 (1): 93–117.

12.

Day

Cervero

2010. “Effects of Residential Relocation on Household and Commuting Expenditures in Shanghai, China.” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 34 (4): 762–88.

13.

De Vos

Schwanen

Van Acker

Witlox

2013. “Travel and Subjective Well-Being: A Focus on Findings, Methods and Future Research Needs.” Transport Reviews 33 (4): 421–42.

14.

Dickerson

Hole

A. R.

Munford

L. A.

2014. “The Relationship between Well-Being and Commuting Revisited: Does the Choice of Methodology Matter?” Regional Science and Urban Economics 49:321–29.

15.

Forsyth

2019. “The British New Towns: Lessons for the World from the New-Town Experiment.” The Town Planning Review 90 (3): 239–46.

16.

Forsyth

2021. “The Promises and Pitfalls of New Towns.” In New Towns for the Twenty-First Century, edited by Peiser

Forsyth

32–42. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

17.

Golob

T. F.

2003. “Structural Equation Modeling for Travel Behavior Research.” Transportation Research Part B 37 (1): 1–25.

18.

Greenhaus

J. H.

Collins

K. M.

Shaw

J. D.

2003. “The Relation between Work–Family Balance and Quality of Life.” Journal of Vocational Behavior 63 (3): 510–31.

19.

Grengs

2010. “Job Accessibility and The Modal Mismatch in Detroit.” Journal of Transport Geography 18 (1): 42–54.

20.

Hall

2014. Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design since 1880. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

21.

S. Y.

2020. “Regional Impact of Rail Network Accessibility on Residential Property Price: Modelling Spatial Heterogeneous Capitalisation Effects in Hong Kong.” Transportation Research Part A 135:244–63.

22.

S. Y.

Giuliano

2018. “School Choice: Understanding the Trade-Off between Travel Distance and School Quality.” Transportation 45:1475–98.

23.

S. Y.

Tao

Hou

Jiang

2018. “Mass Transit Railway, Transit-Oriented Development, and Spatial Justice: The Competition for Prime Residential Locations in Hong Kong since the 1980s.” Town Planning Review 89:467–93.

24.

S. Y.

Tao

M. K.

Tieben

2020. “Evaluating Hong Kong’s Spatial Planning in New Towns from the Perspectives of Job Accessibility, Transport Mobility Patterns, and Work–Life Balance.” Journal of the American Planning Association 86:324–38.

25.

S. Y.

Chen

Hou

M. K.

2020. “New Towns and the Local Agglomeration Economy.” Habitat International 98:102153.

26.

Hong Kong Centre for Health Protection, Department of Health. 2022. “Archives of Latest Situation of Cases of COVID-19.” https://www.chp.gov.hk/tc/features/102997.html?page=35.

27.

Hong Kong Transport Department. 2014. “Travel Characteristics Survey 2011—Final Report.” https://www.td.gov.hk/en/publications_and_press_releases/publications/free_publications/travel_characteristics_survey_2011_final_report/index.html.

28.

Howard

1898. To-morrow: A Peaceful Path in Real Reform. London: Routledge.

29.

2015. “Changing Effects of Job Accessibility on Employment and Commute: A Case Study of Los Angeles.” The Professional Geographer 67 (2): 154–65.

30.

Jain

Lyons

2008. “The Gift of Travel Time.” Journal of Transport Geography 16:81–89.

31.

Kawabata

Shen

2007. “Commuting Inequality between Cars and Public Transit: The Case of the San Francisco Bay Area, 1990-2000.” Urban Studies 44 (9): 1759–80.

32.

Keyes

C. L.

2002. “The Mental Health Continuum: From Languishing to Flourishing in Life.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 43 (2): 207–22.

33.

Levinson

D. M.

1998. “Accessibility and the Journey to Work.” Journal of Transport Geography 6 (1): 11–21.

34.

Lui

H. K.

Suen

2011. “The Effects of Public Housing on Internal Mobility in Hong Kong.” Journal of Housing Economics 20 (1): 15–29.

35.

Lyons

Chatterjee

2008. “A Human Perspective on the Daily Commute: Costs, Benefits and Trade-Offs.” Transport Reviews 28:181–98.

36.

Mao

Ettema

Dijst

2016. “Commuting Trip Satisfaction in Beijing: Exploring the Influence of Multimodal Behavior and Modal Flexibility.” Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 94:592–603.

37.

Mokhtarian

P. L.

Salomon

2001. “How Derived Is the Demand for Travel? Some Conceptual and Measurement Considerations.” Transportation Research A 35:695–719.

38.

O’Sullivan

2009. Urban Economics. 7th ed. Boston: McGraw-Hill.

39.

Peiser

Forsyth

, eds. 2021. New Towns for the Twenty-First Century. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

40.

Rowe

P. G.

2021. “New Towns in East and Southeast Asia.” In New Towns for the Twenty-First Century, edited by Peiser

Forsyth

, 119–51. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

41.

Schwanen

Mokhtarian

P. L.

2005. “What Affects Commute Mode Choice: Neighborhood Physical Structure or Preferences Toward Neighborhoods?” Journal of Transport Geography 13:83–99.

42.

Sirgy

M. J.

Lee

D. J.

2018. “Work-Life Balance: An Integrative Review.” Applied Research in Quality of Life 13 (1): 229–54.

43.

Tao

S. Y.

2021. “Job Accessibility and Joint Household Travel: A Study of Hong Kong with a Particular Focus on New Town Residents.” Transportation 48:1379–1407.

44.

Tao

S. Y.

Chen

Lee

Liu

2023. “Walking Accessibility to Non-Work Facilities and Travel Patterns in Suburban New Towns.” Cities 137:104324.

45.

The Government of Hong Kong. 2021. Northern Metropolis Development Strategy. www.policyaddress.gov.hk.

46.

Wang

Rodríguez

D. A.

Sarmiento

Guaje

2019. “Commute Patterns and Depression: Evidence from Eleven Latin American Cities.” Journal of Transport & Health 14:100607.

47.

Watts

Urry

2008. “Moving Methods, Travelling Times.” Environment and Planning D 26 (5): 860–74.

48.

Wheatley

2014. “Travel-to-Work and Subjective Well-Being: A Study of UK Dual Career Households.” Journal of Transport Geography 39:187–96.

49.

White

J. M.

1999. “Work-Family Stage and Satisfaction with Work-Family Balance.” Journal of Comparative Family Studies 30 (2): 163–75.

50.

Yang

Day

2015a. “Operationalizing the Capabilities Approach for Modeling Household Welfare Shifts in Urban Systems: A Special Focus on the Transportation Outcomes of Urban Resettlement.” In Understanding Complex Urban Systems, edited by Walloth

Atun

Gebetsroither

vol. 2, 95–112. Cham: Springer.

51.

Yang

Day

2015b. “Operationalizing the Capabilities Approach for Urban Policy Evaluation: The Travel Welfare Impacts of Government Job Resettlement.” Geography Research Forum 35:168–99.

52.

Yeh

A. G.

2004. “Public Housing and New Town Development.” In Fifty Years of Public Housing in Hong Kong: A Golden Jubilee Review and Appraisal, edited by Yeung

Y.-M.

Wang

Kowloon: Hong Kong Housing Authority. pp.85–108.

53.

Zhao

Liu

2020. “Long Commutes and Transport Inequity in China’s Growing Megacity: New Evidence from Beijing Using Mobile Phone Data.” Travel Behaviour & Society 20:248–63.

54.

Zhou

Cheng

2013. “The Impact of Spatial Mismatch on Residents in Low-Income Housing Neighbourhoods: A Study of the Guangzhou Metropolis, China.” Urban Studies 50 (9): 1817–35.

55.

Zhu

Fan

2018. “Daily Travel Behavior and Emotional Well-Being: Effects of Trip Mode, Duration, Purpose, and Companionship.” Transportation Research Part A 118:360–73.

56.

Zhu

S. N.

Jiang

Tan

2020. “Built Environment, Commuting Behaviour and Job Accessibility in a Rail-Based Dense Urban Context.” Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 87:102438.