The Demise of “Advocacy Planning” in Community Design? A Content Analysis of the Mission Statements of Community Design Centers (CDCs) in the United States
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2023
The Demise of “Advocacy Planning” in Community Design? A Content Analysis of the Mission Statements of Community Design Centers (CDCs) in the United States
This paper investigates the role(s) of contemporary community design centers (CDC) in the United States. Based on a content analysis of CDCs’ mission statements and semi-structured interviews with selected CDC leaders, I identify seven roles these organizations perform. The results indicate that current CDCs do not exclusively focus on assisting underserved communities. They perform a more diverse set of roles for various socioeconomic communities. These different roles suggest that CDCs can, and should, be thought of as a diverse category of planning organization. In conclusion, I suggest three implications for planning education and future research and practice related to community design.
AveryMichelStreibelBarbara J.AuvineBrianWeissLonnie. 1981. Building United Judgment: A Handbook for Consensus Decision Making. Madison: Center for Conflict Resolution.
3.
BerlanDavid. 2018. “Understanding Nonprofit Missions as Dynamic and Interpretative Conceptions.” Nonprofit Management and Leadership28 (3): 413–22.
4.
BlakeSheri. 2003. “Community Design: An Alternative Practice.” In Time-Saver Standards for Urban Design, edited by WatsonDonaldPlattusAlanShibleyRobert G., 4.11-1–4.11-8. New York: McGraw-Hill.
5.
BlakeSheri. 2014. “Defining/Redefining Community Design: A History of Community Design Centers.” In Activist Architecture: Philosophy & Practice of the Community Design Center, edited by PiteraDanWilkinsCraig L., 50–69. Detroit: Detroit Collaborative Design Center.
6.
BriggsXavier de Souza. 1998. “Doing Democracy Up-Close: Culture, Power, and Communication in Community Building.” Journal of Planning Education and Research18 (1): 1–13.
7.
CaryJohn M.Jr., ed. 2000. The ACSA Sourcebook of Community Design Programs at Schools of Architecture in North America. Washington, DC: ACSA Press.
8.
CephasJana. 2014. “The Influence of Community Design Centers on Society.” In Activist Architecture: Philosophy & Practice of the Community Design Center, edited by PiteraDanWilkinsCraig L., 161–70. Detroit: Detroit Collaborative Design Center.
9.
CharitonidouMarianna. 2021. “The 1968 Effects and Civic Responsibility in Architecture and Urban Planning in the USA and Italy: Challenging ‘Nuova Dimensione’ and ‘Urban Renewal.’” Urban, Planning and Transport Research9 (1): 549–78.
10.
ChristensenKaren S.2015. “Both Process and Outcome Are Essential to Planning.” Journal of Planning Education and Research35 (2): 188–98.
11.
ComerioMary C.1984. “Community Design: Idealism and Entrepreneurship.” Journal of Architectural and Planning Research1 (4): 227–43.
12.
CurryRex. 2004. “Community Design Centers.” In Good Deeds, Good Design: Community Service through Architecture, edited by BellBryan, 61–70. New York: Princeton Architecture Press.
13.
DavidoffPaul. 1965. “Advocacy and Pluralism in Planning.” Journal of the American Institute of Planners31 (4): 331–38.
FinnDonovanBrodyJason. 2014. “The State of Community Design: An Analysis of Community Design Center Services.” Journal of Architectural and Planning Research31 (3): 181–200.
Fox-RogersLindaMurphyEnda. 2016. “Self-Perceptions of the Role of the Planner.” Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design43 (1): 74–92.
18.
GodschalkDavid R.ParhamDavid W.PorterDouglas R.PotapchukWilliam R.SchukraftSteven W.1994. Pulling Together: A Planning and Development Consensus-building Manual. Washington, DC: Urban Land Institute.
19.
GoldsteinBrian D.2016. “‘The Search for New Forms’: Black Power and the Making of the Postmodern City.” Journal of American History103 (2): 375–99.
20.
GoodmanAnna. 2020. “Karl Linn and the Foundations of Community Design: From Progressive Models to the War on Poverty.” Journal of Urban History46 (4): 794–815.
21.
GunderMichael. 2011. “Commentary: Is Urban Design Still Urban Planning? An Exploration and Response.” Journal of Planning Education and Research31 (2): 184–95.
22.
HallPeter. 2014. Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design since 1880. 4th ed.Malden: Wiley Blackwell.
23.
HatchC. Richard, ed. 1984. The Scope of Social Architecture. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Company.
24.
HesterRandolph T.1989. “Community Design Today: From the Inside Out.” Landscape Journal8 (2): 128–37.
25.
HoweElizabethKaufmanJerome. 1979. “The Ethics of Contemporary American Planners.” Journal of the American Planning Association45 (3): 243–55.
26.
JohnsonBonnie J.2012. “Public Service Motivation and the Technical, Political, and Facilitator Roles of City Planners.” International Journal of Public Administration35 (1): 30–45.
27.
JuarezJeffrey A.BrownKyle D.2008. “Extracting or Empowering? A Critique of Participatory Methods for Marginalized Populations.” Landscape Journal27 (2): 190–204.
28.
KingsleyG. ThomasMcNeelyJoseph B.GibsonJames O.1997. Community Building: Coming of Age. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
LevinIra M.2000. “Vision Revisited: Telling the Story of the Future.” The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science36 (1): 91–107.
31.
LinovskiOrlyLoukaitou-SiderisAnastasia. 2012. “Evolution of Urban Design Plans in the United States and Canada: What Do the Plans Tell Us about Urban Design Practice?” Journal of Planning Education and Research33 (1): 66–82.
32.
MadanipourAli. 2014. Urban Design, Space and Society. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
33.
MatlinDaniel. 2018. “‘A New Reality of Harlem’: Imagining the African American Urban Future during the 1960s.” Journal of American Studies52 (4): 991–1024.
34.
MelcherKatherine. 2013. “Equity, Empowerment, or Participation: Prioritizing Goals in Community Design.” Landscape Journal32 (2): 167–82.
35.
MoomawSuzanne Morse. 2016. “Improving Local Results: Fusing Community Design and Community Development.” Community Development47 (5): 670–82.
36.
MooreMark H.2000. “Managing for Value: Organizational Strategy in for-Profit, Nonprofit, and Governmental Organizations.” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly29 (1): 183–204.
37.
NordhausRichard. 2001. “Community Design.” In Architectural Design Portable Handbook: A Guide to Excellent Practices, edited by PressmanAndy, 400–12. New York: McGraw Hill.
38.
OzawaConnie P.SeltzerEthan P.1999. “Taking Our Bearings: Mapping a Relationship among Planning Practice, Theory, and Education.” Journal of Planning Education and Research18 (3): 257–66.
39.
PandeySheelaKimMiraePandeySanjay K.2017. “Do Mission Statements Matter for Nonprofit Performance? Insights from a Study of U.S. Performing Arts Organizations.” Nonprofit Management & Leadership27 (3): 389–410.
40.
SachnerPaul M.1983. “Still Planning with the Poor: Community Design Centers Keep Up the Good Works.” Architectural Record171 (June1983): 126–31.
41.
SanoffHenry. 2000. Community Participation Methods in Design and Planning. New York: John Wiley.
42.
SanoffHenry. 2006. “Origins of Community Design.” Progressive Planning166:14–17.
43.
SmithCharles P.2000. “Content Analysis and Narrative Analysis.” In Handbook of Research Methods in Social and Personality Psychology, edited by ReisH. T.JuddC. M., 313–35. New York: Cambridge University Press.
44.
SteinerFrederick R.ButlerKent S., eds. 2007. Planning and Urban Design Standards. Hoboken: John Wiley.
45.
TokerZeynep. 2007. “Recent Trends in Community Design: The Eminence of Participation.” Design Studies28 (3): 309–23.
46.
TokerZeynepTokerUmut. 2006. “Community Design in Its Pragmatist Age: Increasing Popularity and Changing Outcomes.” METU Journal of the Faculty of Architecture23 (2): 155–66.
47.
TuralElif. 2017. “Organizational Transformations in Community Design Centers: An Analysis through Giddens’ Theory of Structuration Framework.” Journal of Community Practice25 (2): 253–82.
48.
Van MaasakkersMattijsOhJeeson. 2020. “Where Should We Have the Meeting? Venue Creation for Participation and Collaboration in Planning.” Journal of the American Planning Association86 (2): 196–207.
49.
VogelStephen. 2014. “The Foundations of Community Design.” In Activist Architecture: Philosophy & Practice of the Community Design Center, edited by PiteraDanWilkinsCraig L., 69–79. Detroit: Detroit Collaborative Design Center.
50.
WatersRichard D.2007. “Nonprofit Organizations’ Use of the Internet: A Content Analysis of Communication Trends on the Internet Sites of the Philanthropy 400.” Nonprofit Management and Leadership18 (1): 59–76.
