Beyond Neighborhood Design: Exploring the Effects of Smart Growth on Older Adults’ Travel Behavior over Time

Abstract

Spanish

Chinese

Previous studies mainly substantiate the influence of neighborhood design on older adults’ travel behavior. This study goes beyond and examines how smart growth affects older adults’ travel behavior over time in the central Puget Sound. Using regression models for the years 1999, 2006, and 2014, we find that smart growth factors have significant but changing effects. The regional growth centers play a growing role in reducing older adults’ travel distance, trip frequency, and promoting non-car commuting modes. This study adds to the knowledge of how older adults’ travel behavior can be affected by the multilevel and long-term urban development strategies.

Keywords

built environment central Puget Sound older adults smart growth travel behavior

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbott

R. D.

White

L. R.

Ross

G. W.

Masaki

K. H.

Curb

J. D.

Petrovitch

. 2004. “Walking and Dementia in Physically Capable Elderly Men.” Journal of the American Medical Association 292 (12): 1447–53.

American Public Transportation Association. 2016. “The Hidden Traffic Safety Solution: Public Transportation.” Washington, DC: American Public Transportation Association. https://www.apta.com/wp-content/uploads/Resources/resources/reportsandpublications/Documents/APTA-Hidden-Traffic-Safety-Solution-Public-Transportation.pdf.

Bai

Zhai

Steiner

R. L.

. 2020. “Exploring Extreme Commuting and Its Relationship to Land Use and Socioeconomics in the Central Puget Sound.” Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 88:102574.

Banister

2011. “Cities, Mobility and Climate Change.” Journal of Transport Geography 19 (6): 1538–46.

Barnes

Winters

Ste-Marie

McKay

Ashe

M. C.

. 2016. “Age and Retirement Status Differences in Associations between the Built Environment and Active Travel Behaviour.” Journal of Transport & Health 3 (4): 513–22.

Boakye-Dankwa

Barnett

Pachana

N. A.

Turrell

Cerin

. 2019. “Associations between Latent Classes of Perceived Neighborhood Destination Accessibility and Walking Behaviors in Older Adults of a Low-Density and a High-Density City.” Journal of Aging and Physical Activity 27 (4): 553–64.

Boschmann

E. E.

Brady

S. A.

. 2013. “Travel Behaviors, Sustainable Mobility, and Transit-Oriented Developments: A Travel Counts Analysis of Older Adults in the Denver, Colorado Metropolitan Area.” Journal of Transport Geography 33:1–11.

Cao

Chatman

. 2016. “How Will Smart Growth Land-Use Policies Affect Travel? A Theoretical Discussion on the Importance of Residential Sorting.” Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 43 (1): 58–73.

Cao

Mokhtarian

P. L.

Handy

S. L.

. 2010. “Neighborhood Design and the Accessibility of the Elderly: An Empirical Analysis in Northern California.” International Journal of Sustainable Transportation 4 (6): 347–71.

10.

Carp

F. M.

1988. “Significance of Mobility for the Well-Being of the Elderly.” Transportation in an Aging Society: Improving Mobility and Safety of Older Persons 2:1–20.

11.

Carrapatoso

Silva

Colaço

Carvalho

. 2018. “Perceptions of the Neighborhood Environment Associated with Walking at Recommended Intensity and Volume Levels in Recreational Senior Walkers.” Journal of Housing for the Elderly 32 (1): 26–38.

12.

Cerin

Barnett

Zhang

C. J.

Lai

P. C.

Sit

C. H.

Lee

R. S.

. 2020. “How Urban Densification Shapes Walking Behaviours in Older Community Dwellers: A Cross-sectional Analysis of Potential Pathways Of Influence.” International Journal of Health Geographics 19 (1): 1–18.

13.

Cerin

Sit

C. H.

Barnett

Johnston

J. M.

Cheung

M. C.

Chan

W. M.

. 2014. “Ageing in an Ultra-dense Metropolis: Perceived Neighbourhood Characteristics and Utilitarian Walking in Hong Kong Elders.” Public Health Nutrition 17 (1): 225–32.

14.

Cervero

Kockelman

. 1997. “Travel Demand and the 3Ds: Density, Diversity, and Design.” Transportation Research. Part D, Transport and Environment 2 (3): 199–219.

15.

Charles

Symington

. 2009. “From Barriers to Solutions and Best Practices: Urban Centers and TOD in Washington by the Runstad Center for Real Estate Studies for The Quality Growth Alliance.” Reconnecting America. https://www.crwolfelaw.com/downloads/From%20Barriers%20to%20Solutions.pdf.

16.

Chen

Y. J.

Akar

. 2017. “Using Trip Chaining and Joint Travel as Mediating Variables to Explore the Relationships among Travel Behavior, Socio-demographics, and Urban Form.” Journal of Transport and Land Use 10 (1): 573–88.

17.

Cheng

Chen

Yang

Cao

De Vos

Witlox

. 2019. “Active Travel for Active Ageing in China: The Role of Built Environment.” Journal of Transport Geography 76:142–52.

18.

Chudyk

A. M.

Winters

Moniruzzaman

Ashe

M. C.

Gould

J. S.

McKay

. 2015. “Destinations Matter: The Association between Where Older Adults Live and Their Travel Behavior.” Journal of Transport & Health 2 (1): 50–57.

19.

Cui

Loo

B. P.

Lin

. 2017. “Travel Behaviour and Mobility Needs of Older Adults in an Ageing and Car-Dependent Society.” International Journal of Urban Sciences 21 (2): 109–28.

20.

Dalal

Goulias

K. G.

. 2014. “An Analysis of Jobs, Business Establishments, Housing, and Commuting Travel in the Smart Growth Centers of the Puget Sound Region.” https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/An-Analysis-of-Jobs-%2C-Business-Establishments-%2C-%2C-Dalal/f55d869483a4d18773638ad163b1392d55305211.

21.

Dierwechter

2014. “The Spaces that Smart Growth Makes: Sustainability, Segregation, and Residential Change across Greater Seattle.” Urban Geography 35 (5): 691–714.

22.

Dierwechter

Carlson

. 2007. “Effects of Urban Growth Boundaries on Residential Development in Pierce County, Washington.” The Professional Geographer 59 (2): 209–20.

23.

Ettelman

Moran

Cardenas

Hudson

J. G.

Minot

Lasley

. 2017. Identifying Transportation Solutions that Promote Healthy Aging for Texas. No. PRC 17-83 F. College Station: Texas A&M Transportation Institute.

24.

Feng

2017. “The Influence of Built Environment on Travel Behavior of the Elderly in Urban China.” Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 52:619–33.

25.

Filion

McSpurren

. 2007. “Smart Growth and Development Reality: The Difficult Co-ordination of Land Use and Transport Objectives.” Urban Studies 44 (3): 501–23.

26.

Freeland

A. L.

Banerjee

S. N.

Dannenberg

A. L.

Wendel

A. M.

. 2013. “Walking Associated with Public Transit: Moving toward Increased Physical Activity in the United States.” American Journal of Public Health 103 (3): 536–42.

27.

Gonda

1982. “Transportation, Perceived Control, and Well-Being in the Elderly.” Specialized Transportation Planning and Practice 1 (1): 61–72.

28.

Hajna

Dasgupta

Joseph

Ross

N. A.

. 2014. “A Call for Caution and Transparency in the Calculation of Land Use Mix: Measurement Bias in the Estimation of Associations between Land Use Mix and Physical Activity.” Health & Place 29:79–83.

29.

Handy

Cao

Mokhtarian

. 2005. “Correlation or Causality between the Built Environment and Travel Behavior? Evidence from Northern California.” Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 10 (6): 427–44.

30.

Haustein

2012. “Mobility Behavior of the Elderly: An Attitude-Based Segmentation Approach for a Heterogeneous Target Group.” Transportation 39 (6): 1079–1103.

31.

Hepinstall-Cymerman

Coe

Hutyra

L. R.

. 2013. “Urban Growth Patterns and Growth Management Boundaries in the Central Puget Sound, Washington, 1986–2007.” Urban Ecosystems 16 (1): 109–29.

32.

Julien

Richard

Gauvin

Fournier

Kestens

Shatenstein

Daniel

Mercille

Payette

. 2015. “Transit Use and Walking as Potential Mediators of the Association between Accessibility to Services and Amenities and Social Participation among Urban-Dwelling Older Adults: Insights from the VoisiNuAge Study.” Journal of Transport & Health 2 (1): 35–43.

33.

Jun

M. J.

2008. “Are Portland’s Smart Growth Policies Related to Reduced Automobile Dependence?” Journal of Planning Education and Research 28 (1): 100–107.

34.

Kan

H. Y.

Forsyth

Molinsky

. 2020. “Measuring the Built Environment for Aging in Place: A Review of Neighborhood Audit Tools.” Journal of Planning Literature 35 (2): 180–94.

35.

Kang

Moudon

A. V.

Hurvitz

P. M.

Saelens

B. E.

. 2017. “Differences in Behavior, Time, Location, and Built Environment between Objectively Measured Utilitarian and Recreational Walking.” Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 57:185–94.

36.

Kavage

S. E.

Moudon

A. V.

Mabry

J. E.

Pergakes

. 2005. “Transportation-Efficient Land Use Regulations and Their Application in the Puget Sound Region, Washington.” Transportation Research Record 1902 (1): 44–54.

37.

Kim

2003. “Analysis of Elderly Mobility by Structural Equation Modeling.” Transportation Research Record 1854 (1): 81–89.

38.

Lee

J. H.

Tan

T. H.

. 2019. “Neighborhood Walkability or Third Places? Determinants of Social Support and Loneliness among Older Adults.” Journal of Planning Education and Research. Published electronically August 14. doi:10.1177/0739456X19870295.

39.

Maoh

Tang

. 2012. “Determinants of Normal and Extreme Commute Distance in a Sprawled Midsize Canadian City: Evidence from Windsor, Canada.” Journal of Transport Geography 25:50–57.

40.

Margerum

R. D.

Brody

Parker

McEwen

. 2013. “Metropolitan Smart-Growth Centers: An Assessment of Incentive Policies in Four Regions.” Journal of Transport and Land Use 6 (2): 21–32.

41.

Nathan

Pereira

Foster

Hooper

Saarloos

Giles-Corti

. 2012. “Access to Commercial Destinations within the Neighbourhood and Walking among Australian Older Adults.” International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 9 (1): 133.

42.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. 2020. “Traffic Safety Facts Annual Report Tables.” National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, June 30. https://cdan.nhtsa.gov/tsftables/tsfar.htm.

43.

Nyunt

M. S. Z.

Shuvo

F. K.

Eng

J. Y.

Yap

K. B.

Scherer

Hee

L. M.

Chan

S. P.

T. P.

. 2015. “Objective and Subjective Measures of Neighborhood Environment (NE): Relationships with Transportation Physical Activity among Older Persons.” International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 12 (1): 108.

44.

Porter

C. D.

ten Siethoff

Smith

. 2005. “Impacts of Comprehensive Planning and Smart Growth Initiatives on Transportation: Case Studies of Five Regions.” Transportation Research Record 1902 (1): 91–98.

45.

Puget Sound Regional Council. 2010. “Vision 2040 Plan.” Seattle, WA: Puget Sound Regional Council.

46.

Puget Sound Regional Council. 2013. “Implementing Equitable Transit Communities: Regional & Local Recommendations for the Central Puget Sound Region.” https://www.psrc.org/sites/default/files/gtc_implementation_report_se011116withblankpage.pdf.

47.

Puget Sound Regional Council. 2015. “PSRC’S 2014 Regional Travel Study.” Puget Sound Regional Council, June. https://www.psrc.org/sites/default/files/regionaltravelsurveyscomparison.pdf.

48.

Puget Sound Regional Council. 2018. “Aging Population, Smaller Households in Region.” Puget Sound Regional Council, April 18. https://www.psrc.org/whats-happening/blog/aging-population-smaller-households-region.

49.

Puget Sound Regional Council. 2019. “How Do Older Adults Get around the Region?” Puget Sound Regional Council, June 11. https://www.psrc.org/whats-happening/blog/how-do-older-adults-get-around-region.

50.

Puget Sound Regional Council. 2020. “Vision 2050.” Puget Sound Regional Council, October 29. https://www.psrc.org/sites/default/files/vision-2050-plan.pdf.

51.

Ravulaparthy

Yoon

S. Y.

Goulias

K. G.

. 2013. “Linking Elderly Transport Mobility and Subjective Well-Being: A Multivariate Latent Modeling Approach.” Transportation Research Record 2382 (1): 28–36.

52.

Rosenbloom

2001. “Sustainability and Automobility among the Elderly: An International Assessment.” Transportation 28 (4): 375–408.

53.

Rosenbloom

2009. “Meeting Transportation Needs in an Aging-Friendly Community.” Generations 33 (2): 33–43.

54.

Schramm

Jennifer

. 2018. “An Aging Labor Force and the Challenges of 65+ Jobseekers.” AARP Public Policy Institute, September 17. https://www.aarp.org/content/dam/aarp/ppi/2018/09/an-aging-labor-force-and-the-challenges-of-sixty-five-plus-jobseekers.pdf.

55.

Siren

Haustein

. 2013. “Baby Boomers’ Mobility Patterns and Preferences: What Are the Implications for Future Transport?” Transport Policy 29:136–44.

56.

Siren

Hjorthol

Levin

. 2015. “Different Types of Out-of-Home Activities and Well-Being amongst Urban Residing Old Persons with Mobility Impediments.” Journal of Transport & Health 2 (1): 14–21.

57.

Smith

T. C.

Wingard

D. L.

Smith

Kritz-Silverstein

Barrett-Connor

. 2007. “Walking Decreased Risk of Cardiovascular Disease Mortality in Older Adults with Diabetes.” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 60 (3): 309–17.

58.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 2011. “Smart Growth—A Guide to Developing and Implementing Greenhouse Gas Reductions Programs.” U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2017-06/documents/sm_growth_guide.pdf.

59.

Vincent

G. K.

Velkoff

V. A.

. 2010. “The Next Four Decades: The Older Population in the United States: 2010 To 2050.” No. 1138. U.S. Department of Commerce, Economics and Statistics Administration, U.S. Census Bureau.

60.

Weitz

1999. Sprawl Busting: State Programs to Guide Growth. Chicago: Planners Press.

61.

Yang

Rodriguez

D. A.

Michael

Zhang

. 2018. “Active Travel, Public Transportation Use, and Daily Transport among Older Adults: The Association of Built Environment.” Journal of Transport & Health 9:288–98.

62.

Zandieh

Martinez

Flacke

Jones

Van Maarseveen

. 2016. “Older Adults’ Outdoor Walking: Inequalities in Neighbourhood Safety, Pedestrian Infrastructure and Aesthetics.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 13 (12): 1179.

63.

Zeitler

Buys

Aird

Miller

. 2012. “Mobility and Active Ageing in Suburban Environments: Findings from In-Depth Interviews and Person-Based GPS Tracking.” Current Gerontology and Geriatrics Research 2012.

64.

Zhai

Bai

Peng

Z. R.

. 2019. “From Edit Distance to Augmented Space-Time-Weighted Edit Distance: Detecting and Clustering Patterns of Human Activities in Puget Sound Region.” Journal of Transport Geography 78:41–55.