Understanding neighborhood preferences remains a key focus for planners. While many studies document the effects of either neighborhood design or neighborhood preference on health and travel behavior, few have explored their combined effect in smaller regions. Using a sample of 2,597 adults in the Region of Waterloo, Ontario, we found an unmet demand for walkable neighborhoods. Results suggest that walkable neighborhoods are independently associated with less vehicle travel after adjusting for sociodemographic and residential preferences. Our study highlights the importance of combining the effects of walkable neighborhoods and preferences for them when addressing health and sustainability goals in suburban communities.
BadlandHannah M.OliverMelodyKearnsRobin A.MavoaSuzanneWittenKarenDuncanMitch J.BattyG. David. 2012. “Association of Neighbourhood Residence and Preferences with the Built Environment, Work-Related Travel Behaviours, and Health Implications for Employed Adults: Findings from the URBAN Study.” Social Science & Medicine75 (8): 1469–76.
2.
BerkeEthan M.KoepsellThomas D.MoudonAnne VernezHoskinsRichard E.LarsonEric B.2007. “Association of the Built Environment with Physical Activity and Obesity in Older Persons.” American Journal of Public Health97 (3): 486–92.
3.
BoothGillian L.CreatoreMaria I.MoineddinRahimGozdyraPeterWeymanJonathan T.MathesonFlora I.GlazierRichard H.2013. “Unwalkable Neighborhoods, Poverty, and the Risk of Diabetes among Recent Immigrants to Canada Compared with Long-Term Residents.” Diabetes Care36 (2): 302–08.
BuntingTrudiFilionPierreHoernigHeidiSeasonsMarkLedererJeff. 2007. “Density, Size, Dispersion: Towards Understanding the Structural Dynamics of Mid-Size Cities.” Canadian Journal of Urban Research16 (2): 27–52.
6.
CaoXinyu. 2008. “Is Alternative Development Undersupplied? Examination of Residential Preferences and Choices of Northern California Movers.” Transportation Research Record2077:97–105.
7.
CerveroRobert. 1996. “Jobs-Housing Balance Revisited: Trends and Impacts in the San Francisco Bay Area.” Journal of the American Planning Association62 (4): 492–511.
8.
ChiuMariaShahBaiju R.MaclaganLaura C.RezaiMohammad-RezaAustinPeter C.TuJack V.2015. “Walk Score® and the Prevalence of Utilitarian Walking and Obesity among Ontario Adults: A Cross-Sectional Study.” Health Reports26 (7): 3–10.
9.
CreatoreMaria I.GlazierRichard H.MoineddinRahimFazliGhazal S.JohnsAshleyGozdyraPeterMathesonFlora I.et al2016. “Association of Neighborhood Walkability with Change in Overweight, Obesity, and Diabetes.” Journal of the American Medical Association315 (20): 2211–20.
10.
De VosJonasDerudderBenVan AckerVeroniqueWitloxFrank. 2012. “Reducing Car Use: Changing Attitudes or Relocating? The Influence of Residential Dissonance on Travel Behavior.” Journal of Transport Geography22:1–9.
11.
EwingReidCerveroRobert. 2010. “Travel and the Built Environment: A Meta-Analysis.” Journal of the American Planning Association76 (3): 265–94.
12.
FrankLawrence DouglasKershawSuzanne E.ChapmanJames E.CampbellMonicaSwinkelsHelena M.2015. “The Unmet Demand for Walkability: Disparities between Preferences and Actual Choices for Residential Environments in Toronto and Vancouver.” Canadian Journal of Public Health106:12–20.
13.
FrankLawrence DouglasSaelensBrian E.PowellKen E.ChapmanJames E.2007. “Stepping towards Causation: Do Built Environments or Neighborhood and Travel Preferences Explain Physical Activity, Driving, and Obesity?” Social Science & Medicine65:1898–914.
14.
FrankLawrence DouglasSallisJames F.SaelensBrian E.LearyLaurenCainKelliConwayTerry L.HessPaul M.2010. “The Development of a Walkability Index: Application to the Neighborhood Quality of Life Study.” British Journal of Sports Medicine44 (13): 924–33.
15.
FrankLawrence DouglasSchmidThomasSallisJames F.ChapmanJamesSaelensBrian. 2005. “Linking Objective Physical Activity Data with Objective Measures of Urban Form: Findings from SMARTRAQ.” American Journal of Preventative Medicine28 (2): 117–25.
16.
Giles-CortiBillieTimperioAnnaBullFionaPikoraTerri. 2005. “Understanding Physical Activity Environmental Correlates: Increased Specificity for Ecological Models.” Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews33 (4): 175–81.
17.
HandySusanSallisJames F.WeberDeanneMaibachEdHollanderMarla. 2008. “Is Support for Traditionally Designed Communities Growing? Evidence from Two National Surveys.” Journal of the American Planning Association74 (2): 209–21.
18.
HowleyPeter. 2009. “Land Use Policy Attitudes towards Compact City Living: Towards a Greater Understanding of Residential Behaviour.” Journal of Planning Education and Research26:792–98.
19.
KamruzzamanMd.BakerDouglasWashingtonSimonTurrellGavin. 2013. “Residential Dissonance and Mode Choice.” Journal of Transport Geography33:12–28.
20.
KimJaePagliaraFrancescaPrestonJohn. 2005. “The Intention to Move and Residential Location Choice Behaviour.” Urban Studies42 (9): 1621–36.
21.
Kowaleski-JonesLoriZickCathleenSmithKen R.BrownBarbaraHansonHeidiFanJessie. 2018. “Walkable Neighborhoods and Obesity: Evaluating Effects with a Propensity Score Approach.” SSM-Population Health6:9–15.
22.
LevineJonathan. 1998. “Rethinking Accessibility and Jobs-Housing Balance.” Journal of the American Planning Association64 (2): 133–49.
23.
LevineJonathanFrankLawrence D.2007. “Transportation and Land-Use Preferences and Residents’ Neighborhood Choices: The Sufficiency of Compact Development in the Atlanta Region.” Transportation34 (2): 255–74.
24.
LevineJonathanInamAseemTorngGwo-Wei. 2005. “A Choice-Based Rationale for Land Use and Transportation Alternatives: Evidence from Boston and Atlanta.” Journal of Planning Education and Research24 (3): 317–30.
25.
LiFuzhongHarmerPeterCardinalBradley J.VongjaturapatNaruepon. 2009. “Built Environment and Changes in Blood Pressure in Middle Aged and Older Adults.” Preventative Medicine48 (3): 237–41.
26.
LitmanTodd. 2009. Where We Want to Be: Home Location Preferences and Their Implications for Smart Growth. Victoria: Victoria Transport Policy Institute.
27.
MaohHannaTangZhongyuan. 2012. “Determinants of Normal and Extreme Commute Distance in a Sprawled Midsize Canadian City: Evidence from Windsor, Canada.” Journal of Transport Geography25:50–57.
28.
MayaudJerome R.TranMartinoPereiraRafael H. M.NuttallRohan. 2019. “Future Access to Essential Services in a Growing Smart City: The Case of Surrey, British Columbia.” Computers, Environment and Urban Systems73:1–15.
29.
McCormackGavin R.FriedenreichChristineSandalackBeverly A.Giles-CortiBillieDoyle-BakerPatricia K.ShiellAlan. 2012. “The Relationship between Cluster-Analysis Derived Walkability and Local Recreational and Transportation Walking among Canadian Adults.” Health & Place18 (5): 1079–87.
30.
McCormackGavin R.ShiellAlan. 2011. “In Search of Causality: A Systematic Review of the Relationship between the Built Environment and Physical Activity among Adults.” International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity8 (1): 125.
31.
MyersDowGearinElizabeth. 2001. “Current Preferences and Future Demand for Denser Residential Environments.” Housing Policy Debate12 (4): 633–59.
32.
NavaneelanTanyaJanzTeresa. 2014. Adjusting the Scales: Obesity in the Canadian Population after Correcting for Respondent Bias. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
33.
OwenNevilleCerinEsterLeslieEvaduToitLorinneCoffeeNeilFrankLawrence D.BaumanAdrian E.HugoGraemeSaelensBrian E.SallisJames F.2007. “Neighborhood Walkability and the Walking Behavior of Australian Adults.” American Journal of Preventative Medicine33 (5): 387–95.
34.
PapasMia A.AlbergAnthony J.EwingReidHelzlsouerKathy J.GaryTiffany L.KlassenAnn C.2007. “The Built Environment and Obesity.” Epidemiological Reviews29 (27): 129–43.
PikoraTerriGiles-CortiBillieBullFionaJamrozikKonradDonovanRob. 2003. “Developing a Framework for Assessment of the Environmental Determinants of Walking and Cycling.” Social Science & Medicine56 (8): 1693–703.
37.
PivoGaryFisherJeffrey. 2011. “The Walkability Premium in Commercial Real Estate Investments.” Journal of Real Estate Economics39 (2): 185–219.
38.
RauterkusStephanieMillerNorman. 2011. “Residential Land Value and Walkability.” Journal of Sustainable Real Estate3 (1): 23–43.
Region of Waterloo Public Health. 2017. “Population Projections 2021, 2031 & 2041.” Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, IntelliHEALTH Ontario, Toronto.
42.
RundleAndrewNeckermanKathryn M.FreemanLanceLovasiGina S.PurcielMarnieQuinnJamesRichardsCatherineSircarNeelanjanWeissChristopher. 2008. “Neighborhood Food Environment and Walkability Predict Obesity in New York City.” Environmental Health Perspectives117 (3): 442–47.
43.
SaelensBrian E.HandySusan L.2008. “Built Environment Correlates of Walking: A Review.” Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise40 (Suppl. 7): S550–66.
44.
SaelensBrian E.SallisJames F.FrankLawrence D.2003. “Environmental Correlates of Walking and Cycling: Findings from the Transportation, Urban Design, and Planning Literatures.” Annals of Behavioral Medicine25:80–91.
45.
SallisJames F.SaelensBrian E.FrankLawrence D.ConwayTerry L.SlymenDonald J.CainKelli L.ChapmanJamesKerrJacqueline. 2009. “Neighborhood Built Environment and Income: Examining Multiple Health Outcomes.” Social Science & Medicine68 (7): 1285–93.
46.
SchwanenTimMokhtarianPatricia L.2004. “The Extent and Determinants of Dissonance between Actual and Preferred Residential Neighborhood Type.” Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design31 (5): 759–84.
47.
SchwanenTimMokhtarianPatricia L.2005. “What Affects Commute Mode Choice: Neighborhood Physical Structure or Preferences toward Neighborhoods?” Journal of Transport Geography13:83–99.
SultanaSelimaWeberJoe. 2007. “Journey-to-Work Patterns in the Age of Sprawl: Evidence from Two Midsize Southern Metropolitan Areas.” The Professional Geographer59 (2): 193–208.
50.
SwinburnBoyd A.2008. “Obesity Prevention: The Role of Policies, Laws and Regulations.” Australia and New Zealand Health Policy5:12.
51.
ThompsonMaryFrankLawrence D.MinakerLeiaVan LoonJoshMcSpurrenKathleenFisherPatRaineKim. 2013. “Sampling Design and Data Collection for NEWPATH Survey.” Transportation Research Board 92nd Annual Meeting, Washington, DC. January 13–17.
52.
Van CauwenbergJelleHolleVeerle VanSimonsDorienDeridderRietClarysPeterGoubertLiesbetNasarJackSalmonJoBourdeaudhuijIlse DeDeforcheBenedicte. 2012. “Environmental Factors Influencing Older Adults’ Walking for Transportation: A Study Using Walk-along Interviews.” International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity9 (1): 85.
