Derailed Values: Planning Education,External Funding,and Environmental Justice in New Orleans Rail Planning

Abstract

Studio courses can transform practice and impart planning values, but increasing university expectations around revenue generation could create barriers for these objectives. To understand how funding demands could impact planning education, we examine a New Orleans–based case study in which external funders pressured university stakeholders to change a studio course. The studio, focused on environmental justice and freight rail planning, remained much the same, but shifted from an advocacy framework to a technical approach. This approach did little to impart social justice values or transform practice, but planning education can still support social justice values.

Keywords

environmental justice planning education freight rail

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Institute of Certified Planners. 2009. “Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct.” https://www.planning.org/ethics/ethicscode.htm (accessed January 4, 2016).

American Planning Association. 1992. “Ethical Principles in Planning.” https://www.planning.org/ethics/ethicalprinciples.htm (accessed January 4, 2016).

Ashley

A. J.

Vos

2015. “The Department as a Third Sector Planner: Implementing Civic Capacity through the Planning Core Curriculum.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 35 (4): 501–14.

Balassiano

2011. “Tackling ‘Wicked Problems’ in Planning Studio Courses.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 31 (40): 449–60.

Bartholomew

Bettis

Chambers

DePriest

DeRouen

Fisher

Hebert

Hodges

MacKay

McCall

Tatar

2014. “Freight Down the Middle: Neighborhoods Impacts and the New Orleans Middle Belt Rail Proposal.” University of New Orleans, Planning and Urban Studies. http://scholarworks.uno.edu/plus_rpts/19/ (accessed June 1, 2015).

Been

1994. “Locally Undesirable Land Uses in Minority Neighborhoods: Disproportionate Siting or Market Dynamics?” Yale Law Journal 103 (6): 1383–422.

Been

Gupta

1997. “Coming to the Nuisance or Going to the Barrios? A Longitudinal Analysis of Environmental Justice Claims.” Ecology Law Quarterly 24 (1): 1–56.

Boone

C. G.

Modarres

1999. “Creating a Toxic Neighborhood in Los Angeles County: A Historical Examination Environmental Inequity.” Urban Affairs Review 35 (2): 163–87.

Bowen

2002. “An Analytical Review of the Environmental Justice Research: What Do We Really Know?” Environmental Management 29 (1): 3–15.

10.

Breheny

M. J.

1989. “Chalkface to Coalface: A Review of the Academic Practice Interface.” Environment and Planning B 16:451–68.

11.

Brinkman

P. A.

2009. “The Responsibility to Ask Questions: The Case of Bias in Travel Demand Forecasting.” In Ethics and Planning Research, edited by Piccolo

F. Lo

Thomas

A. H.

, 107–18. Farnham: Ashgate.

12.

Brown Cunningham Gannuch with Wilbur Smith Associates and Parsons Transportation Group. 2007. “New Orleans Rail Gateway Infrastructure Feasibility Analysis. New Orleans: Regional Planning Commission, Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development, and Association of American Railroads. http://wwwsp.dotd.la.gov/Business/Projects/norg/Previous%20Studies/2007%20New%20Orleans%20Rail%20Gateway%20Infrastructure%20Feasibility%20Analysis/New_Orleans_Rail_Gateway_Infrastructure_Feasibility_Analysis.pdf.

13.

Bullard

R. D.

1990. Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality. Boulder, CO: Westview.

14.

Bullard

R. D.

Johnson

G. S.

Torres

A. O.

2004. Highway Robbery: Transportation Racism and New Routes to Equity. Cambridge, MA: South End Press.

15.

Bullard

R. D.

Mohai

Sah

Wright

2007. “Toxic Wastes and Race at Twenty: A Report Prepared for the United Church of Christ Justice and Witness Ministries.” http://www.weact.org/Portals/7/toxic20.pdf.

16.

Burby

R. J.

Strong

D. E.

1997. “Coping with Chemicals: Blacks, Whites, Planners, and Industrial Pollution.” Journal of the American Planning Association 63 (4): 469–80.

17.

Cambridge Systematics. 2008. New Orleans Rail Gateway Beneﬁts Report. Cambridge, MA: Association of American Railroads. http://wwwsp.dotd.la.gov/Business/Projects/norg/Previous%20Studies/2009%20New%20Orleans%20Rail%20Gateway%20Benefits/New%20Orleans%20Rail%20Gateway%20Benefits%20Report%202009.pdf.

18.

Campbell

1996. “Green Cities, Growing Cities, Just Cities?: Urban Planning and the Contradictions of Sustainable Development.” Journal of the American Planning Association 62 (3): 296–312.

19.

Cantwell

Kauppinen

2014a. “Academic Capitalism in Theory and Research.” In Academic Capitalism in the Age of Globalization, edited by Cantwell

Kauppinen

, 3–9. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

20.

Cantwell

Kauppinen

, eds. 2014b. Academic Capitalism in the Age of Globalization. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

21.

Caro

R. A.

1975. The Power Broker: Robert Moses and the Fall of New York. New York: Vintage Books.

22.

Cunningham

O’Reilly

O’Kane

Mangematin

2014. “The Inhibiting Factors That Principal Investigators Experience in Leading Publicly Funded Research.” Journal of Technology Transfer 38:93–110.

23.

Cutter

S. L.

2006. Hazards, Vulnerability and Environmental Justice. London: Earthscan.

24.

Federal Highway Administration and Federal Transit Administration. 2000. An Overview of Transportation and Environmental Justice [Brochure]. Washington: United States Department of Transportation, Publication FHWA-EP-00-013. http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/environmental_justice/overview/ej2000.pdf (accessed January 4, 2016).

25.

Forkenbrock

D. J.

Schweitzer

L. A.

1999. “Environmental Justice in Transportation Planning.” Journal of the American Planning Association 65 (1): 96–112.

26.

Frickel

Gibbon

Howard

Kempner

Ottinger

Hess

D. J.

2010. “Undone Science: Charting Social Movement and Civil Society Challenges to Research Agenda Setting.” Science, Technology, and Human Values 35 (4): 444–73.

27.

Gogola

2013. “Hollygrove Train Plan Gains Steam.” The Louisiana Weekly, December 2.

28.

Grissett

2009. “Railroad Rerouting Proposal Gathers Steam—Streamlined Redesign to Cost $139 Million.” Times-Picayune, The (New Orleans, LA), March 22, 01. NewsBank on-line database (America’s News).

29.

Hanson

2003. Civic Culture and Urban Change: Governing Dallas. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.

30.

Harvey

2005. A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

31.

Hasselle

2013. “‘We Won’t Be Railroaded’ in Hollygrove Councilwoman Guidry Says.” Mid-City Messenger, December 11.

32.

Hearn

J. C.

Warshaw

J. B.

Ciarimboli

E. B.

2016. “Privatization and Accountability Trends and Policies in U.S. Public Higher Education.” Ted Eğitim Ve Bilim 41 (184): 1–26.

33.

Hurley

2009. Environmental Inequalities: Class, Race, and Industrial Pollution in Gary, Indiana, 1945-1980. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.

34.

Kim

Campbell

Eckerd

2014. “Residential Choice Constraints and Environmental Justice.” Social Science Quarterly 95 (1): 40–56.

35.

Laban

1996. “Planners Tackle Easing Old Metairie Train Traffic—Carrollton Idea Is Most Feasible.” The Times-Picayune, October 28, A1.

36.

LA DOTD (Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development). 2012. “Scoping Meeting Presentation (New Orleans Rail Gateway Program EIS).” http://wwwsp.dotd.la.gov/Business/Projects/norg/Pages/default.aspx (accessed June 29, 2015)

37.

Letizia

Angelo J.

2016. “The Hollow University: Disaster Capitalism Befalls American Higher Education.” Policy Futures in Education. doi:10.1177/1478210316633378.

38.

Lofland

L. H.

2009. Analyzing Social Settings: A Guide to Qualitative Observation and Analysis. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

39.

Logan

J. R.

Molotch

H. L.

2007. Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of Place. Berkeley: University of California Press.

40.

Long

J. G.

2012. “State of the Studio: Revisiting the Potential of Studio Pedagogy in U.S.-Based Planning Programs.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 32 (4): 431–48.

41.

Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development and Federal Railroad Administration. (n.d.). “New Orleans Rail Gateway EIS Jefferson and Orleans Parishes: Summary of Public Scoping Meetings.” http://wwwsp.dotd.la.gov/Business/Projects/norg/Public%20Meeting%20Materials/Scoping_Meeting_Summary.pdf (accessed December 4, 2016).

42.

Marcelli

E. A.

Power

Spalding

M. J.

2001. “Unauthorized Mexican Immigrants and Business Generated Environmental Hazards in Southern California.” Critical Planning 8:23–41. https://criticalplanning.squarespace.com.

43.

Marcuse

2014. “A Just Code of Ethics for Planners: A Priority for Planners Network.” Progressive Planning 128 (Winter): 16–19. http://www.plannersnetwork.org/category/progressive-planning-magazine/.

44.

McClure

Kevin R.

2016. “Building the Innovative and Entrepreneurial University: An Institutional Case Study of Administrative Academic Capital.” Journal of Higher Education 87 (4): 516–43.

45.

Mitchell

Leachman

Masterson

2016. Funding down, Tuition Up. Washington, DC: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

46.

Mossberger

2009. “Urban Regime Analysis.” In Theories of Urban Politics, 2nd ed., edited by Davies

Imbroscio

, 40–54. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

47.

Myers

2013. “Momentum Is Growing to Reroute Freight Trains out of Old Metairie—By Sending through Hollygrove.” Times-Picayune, The (New Orleans, LA), October 27, A 01. Retrieved May 28, 2015, from NewsBank on-line database (America’s News).

48.

Myers

Banerjee

2005. “Toward Greater Heights for Planning: Reconciling the Differences between Profession, Practice, and Academic Field.” Journal of the American Planning Association 71 (2): 121–29.

49.

Németh

Long

J. G.

2012. “Assessing Learning Outcomes in U.S. Planning Studio Courses.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 32 (4): 476–90.

50.

Pastor

Jr. Sadd

Hipp

2001. “Which Came First? Toxic Facilities, Minority Move-In, and Environmental Justice.” Journal of Urban Affairs 23 (1): 1–21.

51.

Pinheiro

Stensaker

2014. “Designing the Entrepreneurial University: The Interpretation of a Global Idea.” Public Organization Review 14:497–516.

52.

Pompilio

1997. “Metairie Rail Crossing Studied—Further Measures May Ease Congestion.” Times-Picayune, The (New Orleans, LA), March 18, B1. Retrieved May 28, 2015, from NewsBank on-line database (America’s News).

53.

Pulido

1996. “Introduction: Environnemental Racism.” Urban Geography 17 (5): 377–79.

54.

Pulido

Sidawi

Vos

R. O.

1996. “An Archeology of Environmental Racism in Los Angeles.” Urban Geography 17 (5): 419–39.

55.

Rasheed

1999. “Old Metairie Train Study Tab Is $6 Million—Earlier Probe Urges Move to Airline Drive.” The Times-Picayune, June 3, B1.

56.

Reiss

2014. “Guidry Vows to Derail Freight Rerouting.” Gambit, Blog of New Orleans, January 24. http://www.bestofneworleans.com/blogofneworleans/archives/2014/01/24/guidry-vows-to-derail-freight-rerouting (accessed May 30, 2015).

57.

Siemiatycki

2012. “The Role of the Planning Scholar: Research, Conflict, and Social Change.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 32 (2): 147–59.

58.

Slaughter

2014a. “Foreward.” In Academic Capitalism in the Age of Globalization, edited by Cantwell

Kauppinen

, vii–x. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

59.

Slaughter

2014b. “Retheorizing Academic Capitalism: Actors, Mechanisms, Fields and Networks.” In Academic Capitalism in the Age of Globalization, edited by Cantwell

Kauppinen

, 10–32. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

60.

Slaughter

Rhoades

2004. Academic Capitalism and the New Economy: Markets, State, and Higher Education. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

61.

Sletto

2012. “Insurgent Planning and Its Interlocutors: Studio Pedagogy as Unsanctioned Practice in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 33 (2): 228–40.

62.

Stone

C. N.

1989. Regime Politics: Governing Atlanta, 1946-1988. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.

63.

Thomas

2012. “Values and the Planning School.” Planning Theory 11 (4): 400–17.

64.

United Church of Christ Commission for Racial Justice. 1987. Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States: A National Report on the Racial and Socio-economic Characteristics of Communities with Hazardous Waste Sites. New York: Public Data Access.

65.

US DOT and LA DOTD (United States Department of Transportation, Federal Highway Administration, and State of Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development). 1989. “Old Metairie railroad project, Metairie, Jefferson Parish, Louisiana, State project no. 736-10-48, Federal Aid Project no. RR-022R(007), Final Environmental Impact Statement.” http://wwwsp.dotd.la.gov/Business/Projects/norg/Previous%20Studies/1989%20Old%20Metairie%20Rail%20EIS/Old%20Metairie%20EIS_1989_1of2.pdf.

66.

United States General Accounting Office. 1983. Siting of Hazardous Waste Landfills and Their Correlation with Racial and Economic Status of Surrounding Communities. Washington, DC: US GAO.

67.

URS, in association with CANAC, Inc., N-Y and Associates, Inc., and Darrel J. Sizan and Associates, Inc. 2002. “New Orleans Rail Gateway Regional Rail Operational Analysis, State Project no. 737-26-0002.” Louisiana Department of Transportation and Development. http://wwwsp.dotd.la.gov/Business/Projects/norg/Previous%20Studies/2002%20New%20Orleans%20Rail%20Gateway%20Regional%20Rail%20Operations%20Analysis/Regional%20Rail%20Operations%20Analysis%20Report.pdf.

68.

von Hoffman

. 2000. “A Study in Contradictions: The Origins and Legacy of the Housing Act of 1949.” Housing Policy Debate 11 (2): 299–326.

69.

Winkler

2013. “At the Coalface: Community-University Engagements and Planning Education.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 33 (2): 215–27.

70.

Wolfe

D. A.

Bramwell

2008. “Universities and Regional Economic Development: The Entrepreneurial University of Waterloo.” Research Policy 37 (8): 1175–87.

71.

Yin

R. K.

2003. Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.