This study tests four hypotheses related to the much-cited work on density and automobile dependence by Newman and Kenworthy, using multivariate analysis and data for 157 large US urbanized areas. We find that density alone explains only a small fraction of the variation in vehicle miles traveled (VMT), and many confounders account for the differences in automobile dependence. We also find that it is not the localized density of individual neighborhoods that causes VMT to be lower in compact urbanized areas but rather the relative accessibility of neighborhoods to the rest of the region.
BeatleyT.ManningK.1997. The Ecology of Place: Planning for Environment, Economy, and Community. Washington, DC: Island Press.
3.
BerriganD.TatalovichZ.PickleL. W.EwingR.Ballard-BarbashR.2014. “Urban Sprawl, Obesity, and Cancer Mortality in the United States: Cross-sectional Analysis and Methodological Challenges.” International Journal of Health Geographics13 (1): 3.
4.
BronsM.NijkampP.PelsE.RietveldP.2006. A Meta-analysis of the Price Elasticity of Gasoline Demand. A System of Equations Approach. Amsterdam: Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper, No. 06-106/3. http://www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/86304.
5.
CerveroR.2002. “Induced Travel Demand: Research Design, Empirical Evidence, and Normative Policies.” Journal of Planning Literature17 (1): 3–20.
6.
CerveroR.KockelmanK.1997. “Travel Demand and the 3Ds: Density, Diversity, and Design.” Transportation Research D2 (3): 199–219.
7.
CerveroR.MurakamiJ.2010. “Effects of Built Environments on Vehicle Miles Traveled: Evidence from 370 US Urbanized Areas.” Environment and Planning A42 (2): 400–18.
8.
ChoS. H.ChenZ.YenS. T.EastwoodD. B.2006. “The Effects of Urban Sprawl on Body Mass Index: Where People Live Does Matter?” Consumer Interests Annual52:159–69.
9.
CutsingerJ.GalsterG.WolmanH.HansonR.TownsD.2005. “Verifying the Multi-dimensional Nature of Metropolitan Land Use: Advancing the Understanding and Measurement of Sprawl.” Journal of Urban Affairs27 (3): 235–59.
10.
DownsA.2000. Stuck in Traffic: Coping with Peak-Hour Traffic Congestion. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
11.
DoyleS.Kelly-SchwartzA.SchlossbergM.StockardJ.2006. “Active Community Environments and Health: The Relationship of Walkable and Safe Communities to Individual Health.” Journal of the American Planning Association72 (1): 19–31.
12.
DujardinS.PirartF.BreversF.MariqueA. F.TellerJ.2012. “Home-to-Work Commuting, Urban Form and Potential Energy Savings: A Local Scale Approach to Regional Statistics.” Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice46 (7): 1054–65.
13.
EspeyM.1998. “Gasoline Demand Revisited: An International Meta-analysis of Elasticities.” Energy Economics20 (3): 273–95.
14.
EwingR.2008. “Highway Induced Development: Results for Metropolitan Areas.” Transportation Research Record2067:101–9.
15.
EwingR.BartholomewK.WinkelmanS.WaltersJ.ChenD.2008. Growing Cooler: The Evidence on Urban Development and Climate Change. Washington, DC: Urban Land Institute.
16.
EwingR.CerveroR.2001. “Travel and the Built Environment: A Synthesis.” Transportation Research Record1780:87–114.
17.
EwingR.CerveroR.2010. “Travel and the Built Environment: A Meta-analysis.” Journal of the American Planning Association76 (3): 265–94.
18.
EwingR.CerveroR. Forthcoming. “Does Compact Development Make People Drive Less? The Answer Is ‘Yes.’” Journal of the American Planning Association.
19.
EwingR.HamidiS.2014a. Measuring Urban Sprawl and Validating Sprawl Measures. Washington, DC: National Institutes of Health and Smart Growth America.
20.
EwingR.HamidiS.2014b. “Longitudinal Analysis of Transit’s Land Use Multiplier in Portland (OR).” Journal of the American Planning Association80 (2): 123–37.
21.
EwingR.HamidiS.2015. “Urban Sprawl as a Risk Factor in Motor Vehicle Occupant and Pedestrian Fatalities—Update and Refinement.” Transportation Research Record25(13):40–47.
22.
EwingR.HamidiS.GallivanF.NelsonA. C.GraceJ. B.2014a. “Structural Equation Models of VMT Growth in US Urbanised Areas.” Urban Studies51 (14): 3079–96.
23.
EwingR.HamidiS.GraceJ. B.2016. “Urban Sprawl as a Risk Factor in Motor Vehicle Crashes.” Urban Studies53 (2): 247-66.
24.
EwingR.HamidiS.GraceJ. B.WeiY. D.2016. “Does Urban Sprawl Hold Down Upward Mobility?” Landscape and Urban Planning148:80–88.
25.
EwingR.MeakinsG.HamidiS.NelsonA. C.2014b. “Relationship between Urban Sprawl and Physical Activity, Obesity, and Morbidity—Update and Refinement.” Health & Place26:118–26.
26.
EwingR.PendallR.ChenD.2002. Measuring Sprawl and Its Impacts. Washington, DC: Smart Growth America.
27.
EwingR.PendallR.ChenD.2003. “Measuring Sprawl and Its Transportation Impacts.” Transportation Research Record1831 (1): 175–83.
28.
EwingR.RongF.2008. “The Impact of Urban Form on US Residential Energy Use.” Housing Policy Debate, 19 (1): 1–30.
29.
EwingR.TianG.GoatesJ. P.ZhangM.GreenwaldM. J.JoyceA.GreeneW.2014c. “Varying Influences of the Built Environment on Household Travel in 15 Diverse Regions of the United States.” Urban Studies52 (13): 2330–48.
30.
FanY.SongY.2009. “Is Sprawl Associated with a Widening Urban–Suburban Mortality Gap?” Journal of Urban Health86 (5): 708–28.
31.
FrenkelA.AshkenaziM.2008. “Measuring Urban Sprawl: How Can We Deal with It?” Environment and Planning B35 (1): 56–79.
GalsterG.HansonR.RatcliffeM. R.WolmanH.ColemanS.FreihageJ.2001. “Wrestling Sprawl to the Ground: Defining and Measuring an Elusive Concept.” Housing Policy Debate12 (4): 681–717.
34.
GoodwinP.DargayJ.HanlyM.2004. “Elasticities of Road Traffic and Fuel Consumption with Respect to Price and Income: A Review.” Transport Reviews24 (3): 275–92.
35.
GordonP.RichardsonH. W.1989. “Gasoline Consumption and Cities: A Reply.” Journal of the American Planning Association55 (3): 342–46.
36.
GrahamD. J.GlaisterS.2004. “Road Traffic Demand Elasticity Estimates: A Review.” Transport Reviews24 (3): 261–74.
37.
GriffinA. B.EibnerC.BirdC. E.JewellA.MargolisK.ShihR.SlaughterM. E.WhitselE. A.AllisonM.EscarceJ. J.2012. “The Relationship between Urban Sprawl and Coronary Heart Disease in Women.” Health & Place20:51–61.
38.
HamidiS.EwingR.2014. “A Longitudinal Study of Changes in Urban Sprawl between 2000 and 2010 in the United States.” Landscape and Urban Planning128:72–82.
39.
HamidiS.EwingR.2015. “Is Sprawl Affordable for Americans? Exploring the Association between Sprawl and Housing + Transportation Affordability.” Transportation Research Record2500:75–79.
40.
HamidiS.EwingR.PreussI.DoddsA.2015. “Measuring Sprawl and Its Impacts: An Update.” Journal of Planning Education and Research35 (1): 35–50.
41.
HickmanR.SeabornC.HeadicarP.BanisterD.2009. Planning for Sustainable Travel. Summary Guide. London: Halcrow and CfIT.
42.
HolcombeR. G.WilliamsD. W.2012. “Urban Sprawl and Transportation Externalities.” Review of Regional Studies40 (3): 257–72.
43.
JaegerJ. A.BertillerR.SchwickC.KienastF.2010. “Suitability Criteria for Measures of Urban Sprawl.” Ecological Indicators10 (2): 397–406.
44.
JoshuC. E.BoehmerT. K.BrownsonR. C.EwingR.2008. “Personal, Neighborhood and Urban Factors Associated with Obesity in the United States.” Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health62 (3): 202–8.
45.
Kelly-SchwartzA. C.StockardJ.DoyleS.SchlossbergM.2004. Is Sprawl Unhealthy? A Multilevel Analysis of the Relationship of Metropolitan Sprawl to the Health of Individuals.” Journal of Planning Education and Research24 (2): 184–96.
46.
KenworthyJ. R.LaubeF. B.1999. “Patterns of Automobile Dependence in Cities: An International Overview of Key Physical and Economic Dimensions with Some Implications for Urban Policy.” Transportation Research Part A33 (7): 691–723.
47.
KenworthyJ. R.LaubeF. B.NewmanP.BarterP.RaadT.PoboonC.GuiaB.Jr. 1999. An International Sourcebook of Automobile Dependence in Cities 1960–1990. Boulder, CO: University Press of Colorado.
48.
KimD.SubramanianS. V.GortmakerS. L.KawachiI.2006. “U.S State- and County-Level Social Capital in Relation to Obesity and Physical Inactivity: A Multilevel, Multivariable Analysis.” Social Science & Medicine63 (4): 1045–59.
49.
KirbyA.2008. Kick the Habit: A UN Guide to Climate Neutrality. Nairobi: UNEP.
50.
KostovaD.2011. “Can the Built Environment Reduce Obesity? The Impact of Residential Sprawl and Neighborhood Parks on Obesity and Physical Activity.” Eastern Economic Journal37 (3): 390–402.
LeeI.EwingR.SessoH. D.2009. “The Built Environment and Physical Activity Levels: The Harvard Alumni Health Study.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine37 (4): 293–98.
53.
LeeS.LeeB.2014. “The Influence of Urban Form on GHG Emissions in the U.S. Household Sector.” Energy Policy68:534–49.
54.
LopezR.HynesH. P.2003. “Sprawl in the 1990s: Measurement, Distribution, and Trends.” Urban Affairs Review38 (3): 325–55.
55.
MubarekaS.KoomenE.EstreguilC.LavalleC.2011. “Development of a Composite Index of Urban Compactness for Land Use Modelling Applications.” Landscape and Urban Planning103 (3): 303–17.
56.
NewmanP.2014. “Density, the Sustainability Multiplier: Some Myths and Truths with Application to Perth, Australia.” Sustainability6 (9): 6467–87.
57.
NewmanP.KenworthyJ. R.1989a. Cities and Automobile Dependence: An International Sourcebook. Aldershot, UK: Gower Technical.
58.
NewmanP.KenworthyJ. R.1989b. “Gasoline Consumption and Cities: A Comparison of US Cities with a Global Survey.” Journal of the American Planning Association55 (1): 24–37.
59.
NewmanP.KenworthyJ.2006. “Urban Design to Reduce Automobile Dependence.” Opolis2 (1): 35–52.
60.
NewmanP.KenworthyJ.2011a. “Peak Car Use: Understanding the Demise of Automobile Dependence.” World Transport Policy and Practice17 (2): 31–42. http://www.eco-logica.co.uk/pdf/wtpp17.2.pdf.
61.
NewmanP.KenworthyJ.2011b. “The Density Multiplier: A Response to Mees.” World Transport Policy and Practice17 (3).
62.
NewmanP.KenworthyJ.2015. The End of Automobile Dependence: How Cities Are Moving beyond Car-Based Planning. Washington, DC: Island Press.
63.
NguyenD.2010. “Evidence of the Impacts of Urban Sprawl on Social Capital.” Environment and Planning B37 (4): 610–27.
64.
PendallR.1999. “Do Land-Use Controls Cause Sprawl?” Environment and Planning B26 (4): 555–71.
65.
PendallR.CarruthersJ. I.2003. “Does Density Exacerbate Income Segregation? Evidence from US Metropolitan Areas, 1980 to 2000.” Housing Policy Debate14 (4): 541–89.
66.
PerumalA.TimmonsD.2015. “Contextual Density and US Automotive CO2 Emissions across the Rural-Urban Continuum.” International Regional Science Review. Published online November18. doi: 10.1177/0160017615614897.
67.
PlantingaA. J.BernellS.2007. “The Association between Urban Sprawl and Obesity: Is It a Two-Way Street?” Journal of Regional Science47 (5): 857–79.
68.
SchweitzerL.ZhouJ.2010. “Neighborhood Air Quality, Respiratory Health, and Vulnerable Populations in Compact and Sprawled Regions.” Journal of the American Planning Association76 (3): 363–71.
69.
SmallK. A.Van DenderK.2007. “Fuel Efficiency and Motor Vehicle Travel: The Declining Rebound Effect.” International Association for Energy Economics28 (1): 25–51.
70.
StoneB.2008. “Urban Sprawl and Air Quality in Large US Cities.” Journal of Environmental Management86 (4): 688–98.
71.
StoneB.HessJ. J.FrumkinH.2010. “Urban Form and Extreme Heat Events: Are Sprawling Cities More Vulnerable to Climate Change Than Compact Cities?” Environmental Health Perspectives118 (10): 1425–28.
72.
TorrensP. M.2008. “A Toolkit for Measuring Sprawl.” Applied Spatial Analysis and Policy1(1): 5–36.
73.
TrowbridgeM. J.GurkaM. J.O’ConnorR. E.2009. “Urban Sprawl and Delayed Ambulance Arrival in the US.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine37 (5): 428–32.
74.
TrowbridgeM. J.McDonaldN. C.2008. “Urban Sprawl and Miles Driven Daily by Teenagers in the United States.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine34 (3): 202–6.
75.
ZolnikE. J.2011. “The Effect of Sprawl on Private-Vehicle Commuting Outcomes.” Environment and Planning–Part A43 (8): 1875–93.
