Many planners work at private consulting firms, and many local governments use their services, but we have little idea of how consultant involvement affects plans. Analyzing data from a survey of local officials who engage planning consultants, we find that while engaging consultants does not appear to nudge local officials in a policy direction different from their preferences, it does appear to yield plans with a policy focus more oriented toward smart growth. This raises questions about the kind and degree of consultants’ impact on the legitimacy of the planning process.
AltermanR.MacRaeD.Jr. (1983). “Planning and Policy Analysis Converging or Diverging Trends?” Journal of the American Planning Association49 (2): 200–15.
2.
BerkeP. R.CampanellaT. J. (2006). “Planning for Postdisaster Resiliency.” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science604 (1): 192–207.
3.
BerkeP. R.GodschalkD. R. (2009). “Searching for the Good Plan: A Meta-analysis of Plan Quality Studies.” Journal of Planning Literature23 (3): 227–40.
4.
BirchE. (1980). “Advancing the Art and Science of Planning: Planners and Their Organizations, 1909-1980.” Journal of the American Planning Association46 (1): 22–49.
5.
BrehmJ.GatesS. (1997). Working, Shirking, and Sabotage: Bureaucratic Response to a Democratic Republic. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
6.
BrodyS. D.CarrascoV.HighfieldW. E. (2006). “Measuring the Adoption of Local Sprawl.” Journal of Planning Education and Research25 (3): 294–310.
7.
BrodyS. D.KangJ. E.BernhardtS. (2010). “Identifying Factors Influencing Flood Mitigation at the Local Level in Texas and Florida: The Role of Organizational Capacity.” Natural Hazards52 (1): 167–84.
8.
BurbyR. J.DaltonL. C. (1994). “Plans Can Matter! The Role of Land Use Plans and State Planning Mandates in Limiting the Development of Hazardous Areas.” Public Administration Review54 (3): 229–38.
9.
BurbyR. J.MayP. J. (1997). Making Governments Plan: State Experiments in Managing Land Use. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press.
10.
CananP.HennessyM. (1985). “Education in Social Impact Assessment and Planning.” Journal of Planning Education and Research4 (3): 157–63.
11.
CarrJ.ServonL. (2009). “Vernacular Culture and Urban Economic Development: Thinking Outside the (Big) Box.” American Planning Association. Journal of the American Planning Association75 (1): 28.
12.
DaltonL. C. (1986). “Why the Rational Paradigm Persists—The Resistance of Professional Education and Practice to Alternative Forms of Planning.” Journal of Planning Education and Research5 (3): 147–53.
13.
DanielsenK. A.LangR. E.FultonWilliam. (1999). “Retracting Suburbia: Smart Growth and the Future of Housing.” Housing Policy Debate10 (4).
14.
DeyleR.Schively SlotterbackC. (2009). “Group Learning in Participatory Planning Processes: An Exploratory Quasiexperimental Analysis of Local Mitigation Planning in Florida.” Journal of Planning Education and Research29 (1): 23–38.
15.
DownsA. (2005). “Smart Growth: Why We Discuss It More Than We Do It.” Journal of the American Planning Association71 (4): 367–78.
ForsythA. (1999). “Administrative Discretion and Urban and Regional Planners’ Values.” Journal of Planning Literature14 (1): 5–15.
18.
FriedmannJ. (1987). Planning in the Public Domain: From knowledge to Action. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
19.
GardeA. (2008). “City Sense and Suburban Design: Planners’ Perceptions of the Emerging Suburban Form.” Journal of the American Planning Association74 (3): 325.
20.
GrijzenJ. (2010). Outsourcing Planning: What Do Consultants Do in a Regional Spatial Planning in the Netherlands. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
21.
HolmstromB. (1979). “Moral Hazard and Observability.” Bell Journal of Economics10 (1): 74–91.
22.
HoweD.AbbottC.AdlerS. (2004). “What’s on the Horizon for Oregon Planners?” Journal of the American Planning Association70 (4): 391.
23.
InnesJ. E.BooherD. E. (2010). Planning with Complexity: An Introduction to Collaborative Rationality for Public Policy. New York: Routledge.
24.
KaplowitzM. D.HadlockT. D.LevineR. (2004). “A Comparison of Web and Mail Survey Response Rates.” Public Opinion Quarterly68 (1): 94–101.
25.
KellyE. D. (2004). Managing Community Growth, 2nd ed.Westport, CT: Praeger.
26.
KettlD. F. (2002). “Managing Indirect Government.” In The Tools of Government: A Guide to the New Governance, edited by SalamonL. M., 490–510. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
27.
LaurianL.CrawfordJ.DayM.KouwenhovenP.MasonG.EricksenN.BeattieL. (2010). “Evaluating the Outcomes of Plans: Theory, Practice, and Methodology.” Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design37:740–57.
28.
LohC. G.NortonR. K. (2013). “Planning Consultants and Local Planning: Roles and Values.” Journal of the American Planning Association79 (2), 138–47.
29.
LylesW.StevensM. (2014). “Plan Quality Evaluation 1994–2012 Growth and Contributions, Limitations, and New Directions.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 0739456X14549752.
30.
MargerumR. D. (2011). Beyond Consensus. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
31.
McCannE. J. (2001). “Collaborative Visioning or Urban Planning as Therapy? The Politics of Public–Private Policy Making.” Professional Geographer53 (2): 207–18.
32.
MoeT. M. (1984). “The New Economics of Organization.” American Journal of Political Science28 (4): 739–77.
33.
NortonR. K. (2005). “More and Better Local Planning: State-Mandated Local Planning in Coastal North Carolina.” Journal of the American Planning Association71 (1): 55.
34.
NortonR. K. (2008). “Using Content Analysis to Evaluate Local Master Plans and Zoning Codes.” Land Use Policy25 (3): 432–54.
35.
PorterD. (2007). Managing Growth in America’s Communities, 2nd ed.Washington, DC: Island Press.
36.
PunterJ. (2003). The Vancouver Achievement: Urban Planning and Design. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.
37.
ReardonK. M.GreenR.BatesL. K.KielyR. C. (2009). “Commentary: Overcoming the Challenges of Post-disaster Planning in New Orleans: Lessons from the ACORN Housing/University Collaborative.” Journal of Planning Education and Research28 (3): 391–400.
38.
RomzekB. S.DubnickM. J. (1987). “Accountability in the Public Sector: Lessons from the Challenger Tragedy.” Public Administration Review47:227–38.
39.
Saint-MartinD. (1998). “The New Managerialism and the Policy Influence of Consultants in Government: An Historical-Institutionalist Analysis of Britain, Canada and France.” Governance11 (3): 319–56.
40.
SchivelyC. (2007). “A Quantitative Analysis of Consensus Building in Local Environmental Review.” Journal of Planning Education and Research27 (1): 82–98.
41.
SilverC. (1996). “John Nolen: Planner for the New South.” Journal of Planning Education and Research15 (2): 77–88.
42.
SokolowA. (1997). “Town and Township Government: Serving Rural and Suburban Communities.” Handbook of Local Government Administration, edited by GarganJ. J.New York: Marcel Dekker.
43.
SteinR. M. (1990). “The Budgetary Effects of Municipal Service Contracting: A Principal-Agent Explanation.” American Journal of Political Science34 (2): 471–502.
44.
TalenE.KnaapG. (2003). “Legalizing Smart Growth: An Emperical Study of Land Use Regulation in Illinois.” Journal of Planning Education and Research22:345–59.
45.
WatermanR. W.MeierK. J. (1998). “Principal-Agent Models: An Expansion?” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory8 (2): 173–202.
