This article examines land use policy and real estate market activity in the 1990s in two mixed-use neighborhoods in New York City. Using data from case studies of Greenpoint-Williamsburg in Brooklyn and Long Island City in Queens, this article finds that adherence on the part of officials to the principle of highest and best use, together with an incremental approach to planning and land use regulation, has contributed to opportunistic development and industrial displacement in these areas. The question of whether this trajectory is in the interests of the public at large remains the subject of fierce debate in the city's planning community and beyond. The article contributes to the literature on property-led economic development in central cities by exploring the complex task of planners charged with regulating areas that not only are logical sites for commercial and residential expansion but also serve as niches for loweryielding land uses.
Abeles, Peter L.1989. Planning and zoning. In Zoning and theAmerican dream: Promises still to keep, edited by C. M. Haar and J. S. Kayden, 122-153. Chicago: American Planning Association.
2.
Abeles, Phillips, Preiss, and Shapiro. 1990a. A strategic plan for LongIsland City industry. Submitted to New York City Public Development Corporation. November.
3.
Abeles, Phillips, Preiss, and Shapiro. 1990b. Long Island City Industry Study: Executive summary. Submitted to New York City Public Development Corporation. November.
4.
Bagli, Charles V.2001. Schumer proposals address shortage of office space. The New York Times, June 11, B3-B3.
5.
Barahmpour, Tara. 2003. City seeking to rezone Brooklyn waterfront. The New York Times, June 19, B3-B3.
6.
Bartik, Timothy. 1990. The market failure approach to regional economic development policy. Economic Development Quarterly4 (4): 361-370.
7.
Beauregard, Robert. 1993. Voices of decline: The postwar fate of U.S. cities. Oxford: Blackwell.
8.
Bowe, Marisa. 2003. Testimony to the New York City Planning Department on the proposed Greenpoint-Williamsburg rezoning (Representing Neighbors Against Garbage). November 13.
9.
Bowles, Jonathan, and Joel Kotkin. 2003. Engine failure. New York: Center for an Urban Future.
10.
Castells, Manuel. 1996. The rise of the network society. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
11.
Chapple, Karen. 1994. Manufacturing in New York City: A new mixed use paradigm. Masters Thesis, Pratt Institute Graduate Center for Planning and the Environment, Pratt Institute.
12.
Clavel, Pierre. 1986. The progressive city: Planning and participation 1969-1984New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
13.
Clavel, Pierre, and Norman Krumholz, eds. 1994. Reinventing cities:Equity planners tell their stories. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
14.
Council of the City of New York. 2003. Briefing paper: New manufacturing in New York City; policies to retain, promote and attract manufacturing and industry. November 18.
15.
Crean, Sarah. 2001. Testimony to the NewYork City PlanningCommission on Long Island City rezoning (Representing the New York Industrial Retention Network). June 20.
16.
David, Greg. 2003. Employ new ideas to save jobs. Crain's New YorkBusiness, September 8, 3.
17.
DiPasquale, Denise, and William C. Wheaton. 1996. Urban economics and real estate markets. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
18.
Doig, Jameson. 2001. Empire on the Hudson: Entrepreneurial vision and political power at the port of New York authority. New York: Columbia University Press.
19.
Ducharme, Donna. 1991. Planned manufacturing districts: How a community-led initiative became city policy. In Harold Washington and the neighborhoods: Progressive city government in Chicago 1983-1987,edited by P. Clavel and W. Wiewel, 221-237. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
20.
Fainstein, Susan S.1991. Promoting economic development: Urban planning in the United States and the United Kingdom. Journal of the American Planning Association57 (Winter): 22-33.
21.
Fainstein, Susan S.2001. The city builders: Property development in New York and London 1980-20002nd ed, Revised. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.
22.
Fainstein, Susan S., and Norman I. Fainstein. 1989. The Manhattan business district 1945-1988, In Unequal partnerships, edited by G. D. Squires, 59-75. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
23.
Feagin, Joe, and Robert Parker. 1990. Rebuilding American cities: The urban real estate game. 2nd ed.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
24.
Fischler, Raphael. 2000. Linking planning theory and history: The case of development control. Journal of Planning Education and Research19 (3): 233-241.
25.
Fitch, Robert. 1993. The assassination of New York. NewYork: Verso.
26.
Fogelson, Robert. 2003. Downtown: Its rise and fall 1880-1950New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
27.
Freeman, Joshua B.2000. Working class New York: Life and labor sinceWorld War II. New York: The New Press.
28.
Frieden, Bernard, and Lynne Sagalyn. 1991. Downtown, Inc.: HowAmerica rebuilds cities. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
29.
Friedman, Adam. 2003a. Testimony to the Council of the City of New York, Committee on Economic Development, SelectCommittee onWaterfronts. Oversight hearing: New manufacturing in New York City; Policies to retain, promote and attract manufacturing and industry (Representing the New York Industrial Retention Network). November 18, 2003.
30.
Friedman, Adam. 2003b. Zoning to protect manufacturing. Gotham Gazette, April. http://www.gothamgazette.com/article/landuse/20030422/12/358.x.
31.
Garvin, Alexander. 2002. The American city: What works, what doesn't. 2nd ed.New York: McGraw Hill.
32.
Gratz, Roberta, and Norman Mintz. 1998. Cities back from the edge:New life for downtown. New York: John Wiley.
33.
Group of 35 (U.S. Senator Charles E. Schumer and Hon. Robert E. Rubin, co-chairs). 2001. Preparing for the future: A commercial development strategy for New York City. http://urban.nyu.edu/g35/Group-35.pdf (accessed June 2003).
34.
Hall, Peter. 1988. Cities of tomorrow: An intellectual history of urban planning and design in the 20th century. London: Blackwell.
35.
Healey, Patsy. 1990. Understanding land and property development processes: Some key issues. In Land and property development in a changing context, edited by P. Healey and R. Nabarro. Aldershot, Hants, UK: Gower.
36.
Heilbrun, James. 1974. Urban economics and public policy. New York: St. Martin's Press.
37.
Herod, Andrew. 1991. From rag trade to real estate in New York's Garment Center: Remaking the labor landscape in a global city. Urban Geography12 (4): 324-338.
38.
Holusha, John. 2000. Crossing the Queensboro Bridge as a resettler. New York Times, August 13.
39.
Hornick, Sandy. 2003. Remarks at forum Re-Zoning NYC's IndustrialWaterfronts: Job Displacement or an Opportunity to Solve the Housing Crisis? New School for Social Research. Sponsored by the Center for an Urban Future and the J.M. Kaplan Center for New York City Affairs (Representing the New York City Department of City Planning). March 18th.
40.
Ives, Nat. 2000. Zone defense: Manufacturers are demanding an eye for an eye, a factory for an office building. City Limits Magazine26 (6): 6-6.
41.
Kaiser, Edward John, and Richard Godschalk. 2000. Development planning. In The practice of state and local government planning, edited by C. Hoch and L. Dalton, 141-169. Washington, DC: International City and County Management Association.
42.
Kilgannon, Corey. 2003. Going near the water; renovation efforts reclaim the city's forbidden shoreline. The New York Times, August 18, B1-B1.
43.
Kinetz, Erika. 2001. Making the Citicorp Tower less lonesome. TheNew York Times, April 29.
44.
Kleiman, Neil Scott. 2002. The creative engine. New York: Center for an Urban Future.
45.
Lander, Brad, and Laura Wolf-Powers. 2004. Remaking New YorkCity: Can Prosperity Be Shared and Sustainable?Working paper. Brooklyn, NY: Pratt Institute Center for Community and Environmental Development.
46.
Lane, Robert. 1997. The machine next door. Places10 (1): 10-23.
47.
Leon, Jose. 2003. Testimony to the Council of the City of New York, Committee on Economic Development, Select Committee on Waterfronts. Oversight hearing: New manufacturing in New York City; Policies to retain, promote and attract manufacturing and industry (Representing the East Williamsburg Industrial Development Corporation). November 18, 2003.
48.
Levy, John. 2003. Testimony to the Council of the City of New York, Committee on Economic Development, Select Committee on Waterfronts. Oversight hearing: New manufacturing in New York City; Policies to retain, promote and attract manufacturing and industry (Representing John's Gourmet). November 18, 2003.
49.
Logan, John, and Harvey Molotch. 1987. Urban fortunes: The political economy of place. Berkeley: University of California Press.
50.
Loomis, John. 1992. Manufacturing communities: Primer for an enterprise zone. Unpublished manuscript with drawings.
51.
Markusen, Ann, and Vicky Gwiasda. 1994. Multipolarity and the layering of functions in world cities: New York City's struggle to stay on top. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research18 (2): 167-193.
52.
Marshall, J. N., and P. A. Wood. 1992. The role of services in urban and regional development: Recent debates and new developments. Environment and PlanningA24:1255-1270.
53.
Meck, Stuart, Paul Wack, and Michelle J. Zimet. 2000. Zoning and subdivision regulations. In The practice of state and local government planning, edited by C. Hoch and L. Dalton, 343-374. Washington, DC: International City and County Management Association.
54.
Mele, Christopher. 2000. Selling the Lower East Side: Culture, real estate and resistance in New York City. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
55.
Mollenkopf, John H.1983. The contested city. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
56.
Mollenkopf, John H.1988. The post-industrial transformation of New York City's economy. In Power, culture and place: Essays on New York City, edited by J. Mollenkopf, 223-258. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
57.
Molotch, Harvey. 1976. The city as a growth machine. The AmericanJournal of Sociology82:309-332.
58.
Moss, Mitchell L.1994. Made in New York: The future of manufacturing in the City of New York. New York: Urban Research Center, Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service, New York University.
59.
New York City Department of City Planning. 1993a. Citywide industry study geographic atlas of industrial areas. January. New York: New York City Department of City Planning.
60.
New York City Department of City Planning. 1993b. Citywide industry study zoning technical report. January. New York: New York City Department of City Planning.
61.
New York City Department of City Planning. 1993c. New opportunities for a changing economy: Summary report of the citywide industry study. January. New York: New York City Department of City Planning.
62.
New York City Department of City Planning. 1993d. Plan for Long Island City: A framework for development. August. NewYork: NewYork City Department of City Planning.
63.
New York City Department of City Planning. 2001. Proposed zoning text amendments, Long Island City, Queens. NewYork: NewYork City Department of City Planning.
64.
New York City Department of City Planning. 2003. Greenpoint Williamsburg land use and waterfront plan (Summary)June. New York: New York City Department of City Planning.
65.
New York Industrial Retention Network (NYIRN). 2003. The little manufacturer that could: Opportunities and challenges for manufacturing in New York. May.
66.
NYC 2012. 2002. The plan for a New York Olympic Games. New York: NYC 2012. Pratt Institute Center for Community and Environmental
67.
Development (PICCED). 2001. Making it in New York: Manufacturing land use and zoning Initiative. June. Brooklyn, NY: Pratt Institute.
68.
Rabin, Yael. 1989. Expulsive zoning: The inequitable legacy of Euclid. In Zoning and the American dream: Promises still to keep, edited by C. M. Haar and J. S. Kayden, 101-121. Chicago: Planners Press.
69.
Rast, Joel. 1999. Remaking Chicago: The political origins of urban industrial change. Dekalb: Northern Illinois University Press.
70.
Sagalyn, Lynne B.2001. Times Square roulette: Remaking the city icon. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
71.
Sassen, Saskia. 1991. The global city: New York, London, Tokyo. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
72.
Scott, Janny. 2003. Enjoy that danish: It's lifting the city's employment rate. The New York Times, July 31, B1-B1.
73.
Skinner, Curtis, and Frank Braconi. 1994. Manufacturing decline and the land use debate. December. New York: Citizens Housing and Planning Council.
74.
Smith, Ernie. 2001. Testimony to the New York City Planning Commission on Long Island City Rezoning (Representing Penn & Fletcher Inc. and the Manufacturers Association of New York City). June 20.
75.
Smith, Ernie. 2003. Testimony to the Council of the City of New York, Committee on Economic Development, Select Committee on Waterfronts. Oversight hearing: New manufacturing in New York City; policies to retain, promote and attract manufacturing and industry. November 18, 2003.
76.
Smith, Neil. 1986. Gentrification, the frontier and the restructuring of urban space. In Gentrification of the city, edited by N. Smith and P. Williams, 15-34. Boston: Allen and Unwin.
77.
Smith, Neil. 2002. New globalism, new urbanism: Gentrification as global urban strategy. In Spaces of neoliberalism: Urban restructuring in North America and Western Europe, edited by N. Brenner and N. Theodore, 80-103. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
78.
Squires, Gregory. 1991. Partnership and the pursuit of the private city. In Urban life in transition, edited by M. Gottdiener and C. Pickvance, 123-140. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
79.
Swanstrom, Todd. 1987. The limits of strategic planning for cities. Journal of Urban Affairs9 (2): 139-157.
80.
Tasan-Kok, T.2004. Budapest, Istanbul, andWarsaw: Institutional and spatial change. Delft, the Netherlands: Eburon.
81.
Throgmorton, James A.1992. Planning as persuasive storytelling about the future: Negotiating an electric power rate settlement in Illinois. Journal of Planning Education and Research12 (1): 17-31.
82.
Traster, Tina. 2003. Hot Brooklyn properties put a freeze on industry. Crains New York Business, May 12.
83.
Turok, I.1992. Property-led urban regeneration: Panacea or placebo?Environment and PlanningA24:361-379.
84.
Wax, Alan. 2001. The next big thing: Long Island City bustles with activity as developers plan glittering new office space. New York Newsday, November 11, C18-C18.
85.
Weber, Rachel. 2002. Extracting value from the city: Neoliberalism and urban redevelopment. In Spaces of neoliberalism: Urban restructuring in North America and Western Europe, edited by N. Brenner and N. Theodore, 172-193. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
86.
Zukin, Sharon. 1982. Loft living. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
