This study measures satisfaction of residents in two new, higher-density suburban subdivisions: one of small detached houses on small lots, the other townhouses. The post-occupancy evaluation found that satisfaction with housing does not depend on whether a house is attached or detached and that house design can be more important than site design. Putting more houses on less land makes privacy more difficult to attain, and it may force a trade-off between open space and adequate auto accommodation. The findings support the kind of regulatory flexibility that will allow developers to maintain density levels while allowing residents the space they say they need. Adherence to regulatory standards, however, is not sufficient in evaluating a subdivision proposal. The planner needs to evaluate the location, footprint, and orientation of each dwelling and to take differences in site design into account when determining the amount of off-street parking to mandate.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aiello, J.R., and A. Baum, eds. 1979. Residential Crowding and Design. New York: Plenum.
2.
Altman, I., and M.M. Chemers. 1980. Culture and Environment. Monterey, Calif.: Brooks Cole.
3.
Baldassare, M.1986. Trouhle in Paradise: The Stuburban Transformation in America. New York: Columbia University Press.
4.
Baulmgartner, M.P.1988. The Moral Order of a Suburb. New York: Oxford University Press.
5.
Bergdall, J.R., Jr. 1990. Perception of density. Master's thesis. University of California, Berkeley.
6.
Bloodgood, J.1990. Enhancing the livability of high-density lot designs. Professional Builder and Remodeler55: 68-69.
7.
Bonnes, M., M. Bonaiuto, and A.P. Ercolani. 1991. Residential satisfaction in the urban environment: A contextual approach. Environment and Behavior23: 531-552.
8.
Braham, P.1993. Development review planner for Kingstowne. Personal initerview.
9.
Braham, P.1997, 1998. Development review planner for Kingstowne. Telephone interviews.
10.
Brown, R.A.1991. Zero lot line housing: The right direction. Journal ofl Architecture and PlanniTng Research8: 24-31.
11.
Calthorpe, P.1993. The Next Anierican Metropolis. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton Architectural Press.
12.
Copeland, L.1990. Midtown west or mill town. Atlanta Constitution Febrtiarv 21: B 1-B 1,2-2.
13.
Coulson, N.1980. Space arounid the home. Architect-Journal172: 1245-1254.
14.
Cutter, S.1982. Residential satisfaction and the subtirban homeowner. Ulrban Geography3: 315-327.
15.
Day, L.L.1995. Choosing a house: The effect of cost constraints on single family hotLise design and constrtiction. Fnvironment and Planning B: Planning and Designi22: 603-6222.
16.
Devereaux, W.J., and S. Bradford. 1995. Design workshop: Designing for density. BuilderJuly:84-87.
17.
Downs, A.1989. The Needfor a New Visionfor the Development of Large U.S. Metropolitan Areas. New York: Solomon Brothers.
18.
Feldman, R.1990. Settlement-identity: Psychological bonds with home places in a mobile society. Environment and Behavior22: 183-229.
19.
Foddy, W.H.1977. The use of common residential open space in Australia. Ekistics43: 81-83.
20.
Fried, M.1982. Residential attachment: Sources of residential and community satisfaction. Journal ofSocial Issues38: 107-119.
21.
Furbey, R., and B. Goodchild. 1986. Method and methodology in housing user research. Housing Studies1: 166-181.
22.
Girling, C.L, and K.I. Helphand. 1994. Yard, Street Park. New York: John Wiley and Sonis.
23.
Goodchild, B.1994. Housing design, urban form and sustainable development: Reflections on the future residential landscape. Town Planning Review65: 143-157.
24.
Jackson, K.T.1985. Crabgrass FroVitier: The Suburbanization ofthe United States. New York: Oxford University Press.
25.
Jarvis, F.1993. Site Planning and Community Design. Washington, D.C.: Home Builders Press.
26.
Knack, R.E.1991. Design: The one-acre habit is hard to break. Planning August: 8-11-1.
27.
Kreager, W.H.1992. Building small lot homes in your community. Land Development Winter: 22-25.
Lansing, J.B., and Marans, R.W.1969. Evaluation of neighborhood quality. Journal ofthe American Institute ofPlanners35: 195-199.
30.
Marcus, C.C., C. Francis, and C. Meunier. 1987. Mixed messages in sub urbia: Reading the suburban model home. Places4: 24-37.
31.
Marans, R.W.1976. Perceived quality of residential environments: Some methodological issues. In Perceiving Environmental Quality: Research and Applications, eds. K.H. Craik and E.H. Zube, 123-147. New York: Plenum Press.
32.
Michelson, W.1977. Environmental Choice, Human Behavior, and Residential Satisfaction. New York: Oxford University Press.
33.
Rapoport, A.1975. Toward a redefinition of density. Environment and Behavior7: 133-158.
34.
Rapoport, A.1985. Thinking about home environments. In Human Behavior and Environment 8: Home Environments, eds. I. Altman and C. Werner, 255-286. New York: Plenum.
35.
Rapoport, A.1991. Behavioral factors in housing design. Lecture notes from course at the School of Architecture and Urban Planning of the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.
36.
Richardson, W.J.1988. Designing high-density single-family housing: Variations on the zero-lot-line theme. Urban Land February: 15-20.
37.
Richardson, W.J.1993. Architect for Nottingham. Telephone interview.
38.
Rybczynski, W.1991. Living smaller. The Atlantic February: 64-78.
39.
Savasdisara, T.1988. Residents' satisfaction and neighborhood characteristics in Japanese urban communities. Landscape Urban,Planning15: 201-210.
40.
Stauffer, S.1993 and 1998. Miller and Smith Homes, developer of Kingstowne and Nottingham. Telephone interviews.
41.
Thompson, B.1993. Miller and Smith Homes, developer of Kingstowne and Nottingham. Telephone interview.
42.
Urban Land Institute. 1989. Nottingham, Fairfax County, Va. Project Reference File19(4): unnumbered pages and a videotape.
43.
Wentling, J.W.1988. Small lot housing: Innovation or instant slums?The Journal ofReal Estate Development3: 45-53.
44.
Wentling, J.W.1991. Technics: Small lot housing typology. Progressive Architecture June: 45-49.
45.
Wentling, J.W.1995. Designing a Place Called Home: Reordering the Suburbs. New York: Chapman & Hall.
46.
Wentling, J.W., and L.D. Bookout. 1988. Density by Design. Washington, D.C.: Urban land Institute.
47.
Whisenand, R.1997. Director of development review planning for the City of San Luis Obispo, Calif. Personal interview.
48.
Winter, J., T. Coombes and S. Farthing. 1993. Satisfaction with space around the home on large private sector estates: Lessons from surveys in Southern England and South Wales, 1985-89. Town Planning Review64:1-1.
49.
Zimring, C., and R. Wener. 1985. Evaluating evaluation. Environment and Behavior17: 97-117.
