Corrosivity Test Methods for Polymeric Materials. Part 5- A Comparison of Four Test Methods

Abstract

This is the fifth in a series of papers published by the Polyolefins Fire Performance Council, a unit of The Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc. In this paper, four test methods are compared for their ability to evaluate smoke corrosivity of polymeric materials: 1) the proposed ASTM E05.21.70 radiant combustion/exposure standard test method, 2) the CNET corrosivity test stan dard being reviewed by ISO (DIS 11907-2), 3) the DIN 57 472 acid gas test stan dard, and 4) the proposed ASTM D09.21.04 cone corrosimeter standard test method.

The ASTM E05.21.70, CNET, and ASTM D09.21.04 test methods directly de termine the corrosive effects of combustion gases, as they measure the resis tance changes in copper circuit targets exposed to the gases. The ASTM tests report the resistance change in terms of metal loss and the CNET test reports the resistance change in terms of % corrosivity factor. The DIN test standard determines the conductivity and pH changes of aqueous solutions through which combustion gases are passed.

Twenty-four polymeric materials were evaluated for smoke corrosivity by these four test methods, so that the test methods could be reliably compared based on results from many types of polymeric materials. The polymeric materials evaluated are commercially available and they cover a broad range of compositions used for wire and cable insulation and jacketing.

The ASTM E05.21.70, CNET, DIN and ASTM D09.21.04 tests are evaluated based on several criteria. Each test is evaluated on the basis of precision, or whether the test is repeatable, and accuracy, or whether the test differentiates corrosive potentials consistent with the expectations based on the known chem istry of the material compositions. To also determine accuracy, the ASTM E05.21.70, CNET, and D09.21.04 test methods are compared to the DIN 57 472 test method, as this test and similar acid gas tests are accepted standards that have been historically used to measure corrosive potential.

Recommendations are made for improving the proposed test methods.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Reagor, B.T. 1989. Combustion and Corrosivity, Schaumburg, IL: The Hinsdale Challenge Industry Forum, Ameritech Services.

Reagor, B.T. 1987. "The Impact of Smoke Corrosivity on Post-Fire Restoration Rates in Telephone Offices," Proceedings of the Corrosive Effects of Combustion Products Conference, Fire & Materials Centre, Queens Mary College, London, UK, p. 34.

Pownall, J.A. 1987. "Cables Designed to Give Reduced Corrosive Products Resulting from Fires on Warships," Proceedings of the Corrosive Effects of Combustion Products Conference, Fire & Materials Centre, Queens Mary College, London, UK, p. 39.

White, B.S. 1988. Corrosion Resulting from the Use of Halocarbon Fire Extinguishments , West Midlands, UK: Imbach Reclamation Technology.

Morris, W.A. 1987. "Corrosive Effects of Hydrogen Chloride on Concrete Structures following Fires Involving PVC," Proceedings of the Corrosive Effects of Combustion Products Conference, Fire & Materials Centre, Queens Mary College, London, UK, p. 48.

"Test Method for Specific Optical Density of Smoke Generated by Solid Materials," American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) E662-83. Also known as NBS Smoke Chamber test.

" Test Method for Surface Burning Characteristics of Building Materials," ASTM E84-91a. Also known as Steiner Tunnel Test described in UL 910 and NFPA 225.

"Measurement of Smoke Density of Electric Cables Burning under Defined Conditions," Part 1: Test Apparatus (IEC 1034-1) and Part 2: Test Procedure and Requirements (IEC 1034-2), International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC). Also known as Three Meter Cubed Test

IEEE 1202.1 and UL 1685 tests are being adapted to measure smoke generation. IEEE P1202.1 "Draft Standard for Measuring the Release Rates of Smoke, Corrosive Gases, and Heat of Wire and Cable for Use in Industrial and Commercial Occupancies," The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE), February 7, 1991; "Standard Fire Test of Limited-Smoke Cables," UL 1685, Underwriters Laboratories, Northbrook, IL 1990.

10.

"Tests on Gases Evolved during Combustion of Electronic Cable Components ," IEC754-1 and 754-2.

11.

" Test to Determine Acid Gases Evolution," Canadian Standards Association, (CSA) No. 22.2 No. 0.3-M1895, Section 4.31. Also known as CSA Acid Gas Test.

12.

1983. "Testing of Cables, Wires and Flexible Cords; Corrosivity of Combustion Gases," DIN 57 472, Part 813, Standard, Verband Deutscher Elektrotechniker (VDE) Specification 0472, Part 813.

13.

1991. "Test for Flame Propagation and Smoke Density Values for Electrical and Optical-Fiber Cables Used in Spaces Transporting Environmental Air," Northbrook, IL, Underwriters, UL 910.

14.

1990 . "Test for Flame Propagation Height of Electrical and Optical-Fiber Cables Installed Vertically in Shafts," Northbrook, IL , Underwriters, UL 1666.

15.

"Test Method for Heat and Visible Smoke Release Rates for Materials and Products Using an Oxygen Consumption Calorimeter," ASTM E1354-90a.

16.

1992. "Standard Test Method for Measuring the Corrosive Effect of Smoke from the Burning or Thermal Decomposition of Materials and Products ," ASTM E05.21.70, Draft #1, May 1991 , and Draft #2, November.

17.

1987. "CNET Corrosivity Test Standard," Centre National d'Etudes et de Telecommunications (CNET), 130/LAB/SER/ENV, October.

18.

1992. "Fire Test Response Standard for Determining the Corrosive Effect of Combustion Products Using the Cone Corrosimeter," ASTM D09.21.04, Draft #6, June.

19.

Kessel, S.L. , J.G., Bennett, Jr. and C.E. Rogers. 1991. " Corrosivity Test Methods for Polymeric Materials," Proceedings of the 40th International Wire and Cable Symposium, p. 348.

20.

Grand, A.F. 1990. "Development of a Product Performance Smoke Toxicity Test," final report on Southwest Research Institute Project No. 01-1744 for National Institute of Building Sciences, July.

21.

Rogers, C.E. , S.L. Kessel and J.G. Bennett, Jr. 1992. "Corrosivity Test Methods for Polymeric Materials, Part 2—CNET Test Method," Proceedings of the Seventeenth International Conference on Fire Safety, January, p. 392.

22.

Bennett, J.G. , Jr. , S.L. Kessel and C.E. Rogers. 1992. "Corrosivity Test Methods for Polymeric Materials, Part 3-Modified DIN Test Method," Proceedings of the Fire Retardant Chemicals Association Meeting, April, p. 79.

23.

Bennett, J.G. , Jr. , S.L. Kessel and C.E. Rogers. 1992. "Corrosivity Test Methods for Polymeric Materials, Part 4-Cone Corrosimeter Test Method," Proceedings of the Fire Retardant Chemicals Association Meeting, October, p. 1.

24.

Grand, A.F. 1991. "Evaluation of the Corrosivity of Smoke from Fire Retarded Products," Journal of Fire Sciences , 9:44.

25.

Hirschler, M.M. 1990. "Update on Smoke Corrosivity ," Proceedings of the 39th International Wire and Cable Symposium, p. 661.

26.

Keogh, M.J. , C.E. Rogers and G.A. Schmidt. 1991. "Polyolefin Resin Blends and Additive Technology: Advanced Non-Halogen Flame Retarded Compounds," Proceedings of the Fire Retardant Chemicals Association Meeting, March

27.

Botin, M.F. 1990 "Acidity and Corrosivity Measurements of Fire Effluent ," Proceedings of the 39th International Wire and Cable Symposium, p. 205.

28.

Dickinson, P.R. 1992. "Evolving Fire Retardant Material Issues: A Cable Manufacturer's Perspective," International Symposium on Fire Protection for the Telecommunications Industry

29.

1992. SAS/ASSIST® Software, SAS® Institute, Inc., Cary, North Carolina.